THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP Physics A — Motion, Forces, Momentum and Gravitation

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 20 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Motion in One and Two Dimensions
    5
    • 1.1
      Can the Car Stop? Position, Velocity and Motion Graphs
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Ramp Lab: Measuring Acceleration Frame by Frame
      100 mins
    • 1.3
      Reaction Time or Braking Distance? Arguing from the Equations
      50 mins
    • 1.4
      Vectors and Projectiles: Predicting Where It Lands
      100 mins
    • 1.5
      Performance Task — Time to Stop: Yellow Lights and School Zones
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Forces and Newton’s Laws
    5
    • 2.1
      Runaway Trucks on I-70: Forces, Free-Body Diagrams and Newton’s Laws
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Cart Lab: Testing Newton’s Second Law with Data
      100 mins
    • 2.3
      Does Area Matter? Arguing About Friction from Data
      50 mins
    • 2.4
      Inclines, Pulleys and Elevators: Modeling with Newton’s Second Law
      100 mins
    • 2.5
      Performance Task — Design a Runaway-Truck Escape Ramp
      150 mins
  • Unit 3: Momentum, Collisions and Crash Safety
    5
    • 3.1
      Helmets, Airbags and the Impulse-Momentum Theorem
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Collision Carts and the Conservation of Momentum
      100 mins
    • 3.3
      Where Did the Momentum Go? Arguing from Collision Data
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Crumple Zones, Foam and Designed Materials
      100 mins
    • 3.5
      Performance Task — Design, Test and Defend a Crash-Safety Device
      50 mins
  • Unit 4: Gravitation, Circular Motion and Orbits
    5
    • 4.1
      Staying Up: Circular Motion and the Centripetal Force
      100 mins
    • 4.2
      Pendulum Lab: Measuring the Strength of Earth’s Gravity
      100 mins
    • 4.3
      The Apple and the Moon: Arguing for the Inverse-Square Law
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Orbits by the Numbers: GPS, Geostationary Satellites and Kepler’s Third Law
      100 mins
    • 4.5
      Performance Task — Choose an Orbit for a Missouri Flood-Watch Satellite
      150 mins

Does Area Matter? Arguing About Friction from Data

Unit 2  ·  Scientific Argumentation Lab  ·  Lesson 8 of 20

Does Area Matter? Arguing About Friction from Data

9-12.PS2.A.1RLP-PHYA
Hands compare wooden blocks with different contact areas and added masses using spring scales.
By the end of this lesson I can…

use friction data to find coefficients of static and kinetic friction, and argue from evidence whether friction depends on normal force, contact area or both.

Instruction

The argument. Two claims come up again and again. Claim A: “Wider tires stop a car faster because more rubber touches the road.” Claim B: “Friction depends on how hard the surfaces press together, not on how much area touches.” Today you use data to decide which claim the evidence supports for everyday sliding friction, and where the simple model stops working.

The friction model. Static friction holds a resting object in place. It adjusts to match whatever push you apply, up to a maximum fs,max = μsFN. Once the object slides, kinetic friction is roughly constant, fk = μkFN, and usually μk < μs. The coefficients μ have no units and depend on the two materials. OpenStax College Physics 2e lists wood on wood at about μs = 0.5 and μk = 0.3.

Worked example. A 20 kg wooden crate on a wooden floor: FN = 196 N, so it will not move until you push harder than 0.5 × 196 = 98 N. Push with 60 N and static friction pushes back with exactly 60 N; nothing moves. Push with 120 N and it breaks free; kinetic friction is 0.3 × 196 = 58.8 N, so a = (120 − 58.8)/20 = 3.06 m/s2. That is why a heavy object “jumps” once it starts: friction suddenly drops.

Evidence 1: friction against normal force. A student pulled a wooden block with a spring scale, adding masses to change the normal force (illustrative data):

Block + added mass (kg)Normal force FN (N)Max static friction (N)Kinetic friction (N)
0.5004.92.21.6
1.0009.84.53.0
1.50014.76.54.8
2.00019.68.96.2
051015200246810static (max)kineticNormal force FN (N)friction f (N)
Illustrative data: squares are maximum static friction, circles kinetic friction.

Both sets of points lie close to straight lines through the origin, so friction is proportional to the normal force. The slopes are the coefficients: μs ≈ 0.45 and μk ≈ 0.32.

Evidence 2: contact area. The same 1.000 kg block (FN = 9.8 N) was dragged on its wide face and then on its narrow side, three times each. Kinetic friction averaged 3.13 N on the wide face and 3.17 N on the narrow side: μk = 0.320 and 0.323. The difference, 0.03 N, is smaller than the 0.1 N spread between repeated trials, so the data show no measurable effect of area. At the microscopic level, surfaces touch only at tiny high points. Pressing harder flattens more of them together; spreading the same load over more area just means each point presses more lightly, and the true contact area stays about the same.

What it means for stopping a car. For tires, μ is the grip coefficient. OpenStax College Physics 2e lists rubber on dry concrete at μk = 0.7 and on wet concrete at 0.5. At 25 m/s with μ = 0.7 on dry pavement, the maximum deceleration is μg = 6.86 m/s2 and the braking distance is v2/(2μg) = 45.6 m. On wet pavement with μ = 0.5 it is 63.8 m. Mass cancels: a heavier car needs more friction but also presses harder on the road. Rubber on pavement is where the simple model is weakest. Tread, temperature and water film all matter, and wide tires are chosen mainly for heat and wear, not because the textbook model predicts more friction.

Building the argument. A strong argument states a claim, cites specific data (slopes, means, the spread between trials), gives reasoning (the proportional model and the microscopic picture), and answers a counterclaim by saying what evidence would change your mind.

📖 Read for this lesson

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.

  • Friction Record: Static and Kinetic Trials at Four Loads, and the Wide-Face Narrow-Face TestSLS original spring-scale record for the lesson’s wooden block (three static and three kinetic trials at each of four loads; three kinetic trials on each face); constructed teaching data whose means reproduce the lesson’s table · about 4 min

    Static and kinetic spring-scale trials at four loads, on both the wide and narrow face of the same block, so the ‘does area matter’ argument is tested against a full record rather than the lesson’s summary numbers.

Vocabulary in context

  • static friction — Friction on surfaces that are not sliding; it matches the applied push up to μsFN.
  • kinetic friction — Friction on sliding surfaces, about μkFN.
  • coefficient of friction (μ) — The ratio of friction to normal force for a pair of materials; it has no units.
  • counterclaim — A competing claim that a good argument states fairly and answers with evidence.

Lab: Friction mini-lab: normal force and contact area

Question. Is the friction on a sliding block proportional to the normal force, and does it change when the contact area changes?

Materials

  • A rectangular wooden block (or a full box of crayons or a hardcover book) with a hook or string loop
  • A spring scale reading 0-10 N, or a phone force app with a rubber band calibrated with known masses
  • Masses to stack on the block (500 g bags of rice, cans of food or slotted masses) and a kitchen scale
  • A long flat table or floor
Safety.
  • Keep stacked masses low and centered so they do not fall on feet; tape them down if needed.
  • Pull the scale horizontally and slowly; do not let a stretched spring scale snap back toward anyone’s face.

Procedure

  1. Mass the block. Hook the scale to it and pull horizontally, slowly increasing the force. Record the largest reading just before it starts to slide (static) and the steady reading while it slides at constant speed (kinetic). Do three trials.
  2. Add mass to raise the total to about 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 kg and repeat step 1 at each load.
  3. With the load fixed at about 1.0 kg, turn the block onto its narrow side and repeat three kinetic trials. Compare with the wide face.
  4. Compute FN = mg for each load, graph both frictions against FN, and find each slope.

Data

Block + added mass (kg)Normal force FN (N)Max static friction (N)Kinetic friction (N)
0.5004.92.21.6
1.0009.84.53.0
1.50014.76.54.8
2.00019.68.96.2
Rows above are illustrative; record three trials per load and their means.

Analysis

  1. Claim-evidence-reasoning: is friction proportional to normal force? Use your graph’s shape and slopes as evidence.
  2. Compare wide and narrow faces. Is the difference in mean friction larger than the spread between your repeated trials? What does that tell you about the area claim?
  3. Which reading was harder to measure, static or kinetic friction, and how did that affect your uncertainty?

If you cannot do this lab in person: Use the illustrative data table in the lesson, or PhET Forces and Motion: Basics (Friction screen): set friction to a fixed level, find the push that starts the 50 kg crate moving and the push that keeps it moving at constant speed, then stack a second object on top and repeat.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

A 20 kg crate has &mu;s = 0.5 and &mu;k = 0.3. You push horizontally with 80 N. What happens?

The maximum static friction is 0.5 &times; 196 = 98 N. 80 N is less than that, so static friction matches the push at 80 N (not 98 N) and the crate stays at rest.
Myth or Fact?

If turning a block onto a narrower face changes the mean friction by 0.03 N while repeated trials on one face vary by 0.1 N, the data support the claim that area matters.

A difference smaller than the trial-to-trial spread is not evidence of an effect. The data are consistent with friction independent of area.

Simulation & tools

Static and kinetic friction

Open the Friction screen. Turn on Forces, Sum of Forces, Values and Masses. With the 50 kg crate (weight 490 N), raise the applied force slowly from zero and record the largest force at which the crate stays still. Then record the force needed to keep it moving at steady speed once it slides. Compute μs and μk by dividing each by 490 N. Stack a second object on the crate and repeat. Do both coefficients stay the same when the normal force changes? No device: use the illustrative table in the lesson to compute the two coefficients at each load.

Open in a new tab ↗  ·  PhET Interactive Simulations, University of Colorado Boulder · CC BY 4.0

Record a 90-second argument (or write 200 words) that answers Claim A or Claim B from the lesson. Cite your own or the illustrative friction data (slopes, means and spread), explain the microscopic reasoning, and answer the strongest counterclaim, including what new evidence would change your mind. Then write a 75-word reply to your own argument as a skeptical reader would, supporting, qualifying or challenging it, and say what you would change. A written version earns equal credit.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can find friction coefficients from data and argue from evidence about what friction depends on?

Not yetVery confident

Practice

Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.

Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)

Fluency

Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.

  1. A net force of 18.0 N acts on a 12 kg object. What is its acceleration?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 1.50 m/s2
    a = Fnet/m.
  2. What net force gives a 0.5 kg object an acceleration of 3 m/s2?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 1.50 N
    Fnet = ma.
  3. A net force of 0.75 N acts on a 0.5 kg object. What is its acceleration?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 1.50 m/s2
    a = Fnet/m.
  4. A 35 kg dresser has μs = 0.45 and μk = 0.30 on the floor. What push starts it moving, and what friction acts once it slides?
    Check your answer
    Answer: more than 154 N; 103 N
    FN = 343 N. Static max 0.45 × 343 = 154 N; kinetic 0.30 × 343 = 103 N.
  5. A 6.0 kg block slides at constant speed when pulled with 18 N horizontally. Find μk.
    Check your answer
    Answer: 0.306
    Constant speed means friction = 18 N; μk = 18/(6.0 × 9.8) = 0.306.
  6. Once the dresser above is sliding, you push with 200 N. What is its acceleration?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 2.77 m/s2
    (200 − 102.9)/35 = 2.77 m/s2.

Application

Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.

  1. A car at 27 m/s brakes as hard as possible. Compare stopping distances on dry pavement (μ = 0.75) and wet (μ = 0.45), illustrative values.
    Check your answer
    Answer: 49.6 m dry; 82.7 m wet
    a = μg, d = v2/(2μg): 729/(2 × 0.75 × 9.8) = 49.6 m; with 0.45, 82.7 m.
  2. Investigators measure 45 m skid marks from a car whose driver claims to have been going 27 m/s. What effective μ would that require, and is it plausible for dry pavement?
    Check your answer
    Answer: μ = 0.83; plausible
    μ = v2/(2gd) = 729/(2 × 9.8 × 45) = 0.83, within the typical dry range, so the data are consistent with the claim.
  3. A friend claims doubling the load on a block doubles its coefficient of friction. Use the model f = μFN to respond.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Doubling the load doubles the friction force, not μ
    μ depends on the materials. Friction doubles because FN doubles; the ratio f/FN stays the same, as the straight line through the origin on an f-versus-FN graph shows.

Challenge

Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.

  1. You push a 20 kg box with 100 N directed 30° below horizontal; μk = 0.30. Find the normal force and the acceleration. Why is pushing down less effective than pulling up?
    Check your answer
    Answer: FN = 246 N; a = 0.64 m/s2
    FN = mg + 100 sin 30° = 246 N, so friction = 73.8 N. a = (100 cos 30° − 73.8)/20 = 0.64 m/s2. Pushing down raises the normal force and so the friction.

Review

Keep earlier skills sharp.

  1. An object starts at 3 m/s and accelerates at 3 m/s2 for 8 s. How far does it travel?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 120.0 m
    d = v0t + ½at2.
  2. An object starts at 3 m/s and accelerates at 1.5 m/s2 for 7 s. How far does it travel?
    Check your answer
    Answer: 57.8 m
    d = v0t + ½at2.

Missouri Learning Standards — Science addressed: 9-12.PS2.A.1, SEP.4, SEP.7, CCC.2, RST.11-12.8, MP.3

Instructional focus: Argument from data about a force model and its limits

Reading

Friction Record: Static and Kinetic Trials at Four Loads, and the Wide-Face Narrow-Face Test

SLS original spring-scale record for the lesson’s wooden block (three static and three kinetic trials at each of four loads; three kinetic trials on each face); constructed teaching data whose means reproduce the lesson’s table · SLS original (CC BY 4.0); constructed teaching data, labeled illustrative

Why this reading. The argument you record must cite “slopes, means and spread” and answer a counterclaim with what evidence would change your mind. The lesson’s table has means only, and the area test is reported in one sentence. Here are the trials behind both, with the spread you need, and the two claims stated as claims. The numbers are constructed to the lesson’s means; they are illustrative.

The two claims

Claim A. Friction grows with the area of contact: wider tires, or a block on its wide face, produce more friction because more surface touches. Claim B. Friction grows with the normal force, the force pressing the surfaces together, and does not depend on the area of contact.

Evidence 1: four loads, wooden block on a wooden table

Spring scale pulled horizontally and slowly. Static = largest reading just before the block moved; kinetic = steady reading while sliding at constant speed. Scale resolution 0.1 N.

Block + load (kg)FN = mg (N)Static 1 (N)Static 2Static 3Mean staticKinetic 1 (N)Kinetic 2Kinetic 3Mean kinetic
0.5004.92.12.32.22.201.51.71.61.60
1.0009.84.64.34.64.503.12.93.03.00
1.50014.76.46.76.46.504.94.74.84.80
2.00019.68.89.18.88.906.36.16.26.20

Lines through the origin fitted to the means: maximum static friction = 0.451 FN and kinetic friction = 0.318 FN, so μs ≈ 0.45 and μk ≈ 0.32. Doubling the load from 1.000 to 2.000 kg took the kinetic mean from 3.0 to 6.2 N, a factor of 2.07; quadrupling it from 0.500 to 2.000 kg took static friction from 2.2 to 8.9 N, a factor of 4.05. Proportional within the scatter. The trial-to-trial spread at any one load is 0.2 to 0.3 N, and the static readings are the noisier ones: the needle jumps at the instant of release and you read the peak by eye.

Evidence 2: the same load, two faces

Block plus load 1.000 kg (FN = 9.8 N). Kinetic friction, three trials on each face. The wide face has about 2.5 times the area of the narrow side.

FaceTrial 1 (N)Trial 2Trial 3Mean (N)Range (N)μk = mean / 9.8
Wide face (block flat)3.053.23.143.130.150.319
Narrow side (block on edge)3.223.13.193.170.120.323

The means differ by 0.04 N, and the narrow side is the larger of the two, the opposite of what Claim A predicts. But the trials on a single face range over 0.12 to 0.15 N, so a 0.04 N difference between faces is smaller than the disagreement between repeated trials on one face. Data like these do not show that area has no effect; they show that any effect is smaller than about 0.1 N at this load, which is a few percent of the friction. Say it that way.

Why Claim B wins here, and where it stops

Two solid surfaces touch only at their high points. Pressing harder flattens more of them into contact, so the true contact area grows with the normal force, whatever the apparent area. Turning the block onto its edge puts the same load on fewer high points, each pressed harder, and the true contact area comes out about the same. That is the reasoning behind μ being a property of the two materials and not of the block’s shape.

The counterclaim you must answer is the tire. Rubber is soft, so it does not behave like a wooden block: it drapes into the road texture, it heats, and on a wet road a water film changes everything. The lesson’s tire numbers (μ = 0.7 dry, 0.5 wet) are illustrative, and the honest statement is that wide tires are chosen for heat and wear and grip on soft rubber, where the block model is weakest. What evidence would change your mind about the block? A face test at 2.000 kg where the difference between faces exceeded the trial spread in the direction Claim A predicts, repeated on a second block.

Your turn

  1. Plot both frictions against FN with error bars equal to the range of the three trials. Draw the two lines through the origin and read μs and μk from their slopes.
  2. Using the 20 kg crate in the lesson (μs = 0.5, μk = 0.3), find the push needed to start it and its acceleration under a 120 N push. Then redo both with this block’s coefficients.
  3. Is the wide-narrow difference larger than the trial spread? Write the sentence that states exactly what the face test does and does not show.
  4. Record or write the 90-second argument: claim, the slopes and the face-test means as evidence, the high-points reasoning, and the tire counterclaim with the evidence that would change your mind.

Sources: NIST, standard acceleration of gravity g_n = 9.80665 m/s^2 (exact) (physics.nist.gov)

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Cart Lab: Testing Newton’s Second Law with Data
Prev
Inclines, Pulleys and Elevators: Modeling with Newton’s Second Law
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content