
explain the causes and results of the Hawaiian overthrow, the Spanish-American War, the Philippine-American War and the Open Door policy, and evaluate competing interpretations of American expansion in a seminar.
Instruction
Between 1893 and 1900 the United States acquired Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Guam, the Philippines and part of Samoa, and it claimed a voice in the future of China. Americans argued fiercely about what this meant. So do historians.
Why expand? Several forces pushed outward. Industrial output outran domestic demand, and business leaders looked for markets, especially in Asia. Alfred Thayer Mahan’s The Influence of Sea Power upon History (1890) argued that great nations needed navies, coaling stations and overseas bases. Missionaries sought converts. Racial ideas of the time, including Social Darwinism, told many white Americans that they had a duty and a right to rule others. And the 1890 census announced that there was no longer a continuous line of frontier settlement, which some writers took as a sign that expansion must continue overseas.
Hawaii. American sugar planters dominated the Hawaiian economy. In January 1893, with the support of the American minister and U.S. Marines landed from a warship, a group of planters and businessmen overthrew Queen Lili’uokalani. President Cleveland opposed annexation after an investigation, but in 1898 Congress annexed Hawaii by joint resolution. In 1993 Congress passed a resolution formally apologizing to Native Hawaiians for the overthrow.
The Spanish-American War. Cubans rose against Spanish rule in 1895, and Spain’s harsh countermeasures, sensationalised by “yellow” newspapers, stirred American sympathy. In February 1898 the battleship Maine exploded in Havana harbor; Americans blamed Spain, though the cause is still debated and a 1976 Navy study suggested an internal accident. Congress declared war in April, promising in the Teller Amendment not to annex Cuba. Commodore Dewey destroyed the Spanish fleet at Manila Bay on 1 May, and the war ended within months. In the Treaty of Paris, Spain ceded Puerto Rico, Guam and the Philippines, for which the United States paid $20 million. Cuba became nominally independent, but the Platt Amendment (1901) gave the United States the right to intervene and a naval base at Guantánamo Bay.
The Philippine-American War. Filipino nationalists led by Emilio Aguinaldo had declared independence in 1898. When the United States kept the islands, war broke out in February 1899. It was fought with great brutality, including the burning of villages, the forced relocation of civilians into camps, and torture such as the “water cure,” which a Senate committee investigated in 1902. More than 4,000 American soldiers died; historians estimate that hundreds of thousands of Filipinos died, most of them civilians, from combat, famine and disease. The U.S. declared the war over in 1902, though fighting continued in places for years.
The Open Door. In 1899 and 1900 Secretary of State John Hay sent notes to the powers carving China into spheres of influence. Their purpose was to secure equal trading rights for all nations in China and, in the second note, to preserve China’s territorial integrity. Their effect was to protect American commercial access without acquiring colonies, and to commit the United States to an interest in Asia’s balance of power that would lead, eventually, to conflict with Japan.
Rival interpretations. One older view called 1898 a “great aberration,” an accidental burst of empire in a nation that otherwise avoided it. William Appleman Williams, in The Tragedy of American Diplomacy (1959), argued instead that the Open Door reflected a consistent drive for overseas markets — an informal empire of trade. More recent historians such as Paul Kramer have studied how race shaped American rule in the Philippines. HI.3 asks you to judge actors by the context of their time: in 1899 many Americans, including Mark Twain, Andrew Carnegie, Jane Addams and Samuel Gompers, condemned annexation. Some anti-imperialists opposed it for principled reasons; others because they did not want non-white people as fellow citizens.
Seminar question: After 1898, was the United States an empire? If so, what kind? SL.11-12.3 asks you to evaluate a speaker’s point of view, reasoning and use of evidence; in your own reply, assess one speaker’s premise (a senator’s, for example, or the Anti-Imperialist League’s), not just the conclusion.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: The anti-imperialist case
Platform of the American Anti-Imperialist League (October 1899) · Public domain
Notice which founding document the League appeals to. You met the same strategy in Unit 1.
We hold that the policy known as imperialism is hostile to liberty and tends toward militarism, an evil from which it has been our glory to be free.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What was the main purpose of the Open Door notes?
The Philippine-American War was brief and caused few civilian deaths.
1893
Tap to revealOverthrow of Queen Lili’uokalani with support from the U.S. minister and Marines.
1898
Tap to revealSpanish-American War; annexation of Hawaii; Treaty of Paris cedes Puerto Rico, Guam and the Philippines.
1899
Tap to revealPhilippine-American War begins; first Open Door note.
1901
Tap to revealPlatt Amendment makes Cuba a U.S. protectorate in practice.
Mahan (1890)
Tap to revealArgued that national greatness required sea power and overseas bases.
Record a 90-second seminar contribution answering the seminar question, citing two events and one historian’s interpretation. Then write two replies to speakers or historians in the readings: in each, identify the key premise, judge whether the evidence supports it, and add one piece of evidence that strengthens or weakens it.
How confident are you that you can explain the events of 1893-1902 in the Pacific and the Caribbean and evaluate whether they made the United States an empire?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: Platt Amendment; overthrow of Queen Lili’uokalani; first Open Door note; explosion of the Maine; Treaty of Paris signed.
Check your answer
Answer: Overthrow (1893); Maine (February 1898); Treaty of Paris (December 1898); first Open Door note (1899); Platt Amendment (1901). - What was a ‘sphere of influence’ in China, and what did the Open Door notes ask the powers to do about it?
Check your answer
Answer: An area where a foreign power claimed exclusive economic privileges. The notes asked for equal trading rights for all nations and, in the second note, preservation of China’s territorial integrity.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Source: ‘We hold that the policy known as imperialism is hostile to liberty and tends toward militarism.’ Who wrote it, when, and which earlier document does its opening echo? Why?
Check your answer
Answer: The American Anti-Imperialist League in its platform of October 1899. ‘We hold’ echoes the Declaration of Independence, claiming that empire betrays the nation’s founding principle. - Americans in 1898 blamed Spain for the Maine explosion; a 1976 Navy study suggested an internal accident. What does this show about using newspaper coverage from 1898 as evidence?
Check your answer
Answer: The 1898 press is strong evidence of what Americans were told and believed, and of the yellow press’s role in stirring war, but weak evidence of the explosion’s cause. - The Maine exploded in February 1898 and Congress declared war in April. Did the explosion cause the war?
Check your answer
Answer: Model answer: it was a trigger, not the whole cause. Cuba’s war for independence since 1895, sympathy stirred by the press, business and strategic interests, and the Teller Amendment’s promise all belong in the explanation. Strong answers rank causes with evidence.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- From Unit 1: which Semester A document did the Seneca Falls convention, like the Anti-Imperialist League, borrow from?
Check your answer
Answer: The Declaration of Independence.
Who Decides: Hawaii, Cuba and the Open Door in the Documents
Lili’uokalani, Hawaii’s Story by Hawaii’s Queen (Boston: Lee and Shepard, 1898), Appendix B; Joint Resolution of 20 April 1898, 30 Stat. 738-739; Army Appropriations Act of 2 March 1901, 31 Stat. 897-898; Hay to White, 6 September 1899, and circular telegram of 3 July 1900, Foreign Relations of the United States · Public domain
Why this reading. The seminar question is whether the United States became an empire after 1898, and the open question asks you to cite two events and one historian’s interpretation. The lesson describes the events but gives you the words of only one side — a single sentence of the Anti-Imperialist League. Below are the documents the events actually turn on, so that the argument can be made from the record rather than from the mini-lecture. Lesson 3.5 supplies the Philippine annexation debate; this reading covers Hawaii, Cuba and China. What to look for: an empire is usually defined by who decides. In each document, find the sentence that says who decides, and for whom.
1. Hawaii: Queen Lili’uokalani’s protest, Honolulu, 17 January 1893
She printed it herself five years later in Hawaii’s Story by Hawaii’s Queen. Read what she yields to, and what she does not:
I, Liliuokalani, by the grace of God and under the constitution of the Hawaiian kingdom Queen, do hereby solemnly protest against any and all acts done against myself and the constitutional government of the Hawaiian kingdom by certain persons claiming to have established a Provisional Government of and for this kingdom.
That I yield to the superior force of the United States of America, whose Minister Plenipotentiary, His Excellency John L. Stevens, has caused United States troops to be landed at Honolulu, and declared that he would support the said Provisional Government.
Now, to avoid any collision of armed forces, and perhaps the loss of life, I do, under this protest and impelled by said forces, yield my authority until such time as the Government of the United States shall, upon the facts being presented to it, undo (?) the action of its representative, and reinstate me in the authority which I claim as the constitutional sovereign of the Hawaiian Islands.
Done at Honolulu this seventeenth day of January, a.d. 1893.
She does not yield to the Provisional Government. She yields to the United States, and she addresses the protest to Washington rather than to Honolulu — a legal argument in the form of a surrender. The parenthetical “(?)” after “undo” is printed in her own 1898 book.
One hundred years later Congress agreed with part of her account. Public Law 103-150, signed on 23 November 1993, acknowledges that the overthrow occurred “with the active participation of agents and citizens of the United States” and apologizes to Native Hawaiians. A joint resolution of Congress is a usable primary source about 1993; it is not evidence of what people believed in 1893, and your seminar contribution should not treat it as if it were.
2. Cuba: the promise and the terms, side by side
These two are the single sharpest test of the seminar question, because Congress wrote both. First, the fourth resolving clause of the joint resolution of 20 April 1898 — the Teller Amendment — which made war on Spain:
Fourth. That the United States hereby disclaims any disposition or intention to exercise sovereignty, jurisdiction, or control over said Island except for the pacification thereof, and asserts its determination, when that is accomplished, to leave the government and control of the Island to its people.
Now the Platt Amendment, attached to the Army Appropriations Act of 2 March 1901. Cuba was required to write these conditions into its own constitution before American troops would leave:
I. That the government of Cuba shall never enter into any treaty or other compact with any foreign power or powers which will impair or tend to impair the independence of Cuba, nor in any manner authorize or permit any foreign power or powers to obtain by colonization or for military or naval purposes or otherwise, lodgment in or control over any portion of said island.
III. That the government of Cuba consents that the United States may exercise the right to intervene for the preservation of Cuban independence, the maintenance of a government adequate for the protection of life, property, and individual liberty, and for discharging the obligations with respect to Cuba imposed by the treaty of Paris on the United States, now to be assumed and undertaken by the government of Cuba.
VII. That to enable the United States to maintain the independence of Cuba, and to protect the people thereof, as well as for its own defense, the government of Cuba will sell or lease to the United States lands necessary for coaling or naval stations at certain specified points, to be agreed upon with the President of the United States.
Article III is the one to argue about. Cuba “consents” — under military occupation, as the price of the occupation ending — to a standing right of intervention. Is a country that has granted that still independent? Both answers can be defended, and the seminar is for defending one of them. Article VII produced the naval station at Guantánamo Bay, which the United States still holds.
3. China: the Open Door notes
Secretary of State John Hay’s circular to the ambassador in Berlin, 6 September 1899, asks each power with a “sphere of interest” in China to declare three things:
First. Will in no way interfere with any treaty port or any vested interest within any so-called “sphere of interest” or leased territory it may have in China.
Second. That the Chinese treaty tariff of the time being shall apply to all merchandise landed or shipped to all such ports as are within said “sphere of interest” (unless they be “free ports”), no matter to what nationality it may belong, and that duties so leviable shall be collected by the Chinese Government.
Third. That it will levy no higher harbor dues on vessels of another nationality frequenting any port in such “sphere” than shall be levied on vessels of its own nationality, and no higher railroad charges over lines built, controlled, or operated within its “sphere” on merchandise belonging to citizens or subjects of other nationalities…
The second circular, of 3 July 1900, sent during the siege of the legations at Peking, states the aim more broadly:
… the policy of the Government of the United States is to seek a solution which may bring about permanent safety and peace to China, preserve Chinese territorial and administrative entity, protect all rights guaranteed to friendly powers by treaty and international law, and safeguard for the world the principle of equal and impartial trade with all parts of the Chinese Empire.
Two things are worth noticing for the seminar. The first note asks nothing of China and is not addressed to China; it is a set of proposals about China, made between the powers. And what it asks for is equality of commercial access, not territory. William Appleman Williams built his whole interpretation on that distinction — an empire of trade rather than of colonies. The rival reading is that the notes were a weak request that the powers largely ignored, and that reading has evidence too.
Using this in the seminar
The word “empire” is doing the work, so define it before you argue. Three definitions people actually use: rule over territory without the consent of its inhabitants (Hawaii, the Philippines, Puerto Rico); control of another government’s foreign and financial policy without annexation (Cuba after 1901, and the Caribbean in Lesson 3.4); and privileged commercial access secured by power (the Open Door). A strong contribution picks one, says why, and accepts what the other two would then require it to concede. SL.11-12.3 asks you to evaluate a speaker’s reasoning, including your own: the most useful question you can ask is usually “which definition are you using, and would your evidence still work under the other one?”
Sources: Lili’uokalani, Hawaii’s Story by Hawaii’s Queen (1898), Internet Archive (archive.org); Public Law 103-150 (1993), enrolled bill, govinfo.gov (govinfo.gov); Joint Resolution of 20 April 1898 (Teller Amendment), 30 Stat. 738, govinfo.gov (govinfo.gov); Army Appropriations Act of 2 March 1901 (Platt Amendment), 31 Stat. 895, govinfo.gov (govinfo.gov); Hay to White, 6 September 1899, FRUS 1899, Document 91, Office of the Historian (history.state.gov); Hay circular telegram, 3 July 1900, FRUS 1900, Document 343, Office of the Historian (history.state.gov)