
explain the collapse of Reconstruction and the rise of Jim Crow, compare Booker T. Washington’s and W. E. B. Du Bois’s strategies, and write an argument that evaluates both points of view with evidence.
Instruction
By 1900 the promise of Reconstruction had been broken in the South. This workshop asks how Black leaders argued about what to do next, and it teaches you to write an argument that takes two opposed points of view seriously.
Content note. This lesson discusses racial violence, including lynching. The facts matter because they shaped every choice these leaders made.
The context: Jim Crow. After 1877, Southern legislatures passed laws segregating railroads, schools and public places. In Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) the Supreme Court upheld a Louisiana law requiring separate railway cars, as long as the facilities were “equal”; Justice John Marshall Harlan dissented alone. Mississippi’s 1890 constitution introduced a poll tax and a literacy test, and other states followed, removing most Black men from the voter rolls. Lynching — murder by mobs, often in public — killed thousands of Black Americans between the 1880s and the 1930s. The journalist Ida B. Wells investigated lynchings in the 1890s and showed that the usual justification, an accusation of crime, was often false; her press in Memphis was destroyed and she was driven from the city.
Washington’s strategy. Booker T. Washington, born enslaved in Virginia, led Tuskegee Institute in Alabama. In his 1895 Atlanta address, delivered to a largely white Southern audience, he urged Black Southerners to build economic strength through industrial education, farming and trades, and to put the fight for social equality and political rights aside for the time being. Read the reading’s image of the hand and fingers: social separation, economic cooperation. White leaders praised the speech, and Washington became the most powerful Black leader in the country, advising presidents and directing philanthropy. Historians have also found that he secretly funded lawsuits against segregation and disfranchisement.
Du Bois’s strategy. W. E. B. Du Bois, born free in Massachusetts and the first Black American to earn a Harvard PhD, answered Washington in The Souls of Black Folk (1903). He argued that economic progress could not last without the vote, civil rights and higher education for a talented leadership. In 1905 he helped found the Niagara Movement, and in 1909 the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), which pursued rights through courts and publicity.
Could it have gone differently? HI.4 asks you to recognize that events could have taken other directions. Neither strategy ended Jim Crow in either man’s lifetime. Historians still debate whether Washington’s caution protected lives in a violent time or conceded too much, and whether Du Bois’s demands were realistic in 1903 or simply right.
Writing the argument. WHST.11-12.1.a asks for a precise claim distinguished from opposing claims. Weak: Du Bois was right and Washington was wrong. Stronger: Washington’s 1895 strategy was a rational response to terror in the Deep South, but Du Bois was right that economic progress without political rights could not be protected, as the destruction of Black-owned businesses in the following decades showed. That claim concedes something, takes a position, and tells the reader what evidence is coming. WHST.11-12.1.c asks you to link sections with words that show the logic — because, although, as a result, even so.
Using point of view as evidence. RH.11-12.6 asks you to evaluate authors’ differing points of view. Washington was speaking to white Southerners whose support Tuskegee depended on; Du Bois was writing a book for a national audience. That difference does not settle who was right, but a strong paragraph uses it.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Two strategies
Booker T. Washington, Address at the Cotton States and International Exposition, Atlanta (18 September 1895); W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903), ‘The Forethought’ and chapter 3 · Public domain
Identify each author’s audience. How might the audience explain what each chose to say?
Washington (1895): In all things that are purely social we can be as separate as the fingers, yet one as the hand in all things essential to mutual progress.
Du Bois (1903), The Forethought: The problem of the Twentieth Century is the problem of the color-line.
Du Bois (1903), chapter 3: Mr. Washington represents in Negro thought the old attitude of adjustment and submission.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which best describes the difference between Washington’s 1895 strategy and Du Bois’s 1903 response?
In Plessy v. Ferguson the Supreme Court held that state-mandated racial segregation violated the Fourteenth Amendment.
Write an argument paragraph set (450-550 words) answering: Whose strategy better served Black Americans in the South between 1895 and 1915? Include a precise claim, a quotation from each author, one fact about context, the strongest counterclaim stated fairly, your response, and at least three transitions that show the logic of your argument.
How confident are you that you can explain how Reconstruction collapsed and argue about Washington’s and Du Bois’s strategies using both points of view?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: the founding of the NAACP; Washington’s Atlanta address; Plessy v. Ferguson; The Souls of Black Folk; the Niagara Movement.
Check your answer
Answer: Atlanta address (1895); Plessy (1896); The Souls of Black Folk (1903); Niagara Movement (1905); NAACP (1909). - Use ‘disfranchisement’ in a sentence about Mississippi’s 1890 constitution.
Check your answer
Answer: Example: Mississippi’s 1890 constitution introduced a poll tax and a literacy test, tools of disfranchisement that removed most Black men from the voter rolls.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Washington said in 1895: ‘In all things that are purely social we can be as separate as the fingers, yet one as the hand in all things essential to mutual progress.’ Who was his audience, and how might it have shaped his words?
Check your answer
Answer: A largely white Southern audience at the Cotton States Exposition in Atlanta, whose support Tuskegee depended on. The audience helps explain why he emphasized economic cooperation and set aside demands for social and political equality.A strong answer uses audience to explain word choice without claiming it settles whether his strategy was right. - Corroborate: Du Bois wrote in 1903 that ‘Mr. Washington represents in Negro thought the old attitude of adjustment and submission.’ What other evidence from the lesson complicates this description of Washington?
Check your answer
Answer: Historians have found that Washington secretly funded lawsuits against segregation and disfranchisement, so his public caution was not the whole of his activity.Corroboration means testing one source’s claim against others; strong answers note Du Bois’s purpose (a public critique) as well. - Washington’s Atlanta address (1895) came one year before Plessy v. Ferguson (1896). Did the speech cause the decision?
Check your answer
Answer: No evidence shows that. The sequence is close, but Plessy arose from a Louisiana test case begun years earlier and from the Court’s reading of the Fourteenth Amendment; both events reflect the same climate rather than one causing the other.Name what would be needed to prove causation (evidence the justices relied on the speech) and why its absence matters.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- From Lesson 1.1: what two words did the Seneca Falls Declaration add to the Declaration of Independence’s sentence on equality?
Check your answer
Answer: ‘and women’. - From Lesson 1.2: name the first Black U.S. senator and the year he took office.
Check your answer
Answer: Hiram Revels of Mississippi, 1870.
Two Strategies at Full Length: Washington at Atlanta, Du Bois in Reply
Booker T. Washington, address at the Cotton States and International Exposition, Atlanta, 18 September 1895, as printed in Up from Slavery (1901), chapter 14; W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903), chapter 3 · Public domain
Why this reading. Lesson 1.4 asks you to write an argument with a quotation from each author and the strongest counterclaim stated fairly. You cannot do that from three sentences. Below are the load-bearing passages of Washington’s Atlanta address and of the chapter in which Du Bois answers it, long enough that each man’s case can be stated in the form he would sign. What to look for: Washington is speaking to an audience whose money and goodwill Tuskegee depends on, and he says one thing to that audience and one thing to his own people in the same speech. Find both. In Du Bois, find the three-part paradox, because it is the shape of the strongest argument against Washington and the thing your counterclaim will have to answer.
Booker T. Washington, address at the Cotton States and International Exposition, Atlanta, 18 September 1895
Washington printed the speech in full in Up from Slavery (1901). He opens by telling the white Southerners in the hall that they cannot succeed without the third of the South that is Black:
One-third of the population of the South is of the Negro race. No enterprise seeking the material, civil, or moral welfare of this section can disregard this element of our population and reach the highest success.
Not only this, but the opportunity here afforded will awaken among us a new era of industrial progress. Ignorant and inexperienced, it is not strange that in the first years of our new life we began at the top instead of at the bottom; that a seat in Congress or the state legislature was more sought than real estate or industrial skill; that the political convention or stump speaking had more attractions than starting a dairy farm or truck garden.
Then the parable that gave the speech its name, told first to Black listeners:
A ship lost at sea for many days suddenly sighted a friendly vessel. From the mast of the unfortunate vessel was seen a signal, “Water, water; we die of thirst!” The answer from the friendly vessel at once came back, “Cast down your bucket where you are.” … The captain of the distressed vessel, at last heeding the injunction, cast down his bucket, and it came up full of fresh, sparkling water from the mouth of the Amazon River. To those of my race who depend on bettering their condition in a foreign land or who underestimate the importance of cultivating friendly relations with the Southern white man, who is their next-door neighbour, I would say: “Cast down your bucket where you are”—cast it down in making friends in every manly way of the people of all races by whom we are surrounded.
Cast it down in agriculture, mechanics, in commerce, in domestic service, and in the professions. … No race can prosper till it learns that there is as much dignity in tilling a field as in writing a poem. It is at the bottom of life we must begin, and not at the top. Nor should we permit our grievances to overshadow our opportunities.
And then the same words turned around and addressed to the white half of the hall:
To those of the white race who look to the incoming of those of foreign birth and strange tongue and habits of the prosperity of the South, were I permitted I would repeat what I say to my own race: “Cast down your bucket where you are.” Cast it down among the eight millions of Negroes whose habits you know, whose fidelity and love you have tested in days when to have proved treacherous meant the ruin of your firesides. Cast down your bucket among these people who have, without strikes and labour wars, tilled your fields, cleared your forests, builded your railroads and cities, and brought forth treasures from the bowels of the earth… you can be sure in the future, as in the past, that you and your families will be surrounded by the most patient, faithful, law-abiding, and unresentful people that the world has seen. … In all things that are purely social we can be as separate as the fingers, yet one as the hand in all things essential to mutual progress.
A warning follows, and it is easy to miss because it is addressed upward:
There is no defence or security for any of us except in the highest intelligence and development of all. If anywhere there are efforts tending to curtail the fullest growth of the Negro, let these efforts be turned into stimulating, encouraging, and making him the most useful and intelligent citizen. … Nearly sixteen millions of hands will aid you in pulling the load upward, or they will pull against you the load downward.
And the sentence that Du Bois, and many others, could not forgive:
The wisest among my race understand that the agitation of questions of social equality is the extremest folly, and that progress in the enjoyment of all the privileges that will come to us must be the result of severe and constant struggle rather than of artificial forcing. No race that has anything to contribute to the markets of the world is long in any degree ostracized. It is important and right that all privileges of the law be ours, but it is vastly more important that we be prepared for the exercises of these privileges. The opportunity to earn a dollar in a factory just now is worth infinitely more than the opportunity to spend a dollar in an opera-house.
Note what that last paragraph concedes and what it holds back. “It is important and right that all privileges of the law be ours” is a claim to full civil and political rights. “Just now” postpones it. Any fair statement of Washington’s position has to carry both halves.
W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903), chapter 3, “Of Mr. Booker T. Washington and Others”
Du Bois begins by explaining why the criticism was slow in coming: the North was weary of the race problem and investing in the South, and “the voice of criticism was hushed.” Then:
Mr. Washington represents in Negro thought the old attitude of adjustment and submission; but adjustment at such a peculiar time as to make his programme unique. This is an age of unusual economic development, and Mr. Washington’s programme naturally takes an economic cast, becoming a gospel of Work and Money to such an extent as apparently almost completely to overshadow the higher aims of life. Moreover, this is an age when the more advanced races are coming in closer contact with the less developed races, and the race-feeling is therefore intensified; and Mr. Washington’s programme practically accepts the alleged inferiority of the Negro races. Again, in our own land, the reaction from the sentiment of war time has given impetus to race-prejudice against Negroes, and Mr. Washington withdraws many of the high demands of Negroes as men and American citizens. In other periods of intensified prejudice all the Negro’s tendency to self-assertion has been called forth; at this period a policy of submission is advocated.
He then states the question in a form that can be tested against evidence:
The question then comes: Is it possible, and probable, that nine millions of men can make effective progress in economic lines if they are deprived of political rights, made a servile caste, and allowed only the most meagre chance for developing their exceptional men? If history and reason give any distinct answer to these questions, it is an emphatic No. And Mr. Washington thus faces the triple paradox of his career:
1. He is striving nobly to make Negro artisans business men and property-owners; but it is utterly impossible, under modern competitive methods, for workingmen and property-owners to defend their rights and exist without the right of suffrage.
2. He insists on thrift and self-respect, but at the same time counsels a silent submission to civic inferiority such as is bound to sap the manhood of any race in the long run.
3. He advocates common-school and industrial training, and depreciates institutions of higher learning; but neither the Negro common-schools, nor Tuskegee itself, could remain open a day were it not for teachers trained in Negro colleges, or trained by their graduates.
And the close of the chapter, which sets out exactly how far Du Bois agrees and where he stops:
The black men of America have a duty to perform, a duty stern and delicate,—a forward movement to oppose a part of the work of their greatest leader. So far as Mr. Washington preaches Thrift, Patience, and Industrial Training for the masses, we must hold up his hands and strive with him, rejoicing in his honors and glorying in the strength of this Joshua called of God and of man to lead the headless host. But so far as Mr. Washington apologizes for injustice, North or South, does not rightly value the privilege and duty of voting, belittles the emasculating effects of caste distinctions, and opposes the higher training and ambition of our brighter minds,—so far as he, the South, or the Nation, does this,—we must unceasingly and firmly oppose them. By every civilized and peaceful method we must strive for the rights which the world accords to men, clinging unwaveringly to those great words which the sons of the Fathers would fain forget: “We hold these truths to be self-evident: That all men are created equal…”
Notice where Du Bois ends: at the same sentence you read in Lesson 1.1. He is doing in 1903 what Stanton did in 1848 and Douglass in 1852.
Two facts of context your paragraph needs
- Washington spoke in September 1895. In the previous decade Ida B. Wells had documented lynchings in the South and been driven out of Memphis for publishing what she found; the year after the speech, Plessy v. Ferguson upheld state-mandated segregation. He was speaking inside a campaign of terror, to the people carrying it out or tolerating it.
- Du Bois wrote in 1903 from Atlanta University, with a Harvard doctorate and no institution dependent on Southern white donors in the way Tuskegee was. Historians later established that Washington quietly paid for legal challenges to disfranchisement and segregation while saying in public what you have just read. That fact does not settle the argument; it changes what “his strategy” means.
The law behind the debate: the Fourteenth Amendment and Plessy
Both men wrote after the Fourteenth Amendment (1868) and before Brown. Section 1 says that no State shall “deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” In Plessy v. Ferguson, 163 U.S. 537 (1896), the Supreme Court upheld a Louisiana law of 1890 that required separate railway cars for Black and white passengers, holding that separate facilities were constitutional if they were “equal.” Justice Harlan alone dissented. So the Court did not hold that segregation violated the Fourteenth Amendment; it held the opposite. That ruling is the legal setting for Washington’s Atlanta address (1895) and for Du Bois’s reply in The Souls of Black Folk (1903). Source: U.S. Constitution, Amendment XIV (public domain); Plessy v. Ferguson, 163 U.S. 537 (1896), Supreme Court opinion (public domain).
Sources: Booker T. Washington, Up from Slavery (1901), Project Gutenberg (gutenberg.org); W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903), Project Gutenberg (gutenberg.org)