
analyze the events and ideas that prompted attacks on civil liberties after the war — the Red Scare, the Klan, immigration quotas and Prohibition — and evaluate the responses of the ACLU, the NAACP, the Anti-Defamation League and Garvey’s movement.
Instruction
The 1920s are remembered for jazz and prosperity. They were also years when many Americans tried to define the nation narrowly — by politics, race, religion and national origin — and when others built organizations to fight back.
Content note. This lesson discusses racial and religious violence.
The Red Scare. The Russian Revolution of 1917, a wave of strikes in 1919 and a series of anarchist mail bombs — one damaged Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer’s house in June 1919 — convinced many Americans that revolution was near. In November 1919 and January 1920 federal agents in the Palmer Raids arrested thousands of suspected radicals, many of them immigrants, often without warrants. In December 1919 the government deported 249 people to Russia on a single ship, including the anarchist Emma Goldman. A Labor Department official, Louis Post, canceled many further deportations for lack of evidence, and the panic faded when predicted uprisings did not happen. The trial of two Italian anarchists, Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, for a 1920 robbery-murder became an international cause; many observers believed prejudice shaped the verdict, and both were executed in 1927.
The Klan reborn. A new Ku Klux Klan was founded in 1915. Unlike the first, it was national and targeted Catholics, Jews and immigrants as well as Black Americans, claiming to defend “100 percent Americanism” and Protestant morality. By the mid-1920s it had millions of members and elected officials in states from Indiana to Oregon. It declined rapidly after its Indiana leader was convicted of murder in 1925. White mobs also attacked Black communities: in 1921 a mob destroyed the Greenwood district of Tulsa, Oklahoma, killing many residents.
Immigration restriction. The Emergency Quota Act (1921) and the Immigration Act of 1924 limited immigration by national origin, using the 1890 census so that quotas favored Northern and Western Europe over the Italians, Jews and Slavs of the new immigration. The 1924 law barred immigrants “ineligible to citizenship,” which in practice ended Japanese immigration. The Supreme Court had just held in Ozawa (1922) and Thind (1923) that Japanese and Indian immigrants could not naturalize because they were not “white”; after Thind, the government stripped some Indian Americans of citizenship. Immigration from the Western Hemisphere, including Mexico, was not capped, and the Border Patrol was created in 1924.
Prohibition. Temperance had deep religious roots in the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union and the Anti-Saloon League. The Eighteenth Amendment was ratified in 1919, and the Volstead Act, passed over Wilson’s veto, defined intoxicating liquor and set up enforcement. Drinking fell, but bootlegging, speakeasies and organized crime flourished, and enforcement fell hardest on the poor and on immigrant neighborhoods. The Twenty-first Amendment repealed Prohibition in 1933.
Faith and science. Fundamentalist Protestants defended the literal truth of Scripture against modernist theology and evolution. In 1925 John Scopes was tried in Dayton, Tennessee, for teaching evolution; William Jennings Bryan helped the prosecution and Clarence Darrow defended. Scopes was convicted (the verdict was later overturned on a technicality), but the trial exposed a cultural divide that has not closed.
The responses. The American Civil Liberties Union, founded in 1920, defended free speech for radicals and backed the Scopes defense. The NAACP investigated lynchings and pressed the Dyer anti-lynching bill, which passed the House in 1922 and died in a Senate filibuster. The Anti-Defamation League, founded in 1913 after the Leo Frank case, campaigned against anti-Semitism, including Henry Ford’s newspaper attacks on Jews, for which Ford publicly apologized in 1927. Marcus Garvey’s Universal Negro Improvement Association offered another answer: Black pride, Black-owned enterprise and a return to Africa. It attracted a mass following before Garvey was convicted of mail fraud in 1923 and deported in 1927.
Seminar question: Why did so many Americans accept limits on liberty after 1919, and which response did the most to defend it? HR.2 asks you to identify prejudice in historical sources and interpretations; name it where you find it. SL.11-12.1.c asks you to pose questions that probe reasoning and evidence.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Prohibition and the marketplace of ideas
U.S. Constitution, Amendment XVIII §1 (ratified 1919); Abrams v. United States, 250 U.S. 616 (1919), Holmes, J., dissenting · Public domain
Holmes wrote the Schenck opinion in March 1919. By November he was dissenting. What had changed in his reasoning?
Eighteenth Amendment, §1: After one year from the ratification of this article the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited.
Holmes, dissenting in Abrams (1919): The best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Why did the Immigration Act of 1924 base its quotas on the 1890 census rather than a more recent one?
The second Ku Klux Klan of the 1920s targeted only Black Americans.
ACLU (1920)
Tap to revealDefended free speech for unpopular groups; backed the Scopes defense.
NAACP and the Dyer bill
Tap to revealAnti-lynching bill passed the House in 1922; killed by Senate filibuster.
ADL (1913)
Tap to revealFounded after the Leo Frank case to fight anti-Semitism.
Scopes trial (1925)
Tap to revealTennessee trial over teaching evolution; fundamentalism versus modernism.
Twenty-first Amendment (1933)
Tap to revealRepealed Prohibition.
Record a 90-second contribution answering the seminar question with evidence from two events and one response. Then write two questions that probe the reasoning behind two of the sources or responses (for example, ‘What evidence shows that fear, rather than prejudice, drove this?’), and answer each in a sentence or two.
How confident are you that you can explain the attacks on civil liberties after 1919 and evaluate the organizations that responded?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: Scopes trial; ADL founded; ACLU founded; Immigration Act with national origins quotas based on 1890; Palmer Raids; Twenty-first Amendment.
Check your answer
Answer: ADL (1913); Palmer Raids (1919-1920); ACLU (1920); Immigration Act (1924); Scopes (1925); Twenty-first Amendment (1933). - What did the Volstead Act do?
Check your answer
Answer: It enforced Prohibition and defined intoxicating liquor; Congress passed it in 1919 over Wilson’s veto.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Holmes wrote in his Abrams dissent (November 1919): ‘The best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market.’ Compare with his Schenck opinion that March. What does the change suggest?
Check your answer
Answer: In Schenck he upheld a conviction under the clear-and-present-danger test; in Abrams he dissented, defending free competition of ideas. The shift suggests the question was genuinely hard at the time and that the Red Scare’s prosecutions pushed him to protect dissent. - Read the Eighteenth Amendment: it prohibited ‘the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors.’ What does the text not prohibit, and why might that matter for enforcement?
Check your answer
Answer: It does not prohibit drinking or possession. Enforcement therefore targeted production and trade, and people who already owned liquor or bought from bootleggers were hard to reach. - Prohibition took effect in 1920 and the second Klan grew rapidly in the early 1920s. A student concludes Prohibition caused the Klan. Evaluate.
Check your answer
Answer: The dates show overlap, not cause. The lesson connects them through shared claims about Protestant morality and ‘100 percent Americanism’; the Klan had other drivers too, including anti-Catholicism, anti-immigrant fear and racism. A strong answer asks for evidence linking the two.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- From Unit 2: which 1882 law was the first federal law to bar immigrants by nationality — a precedent for the 1924 quotas?
Check your answer
Answer: The Chinese Exclusion Act. - From Unit 1: which movement of the 1850s was anti-Catholic, like the second Klan?
Check your answer
Answer: The Know-Nothings.
Four Responses and Two Clauses: Liberty under Pressure after 1919
Immigration Act of 1924, 43 Stat. 153, sections 11(a) and 13(c); Abrams v. United States, 250 U.S. 616 (1919), Holmes, J., dissenting; NAACP, Thirty Years of Lynching in the United States, 1889-1918 (1919), 7; H.R. 13, 67th Cong., as reported (H.R. Rep. No. 452, 67th Cong., 1st Sess.); Marcus Garvey, ‘Africa for the Africans’, in Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey, ed. Amy Jacques-Garvey, vol. 1 (1923), 68-69 · Public domain
Why this reading. The seminar question in Lesson 4.3 has two halves — why so many Americans accepted limits on liberty after 1919, and which response did most to defend it — and the open question asks you to cite two events and one response. The lesson gives you one sentence of Holmes and the text of Prohibition, and not one word from the ACLU, the NAACP, the Anti-Defamation League or Marcus Garvey, whose work you are asked to evaluate. These are the documents for the second half of the question, plus the two clauses of the 1924 Act that the lesson’s quiz turns on. Content note: this reading contains the statistics of lynching and the legislative response to it. What to look for: each of these responses chooses a different instrument — a court, a statute, a count, a nation. Ask what each one assumed about where the danger was.
1. The limits themselves: the Immigration Act of 1924, in two sentences
The quiz asks why the quotas used the 1890 census. Here is the clause, at 43 Stat. 159:
SEC. 11. (a) The annual quota of any nationality shall be 2 per centum of the number of foreign-born individuals of such nationality resident in continental United States as determined by the United States census of 1890, but the minimum quota of any nationality shall be 100.
That is the whole mechanism. Two per cent of a population counted thirty-four years earlier, before the great migration from Italy, Poland, Greece and the Russian Empire. Nothing in the sentence mentions a nationality by name. The date does the work.
And the clause that ended Japanese immigration, at 43 Stat. 162:
(c) No alien ineligible to citizenship shall be admitted to the United States unless such alien (1) is admissible as a non-quota immigrant under the provisions of subdivision (b), (d), or (e) of section 4…
“Ineligible to citizenship” is defined in section 28(c) of the same Act by reference to the naturalization statutes — including section 14 of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which you read in Unit 1. This is the clause the Supreme Court had just filled with meaning in Ozawa (1922) and Thind (1923). The statute never says “Japanese.” It points at a court decision that does the excluding for it, exactly as Mississippi’s 1890 constitution pointed at a registrar. You have now seen the same technique three times in this course.
2. Holmes changes his mind: Abrams v. United States, 250 U.S. 616 (1919)
Holmes had written Schenck in March. In November he dissented, with Brandeis, from the conviction of five Russian-born anarchists sentenced to twenty years for throwing leaflets from a window. The lesson quotes one clause of the famous sentence; here is the paragraph it lives in, and the one before it.
In this case sentences of twenty years imprisonment have been imposed for the publishing of two leaflets that I believe the defendants had as much right to publish as the Government has to publish the Constitution of the United States now vainly invoked by them. … the most nominal punishment seems to me all that possibly could be inflicted, unless the defendants are to be made to suffer not for what the indictment alleges but for the creed that they avow — a creed that I believe to be the creed of ignorance and immaturity when honestly held…
Persecution for the expression of opinions seems to me perfectly logical. If you have no doubt of your premises or your power and want a certain result with all your heart you naturally express your wishes in law and sweep away all opposition. To allow opposition by speech seems to indicate that you think the speech impotent, as when a man says that he has squared the circle, or that you do not care whole-heartedly for the result, or that you doubt either your power or your premises. But when men have realized that time has upset many fighting faiths, they may come to believe even more than they believe the very foundations of their own conduct that the ultimate good desired is better reached by free trade in ideas — that the best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market, and that truth is the only ground upon which their wishes safely can be carried out. That at any rate is the theory of our Constitution. It is an experiment, as all life is an experiment. Every year if not every day we have to wager our salvation upon some prophecy based upon imperfect knowledge. While that experiment is part of our system I think that we should be eternally vigilant against attempts to check the expression of opinions that we loathe and believe to be fraught with death, unless they so imminently threaten immediate interference with the lawful and pressing purposes of the law that an immediate check is required to save the country.
Read the first sentence of that paragraph again: persecution is perfectly logical. Holmes is conceding the strongest case for the other side before answering it. His answer is not that speech is harmless; it is that certainty is unreliable, and that the Constitution is a bet placed on that fact. Your seminar contribution on why Americans accepted limits in 1919 is half-written by that paragraph — people who have no doubt of their premises do not think they are limiting liberty.
3. The NAACP counts: Thirty Years of Lynching in the United States, 1889–1918 (1919)
The NAACP’s instrument was arithmetic. It published this in April 1919, compiled from the records of the Chicago Tribune, Tuskegee Institute and The Crisis:
In the present study of the subject, we have confined ourselves to the story of the past thirty years, from 1889 to 1918, inclusive. During these years 3,224 persons have been killed by lynching mobs. Seven hundred and two white persons and 2,522 Negroes have been victims. Of the whites lynched, 691 have been men and 11 women; of the colored, 2,472 were men and 50 were women. For the whole period, 78.2 per cent. of the victims were Negroes and 21.8 per cent. white persons.
For the thirty years’ period as a whole, the North has had 219 victims, the South, 2,834, the West, 156, and Alaska and unknown localities, 15 victims. … Georgia leads in this unholy ascendancy with 386 victims, followed closely by Mississippi with 373 victims, Texas with 335, Louisiana with 313, Alabama with 276, Arkansas with 214, Tennessee with 196, Florida with 178 and Kentucky with 169.
Note the footnote the NAACP attached to its own total: 181 cases (43 white, 138 colored) were removed from the count after further investigation. An organization arguing for a federal law published the evidence that its own earlier figures had been too high, because the number had to survive being checked. That is the point of the document.
4. The NAACP legislates: the Dyer anti-lynching bill, H.R. 13, 67th Congress
Passed by the House on 26 January 1922 and killed by a Senate filibuster. The bill’s design is the interesting part: it does not simply make lynching a federal crime, it makes a state’s failure to prevent it a denial of equal protection, which is how it reaches into the states under the Fourteenth Amendment.
That the phrase “mob or riotous assemblage,” when used in this act, shall mean an assemblage composed of five or more persons acting in concert for the purpose of depriving any person of his life without authority of law as a punishment for or to prevent the commission of some actual or supposed public offense.
SEC. 2. That if any State or governmental subdivision thereof fails, neglects, or refuses to provide and maintain protection to the life of any person within its jurisdiction against a mob or riotous assemblage, such State shall by reason of such failure, neglect, or refusal be deemed to have denied to such person the equal protection of the laws of the State…
SEC. 3. That any State or municipal officer charged with the duty or who possesses the power or authority as such officer to protect the life of any person that may be put to death by any mob or riotous assemblage, or who has any such person in his charge as a prisoner, who fails, neglects, or refuses to make all reasonable efforts to prevent such person from being so put to death … shall be guilty of a felony, and upon conviction thereof shall be punished by imprisonment not exceeding five years or by a fine of not exceeding $5,000, or by both such fine and imprisonment.
Section 3 is aimed at the sheriff who hands over a prisoner, and section 5 (not quoted here) fined the county $10,000, payable to the victim’s family. The bill was drafted to make lynching expensive for the officials who allowed it. It never became law; the House passed it again in 1937 and 1940 and the Senate filibustered each time. Congress made lynching a federal hate crime in 2022.
5. Marcus Garvey answers differently: “Africa for the Africans” (1923)
Garvey’s instrument was neither a court nor a statute. His Universal Negro Improvement Association claimed millions of members and proposed to leave.
For five years the Universal Negro Improvement Association has been advocating the cause of Africa for the Africans—that is, that the Negro peoples of the world should concentrate upon the object of building up for themselves a great nation in Africa. When we started our propaganda toward this end several of the so-called intellectual Negroes who have been bamboozling the race for over half a century said that we were crazy, that the Negro peoples of the western world were not interested in Africa and could not live in Africa. … Some said that the black man would ultimately work out his existence alongside of the white man in countries founded and established by the latter. Therefore, it was not necessary for Negroes to seek an independent nationality of their own.
And the association’s aims, as printed in the same volume:
To improve the general condition of Negroes everywhere. To establish a government for Negroes in Africa where they will be given the opportunity to develop themselves.
“One editor and leader” who said Americans could not live in Africa is Du Bois, whom you met in Unit 1; the two men attacked each other for years. Put the four responses side by side and the seminar question becomes answerable. The ACLU took cases to courts. The NAACP counted, then legislated, then went back to the courts. The Anti-Defamation League, founded after the lynching of Leo Frank, worked on public opinion, and in 1927 extracted a public apology from Henry Ford for his newspaper’s campaign against Jews. Garvey concluded that none of that would work in a country built this way, and proposed a different country. None of the four got what it asked for in the 1920s. Judging which “did the most” means saying what you are counting — laws passed, cases won, people organized, or arguments that survived to be used later — and a contribution that does not name its measure has not answered the question.
A note on the texts. The 1924 Act is from the official Statutes at Large volume on govinfo.gov. Holmes is from the official United States Reports, with two scanner errors corrected to the printed reading. The NAACP pamphlet and Garvey are from scans of the 1919 and 1923 printings; Garvey’s own spelling is kept. The Dyer bill is the committee substitute as reported to the House in October 1921, which is the text the House passed; it has not been collated against the engrossed bill. Omissions are marked …
Sources: United States Statutes at Large, vol. 43 (Immigration Act of 1924), govinfo.gov (govinfo.gov); Abrams v. United States, 250 U.S. 616 (1919), official U.S. Reports (tile.loc.gov); NAACP, Thirty Years of Lynching in the United States, 1889-1918 (1919), Internet Archive (archive.org); Anti-lynching bill: report to accompany H.R. 13, 67th Congress, Internet Archive (archive.org); Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey, vol. 1 (1923), Internet Archive (archive.org)