
compare the Haitian Revolution with the Spanish American independence movements, explain how Bolívar and others adapted Enlightenment ideas, and discuss in seminar whose interests each revolution served.
Instruction
The revolutions of 1776 and 1789 set off a wave across the Atlantic world. But each revolution had a different answer to a basic question: liberty and equality for whom?
Haiti: the revolution of the enslaved. Saint-Domingue, France’s Caribbean colony, was the most profitable colony in the world, producing much of Europe’s sugar and coffee. Roughly half a million enslaved Africans and their descendants lived there under extreme violence, alongside a much smaller population of white colonists and free people of color. In August 1791 the enslaved rose in revolt. Toussaint Louverture, formerly enslaved himself, became the revolution’s leading general and politician, defeating Spanish and British forces. France abolished slavery in 1794. But when Napoleon sent an army to restore French control, Toussaint was captured by deceit and died in a French prison in 1803. His successor Jean-Jacques Dessalines defeated the French, and on 1 January 1804 declared the independent nation of Haiti — the second independent republic in the Americas and the first founded by formerly enslaved people. Haiti’s revolution applied “the rights of man” more completely than France or the United States had. The world’s powers punished it: the United States refused to recognize Haiti until 1862, and in 1825 France demanded a huge indemnity, which Haiti paid for decades, as the price of recognition. The failure of Napoleon’s army there also helped persuade him to sell France’s Louisiana territory to the United States in 1803 for $15 million; St. Louis and Kansas City both lie inside it.
Spanish America: Creole revolutions. In Spain’s empire, a strict social hierarchy put Spanish-born peninsulares at the top, American-born Spaniards (criollos or Creoles) below them, and mestizos, Indigenous peoples and people of African descent below that. When Napoleon invaded Spain in 1808 and removed its king, the empire’s authority collapsed, and Creole elites seized the moment. In New Spain, the priest Miguel Hidalgo called his parishioners to revolt on 16 September 1810, the Grito de Dolores; his mass movement of Indigenous and mestizo peasants frightened Creole elites, and Hidalgo was captured and executed in 1811. Mexico won independence in 1821 under a more conservative coalition. September 16 is still Mexico’s Independence Day, and the new Mexican state claimed lands that are now part of the American Southwest.
Bolívar. In South America, Simón Bolívar, a wealthy Creole from Caracas who had read Locke, Montesquieu and Rousseau, led armies that liberated what became Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and Bolivia, while José de San Martín liberated Argentina and Chile. Bolívar admired the United States but, as his Jamaica Letter shows, doubted that its federal system suited peoples without experience of self-government; he favored strong central government and a powerful executive. He called for an end to slavery and freed people he had enslaved, but slavery lasted for decades in several of the new republics. Brazil took yet another path: it became independent in 1822 as a monarchy under a Portuguese prince, and kept slavery until 1888.
Seminar question. Which Atlantic revolution best fulfilled the ideals of liberty and equality — and does the answer depend on whose point of view we take?
Responding to diverse perspectives (SL.9-10.1.d). Before you disagree with a position, summarize it in a sentence its holder would accept. Then add, qualify or challenge it with evidence. End the seminar by writing a summary of where the positions agreed, where they disagreed and what evidence would settle the disagreement.
Watch for bias (HR.2). Older histories often told the Haitian Revolution as a story of violence alone, or left it out entirely. Ask why a revolution by enslaved people was so often omitted from accounts of the “age of democratic revolution.”
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Three voices of American independence — summaries
Summaries by the course authors of Toussaint Louverture’s proclamation of 29 August 1793; Miguel Hidalgo’s Grito de Dolores, 16 September 1810 (no written text survives); and Simón Bolívar’s Letter from Jamaica, 6 September 1815 · SLS original
These are paraphrases, not quotations. The originals are in French and Spanish, and English translations differ. A library or an online search for the document’s title plus “English translation” will find full translations.
Toussaint Louverture, 1793 (paraphrase): Toussaint introduces himself to the people of Saint-Domingue as a leader who has taken up the cause of vengeance for the enslaved and wants liberty and equality to reign there. He calls on his fellow Black people to unite with him in the same cause.
Hidalgo, 1810 (paraphrase of what witnesses reported): The parish priest of Dolores rang the church bell and called his largely Indigenous and mestizo parishioners to rise against the Spanish-born officials who ruled New Spain, in the name of the Virgin of Guadalupe and against bad government. No written text of the speech survives.
Bolívar, 1815 (paraphrase): Writing in exile in Jamaica, Bolívar argues that Spain has kept its American colonies in a state of permanent childhood, excluding Americans from government and trade. He describes Spanish Americans born in the Americas as neither fully European nor Indigenous, but a people in between. He doubts that the new nations are ready for fully federal, democratic republics like the United States, and argues for strong, centralized republics with limited popular participation until the people gain experience of self-government.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What made the Haitian Revolution different from the American and Spanish American revolutions?
Bolívar believed the new Spanish American nations should copy the U.S. federal system exactly.
What triggered the collapse of Spanish authority in the Americas after 1808?
After the seminar (written, recorded, or talked through with a parent, guardian or study partner), write a summary of 150-200 words: the two strongest positions you met in the readings or in discussion, stated fairly; the points of agreement; the main disagreement; and one piece of evidence that would help settle it. Name one place where a speaker’s reasoning was weak, and say why, without naming the speaker.
How confident are you that you can compare the Haitian and Spanish American revolutions and discuss whose interests each served?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: (a) Haiti declares independence; (b) Grito de Dolores; (c) enslaved people rise in Saint-Domingue; (d) Bolívar’s Jamaica Letter; (e) Mexican independence.
Check your answer
Answer: (c) 1791 → (a) 1 January 1804 → (b) 16 September 1810 → (d) 1815 → (e) 1821.Haiti’s revolution began before the Spanish American movements, which were triggered by Napoleon’s 1808 invasion of Spain. - Match: Creole (criollo), peninsular, mestizo — (1) Spanish-born official in the Americas; (2) person of Spanish descent born in the Americas; (3) person of mixed Indigenous and European ancestry.
Check your answer
Answer: Creole = 2; peninsular = 1; mestizo = 3.The hierarchy put peninsulares above Creoles, and both above mestizos, Indigenous peoples and people of African descent.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Perspectives: why did Hidalgo’s mass rising of 1810 frighten Creole elites who also wanted independence from Spain?
Check your answer
Answer: His movement of Indigenous and mestizo peasants threatened the social hierarchy that Creoles sat near the top of; Creoles wanted to replace Spanish rule, not overturn their own position.A strong answer names both groups’ interests and connects them to the conservative coalition that won independence in 1821. - Sourcing: the course gives Bolívar’s Jamaica Letter as a labeled paraphrase, not a quotation. What does that mean for how you may use it in writing?
Check your answer
Answer: Cite it as the course summary of the letter, do not put quotation marks around its words, and avoid building an argument on a single word, since the original is in Spanish and translations differ.A strong answer distinguishes quotation from paraphrase and explains why translation matters. - Cause or sequence? “Napoleon invaded Spain in 1808; Spanish American independence movements began in 1810.” Explain the mechanism, if there is one.
Check your answer
Answer: There is one: the invasion removed Spain’s king, so the empire’s legitimate authority collapsed, and Creole elites formed their own governing juntas.A strong answer shows why this is cause (a named mechanism) and not only sequence.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 1.4): which idea from the Declaration of Independence did the Atlantic revolutions most often borrow?
Check your answer
Answer: That people may alter or abolish a government that destroys their rights — the right of revolution.Colonized peoples from Haiti onward used this universal claim against empires, which is why it traveled further than the Constitution’s structure.
Haiti in Its Own Documents, and an Honest Account of the Others
Declaration of the independence of St. Domingo, Fort Dauphin, 29 November 1803, and the proclamation of independence, Gonaives, 1 January 1804, in the contemporary English translations printed in Marcus Rainsford, An Historical Account of the Black Empire of Hayti (London: Albion Press, 1805), Appendix Nos. XIII and XIV; the accounts of Hidalgo’s decree of 6 December 1810, Morelos’s Sentimientos de la Nacion (1813) and Bolivar’s Letter from Jamaica (6 September 1815) are written by the course authors, because the English translations in circulation are modern and under copyright · Public domain
Why this reading. The seminar asks which Atlantic revolution best fulfilled the ideals of liberty and equality, and whether the answer depends on whose point of view we take. The lesson gives you three paragraphs of paraphrase written by us, and no revolutionary in this lesson gets to speak. You cannot answer a question about points of view from three summaries all written in the same voice. Below, the Haitian revolution speaks for itself, in a contemporary English translation printed in London in 1805, at the length the seminar needs — and where we could not reach a trustworthy translation of a document, this reading says so instead of inventing one. What to look for: each of these revolutions had to decide who counted as the people. Find, in each case, the sentence or the policy that draws that line.
A translation problem you should know about. Almost nothing in this lesson was written in English. The Haitian documents below were translated into English at the time, within two years, and printed in a book we can check; that is as good as this kind of evidence gets. For Bolívar and for Hidalgo, the English translations that everyone quotes were made in the twentieth century and are still in copyright, and we could not reach a public-domain English rendering we trusted. So sections 4 and 5 are written in our own words, marked as ours, with the original documents named so that you can cite them properly. Do not quote sections 4 and 5 as though they were the speaker’s words.
1. Haiti declares itself, 29 November 1803
From Marcus Rainsford, An Historical Account of the Black Empire of Hayti (London, 1805), Appendix No. XIII: the preliminary declaration issued at Fort Dauphin by Dessalines, Christophe and Clerveaux, two months before independence was proclaimed. Rainsford was a British army officer who had been in Saint-Domingue; his book prints the documents he collected. Spelling and punctuation are as printed.
But as for those, who, intoxicated with foolish pride, interested slaves of a guilty pretension, are blinded so much as to believe themselves the essence of human nature, and assert that they are destined by heaven to be our masters and our tyrants, let them never come near the land of St. Domingo: if they come hither, they will only meet with chains or deportation; then let them stay where they are…
We have sworn not to listen with clemency towards all those who would dare to speak to us of slavery; we will be inexorable, perhaps even cruel, towards all troops who, themselves forgetting the object for which they have not ceased fighting… should come from Europe to bring among us death and servitude. Nothing is too dear, and all means are lawful, to men from whom it is wished to tear the first of all blessings. Were they to cause rivers and torrents of blood to run; were they, in order to maintain their liberty, to conflagrate seven eighths of the globe, they are innocent before the tribunal of Providence, that never created men, to see them groaning under so harsh and shameful a servitude.
In the various commotions that took place, some inhabitants against whom we had not to complain, have been victims by the cruelty of a few soldiers or cultivators, too much blinded by the remembrance of their past sufferings to be able to distinguish the good and humane land-owners from those that were unfeeling and cruel; we lament with all feeling souls so deplorable an end, and declare to the world… that the murders were committed contrary to the wishes of our hearts.
Done at the Head-Quarters, Fort Dauphin, November 29, 1803. (Signed) Dessalines. Christophe. Clerveaux.
Three things for the seminar. First, the claim in the second paragraph is a claim about natural right, made in the same form as Locke and the Declaration of Independence, and reaching a conclusion neither of them reached: that people from whom liberty is taken may use any means to get it back. Second, the third paragraph is a defense against an accusation, which tells you these men expected to be judged by European readers — they are writing for an audience, months before independence was even declared. Third, notice that the sentence about the troops dates the fight from the French Revolution: the writers treat themselves as the people who kept faith with 1789 while France abandoned it. (The scan of Rainsford’s printing gives the year as 1780, which is almost certainly a misprint or a fault in the scan; we have left it out of the quotation rather than correct it silently.)
2. Independence proclaimed, Gonaives, 1 January 1804
Rainsford, Appendix No. XIV, “Proclamation for a solemn Abjuration of the French Nation”. This is the Haitian declaration of independence.
LIBERTY OR DEATH! — NATIVE ARMY. THE GENERAL IN CHIEF TO THE PEOPLE OF HAYTI.
Citizens, It is not enough to have expelled from your country the barbarians who have for ages stained it with blood — it is not enough to have curbed the factions which, succeeding each other by turns, sported with a phantom of liberty which France exposed to their eyes. It is become necessary, by a last act of national authority, to ensure for ever the empire of liberty in the country which has given us birth… Finally, it is necessary to live independent, or die. Independence or Death! Let these sacred words serve to rally us — let them be signals of battle, and of our re-union.
The French name still darkens our plains: every thing recals the remembrance of the cruelties of that barbarous people. Our laws, our customs, our cities, every thing bears the characteristic of the French. Hearken to what I say! — the French still have a footing in our island! and you believe yourselves free and independent of that republic, which has fought all nations, it is true, but never conquered those who would be free! What! victims for fourteen years by credulity and forbearance! conquered not by French armies, but by the canting eloquence of the proclamations of their agents!
Citizens, men, women, young and old, cast round your eyes on every part of this island; seek there your wives, your husbands, your brothers, your sisters — what did I say? seek your children — your children at the breast, what is become of them: I shudder to tell it — the prey of vultures…
We have dared to be free — let us continue free by ourselves, and for ourselves; let us imitate the growing child; his own strength breaks his leading-strings, which become useless and troublesome to him in his walk. What are the people who have fought us? what people would reap the fruits of our labours? and what a dishonourable absurdity, to conquer to be slaves! Slaves — leave to the French nation this odious epithet; they have conquered to be no longer free — let us walk in other footsteps…
Let us, at the same time, take care, lest a spirit of proselytism should destroy the work — let our neighbours breathe in peace — let them live peaceably under the shield of those laws which they have framed for themselves; let us beware of becoming revolutionary fire-brands — of creating ourselves the legislators of the Antilles — of considering as a glory the disturbing the tranquility of the neighbouring islands… Peace with our neighbours, but accursed be the French name — eternal hatred to France: such are our principles.
Let us swear to the whole world, to posterity, to ourselves, to renounce France for ever, and to die, rather than live under its dominion — to fight till the last breath for the independence of our country… Swear then to live free and independent, and to prefer death to every thing that would lead to replace you under the yoke; swear then to pursue for everlasting, the traitors, and enemies of your independence.
J. J. Dessalines. Head-quarters, Gonaives, 1st Jan. 1804, 1st Year of Independence.
Read the fifth paragraph again. It is a foreign policy, and it is the opposite of what the United States, Britain and France said Haiti was: a state promising not to export its revolution to the neighboring slave colonies. Dessalines is trying to be admitted to the world of states. It did not work; the United States withheld recognition until 1862, and in 1825 France sent a fleet and demanded a payment of 150 million francs as the price of recognizing the independence Haiti had already won. Haiti was still paying off that debt and its refinancing into the twentieth century. If your seminar contribution is about whether a revolution “succeeded”, that sequence is the evidence to use, because it shows the cost being imposed from outside rather than arising from inside.
3. What the Haitian documents let you argue
Compare, directly, three sentences you now have in front of you across three readings:
| Document | The claim | Who is included |
|---|---|---|
| Declaration of Independence, 1776 | All men are created equal; government rests on consent | Not the enslaved (see “domestic insurrections” in the same text), not Native nations, not women |
| Declaration of the Rights of Man, 1789, art. 1 | Men are born and always continue free and equal in respect of their rights | Not women (answered by Olympe de Gouges); and after September 1791, not men too poor to pay a direct tax worth three days’ labor |
| Fort Dauphin and Gonaives, 1803–04 | People from whom liberty has been taken may use any means to recover it; slavery will never again be permitted on this soil | Everyone in Haiti; the proclamation of 1 January 1804, however, excludes the French from the island by name, which is a boundary of its own |
4. Mexico: Hidalgo and Morelos — our account, not their words
The Grito de Dolores of 16 September 1810 survives only in what witnesses later said they heard; there is no text. That is a fact about the evidence and a useful one for a seminar: a founding moment of a nation is known only through recollection. But Hidalgo also signed documents, and those do exist.
In Guadalajara on 6 December 1810 Hidalgo issued a decree abolishing slavery in the territory his movement controlled, ending tribute payments demanded from Indigenous people, and ordering that lands belonging to Indigenous communities be used by them alone. In 1813 José María Morelos, the priest who took over the movement after Hidalgo’s execution, put before the Congress of Chilpancingo a document known as the Sentimientos de la Nación (“Sentiments of the Nation”), which declared that America was free and independent of Spain, that sovereignty came from the people, that slavery and the caste distinctions between Spanish, Indigenous, mixed and African descent were to be abolished forever, and that laws should reduce the gap between rich and poor.
We have written that paragraph in our own words. The original documents are in Spanish; the English translations in general circulation are modern and under copyright, and we do not print quotations we cannot verify against the source. If you use Hidalgo or Morelos in the seminar, describe the content as we have, name the document and its date, and say that you are describing rather than quoting. Then use it for the argument it supports: the Mexican independence movement led by priests made the abolition of slavery and of caste a founding demand in 1810 and 1813, and the independence actually achieved in 1821, under a conservative coalition led by Agustín de Iturbide, did not deliver it — slavery was abolished in Mexico in 1829. That gap between what a revolution demanded and what a settlement delivered is the seminar question in miniature.
5. Bolívar’s Jamaica Letter, 6 September 1815 — our account, not his words
Bolívar wrote the letter in exile in Kingston, in Spanish, answering a correspondent who had asked about the prospects of Spanish America. The English translation everyone quotes was made in the twentieth century and is still in copyright; we could not reach a public-domain English version we could check, so what follows is our summary of his argument, not his sentences.
He argues, first, that Spain has governed its American possessions by keeping Americans out of every office that mattered, so that they have arrived at independence with no experience of governing — a condition he calls a kind of permanent infancy. Second, that Spanish Americans are neither Europeans nor Indigenous, but a third people, occupying the land as the possessors of it while being descended in part from those who took it; he describes this as a situation without precedent, and as a difficulty rather than a boast. Third, that this inexperience makes the United States’ federal system a bad model: a federation of weak states will not hold together against the forces pulling it apart, and what is needed instead is strong, centralized republics with an executive powerful enough to govern and a legislature elected on a limited franchise until the people have learned self-government. Fourth, he predicts — correctly — the shape of the states that would emerge, and hopes, wrongly, that they might be joined in a single league with a capital at Panama.
How to use this fairly in the seminar. Bolívar is doing two things at once, and a strong contribution separates them. He is making an anti-colonial argument: the incapacity he describes was manufactured by Spanish rule, not natural. And he is making an argument for restricting political power to the educated and propertied, on the grounds of that same incapacity. Those two moves together are the pattern of Creole revolution — independence for the colony, government by the colonial-born elite. Set that against Haiti, where the people who had been the property of the colony became the nation, and you have the sharpest comparison available to you, and one where the answer really does depend on whose point of view you take.
Watching for bias in the histories, which the lesson asks you to do
The Haitian documents above were printed in London in 1805 by a British officer who admired the Haitian army and wanted British readers to take it seriously. He was unusual. For most of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries the Haitian Revolution was told in Europe and North America as a story of massacre, and left out of the standard accounts of the “age of democratic revolution” altogether. Ask why the one revolution that abolished slavery outright was the one most often dropped — and notice that Rainsford’s own text shows you the answer being worked on at the time, since the Fort Dauphin declaration spends a paragraph answering the massacre charge before independence had even been declared.
Sources: Marcus Rainsford, An Historical Account of the Black Empire of Hayti (London, 1805) (archive.org)