
explain the policies of Harding, Coolidge and Hoover, and analyze how mass production, the automobile, electricity, radio and the movies changed the economy, the landscape and popular culture at home and abroad.
Instruction
After the war, voters chose calm. Harding won the 1920 election in a landslide, promising a return to “normalcy.” The three Republican presidents of the 1920s governed during a boom built on new machines, and their choices shaped both the prosperity and its weaknesses.
Harding (1921-1923). Harding’s Treasury Secretary, Andrew Mellon, cut income taxes, especially on the highest incomes, arguing that lower rates would spur investment. Congress raised tariffs in the Fordney-McCumber Act (1922) and created a national budget system. Abroad, the Washington Naval Conference (1921-1922) limited battleship building by the major naval powers. Harding’s administration was also marked by scandal: in the Teapot Dome affair, Interior Secretary Albert Fall leased federal oil reserves to private companies in exchange for bribes and became the first cabinet member sent to prison. Harding died in office in August 1923.
Coolidge (1923-1929). Coolidge believed in limited government, balanced budgets and debt reduction. He twice vetoed the McNary-Haugen bills, which would have had the government buy surplus crops to raise farm prices. His administration signed the Kellogg-Briand Pact (1928), in which nations renounced war as an instrument of policy.
Hoover (1929-1933). Herbert Hoover, an engineer and the Commerce Secretary under both predecessors, championed “associationalism”: voluntary cooperation among businesses, guided by government information. He praised “rugged individualism.” Seven months into his term, the stock market crashed; you will judge his response in the second semester.
Mass production. In 1913 Henry Ford introduced a moving assembly line at his Highland Park plant, cutting the time to build a Model T from hours to about an hour and a half. The price of the car fell sharply, and in 1914 Ford raised pay to five dollars a day to keep workers on monotonous jobs. Other industries copied the method. Car registrations roughly tripled during the 1920s. The car created demand for steel, rubber, glass and oil; it created paved highways, gas stations, suburbs and tourist courts; and it changed courtship, family life and where people could live.
Electricity and credit. By 1930 most city homes had electricity, bringing refrigerators, washing machines and vacuum cleaners, while most farms still did not. Buying “on time” — installment credit — let families purchase these goods, and advertising taught them to want them.
Radio and the movies. Commercial radio began in 1920 when KDKA in Pittsburgh broadcast election returns; national networks followed (NBC, 1926). By 1930 about 40 percent of households owned a radio. Movies became the leading entertainment, and the industry concentrated on the West Coast, drawn by sunshine, varied scenery and cheap land. The Jazz Singer (1927) introduced synchronised dialogue to feature films. American films dominated screens around the world, spreading American fashions, slang and jazz, which is what historians mean by the global diffusion of popular culture.
Missouri in the boom. Missouri’s two big cities grew at different speeds. According to the Census Bureau, St. Louis grew from 772,897 residents in 1920 to 821,960 in 1930, about 6 percent, while Kansas City grew from 324,410 to 399,746, about 23 percent. In 1927 a young airmail pilot, Charles Lindbergh, flew solo across the Atlantic in the Spirit of St. Louis, a plane named for the St. Louis businessmen who had backed him; the flight made aviation, and Missouri’s part in it, famous.
Who shared the boom? Not everyone. Farm prices collapsed after wartime demand ended, and farmers stayed depressed all decade. Coal and textile workers faced wage cuts. The share of income going to the richest Americans rose. HI.6 asks you to use indicators carefully: rising average income can hide a falling median or whole sectors in decline. Keep this in mind; it is one of the explanations for the Depression.
Words in context. RH.11-12.4: Harding’s nostrums are quack remedies — a dig at Progressive and socialist programs.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Two presidents on the nation’s business
Warren G. Harding, ‘Readjustment’ address, Home Market Club, Boston (14 May 1920); Calvin Coolidge, Address to the American Society of Newspaper Editors, Washington (17 January 1925) · Public domain
Harding was a candidate speaking after war, strikes and the Red Scare. Coolidge was speaking to newspaper editors. What does each want his audience to believe about government?
Harding (1920): America’s present need is not heroics, but healing; not nostrums, but normalcy; not revolution, but restoration.
Coolidge (1925): After all, the chief business of the American people is business.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which policy best represents Coolidge’s approach to the economy?
Ford’s moving line began at Highland Park in 1913; KDKA in Pittsburgh began commercial in 1920; The Jazz (1927) brought sound to feature films.
Average income rose in the 1920s. What would you expect to find if you looked at farmers’ incomes over the same years?
Complete the analysis table: for each president, one policy and its intended effect; for three technologies (car, electricity, radio or movies), one economic and one social or landscape effect. Then write a paragraph (150-200 words) answering ‘Who shared in the prosperity of the 1920s?’ using at least two pieces of quantitative evidence with their sources.
How confident are you that you can explain the policies of the three 1920s presidents and how new technology reshaped the economy and culture?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: The Jazz Singer; KDKA’s first commercial broadcast; Ford’s moving assembly line; Teapot Dome scandal breaks during Harding’s term; Kellogg-Briand Pact.
Check your answer
Answer: Assembly line (1913); KDKA (1920); Teapot Dome (Harding’s term, 1921-1923); The Jazz Singer (1927); Kellogg-Briand (1928). - In Harding’s phrase ‘not nostrums, but normalcy’, what are nostrums?
Check your answer
Answer: Quack remedies — a dig at Progressive and socialist programs.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Coolidge said in 1925: ‘After all, the chief business of the American people is business.’ Who was his audience, and why might that matter?
Check your answer
Answer: The American Society of Newspaper Editors. Speaking to the press, he was explaining his view of government’s limited role and of the press’s place in a commercial society; the line is evidence of his philosophy, not of what all Americans valued. - Average income rose in the 1920s. Which other evidence from the lesson would you use to test the claim that ‘everyone prospered’?
Check your answer
Answer: Farm prices collapsed after 1920 and stayed low; coal and textile workers faced wage cuts; the richest Americans’ share of income rose; most farms lacked electricity. A strong answer distinguishes averages from distribution. - Ford’s assembly line began in 1913; car registrations roughly tripled in the 1920s. Cause or sequence?
Check your answer
Answer: Largely cause: mass production cut the price of cars sharply, making them affordable. Other causes include installment credit, advertising and paved roads; a strong answer names several.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- From Unit 2: which Gilded Age policy favored by industrial leaders did the Fordney-McCumber Act (1922) continue?
Check your answer
Answer: High protective tariffs.
Who Shared It: The 1920s in Eight Federal Series
U.S. Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to 1970, Bicentennial Edition (1975), series D723, D725, D727, K344, Q152, Q153, R104, S109, S110, S111 · Public domain (U.S. government work)
Why this reading. Lesson 4.2 answers its own quiz, blank-filling and prediction questions from the mini-lecture. One task it does not supply is the last one: a paragraph on who shared in the prosperity of the 1920s, “using at least two pieces of quantitative evidence with their sources.” There are no figures in the lesson to use. These are the figures, all from one federal compilation, with the series number for each. What to look for: the decade looks different depending on which row you stand on. Find the two rows that most sharply contradict the word “prosperity,” and the two that most support it.
The 1920s in eight rows
| Measure | Earlier | Later | Series |
|---|---|---|---|
| Passenger-car registrations | 8,131,500 (1920) | 23,120,800 (1929) | Q153 |
| All motor vehicles registered | 9,239,100 (1920) | 26,704,800 (1929) | Q152 |
| Households with radio sets | 60,000 (1922) | 10,250,000 (1929) | R104 |
| Dwellings with electric service, all | 34.7% (1920) | 68.2% (1930) | S109 |
| Dwellings with electric service, farms | 1.6% (1920) | 10.4% (1930) | S110 |
| Index of prices received by farmers (1967 = 100) | 85 (1919), 83 (1920) | 49 (1921), 58 (1929) | K344 |
| Average annual money earnings, all employees, after deduction for unemployment | $1,236 (1920) | $1,356 (1929) | D723 |
| The same earnings in constant 1914 dollars | $619 (1920) | $793 (1929) | D725 |
All rows are from the U.S. Bureau of the Census, Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to 1970 (1975), chapters D, K, Q, R and S. Give the series letter and number when you cite one; that is how a reader checks you.
What each row will and will not support
- The car and the radio are the decade’s best evidence for a mass consumer boom. Passenger cars nearly tripled in nine years. Households with radios went from 60,000 to over ten million in seven. Neither series tells you who bought on credit, and a great many did.
- Electricity shows the boom was not evenly spread, in one row. By 1930 more than two thirds of all dwellings had electric service — and one farm in ten. The same table gives urban and rural non-farm dwellings at 84.8 per cent. If you want a single number for the gap between the two Americas of the 1920s, it is 10.4 against 84.8.
- The farm-price row is the sharpest contradiction of “prosperity.” Prices received by farmers fell from 83 in 1920 to 49 in 1921 — a collapse of about forty per cent in one year — and had recovered only to 58 by 1929, still a third below the wartime level. This is the number behind the lesson’s prediction question, and behind the McNary-Haugen bills that Coolidge vetoed twice.
- The earnings rows need care, and they are where the paragraph is won or lost. Money earnings rose about 10 per cent between 1920 and 1929. Real earnings, in constant 1914 dollars, rose about 28 per cent — because consumer prices fell over the decade, from an index of 199.7 in 1920 to 170.9 in 1929. So the average worker really was better off, and the money figure understates it. But note what the series is: an average across all employees. It cannot tell you how the gain was distributed, and it includes neither farmers working their own land nor people out of work for the whole year.
That last point is the one the lesson’s skill note is about. An average rises when the top rises fast enough, even if the middle is flat. Nothing in this table settles that question; it takes a distribution, not a mean. What this table can settle is that at least one large group — farmers, still about a fifth of the workforce — did not share in the decade at all, and that another — rural households without electricity — was not living in the machine age the advertisements described. A paragraph built on the farm-price row and the farm-electricity row, with their series numbers, answers the question properly.
One caution about the radio row. The published table counts households with sets, not the share of households. You will see “about 40 per cent of households owned a radio by 1930” in many places; that is a calculation somebody made from these counts and a household total, not a printed figure. If you use a percentage, say how you got it.
Sources: Historical Statistics of the United States, Part 1, Chapter D (Labor), U.S. Census Bureau (www2.census.gov); Historical Statistics of the United States, Part 1, Chapter K (Agriculture), U.S. Census Bureau (www2.census.gov); Historical Statistics of the United States, Part 2, Chapter Q (Transportation), U.S. Census Bureau (www2.census.gov); Historical Statistics of the United States, Part 2, Chapter R (Communications), U.S. Census Bureau (www2.census.gov); Historical Statistics of the United States, Part 2, Chapter S (Energy), U.S. Census Bureau (www2.census.gov)