
specify criteria and constraints, break a Missouri energy challenge into sub-problems, compare competing designs with a weighted decision matrix and chemistry calculations, and model a design with a spreadsheet or simulation.
Instruction
The challenge. This capstone brings together the course. A Missouri city needs 200 MWh of electricity every evening, 73,000 MWh a year. You will compare gas turbines, lead-acid battery storage, and a share of nuclear output like Callaway’s, and recommend a design. Callaway makes about 9.2 million MWh a year at 1,190 MW, a capacity factor of 88.3 percent, so the city’s need is 0.79 percent of one plant’s output.
Specify and divide the problem. Specify criteria and constraints first (carbon dioxide released, material handled, reliability, cost, hazard). Then break the problem into sub-problems you can calculate: the energy balance of the fuel (Unit 1), the rate and reversibility of the storage reaction (Unit 2), the water and acid chemistry of the battery and ore processing (Unit 3), the carbon budget (Unit 3), and the nuclear fuel (this unit).
Worked sub-problem: gas. Methane burns with ΔH = −890.57 kJ/mol (Hess’s law from NIST data). For 73,000 MWh (2.628 × 1014 J) at 50 percent efficiency (illustrative), the heat needed is 5.256 × 1014 J, which is 5.90e+08 mol of CH4 and the same number of moles of CO2: 25,973 tonnes of CO2 each year. Worked sub-problem: battery. In Pb + PbO2 + 2 H2SO4 → 2 PbSO4 + 2 H2O, two electrons are transferred, so one mole of reaction stores 2 × 96,485 × 2.0 V = 386 kJ in 446.4 g of lead and lead dioxide, 0.240 kWh per kg. At 30 percent utilization (illustrative), 200 MWh needs about 2,776 tonnes of active material, which is 0.28 percent of one year’s U.S. secondary lead.
Compare and model. Use a weighted decision matrix with at least four criteria, justify the weights, and run a sensitivity check. Build a spreadsheet or use a PhET or other simulation to model at least one sub-problem, with the assumptions listed in cells you can change. Use the capstone data reading if you prefer the provided data path.
Communicate it. A good recommendation says what you chose, why the trade-offs favor it, what the numbers are and where they came from, and what you would test next. Label every illustrative assumption, show units and significant figures in each calculation, and say plainly what your model cannot tell the city, such as the actual price per megawatt-hour.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Burning methane to make 73,000 MWh of electricity at 50 percent efficiency releases about how many tonnes of CO2 per year (NIST data)?
A model with a stated assumption of 30 percent battery utilization is more useful if you also test what happens at 20 percent and 40 percent.
Using the data and assumptions in this lesson’s reading, draft your plan: state four criteria and three constraints, list the sub-problems you will calculate, and name the three designs you will compare.
How confident are you that you can specify a problem, break it into calculable parts, compare designs and model one?
Unit 4 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
The beta decay of cesium-137 (atomic number 55) makes a daughter with atomic number
After 3 half-lives, the fraction of a radioisotope remaining is
Fusion releases more energy per nucleon than fission mainly because
The mass defect of helium-4 is 0.03038 u. Using 1 u = 931.494 MeV, its binding energy is MeV.
Radium-226 can build up in waste that contains thorium-230 even if nothing is added.
The ethanol energy per gram (29.71 kJ/g) compared with octane (47.89 kJ/g) is
Condensation polymerization releases a small molecule such as water.
An alkane with 8 carbon atoms has hydrogen atoms.
In a weighted decision matrix, the weights should
With weights 0.4, 0.3, 0.2, 0.1 and scores 4, 4, 4, 3, the weighted total is .
A computer model’s results depend on its stated assumptions, so a sensitivity check is part of good modeling.
USGS says secondary lead is about 70 percent of U.S. apparent lead consumption. This mostly comes from
Burning methane to deliver 73,000 MWh of electricity at 50 percent efficiency releases about
Complete: Missouri Evening Power Design Recommendation (decision matrix, model and a four-minute recorded defense)
Task: A Missouri city wants 200 MWh of electricity each evening. Write a design recommendation of 900 to 1,300 words that (1) states the problem with at least four criteria and three constraints and says how each is measured; (2) breaks the problem into at least four sub-problems, each solved with a chemistry calculation that shows units and significant figures; (3) compares at least three designs in a weighted decision matrix and runs a sensitivity check on the weights; (4) includes a spreadsheet, a PhET simulation, or another computer model of at least one sub-problem with the assumptions stated; and (5) cites sources and labels every illustrative assumption. Use this lesson’s reading for the provided data if you do not choose your own Missouri materials-or-energy challenge. Callbacks to Units 1 to 3 (energy, rates and equilibrium, water, carbon) are expected.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 – Plan. The problem statement with criteria and constraints, the sub-problem list, the designs you will compare and your sources.
- Stage 2 – Reviewed draft. Your draft with a spreadsheet or model. An adult reads it as a city resident would and marks anything unclear. You check every number against its source using this list: each fact has a named source, each calculation shows units, every assumption is labeled illustrative. Keep the marked draft or the adult’s notes and a revision plan.
- Stage 3 – Final recommendation. 900 to 1,300 words with the matrix, sensitivity check, model and citations.
- Stage 4 – Presentation and defense. Record a four-minute presentation, then answer one question on the recording: Which assumption would change your recommendation, and by how much? Why did you weight the criteria as you did? What would you need to know before building it?
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Problem and criteria (9-12.ETS1.A.1) | States the challenge, criteria and constraints clearly and with measures. |
| Sub-problems (9-12.ETS1.A.2) | Breaks the problem into smaller problems that are each solved with correct chemistry calculations. |
| Comparison and trade-offs (9-12.ETS1.B.1) | Weighted matrix with a sensitivity check and a recommendation tied to the trade-offs. |
| Model (9-12.ETS1.B.2) | A working model with stated assumptions, tested by changing at least one input. |
| Evidence and resources (9-12.ESS3.A.2) | Uses documented Missouri or national data accurately, labels assumptions, and weighs costs and benefits. |
Capstone Data: Missouri Evening Power, Sourced Facts and Chemistry Calculations
Ameren Missouri Callaway fact sheet; NIST Chemistry WebBook; USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025: Lead, all retrieved 2026-11-15; SLS calculations and labeled assumptions · Public domain (NIST, USGS data), with SLS commentary and original calculations
Why this reading. The capstone asks you to choose among designs for a Missouri energy challenge using criteria, calculations and a model. This reading supplies the challenge, the sourced facts, and a complete table of chemistry calculations so no student is blocked.
The challenge
A Missouri city wants 200 MWh of electricity every evening for a year (73,000 MWh per year). Three designs are on the table: (A) natural gas turbines, (B) lead-acid battery storage charged at midday, and (C) a share of output from a nuclear plant such as Callaway. Everything below uses documented facts plus clearly labeled assumptions.
Sourced facts
- Callaway Energy Center (Ameren Missouri fact sheet): 1,190 MW net capacity, about 9.2 million MWh net generation a year, 26 percent of Ameren Missouri’s generation.
- NIST enthalpies of formation: CO2(g) −393.51, H2O(l) −285.83, CH4(g) −74.6 kJ/mol.
- USGS (2025): secondary lead 1,000 thousand tons a year, 70 percent of apparent U.S. consumption; 86 percent of lead used in lead-acid batteries; net import reliance 28 percent (2024 estimate).
- Constants: Faraday constant 96,485 C/mol; 1 MeV = 1.602 × 10−13 J; Avogadro 6.022 × 1023/mol.
Assumptions (illustrative; change them in your model)
- Gas turbines convert 50 percent of the heat of combustion to electricity.
- Lead-acid cell: Pb + PbO2 + 2 H2SO4 → 2 PbSO4 + 2 H2O, 2 electrons per Pb, nominal 2.0 V; 30 percent of the theoretical active material is usable.
- Nuclear plant thermal efficiency 33 percent; about 200 MeV released per fission (the estimate from lesson 4.1’s binding-energy curve).
Chemistry results (SLS calculations)
| Quantity | Result |
|---|---|
| Heat of combustion of methane (Hess) | 890.57 kJ/mol |
| A. Methane burned per year for 73,000 MWh | 5.902e+08 mol = 9,468 t |
| A. CO2 released per year | 25,973 t |
| Energy per kg of Pb + PbO2 reacted (theoretical) | 0.240 kWh/kg |
| B. Active material for 200 MWh: theoretical / 30% usable | 833 t / 2,776 t |
| B. Same at 20% / 40% usable | 4,164 t / 2,082 t |
| B. 30%-case mass as a share of annual U.S. secondary lead | 0.28 percent |
| Callaway capacity factor | 88.3 percent |
| C. Share of Callaway output | 0.79 percent |
| Callaway uranium-235 fissioned per year | 1,222 kg |
| C. Uranium-235 fissioned for the city per year | 9.7 kg |
Note on the battery: the active-material mass is a one-time inventory that lasts for the battery’s service life, while gas is burned every year. Charging the battery also needs about 25 percent more electricity if the round trip is 80 percent efficient (illustrative).
Decision matrix starter
Suggested criteria: CO2 released per year; mass of material to handle; reliability; cost; and long-lived waste or hazard. For a quantitative criterion, score = 1 + 4 × (worst value − value) ÷ (worst value − best value), so the best design gets 5 and the worst gets 1. For cost, reliability and hazard use illustrative 1 to 5 scores you can defend. Multiply each score by its weight (weights must total 1.00), sum, and then test whether the winner changes when you change the weights by 10 percentage points.
Sources: Ameren Missouri, Callaway Energy Center facts and stats (ameren.com); NIST Chemistry WebBook: Methane (webbook.nist.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: Water (webbook.nist.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: Carbon dioxide (webbook.nist.gov); USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025: Lead (pubs.usgs.gov)