
model an impact with stopping distance, stopping time and average force, and explain how the molecular and cellular structure of foam and other designed materials lets them absorb a collision.
Instruction
Stopping distance is the design variable
Engineers rarely control stopping time directly; they control how far something can crush. If an object decelerates uniformly from speed v to rest over distance d, its average speed is v/2, so Δt = 2d/v and the deceleration is a = v2/(2d). Double the crush distance and you halve the force.
Worked example: the egg drop
A 60 g egg falls 1.0 m. It lands at v = √(2gh) = √(2 × 9.8 × 1.0) = 4.43 m/s with momentum 0.060 × 4.43 = 0.266 kg·m/s.
- On a hard floor the shell and floor give only about 2 mm (illustrative): Δt = 2 × 0.002 / 4.43 = 0.90 ms, so F = 0.266 / 0.00090 = 294 N.
- On foam that crushes 3 cm: Δt = 13.6 ms and F = 19.6 N, fifteen times smaller.
Worked example: a crumple zone
A 1,500 kg car hits a rigid barrier at 13.4 m/s (30 mph). If its front were nearly rigid and crushed only 10 cm, the deceleration would be 13.42/(2 × 0.10) = 898 m/s2 (about 92 g) over 15 ms. A crumple zone that folds over 60 cm gives 150 m/s2 (about 15 g) over 90 ms, and the average force on the car drops from 1,347 kN to 224 kN (distances illustrative). The passenger compartment is built stiff so that the front does the crushing and the cabin keeps its shape.
Missouri highways use the same idea outside the car. MoDOT’s Engineering Policy Guide says impact attenuators, such as the yellow sand-barrel arrays at the blunt ends of work-zone barriers, “are designed to absorb energy of an impacting vehicle and reduce the force on a passenger.” The barrels lengthen the stop exactly as a crumple zone does.
Why materials matter: structure at the molecular level (9-12.PS1.A.4)
Expanded polystyrene (EPS), the white foam in most bike helmets, is made of long polystyrene polymer chains. Beads of the polymer are expanded with a gas and fused into a foam of tiny closed cells whose walls are thin polymer films. Solid polystyrene has a density of about 1,050 kg/m3; a foam of 60 kg/m3 (illustrative) is about 94% gas by volume. On impact the cell walls buckle and collapse one layer after another. Because the chains are tangled and glassy at room temperature, they do not snap back: the work of crushing becomes permanent deformation and heat instead of being returned as a bounce. That is why a helmet that has taken a hard hit must be replaced.
Compare three structures. A rubber ball’s cross-linked chains stretch and recoil; it returns energy, so the object rebounds and Δp grows. A brittle solid such as glass has rigid bonds that crack before they deform much, so it stops things in a tiny distance. A crushable cellular material (EPS foam, corrugated cardboard, a honeycomb, a folded steel crumple rail) is designed to collapse at a nearly constant force over a long distance.
The area under a force-distance graph is the energy absorbed, mgh = 0.060 × 9.8 × 1.0 = 0.588 J. The foam holds 19.6 N the whole way; a spring stopping the egg in the same 3 cm has to reach 39.2 N, then pushes the egg back up. A flat plateau is the ideal crash-safety shape.
Common misconceptions
- “Softer is always safer.” Foam that is too soft bottoms out and the force spikes at the end; the best liner is matched to the expected speed and mass.
- “Strong cars are safe cars.” The cabin should be strong; the front and rear should be designed to crumple.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Egg Crash-Test Cart: Measuring the Effect of a Crumple Zone
Question. How does the crush distance of a crumple zone on a cart change the average force on an egg ‘passenger’ when the cart hits a wall at a fixed speed?
Materials
- Toy truck or toy car with a flat bed
- Raw egg sealed in a zip-top bag (the passenger) and tape or a rubber band as a seat belt
- Ramp: a board 1 m long propped on books to a measured height of 10-20 cm
- Crumple-zone materials: paper cups, straws, index cards, corrugated cardboard, packing foam
- Heavy book or brick as the wall, meter stick, phone camera for slow-motion video
- Safety goggles, paper towels and a tray or plastic sheet under the impact zone
- Wear goggles: the egg or bits of the crumple zone can fly on impact.
- Keep the egg sealed in its bag; wash hands with soap after handling eggs (raw egg can carry Salmonella).
- Release the cart from a fixed mark; do not push it, and keep hands and faces out of the lane.
- Clean up any broken egg immediately with paper towels so no one slips.
Procedure
- Measure the ramp height and mark a release line so every run starts at the same speed. Film one run without an egg to measure the speed at the bottom from video.
- Run the cart into the wall with a bare, rigid front (a block of wood) and a hard-boiled or plastic practice egg. From slow-motion video, estimate the crush distance (likely a few millimeters).
- Build crumple zone 1 (for example, 4 paper cups taped mouth-down to the front). Measure how far it crushes from video or by measuring its length before and after.
- Build two more designs with different materials or structures (straw bundles, folded card accordions, foam). Keep the total added mass within 20 g of the other designs.
- Run each design three times with a fresh raw egg only after it survives with the practice egg. Record survival, crush distance and speed.
- Compute the stopping time 2d/v and the average force mΔv/Δt on the egg for each run.
Data
| Design | Material and structure | Speed at wall (m/s) | Crush distance (m) | Stopping time 2d/v (s) | Average force on egg (N) | Egg survived? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Illustrative | 4 paper cups, mouth down | 1.40 | 0.035 | 0.050 | 1.7 | yes |
| Rigid front | ||||||
| Design 1 | ||||||
| Design 2 | ||||||
| Design 3 |
The illustrative row (a 60 g egg) shows the calculation and is not a real measurement.
Illustrative data set (Option B). Five designs run on the same ramp with a 60 g egg. These numbers are constructed to show the calculation; they are not real measurements. Stopping time is 2d/v and average force is mΔv/Δt.
| Design | Speed at the wall (m/s) | Crush distance d (m) | Stopping time 2d/v (s) | Average force on the egg (N) | Egg survived? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rigid wooden front (control) | 1.40 | 0.004 | 0.0057 | 14.7 | no |
| 4 paper cups, mouth down | 1.40 | 0.035 | 0.050 | 1.68 | yes |
| 20 drinking straws standing upright | 1.42 | 0.055 | 0.0775 | 1.10 | yes |
| Folded index-card accordion | 1.38 | 0.022 | 0.0319 | 2.60 | yes |
| Packing-foam block | 1.41 | 0.018 | 0.0255 | 3.31 | yes |
A crush distance read from 30 fps video is good to about ±0.003 m. Carry that uncertainty through when you decide which designs really differ.
Analysis
- Claim, evidence, reasoning: which design produced the smallest average force, and how does your data show that crush distance (and therefore stopping time) controls the force?
- Explain your best material’s performance in terms of its structure: what happens to the cup walls, straw tubes or foam cells as they crush, and why does that absorb energy instead of returning it?
- Your crush distances come from video with limited resolution. Estimate the uncertainty in d and how it affects your force estimate; was the difference between designs larger than that uncertainty?
If you cannot do this lab in person: Choose one. All three earn full credit and end in the same force calculations and the same claim-evidence-reasoning conclusion. Option A — build and crash. The procedure above, on a table or floor at home with a toy truck, a ramp of books and a heavy book as the wall. Option B — the illustrative data set in the data section above. No equipment and no internet needed. Compute the stopping time and average force for all five designs yourself, rank them, and use the ±0.003 m uncertainty in d to decide which differences are larger than the measurement. Option C — PhET Collision Lab. Use the sim block below as a measured experiment rather than a demonstration: on the Explore 1D screen, record ball 1’s momentum change at 100% and at 0% elasticity, then compute the average force you would need for each of three stopping times you choose (0.005 s, 0.020 s and 0.050 s). Use those numbers to explain why crush distance controls the force and why a zone that crushes and stays crushed is safer than one that springs back. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A 60 g egg lands at 4.43 m/s on foam that crushes 3 cm. Assuming uniform deceleration, what is the stopping time?
A good helmet liner should spring back to its original shape after an impact so it can return the energy to the head.
Simulation & tools
Bounce versus stick: impulse on the target
Open the Explore 1D screen. Set ball 1 to 0.50 kg moving at 1.00 m/s and ball 2 to 3.00 kg at rest (a heavy ‘wall’). Turn on the data table. Run with elasticity 100% and record ball 1’s velocity after; compute Δp1 = m(v′ − v). Reset and repeat at elasticity 0%. Which setting gives ball 1 the larger momentum change, and so the larger impulse from the wall? Use your answer to explain why helmet foam is designed not to bounce. No device? Compute it by hand: for 100% elasticity, v′1 = (m1 − m2)v/(m1 + m2); for 0%, v′ = m1v/(m1 + m2).
Open in a new tab ↗ · PhET Interactive Simulations, University of Colorado Boulder · CC BY 4.0
Write a one-paragraph explanation, with a labeled sketch, for a family buying a child’s bike helmet: why is the liner made of foam full of tiny closed cells rather than solid plastic or rubber, and why should a helmet be replaced after one hard crash? Use the words polymer, cell, deform and force.
How confident are you that you can calculate the force in an impact from crush distance and explain how a material’s structure helps it absorb a collision?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- A ball is released from rest 20 m above the ground. Use conservation of energy (ignore air resistance) to find its speed just before impact.
Check your answer
Answer: 19.8 m/smgh = ½mv2, so v = √(2gh); mass cancels. - A ball is released from rest 2 m above the ground. Use conservation of energy (ignore air resistance) to find its speed just before impact.
Check your answer
Answer: 6.3 m/smgh = ½mv2, so v = √(2gh); mass cancels. - An object starts at 9 m/s and accelerates at 3 m/s2 for 5 s. How far does it travel?
Check your answer
Answer: 82.5 md = v0t + ½at2. - An object starts at 5 m/s and accelerates at 1 m/s2 for 7 s. How far does it travel?
Check your answer
Answer: 59.5 md = v0t + ½at2. - A 60 g egg falls 1.5 m. Find its impact speed and the average force if it stops in 4.0 cm of foam.
Check your answer
Answer: 5.42 m/s; 22.1 Nv = √(2 × 9.8 × 1.5) = 5.42 m/s. F = mv2/(2d) = 0.060 × 29.4/0.08 = 22.1 N. - For the same egg stopping in 4.0 cm, what is the stopping time?
Check your answer
Answer: 14.8 msΔt = 2d/v = 0.08/5.42 = 14.8 ms.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A 1,500 kg car hits a barrier at 15.6 m/s (35 mph). Compare the average force on the car for crush distances of 0.15 m and 0.75 m (illustrative).
Check your answer
Answer: 1,217 kN vs 243 kNF = mv2/(2d): 1,216,800 N and 243,360 N; five times the crush distance gives one fifth the force. - Design target: the 60 g egg dropped 1.5 m must feel an average force under 15 N. What minimum crush distance does the model require?
Check your answer
Answer: 5.9 cmd = mv2/(2F) = 0.060 × 29.4/30 = 0.0588 m. - Explain, in terms of structure, why expanded polystyrene absorbs an impact better than a rubber block of the same size.
Check your answer
Answer: EPS cells buckle and stay crushed, turning the energy into permanent deformation and heat; rubber’s cross-linked chains recoil and return the energy as a bounce.The work of crushing the egg’s 0.882 J of fall energy goes into collapsing thin polymer cell walls. A bounce would reverse the velocity and increase Δp.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Two liners each stop the same egg in 3.0 cm. Foam A holds a nearly constant force; liner B behaves like a spring whose force rises linearly from zero. Both absorb the same energy. What is B’s peak force compared with A’s constant force?
Check your answer
Answer: Twice as largeEnergy = area under F-d. A: FAd. B: ½Fpeakd. Equal areas give Fpeak = 2FA (for this egg, 58.8 N vs 29.4 N).
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- A net force of 120 N acts on a 60 kg object. What is its acceleration?
Check your answer
Answer: 2.00 m/s2a = Fnet/m. - A net force of 3.0 N acts on a 2 kg object. What is its acceleration?
Check your answer
Answer: 1.50 m/s2a = Fnet/m.
Crush Record: Three Runs per Design, the Force-Distance Plateau, and Why the Cells Do Not Spring Back
SLS original run-by-run record behind the lesson’s five-design illustrative data set (60 g egg, 30 fps video, +/-0.003 m in d), the foam-versus-spring force-distance tables for a 0.588 J egg drop, and the crumple-zone check values; constructed teaching data, not measurements; federal limits re-checked against Cornell LII, Nov. 5, 2026 · SLS original (CC BY 4.0); constructed teaching data, labeled illustrative
Why this reading. The lab’s Option B hands you five means and asks you to decide which designs “really differ” using an uncertainty of ±0.003 m. Means without their runs cannot show you a spread. Here are the three runs behind each mean, the force-distance plateau the lesson graphs, given as numbers so you can integrate it, and the crumple-zone figures with their arithmetic shown. Illustrative throughout.
1. The runs
Same ramp, same release mark, 60 g egg in a bag, wall a heavy book. Speed at the wall from video over the last 0.30 m; crush distance from the design’s length before and after, checked against video. Stopping time 2d/v; average force on the egg mv2/(2d), which is the same as mΔv/Δt.
| Design | v run 1 (m/s) | v run 2 | v run 3 | d run 1 (m) | d run 2 | d run 3 | Mean v | Mean d | 2d/v (s) | Average force (N) | Egg survived (3 runs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rigid wooden front (control) | 1.40 | 1.41 | 1.39 | 0.004 | 0.005 | 0.003 | 1.40 | 0.004 | 0.0057 | 14.70 | no, no, no |
| 4 paper cups, mouth down | 1.40 | 1.38 | 1.42 | 0.035 | 0.032 | 0.038 | 1.40 | 0.035 | 0.0500 | 1.68 | yes, yes, yes |
| 20 drinking straws standing upright | 1.42 | 1.43 | 1.41 | 0.055 | 0.058 | 0.052 | 1.42 | 0.055 | 0.0775 | 1.10 | yes, yes, yes |
| Folded index-card accordion | 1.38 | 1.37 | 1.39 | 0.022 | 0.025 | 0.019 | 1.38 | 0.022 | 0.0319 | 2.60 | yes, yes, no |
| Packing-foam block | 1.41 | 1.40 | 1.42 | 0.018 | 0.017 | 0.019 | 1.41 | 0.018 | 0.0255 | 3.31 | yes, yes, yes |
The means reproduce the lesson’s table (14.7, 1.68, 1.10, 2.60 and 3.31 N). Now the spread. The straws’ three crush distances span 0.006 m; the cups’ span 0.006 m; the accordion’s 0.006 m. Each is about twice the ±0.003 m reading uncertainty, so the run-to-run variation in how a structure buckles is at least as large as the video resolution. The cups (1.68 N) and the straws (1.10 N) differ by 0.58 N; the force is proportional to 1/d, so a ±0.003 m uncertainty on 0.035 m is ±9% in force, about ±0.15 N, and on 0.055 m it is ±5%, about ±0.06 N. The difference between them is real. The accordion (2.60 N) and the foam (3.31 N) differ by 0.71 N against uncertainties of about ±0.35 N and ±0.55 N; that difference is marginal, and the accordion’s one failure in three runs says the same thing in a different way.
2. The plateau, as numbers
A 60 g egg dropped 1.0 m arrives with kinetic energy mgh = 0.060 × 9.8 × 1.0 = 0.588 J. Whatever stops it over 3.0 cm must absorb 0.588 J, and the area under the force-distance curve is that energy. Two ways to do it:
| Compression x (cm) | Ideal crushable foam: F (N) | Ideal spring stopping in the same 3.0 cm: F (N) |
|---|---|---|
| 0.0 | 19.6 | 0.0 |
| 0.5 | 19.6 | 6.5 |
| 1.0 | 19.6 | 13.1 |
| 1.5 | 19.6 | 19.6 |
| 2.0 | 19.6 | 26.1 |
| 2.5 | 19.6 | 32.7 |
| 3.0 | 19.6 | 39.2 |
Foam: 19.6 N × 0.030 m = 0.588 J. Spring: ½ × 39.2 N × 0.030 m = 0.588 J. Same area, and the spring’s peak is twice the foam’s. Then the spring gives the energy back and the egg leaves at 4.43 m/s upward: its momentum change doubles, and so does the impulse the shell has to carry. The flat plateau is the shape crash engineers design toward.
3. Why some structures give a plateau
Expanded polystyrene, paper cups, straws and cardboard are all cellular: thin walls around empty space. Load a thin wall along its length and it holds a nearly fixed force until it buckles; once one layer of cells has folded, the next layer takes the load at about the same force, and so on down the block. That sequence is what makes the force nearly constant over centimeters. Whether the structure springs back depends on what its walls are made of. Polystyrene chains at room temperature are stiff and tangled and do not slide back once bent, so a crushed EPS cell stays crushed and the work done on it has become heat and permanent deformation; that is why a helmet that has taken one hard hit is replaced. Rubber’s cross-linked chains stretch and recoil, so a rubber ball returns the energy and the object rebounds. Glass has rigid bonds that crack before they deform much, so it stops things over a very short distance with a very high peak. The lesson’s density figures for polystyrene and EPS foam are typical values used for illustration; the design conclusion does not depend on them.
4. Crumple-zone check values
1,500 kg car, rigid barrier, 13.4 m/s (30 mph). Crush 0.10 m: a = 13.42/(2 × 0.10) = 898 m/s2 (91.6 g); Δt = 2 × 0.10/13.4 = 14.9 ms; average force on the car 1,500 × 898 = 1,347 kN. Crush 0.60 m: 150 m/s2 (15.3 g); 89.6 ms; 224 kN. Both distances illustrative. The federal occupant-protection standard’s chest limit is 60 g (Lesson 3.1 reading), so the rigid 0.10 m case fails it by a factor of 1.5 before the occupant has even hit anything.
Your turn
- Recompute the mean force for the straws and the foam from the runs and confirm the table. Then compute the force for the straws’ worst single run (smallest d).
- Using ±0.003 m, decide which pairs of designs differ by more than their uncertainty. Write the claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph for the best design.
- Integrate the spring column by the trapezoid rule and confirm 0.588 J. Then sketch the force-time graph that goes with each column and say which has the larger peak.
- Write the explanation for the family buying a helmet, using the words polymer, cell, deform and force, and using the plateau table as your evidence.
Sources: 16 CFR 1203.12, bicycle helmet test requirements (300 g limit), Cornell LII (law.cornell.edu); 49 CFR 571.208, FMVSS 208 injury criteria (Cornell LII) (law.cornell.edu)
What Is Actually in Front of the Barrier: Missouri’s Sand Barrels, the Crash Test They Passed, and Two Stops Compared
MoDOT Engineering Policy Guide, Category 612 Impact Attenuators (sections 612.2 and 612.4); MoDOT roadside hardware listing, End Terminals, Crash Cushions and Barrier Systems; TrafFix Devices, Big Sandy Inertial Crash Cushion System manual, P/N 48100 Rev. A1 (February 27, 2020); MoDOT news release “MoDOT Urges Drivers to ‘Work with Us’ in Busy Construction Season” (April 17, 2025); the two stopping tables are SLS original and illustrative; retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original (tables and explanation); quotes brief passages from MoDOT public records and a manufacturer manual for education
Why this reading. The lesson asks you to build a question board and to sort your questions into three piles: testable with toy cars and a ramp, answerable only from published crash-test data, and answerable only with a model. You cannot sort into the second pile without knowing what published data exist. This reading holds the real numbers behind the phenomenon: what the Missouri Department of Transportation (MoDOT) says a sand-barrel array does and when it uses one, what is in the barrels, the crash test every such device must pass, how many people die in Missouri work-zone crashes, and, as an illustrative model, the two stops the mini-lecture compares, worked out step by step so that the −250 m/s2 and −50 m/s2 are numbers you can check rather than accept.
1. What MoDOT says the yellow barrels do
MoDOT’s Engineering Policy Guide (EPG), Article 612, “Impact Attenuators,” opens with the purpose of every device in this unit: “Impact attenuators are designed to absorb energy of an impacting vehicle and reduce the force on a passenger.” Section 612.2 describes the sand barrels you see in Missouri work zones:
“An Impact Attenuator Array (Sand Barrels) is most often used to shield fixed objects that cannot be removed or relocated, when posted speeds are greater than 35 mph. … An Impact Attenuator Array (Sand Barrels) consists of a group of freestanding plastic barrels configured in an array of increasing weights from the impact point toward the object. Such an array transfers the vehicle’s momentum to the increasing masses of sand in the barrels and provides a gradual deceleration.”
That one sentence names three ideas from this unit: momentum (Lesson 1.3), transfer of momentum from one object to another in a collision, and a gradual deceleration, which is a longer stopping time and therefore a smaller force (Lessons 1.1 and 1.4). The same section adds that the array’s “‘footprint’ length and width and the number of barrels will change based upon the permanent posted speed limit of the roadway.” A faster car carries more momentum, so the array has to be longer and heavier to stop it gently.
Two Missouri details are worth noticing. MoDOT recommends sand barrels mainly “for temporary usage such as in work zones,” so the place you are most likely to see them is the blunt end of a concrete barrier in a highway construction zone; permanent off-ramp gores more often get a folding crash cushion that does the same job. And because Missouri winters freeze wet sand into a solid block, the EPG’s inspection guidelines require that “the sand shall have a maximum moisture content and rock salt added,” with inspectors checking during cold spells that the sand “has not frozen.” Frozen sand cannot be flung forward by a car; it would act more like the rigid barrier the array is supposed to soften.
2. What is in the barrels
MoDOT’s roadside-hardware listing includes the Big Sandy sand-barrel system among its approved products. The manufacturer’s installation manual describes it as “a non-redirective, gating crash cushion, designed to shield the end of rigid objects in both temporary and/or permanent roadside installations,” built from free-standing barrels “in consecutive rows which contain gradually increasing weights of sand.” The barrel sizes, with the manual’s own metric values:
| Sand per barrel (as published) | Mass (manual’s metric value) |
|---|---|
| 200 lb | 90 kg |
| 400 lb | 180 kg |
| 700 lb | 320 kg |
| 1,400 lb | 640 kg |
| 2,100 lb | 960 kg |
| Lid diameter, 37 in | 940 mm |
The word inertial in the product name is the physics. Nothing in the array is a spring. A car that hits the first barrel has to set its sand moving; the sand’s inertia is what slows the car, and the increasing masses along the array mean the car meets a little more resistance at each row instead of all of it at once.
3. The test the barrels had to pass
The EPG states that “All impact attenuators manufactured after January 1, 2023 shall meet MASH 2016 Test Level 3 crash test requirements” (MASH is AASHTO’s Manual for Assessing Safety Hardware). The Big Sandy manual states the Test Level 3 conditions it was tested at: “TL-3 (62.1 mph/ 100 km/hr),” with “cars with an approx. weight of 2425 lbs [1100 kg] to trucks with an approx. weight of 5004 lbs [2270 kg].” Converted:
| Published test | Vehicle mass | Speed | Speed in m/s | Momentum (kg·m/s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MASH TL-3, small car | 1,100 kg | 100 km/h | 27.8 | 30,600 |
| MASH TL-3, pickup | 2,270 kg | 100 km/h | 27.8 | 63,100 |
(100 km/h ÷ 3.6 = 27.8 m/s; momentum = mass × speed, rounded to three figures.) The pickup carries about twice the momentum of the small car, and the same array must stop both. The manual is also honest about the limits of a test: “These specified tests are not intended to represent the systems performance when impacted by every vehicle type or every impact condition existing on the roadway.” Keep that sentence for the design challenge in Lesson 1.5, where you will have to state what your cushion is not designed for. The mini-lecture’s 25 m/s (90 km/h, 56 mph) is a little below the test speed: a realistic speed for a car drifting out of a lane on a Missouri highway.
4. Why Missouri cares: work-zone crashes
MoDOT’s April 2025 Work Zone Awareness release reported: “In 2024, 23 people were killed in Missouri work zone crashes. Distracted driving contributed to at least four of those fatalities as well as more than 350 work zone crashes overall.” The state’s highway safety engineer added that “you can expect to see between 800-1,000 active work zones” on any given day of construction season. Every one of those zones with a barrier end facing traffic at more than 35 mph is a place where the physics of this unit decides how hard a crash is.
5. Two stops from 25 m/s, step by step (SLS illustrative model)
The mini-lecture says a car stopping from 25 m/s in 0.10 s has an acceleration of −250 m/s2, and one stopping in 0.50 s has −50 m/s2. Those are averages over the whole stop. The tables below assume the deceleration is steady (real crash pulses are not, but the average is what the impulse argument in Lesson 1.4 needs). Velocity is v = 25 + at; distance is x = 25t + ½at2. These tables are constructed to teach the method and are labeled illustrative; they are not a recording of any real crash.
| Stop A: rigid concrete, 0.10 s. a = (0 − 25) ÷ 0.10 = −250 m/s2 | ||
|---|---|---|
| t (s) | v (m/s) | x (m) |
| 0.00 | 25.0 | 0.00 |
| 0.02 | 20.0 | 0.45 |
| 0.04 | 15.0 | 0.80 |
| 0.06 | 10.0 | 1.05 |
| 0.08 | 5.0 | 1.20 |
| 0.10 | 0.0 | 1.25 |
| Stop B: sand-barrel array, 0.50 s. a = (0 − 25) ÷ 0.50 = −50 m/s2 | ||
|---|---|---|
| t (s) | v (m/s) | x (m) |
| 0.00 | 25.0 | 0.00 |
| 0.10 | 20.0 | 2.25 |
| 0.20 | 15.0 | 4.00 |
| 0.30 | 10.0 | 5.25 |
| 0.40 | 5.0 | 6.00 |
| 0.50 | 0.0 | 6.25 |
Read the tables. In both stops the car loses the same 25 m/s. In Stop A it loses 5 m/s every 0.02 s; in Stop B it loses 5 m/s every 0.10 s, five times more slowly, so the acceleration is one-fifth. The stopping distances are 1.25 m and 6.25 m. A cushion that stretches a stop to half a second needs several meters of room to crush through, which is why a sand-barrel array takes up a long stretch of pavement in front of the barrier, and why MoDOT sizes the array by the posted speed.
The force on a person. Newton’s second law for a 70 kg driver: Stop A, 70 × 250 = 17,500 N; Stop B, 70 × 50 = 3,500 N. A 70 kg person weighs 70 × 9.8 = 686 N, so the two forces are about 25 and 5 times body weight. That five-to-one ratio is the answer to the lesson’s prediction question, and it does not depend on the car’s mass at all: the person’s own mass and the acceleration fix it.
6. Sorting your questions
- Testable at home with toy cars and a ramp: does doubling the stopping time halve the average force? Does a heavier car need a longer cushion? Lesson 1.2 and the design challenge answer these.
- Published data: what speeds and masses are the barrels rated for (section 3)? How much sand is in each barrel (section 2)? How many Missouri work-zone crashes are there (section 4)? These come from agencies and manufacturers, not from a tabletop.
- A model: why does the sand need to be heavier toward the back? What happens to the sand’s momentum when the car hits it? Lesson 1.3 builds that model.
When you write a question on the board, write beside it which pile it belongs to and, for the second pile, which document in this reading would answer it.
Sources: MoDOT Engineering Policy Guide, Category 612 Impact Attenuators (epg.modot.org); MoDOT, End Terminals, Crash Cushions and Barrier Systems (roadside hardware listing) (modot.org); TrafFix Devices, Big Sandy Inertial Crash Cushion System manual, Rev. A1 (2020) (media.trafficsafetystore.com); MoDOT, “MoDOT Urges Drivers to ‘Work with Us’ in Busy Construction Season” (April 17, 2025) (modot.org)