compare the rates of change and initial values of two functions when one is an equation, a table, a graph or a verbal description.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Showerhead A is described by an equation, W = 2.5m. Showerhead B is described by a table: 2 minutes, 4 gallons; 4 minutes, 8 gallons; 6 minutes, 12 gallons.
Which showerhead uses less water per minute?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same questions, different forms. To compare two functions, find the same property in each: the rate of change, the initial value, or the output at a chosen input. Each form hides the numbers in a different place.
Where to look. Equation y = mx + b: m and b are written in it. Table: rate = change in y over change in x; work back to x = 0 for b. Graph: slope from two points; b where the line crosses the y-axis. Words: look for “per” or “each” (rate) and “starts at” or “already” (initial value).
Worked example 1: three showerheads. Imani compares A: W = 2.5m (equation); B: the Do Now table; C, a sample older showerhead: “it used 15 gallons in 5 minutes, starting from 0” (words). Step 1: A’s rate is 2.5. Step 2: B’s rate is 4 ÷ 2 = 2. Step 3: C’s rate is 15 ÷ 5 = 3. Step 4: order from least to most water per minute: B, A, C. All three start at 0, so the rates decide everything.
Worked example 2: different starts. Carlos compares two sample tubs. Tub P: W = 4m + 6. Tub Q: a graph through (0, 10) and (2, 16). Step 1: P has rate 4 and initial value 6. Step 2: Q has rate (16 − 10) ÷ 2 = 3 and initial value 10. Step 3: at 3 minutes, P has 4 × 3 + 6 = 18 gallons and Q has 3 × 3 + 10 = 19. Step 4: at 5 minutes, P has 26 and Q has 25. Q starts ahead, but P fills faster and passes it. They are equal at 4 minutes, when both hold 22 gallons.
Making the argument. A good comparison names the property, gives both values with units and says what the difference means: “B uses 0.5 gallon per minute less than A, so a 10-minute shower saves 5 gallons.”
Find the same property in both functions before you compare.
Compare carefully and justify with numbers.
Plan R: a graph through (0, 20) and (5, 45). Plan S: y = 6x + 15. Which has the greater rate of change?
In the library question above, the first fine was described in words and the second by an equation. After how many days are they equal? Show how you know.
Choose two of these: the thunder rule, a WaterSense shower, a fill-up at $4.06 a gallon. Show each in a different form and compare their rates.
We can compare functions in any form. Next we write our own function models from stories about earning money.
Exit ticket: when comparing two functions, why is it not enough to look at their starting values?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 6, mini lesson 12, guided practice 13, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: 2.5 and 2.0 gpm, 2,700 gallons, 260 billion gallons, $2.9 billion and $2.5 billion are from the EPA page. Showerhead C, the tubs, the library fines and Plans R and S are sample data. Checked: 4 × 4 + 6 = 22 = 3 × 4 + 10; 0.5 × 10 = 5; 0.5 × 8 × 365 = 1,460; 1 + 0.25 × 6 = 2.50; 0.50 × 6 = 3.00; (45 − 20)/5 = 5.
Likely misconceptions: comparing the table’s first output to b when the table does not start at 0; assuming the larger starting value stays larger.
Supports: a comparison chart with rows for rate and initial value and columns for each form. Stretch: find when Plans R and S are equal (5x + 20 = 6x + 15, x = 5).
Answer guide: library fines equal when 1 + 0.25x = 0.5x, so x = 4 days ($2.00 each). Tub sentence: “Q starts with 10 gallons and adds 3 per minute; P starts with 6 and adds 4 per minute; they both hold 22 gallons at 4 minutes, and after that P holds more.”
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense: Showerheads · U.S. government work, public domain
EPA’s WaterSense page compares two kinds of showerheads. A standard showerhead uses 2.5 gallons per minute. A WaterSense labeled showerhead must use no more than 2.0 gallons per minute. Products with the label must be independently certified to show they meet EPA’s rules for saving water and for working well.
EPA worked with many groups, including shoppers who tested showerheads, to decide how well the water should cover a person and how strong the spray should be. A WaterSense showerhead has to give a shower as good as or better than regular models.
The page adds up the savings. The average family could save 2,700 gallons a year. If every home in the United States installed WaterSense showerheads, the country could save more than 260 billion gallons of water a year and more than $2.9 billion in water bills. It could also avoid about $2.5 billion in energy costs for heating water.
The page suggests that many local utilities offer rebates that lower the price.
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense: Showerheads (epa.gov)