
A 2050 Forecast for a Harbor City
By 2050, how much higher are carbon dioxide, temperature and sea level likely to be at a harbor city, how confident can we be, and how much depends on the choices people make?
The mystery: Carbon dioxide measured on Mauna Loa has risen every year since 1958, from 315.98 ppm in 1959 to 424.61 ppm in 2024, ever faster, while a harbor’s tide gauge records a sea that keeps creeping up the pier.
analyze the Mauna Loa carbon dioxide record and the NASA global temperature record, calculate rates of change for different periods, and ask questions about what the patterns mean.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. A graph on the board shows a jagged line that climbs from left to right, with a small up-and-down wiggle every year. No labels. Write what you think it could be a record of, and one thing you would need to know to be sure.
The carbon dioxide in the air has been measured on a Hawaiian volcano since 1958. Compared with the 1960s, how fast is it rising today?
The phenomenon. In 1958 the scientist Charles David Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa, a volcano in Hawaiʻi whose summit sits high above local pollution and forests. NOAA and the Scripps Institution of Oceanography have continued the record ever since. The annual mean was 315.98 parts per million (ppm) in 1959, 369.71 ppm in 2000 and 424.61 ppm in 2024. Air bubbles trapped in Antarctic ice show that for at least 800,000 years before industrialization, carbon dioxide stayed between about 180 and 300 ppm, and it was about 280 ppm in the 1700s.
| Year | Mauna Loa CO2, annual mean (ppm) |
|---|---|
| 1959 | 315.98 |
| 2000 | 369.71 |
| 2014 | 398.81 |
| 2024 | 424.61 |
| 2025 | 427.35 |
Source: NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory, Mauna Loa annual means (public domain).
Two patterns in one curve. The Keeling curve rises every year, and it also wiggles: each year carbon dioxide falls by about 6 ppm from May to late September and rises again through winter. The wiggle is the Northern Hemisphere’s plants breathing: in summer, photosynthesis draws carbon dioxide out of the air; in winter, decay and respiration return it. The biosphere and atmosphere exchange carbon every year. The rise underneath is something else.
Worked example 1: rates of change. A rate is change divided by time. From 1959 to 1969 the annual mean rose 0.86 ppm per year on average. From 2014 (398.81 ppm) to 2024 (424.61 ppm) it rose (424.61 − 398.81) / 10 = 2.58 ppm per year, three times as fast. The total rise since 1959 is 108.63 ppm, 34%. Compared with 280 ppm, the 2024 level is about 52% higher. When the rate itself is increasing, the curve bends upward, and a straight-line forecast will underestimate the future unless something changes.
Temperature. NASA’s GISTEMP analysis combines thousands of weather stations and ocean measurements into a global average, reported as an anomaly: the difference from the 1951–1980 average. The mean anomaly for 1880–1899 was about −0.23 °C. In 2024 it was 1.29 °C, the warmest year in the record, about 1.5 °C above the late 1800s; 2025 (1.19 °C) was second. Single years jump up and down with El Niño and La Niña, so scientists look at trends: a least-squares line through 1975–2024 rises about 0.20 °C per decade. Averaged over 2015–2024, the world was about 1.2 °C warmer than in 1880–1899.
Worked example 2: from anomaly to change. A change is a difference between two anomalies, so the baseline cancels: 1.29 − (−0.23) = 1.52 °C between the late 1800s and 2024. At 0.20 °C per decade, the 50 years from 1975 to 2025 add about 1.0 °C.
Reading the data honestly. Two records rising together do not by themselves prove that one causes the other. The case for cause comes from physics (Unit 2: carbon dioxide absorbs infrared energy), from fingerprints and from models, which you will examine in this unit. Good questions separate what the data show from what they mean: How much of the carbon dioxide comes from fossil fuels, and how do we know? Where does the rest of the carbon go? How fast will the sea rise at a harbor?
Scale. Keep units straight: 1 ppm of carbon dioxide in the whole atmosphere contains about 2.13 billion metric tons (gigatons) of carbon. Today’s 424.61 ppm is about 900 gigatons of carbon in the air.
Reading: Steven Earle, Physical Geology, 2nd ed., chapter 19 (CC BY 4.0).
Work with your table group. Use the Mauna Loa table and the GISTEMP numbers in the lesson.
Start your Forecast Notebook.
Organize the Mauna Loa table into a graph with a labeled axis and units. Calculate the rate for 1959–2000, 2000–2014 and 2014–2024, and write two sentences describing how the rate has changed in the short term and the long term.
Write two investigable questions for the class Wonder Board: one about where the added carbon dioxide comes from, and one about what the trend means for a city on the coast.
Two long records, both climbing, one bending upward. Next lesson we meet a client who needs to know where those lines are headed.
How confident are you that you can I can analyze long climate records and calculate rates of change for different periods.
Exit ticket: give one rate from today's data, with its period and units, and explain why a single warm or cool year is not a trend.
Materials: printed Keeling curve and GISTEMP graphs with labels covered for the Do Now, the GISTEMP annual table as a handout, graph paper, Forecast Notebooks.
Setup: the Mauna Loa and GISTEMP values are real public-domain records as Poly cited them; check the latest year before class, since both are updated.
Listen for: “the wiggle is pollution from traffic”; treating one cool year as an end to warming; correlation stated as proof.
Support / stretch: give a rate template (change / time = rate, with units). Stretch: fit a least-squares line to the five table points in a spreadsheet and compare its slope with the 2014–2024 rate.