THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP U.S. History A — Founding Ideals, Industrial America and a World Power

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 20 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Founding Ideals and a Nation Remade
    5
    • 1.1
      Self-Evident Truths — The Founding and Its Promise
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Federal Power, State Power and a Widening Democracy, 1787-1900
      50 mins
    • 1.3
      Seminar — Faith, Reform and Religious Liberty
      50 mins
    • 1.4
      Workshop — Washington, Du Bois and the Meaning of Progress
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Performance Task — The Promise of the Declaration by 1900
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Industry, Immigration and the City
    5
    • 2.1
      Rails, Steel and Oil — Building an Industrial Nation
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Working Lives — Factories, Tenements and The Jungle
      50 mins
    • 2.3
      Seminar — Newcomers, Exclusion and Americanization
      50 mins
    • 2.4
      Workshop — Survival of the Fittest or the Social Gospel? Machines and Reformers
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Performance Task — Public-History Exhibit: The Industrial City and Its People
      200 mins
  • Unit 3: Populists, Progressives and an Emerging World Power
    5
    • 3.1
      The Farmers’ Revolt — Populism and the Money Question
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      The Progressive Toolkit — Regulation, Amendments, Conservation and Missouri’s Reforms
      50 mins
    • 3.3
      Seminar — Did the United States Become an Empire?
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Workshop — Big Stick, Dollar and Moral Diplomacy
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Performance Task — Structured Academic Controversy: Annexing the Philippines
      200 mins
  • Unit 4: World War I and the Twenties
    5
    • 4.1
      Over There and Over Here — World War I and the Home Front
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Normalcy and the Machine Age — Harding, Coolidge, Hoover and the New Economy
      50 mins
    • 4.3
      Seminar — Liberty under Pressure in the 1920s
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Workshop — New Women, New Voices: Suffrage and the Harlem Renaissance
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Performance Task — Historical Research Paper, 1914-1929
      250 mins

Workshop — Survival of the Fittest or the Social Gospel? Machines and Reformers

Unit 2  ·  Evidence-Based Writing Workshop  ·  Lesson 9 of 20

Workshop — Survival of the Fittest or the Social Gospel? Machines and Reformers

US.11.2.7RLP-USHA
Industrial city contrasts political machine favors with settlement-house reform and crowded urban poverty.
By the end of this lesson I can…

compare Social Darwinism and the Social Gospel, explain how urban political machines worked and why immigrants and reformers responded to them as they did, and write an argument that evaluates an author’s reasoning.

Instruction

Industrial America produced great wealth and great poverty side by side. Two ideas competed to explain that gap, and two kinds of politics competed to run the cities where it was most visible.

Social Darwinism. The English writer Herbert Spencer applied Darwin’s theory of evolution to society and coined the phrase “survival of the fittest.” In America the Yale professor William Graham Sumner argued in What Social Classes Owe to Each Other (1883) that wealth and poverty resulted from competition, that government efforts to help the poor took from the thrifty “forgotten man” who paid for them, and that reform would only interfere with natural progress. The ideas flattered the successful and justified opposition to regulation. Carnegie accepted much of this, but his “Gospel of Wealth” added a duty: the rich should give their fortunes away during their lifetimes for libraries, schools and other public goods.

The Social Gospel. Protestant ministers such as Washington Gladden and Walter Rauschenbusch answered that Christianity demanded justice in this world, not only salvation in the next. Rauschenbusch’s Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907) called on churches to fight child labor, slums and unsafe work. Charles Sheldon’s best-selling novel In His Steps (1896) asked readers to decide every choice by asking what Jesus would do. Social Gospel ideas fed settlement houses and Progressive reform.

A comparison to get right. The state standard names the revivalists Dwight L. Moody and Billy Sunday in this context. Both drew enormous crowds; neither was a Social Gospel leader. They preached individual conversion as the answer to social problems, and Sunday campaigned hard for Prohibition. They are a useful third position: they agreed with the Social Gospel that society was sick, and with Sumner that the cure lay with individuals rather than government.

Political machines. A machine was a party organization that controlled a city through loyalty and favors. New York’s Tammany Hall is the best-known example; its boss William Tweed stole millions before his conviction in 1873, and Thomas Nast’s cartoons in Harper’s Weekly helped bring him down. St. Louis had its own: Circuit Attorney Joseph Folk investigated corruption in the city’s municipal assembly, where businessmen were said to buy franchises and contracts with kickbacks, and his inquiry led to the indictment of 39 people, including 21 members of the assembly and the Democratic boss Ed Butler. Many of the indictments were later overturned on technicalities by the Missouri Supreme Court, but the exposure helped make Folk governor in 1904. Machines survived because they served people government ignored. A ward boss found an immigrant family a job, coal in winter, or help with the police, and asked only for votes. Immigrants often supported machines for that reason; middle-class reformers attacked them as corrupt and wasteful.

Reform responses. After a disappointed office-seeker assassinated President Garfield in 1881, the Pendleton Act of 1883 began a merit-based civil service. Reformers promoted the secret ballot, city managers and nonpartisan elections — changes that also reduced immigrant influence, which some reformers intended.

Skill: evaluating an author’s reasoning. RH.11-12.8 asks you to evaluate premises and evidence. Plunkitt claims that “honest graft” — profiting from inside knowledge, such as buying land he knew the city would need — is different from stealing. Premise: using information is not taking public money. Test: the city paid more for land because an official profited, so the public lost money either way. His distinction is clever and self-serving. HR.1 asks you to distinguish valid from fallacious arguments; here the conclusion does not follow from the premise.

Writing the comparison. A comparative argument does more than list similarities and differences; it makes a claim about what the comparison shows. Example claim: Social Darwinism and the Social Gospel disagreed about who was responsible for poverty, but both treated industrial inequality as a moral question, which is why the argument moved so quickly from pulpits and lecture halls into politics. WHST.11-12.1.b asks you to develop the counterclaim fairly, with its strengths and limitations.

📖 Read for this lesson

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.

  • Three Premises: Sumner, Rauschenbusch and Plunkitt in Their Own WordsWilliam Graham Sumner, What Social Classes Owe to Each Other (1883); Walter Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis (New York: Macmillan, 1907), Introduction; William L. Riordon, Plunkitt of Tammany Hall (1905), chapter 1 · about 7 min

    You are asked to use Sumner and Rauschenbusch and to test a premise the way the lesson tests Plunkitt’s, and the lesson quotes none of them. Here is Sumner’s Forgotten Man, Rauschenbusch on why a church cannot stand aside, and enough of Plunkitt’s honest graft to take the argument apart.

Reading: A machine politician explains himself

William L. Riordon, Plunkitt of Tammany Hall (1905), chapter 1, ‘Honest Graft and Dishonest Graft’ · Public domain

Plunkitt, a Tammany Hall leader, is talking to a reporter. Is he confessing, boasting or persuading?

There’s an honest graft, and I’m an example of how it works… I seen my opportunities and I took ’em.

Vocabulary in context

  • Social Darwinism — The application of ‘survival of the fittest’ to society, used to oppose reform and justify inequality.
  • Social Gospel — A Protestant movement calling on Christians to reform social conditions such as slums and child labor.
  • political machine — A party organization that controlled a city through patronage, services and loyalty.
  • graft — Using public office for illegal or dishonest personal gain.
  • Pendleton Act (1883) — Federal law beginning a merit-based civil service.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

Which statement would William Graham Sumner most likely have made?

Sumner argued that reform and aid interfered with natural competition and burdened the thrifty taxpayer.
Myth or Fact?

Many immigrants supported political machines because machines provided jobs and help that government did not.

True. Machines traded services and favors for votes; reformers saw corruption, while many immigrants saw practical help.

Write a comparative argument (450-550 words): Which better explained industrial poverty — Social Darwinism or the Social Gospel? Use Sumner, Carnegie, Rauschenbusch and one other source. State a claim about what the comparison shows, test one author’s premise as the lesson models with Plunkitt, and develop the strongest counterclaim fairly before answering it.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can compare Social Darwinism and the Social Gospel and explain why machines and reformers each drew support?

Not yetVery confident

Practice

Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.

Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)

Fluency

Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.

  1. Order: Pendleton Act; Tweed’s conviction; Garfield’s assassination; Christianity and the Social Crisis; What Social Classes Owe to Each Other.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Tweed convicted (1873); Garfield assassinated (1881); Pendleton Act (1883); Sumner’s book (1883); Rauschenbusch’s book (1907).
    The Pendleton Act and Sumner’s book both date from 1883.
  2. Match: Social Darwinism, Social Gospel, graft — (a) using public office for dishonest gain; (b) ‘survival of the fittest’ applied to society; (c) Christianity demands reform of social conditions.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Social Darwinism–(b); Social Gospel–(c); graft–(a).

Application

Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.

  1. Plunkitt said, ‘I seen my opportunities and I took ’em.’ The words come from a book by a reporter who interviewed him (Riordon, 1905). How does the way the source was produced affect its reliability?
    Check your answer
    Answer: Model answer: it records Plunkitt’s views in his own voice, but a reporter selected and shaped the talks for publication, and Plunkitt was defending himself. It is good evidence of how a machine politician justified himself, weaker evidence of how machines actually operated.
  2. Test the premise behind ‘honest graft’: using inside knowledge is different from stealing public money.
    Check your answer
    Answer: If a boss buys land he knows the city will need and resells it at a higher price, the city pays more, so the public loses money either way. The premise fails; the argument is clever but self-serving.
    State the premise, then test it against a consequence.
  3. Garfield was assassinated in 1881 and the Pendleton Act passed in 1883. Cause or sequence?
    Check your answer
    Answer: Cause, supported by evidence: Garfield’s killer was a disappointed office-seeker, and the murder turned public opinion toward civil-service reform that reformers had long urged.

Review

Keep earlier skills sharp.

  1. From Unit 1: which revival movement taught that people could perfect society, feeding reform movements before the Social Gospel?
    Check your answer
    Answer: The Second Great Awakening.
  2. From Unit 1: what did Du Bois call ‘the problem of the Twentieth Century’?
    Check your answer
    Answer: The problem of the color-line.

Missouri Learning Standards — Social Studies addressed: 9-12.AH.2.PC.D, 9-12.AH.2.EC.D, 9-12.AH.2.GS.C, 9-12.AH.2.EC.C, WHST.11-12.1, RH.11-12.6, RH.11-12.8, 9-12.AH.1.CC.B, 9-12.AH.1.CC.D

Instructional focus: Comparative argumentative writing on ideologies and urban politics

Reading

Three Premises: Sumner, Rauschenbusch and Plunkitt in Their Own Words

William Graham Sumner, What Social Classes Owe to Each Other (1883); Walter Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis (New York: Macmillan, 1907), Introduction; William L. Riordon, Plunkitt of Tammany Hall (1905), chapter 1 · Public domain

Why this reading. Lesson 2.4 asks you to write a comparative argument using Sumner, Carnegie and Rauschenbusch, and to test one author’s premise the way the lesson tests Plunkitt’s. The lesson supplies one line of Plunkitt and describes the other three without quoting them, so there is nothing to test. Here are Sumner and Rauschenbusch in their own words, and enough of Plunkitt’s argument to take it apart. Carnegie is in the reading for Lesson 2.1. What to look for: each of these three men builds from a premise about what human beings are like. Underline it. That sentence, not the conclusion, is where the argument can be tested.

1. William Graham Sumner, What Social Classes Owe to Each Other (1883)

Sumner taught political and social science at Yale. His book is an attack on reform, and its device is a four-letter diagram:

The type and formula of most schemes of philanthropy or humanitarianism is this: A and B put their heads together to decide what C shall be made to do for D. The radical vice of all these schemes, from a sociological point of view, is that C is not allowed a voice in the matter, and his position, character, and interests, as well as the ultimate effects on society through C’s interests, are entirely overlooked. I call C the Forgotten Man.

… They are always under the dominion of the superstition of government, and, forgetting that a government produces nothing at all, they leave out of sight the first fact to be remembered in all social discussion—that the State cannot get a cent for any man without taking it from some other man, and this latter must be a man who has produced and saved it. This latter is the Forgotten Man.

He then applies it to a man in a gutter:

The consequence is that those who have gone astray, being relieved from Nature’s fierce discipline, go on to worse, and that there is a constantly heavier burden for the others to bear. Who are the others? When we see a drunkard in the gutter we pity him. If a policeman picks him up, we say that society has interfered to save him from perishing. “Society” is a fine word, and it saves us the trouble of thinking. The industrious and sober workman, who is mulcted of a percentage of his day’s wages to pay the policeman, is the one who bears the penalty. But he is the Forgotten Man. He passes by and is never noticed, because he has behaved himself, fulfilled his contracts, and asked for nothing.

The premises to underline: that relief releases people from a discipline imposed by Nature; that “a government produces nothing at all”; and that the man in the gutter is there because he went astray. Each is a claim about the world, and each can be checked. Ask, for instance, what happens to the argument if the man in the gutter lost three fingers in a mill with no compensation law — the situation Lesson 2.2 describes.

2. Walter Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907), Introduction

Rauschenbusch had been pastor of a German Baptist church beside Hell’s Kitchen in New York before he became a seminary professor. He starts from the same facts as Sumner and draws the opposite conclusion:

Western civilization is passing through a social revolution unparalleled in history for scope and power. Its coming was inevitable. The religious, political, and intellectual revolutions of the past five centuries, which together created the modern world, necessarily had to culminate in an economic and social revolution such as is now upon us.

By universal consent, this social crisis is the overshadowing problem of our generation. The industrial and commercial life of the advanced nations are in the throes of it. In politics all issues and methods are undergoing upheaval and re-alignment as the social movement advances. In the world of thought all the young and serious minds are absorbed in the solution of the social problems. Even literature and art point like compass-needles to this magnetic pole of all our thought.

And then the claim that made the book a manifesto — that a church cannot stand aside from this, because standing aside is itself a choice:

It is realized by friend and foe that religion can play, and must play, a momentous part in this irrepressible conflict. The Church, the organized expression of the religious life of the past, is one of the most potent institutions and forces in Western civilization. Its favor and moral influence are wooed by all parties. It cannot help throwing its immense weight on one side or the other. If it tries not to act, it thereby acts; and in any case its choice will be decisive for its own future.

The premises to underline: that poverty is produced by an economic order rather than by the character of the poor; that a social order can be judged morally; and that neutrality is impossible. Compare the third with Sumner’s position, which is that the moral question is already settled by who saved and who did not.

3. George Washington Plunkitt on honest graft (1905), at greater length

The lesson quotes the famous sentence. Here is the argument it sits inside, taken down by the reporter William L. Riordon:

EVERYBODY is talkin’ these days about Tammany men growin’ rich on graft, but nobody thinks of drawin’ the distinction between honest graft and dishonest graft. There’s all the difference in the world between the two. Yes, many of our men have grown rich in politics. I have myself. I’ve made a big fortune out of the game, and I’m gettin’ richer every day, but I’ve not gone in for dishonest graft—blackmailin’ gamblers, saloonkeepers, disorderly people, etc.—and neither has any of the men who have made big fortunes in politics.

There’s an honest graft, and I’m an example of how it works. I might sum up the whole thing by sayin’: “I seen my opportunities and I took ’em.”

Just let me explain by examples. My party’s in power in the city, and it’s goin’ to undertake a lot of public improvements. Well, I’m tipped off, say, that they’re going to lay out a new park at a certain place.

I see my opportunity and I take it. I go to that place and I buy up all the land I can in the neighborhood. Then the board of this or that makes its plan public, and there is a rush to get my land, which nobody cared particular for before.

Ain’t it perfectly honest to charge a good price and make a profit on my investment and foresight? Of course, it is. Well, that’s honest graft.

Now the argument is testable. The premise is that using information is not taking public money. The test is who paid: the city bought land at the higher price Plunkitt’s purchase helped create, and the difference came out of taxes. The conclusion does not follow from the premise, which is what the lesson means by distinguishing a valid argument from a fallacious one. Do the same to Sumner.

The third position the lesson names

Dwight L. Moody and Billy Sunday drew bigger crowds than either Sumner or Rauschenbusch and belong in the comparison as a third answer, not a variant of the second: they agreed with the Social Gospel that the society was sick and with Sumner that the cure lay in individuals rather than in government. If you use them, say which of the two premises above each of them is denying.

A note on the texts. Sumner and Plunkitt are transcribed from Project Gutenberg editions of the 1883 and 1905 printings. Rauschenbusch is transcribed from a scan of the 1907 first edition and checked word for word against a second, independent scan of the same edition. Omissions are marked …

Sources: William Graham Sumner, What Social Classes Owe to Each Other (1883), Project Gutenberg (gutenberg.org); Walter Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907), scanned first edition (archive.org); Walter Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907), second scanned copy used to check the text (archive.org); William L. Riordon, Plunkitt of Tammany Hall (1905), Project Gutenberg (gutenberg.org)

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Seminar — Newcomers, Exclusion and Americanization
Prev
Performance Task — Public-History Exhibit: The Industrial City and Its People
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content