
list the principles of Magna Carta and the English Bill of Rights, compare Hobbes’s and Locke’s theories of government, and discuss in seminar whether 1688 was a revolution for liberty or for Parliament.
Instruction
England’s revolution came a century before America’s and France’s, and it set the pattern both would argue about: a monarch forced, step by step, to accept that law and Parliament limit royal power.
1215: Magna Carta. King John, having lost wars and taxed his barons heavily, was forced at Runnymede to seal the “Great Charter.” Most of its 63 clauses dealt with feudal grievances of the barons, not the rights of ordinary people. But two principles outlasted the details: the king is bound by law, and no free man may be imprisoned or punished “except by the lawful judgment of his peers or by the law of the land.” Later generations stretched those words into the ideas of due process and trial by jury.
The 1600s: kings against Parliament. The Stuart kings believed in the divine right of kings: a monarch answers to God alone. Charles I raised taxes without Parliament and imprisoned critics. Civil war broke out in 1642; Charles was tried and beheaded in 1649, and Oliver Cromwell ruled without a king until his death in 1658. The monarchy returned in 1660, but the struggle did not end. When the Catholic James II suspended laws on his own authority and his newborn son promised a Catholic dynasty, leading politicians invited his Protestant daughter Mary and her husband William of Orange to take the throne. James fled in 1688 with little bloodshed in England, which is why the English called it the Glorious Revolution. In Ireland and Scotland the change was fought over, and in Ireland it led to harsh laws against the Catholic majority.
1689: the Bill of Rights. William and Mary accepted the crown together with a Bill of Rights. Its principles: the monarch may not suspend laws or raise taxes without Parliament; elections to Parliament should be free; members have freedom of speech in debate; subjects may petition the king; there is to be no standing army in peacetime without Parliament’s consent; and there shall be no excessive bail or “cruel and unusual punishments.” You will see that last phrase again, word for word, in the U.S. Eighth Amendment.
Two philosophers read the same crisis differently. Thomas Hobbes lived through the civil war and concluded that without a strong ruler, life would be a “war of every man against every man” — “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.” People therefore agree to hand almost total power to a sovereign in exchange for peace. John Locke agreed that government rests on an agreement, but not that it should be unlimited. People in the state of nature already have rights to “life, health, liberty, or possessions”; they create government to protect those rights; and a ruler who exercises “power beyond right” is a tyrant whom the people may replace. Locke’s Second Treatise was published in 1689 and read as a defense of the Glorious Revolution.
Seminar question. Was 1688 a revolution for liberty, or a revolution for Parliament and the Protestant property-owning class? Evidence cuts both ways. The Bill of Rights limited royal power for good. Yet only a small minority of English men could vote, Catholics were barred from the throne and public office, and England’s growing empire and its slave trade expanded in the decades that followed.
How to propel a seminar (SL.9-10.1.c). Strong contributions do more than state opinions. Try these moves: connect (“That links to Aristotle’s idea that law should rule, because…”); question (“What evidence shows ordinary people gained anything in 1689?”); extend (“If Locke is right that tyranny is power beyond right, then was James II a tyrant under Locke’s own test?”). Each move should point to a document.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Limits on the Crown, and two theories of government
Magna Carta (1215), clause 39, older English translation as published by the Avalon Project; Hobbes, Leviathan (1651), ch. 13; Locke, Second Treatise (1689), §§6 and 199; Bill of Rights (1689) · Public domain
The Magna Carta was written in Latin; several English translations exist, so its wording varies between editions. The Bill of Rights, Hobbes and Locke are the authors’ own English.
Magna Carta, clause 39: No freemen shall be taken or imprisoned or disseised or exiled or in any way destroyed, nor will we go upon him nor send upon him, except by the lawful judgment of his peers or by the law of the land.
Hobbes, Leviathan: …and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.
Locke, Second Treatise §6: The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one: and reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions.
Locke, §199: As usurpation is the exercise of power, which another hath a right to; so tyranny is the exercise of power beyond right, which nobody can have a right to.
English Bill of Rights (1689): That the pretended power of suspending of laws or the execution of laws by regal authority without consent of Parliament is illegal; … That levying money for or to the use of the Crown by pretence of prerogative, without grant of Parliament… is illegal; … That it is the right of the subjects to petition the king…; … That election of members of Parliament ought to be free; … That excessive bail ought not to be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which principle appears in the English Bill of Rights of 1689?
How did Locke’s view of government differ from Hobbes’s?
Seminar preparation: answer the seminar question in three sentences, citing two documents. Then write (or record) two contributions you would make in the seminar, each using a named move — connect, question or extend — and each pointing to a specific line in the reading. You can try them out aloud with a parent, guardian or study partner if you like.
1215
Tap to revealMagna Carta: the king is bound by law; judgment by peers or the law of the land.
1642-1649
Tap to revealEnglish Civil War; Charles I executed in 1649.
1688
Tap to revealGlorious Revolution: James II replaced by William and Mary.
1689
Tap to revealEnglish Bill of Rights; Locke’s Second Treatise published.
Hobbes
Tap to revealWithout strong government, life is ‘solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short’.
How confident are you that you can list the principles of Magna Carta and the English Bill of Rights and use them as evidence in discussion?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: (a) the Glorious Revolution; (b) Magna Carta; (c) the execution of Charles I; (d) Hobbes’s Leviathan; (e) the English Bill of Rights.
Check your answer
Answer: (b) 1215 → (c) 1649 → (d) 1651 → (a) 1688 → (e) 1689.Leviathan appeared two years after Charles I’s execution, which helps explain Hobbes’s fear of disorder. - Define divine right of kings and name the event of 1688-1689 that most directly rejected it in England.
Check your answer
Answer: The belief that monarchs get authority from God and answer only to God. The Glorious Revolution and the Bill of Rights, which made the Crown accept limits set by Parliament.A strong answer ties the term to the Bill of Rights’ limits on suspending laws and taxing without Parliament.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Corroborate: which clause of the Bill of Rights puts into law the idea in Locke’s §199 that “tyranny is the exercise of power beyond right”?
Check your answer
Answer: “That the pretended power of suspending of laws or the execution of laws by regal authority without consent of Parliament is illegal” — it names a specific power beyond right and forbids it.A strong answer quotes the clause, explains the match (a king acting beyond lawful authority), and notes that Locke’s book appeared the same year, so the two corroborate a shared view rather than one causing the other. - Cause or sequence? “The English Civil War happened in the 1640s, and the Glorious Revolution came in 1688, so the Civil War caused the Glorious Revolution.” Rewrite as a causal claim, or explain why it fails.
Check your answer
Answer: As written it is sequence. A causal version: the Civil War and the execution of Charles I showed that Parliament would resist royal overreach, so in 1688 leading politicians acted quickly to replace James II when he suspended laws — while wanting to avoid another war.A strong answer names a mechanism linking the events and recognizes that forty years and other causes (James II’s actions, religion) lie between them. - Compare Hobbes (“solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short”) with Locke §6 (“no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions”). How does each view of the state of nature lead to a different kind of government?
Check your answer
Answer: Hobbes sees life without government as war, so people should give a sovereign near-total power for peace. Locke sees a state of nature already governed by a law of reason and rights, so government is limited to protecting those rights and may be replaced if it becomes tyrannical.A strong answer links each premise about human life to its conclusion about government power.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 1.2): which Aristotle idea does the Bill of Rights’ limit on the Crown best reflect — philosopher-kings, or the rule of law?
Check your answer
Answer: The rule of law: the king too is bound by known law made with Parliament’s consent.Philosopher-kings is Plato’s idea and trusts wise rulers, not limits on them.
From Runnymede to Westminster: the Documents, Including the Clauses Usually Cut
Magna Carta (1215), clauses 12, 14, 39, 40, 52 and 61, and the English Bill of Rights (1689), in Edward P. Cheyney, Readings in English History Drawn from the Original Sources (Boston: Ginn and Company, 1908); Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan (1651), chapters 13 and 17, original spelling; John Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1689), sections 4, 6, 87, 95, 123, 199, 202, 222 and 240; Gilbert Burnet, History of My Own Time, on the Toleration Act of 1689, in Cheyney · Public domain
Why this reading. The seminar question is whether 1688 was a revolution for liberty or for Parliament and the Protestant propertied class, and you are told that every contribution must point to a document. The lesson gives you one clause of Magna Carta, one clause of Hobbes, two sections of Locke and five of the thirteen clauses of the Bill of Rights. That is not enough to argue either side, and it is certainly not enough to argue the “for whom” half, because the evidence for that half is in the parts of these documents the lesson leaves out. What to look for: in each document, find (1) the limit it places on the ruler and (2) the name of the group it places that limit on behalf of. The gap between those two is the seminar.
1. Magna Carta, 1215 — the famous clauses, and the ones around them
Translated from the Latin in Edward P. Cheyney, Readings in English History Drawn from the Original Sources (Boston: Ginn, 1908). Sixty-three clauses were sealed at Runnymede. Here are six, in the order they appear, so you can see what kind of document it is.
12. No scutage or aid shall be imposed in our kingdom except by the common council of our kingdom, except for the ransoming of our body, for the making of our oldest son a knight, and for once marrying our oldest daughter; and for these purposes it shall be only a reasonable aid.
14. And for holding a common council of the kingdom concerning the assessment of an aid… or concerning the assessment of a scutage, we shall cause to be summoned the archbishops, bishops, abbots, earls, and greater barons by our letters under seal; and besides we shall cause to be summoned generally, by our sheriffs and bailiffs, all those who hold from us in chief…
39. No freeman shall be taken or imprisoned or dispossessed, or outlawed or banished or in any way destroyed, nor will we go upon him, nor send upon him, except by the legal judgment of his peers or by the law of the land.
40. To no one will we sell, to no one will we deny, or delay right or justice.
52. If any one shall have been dispossessed or removed by us without legal judgment of his peers, from his lands, castles, franchises, or his right, we will restore them to him immediately…
61. …they shall elect twenty-five barons of the kingdom, whom they will, who ought with all their power to observe, hold, and cause to be observed, the peace and liberties which we have conceded to them… And if we shall not have corrected the transgression… within a period of forty days… the aforesaid four barons shall refer the matter to the remainder of the twenty-five barons, and let these twenty-five barons with the whole community of the country distress and injure us in every way they can; that is to say, by the seizure of our castles, lands, possessions… saving our person and that of our queen, and those of our children.
Read clause 12 and clause 14 together. Clause 12 says the king may not tax without the kingdom’s common council. Clause 14 says who the common council is: archbishops, bishops, abbots, earls, greater barons, and tenants-in-chief. No one else is summoned. This is the strongest single piece of evidence on the “for whom” side, and it is four hundred and seventy years before 1688.
Now read clause 39. It says “freeman”, which in 1215 excluded the villeins who were most of the population. Later generations read it as though it said “everyone”, and built due process and jury trial out of it. Both facts are true, and a strong seminar contribution says both: the clause was written narrowly and used broadly. Clause 61, meanwhile, is an armed enforcement mechanism run by twenty-five barons — a treaty between a king and his magnates, not a constitution for a people.
2. Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan (1651) — the argument, not the phrase
Hobbes wrote in English, so this is his own spelling, printed exactly. The famous six words are the end of a paragraph about what people lose when there is no common power, and the list is the argument:
Whatsoever therefore is consequent to a time of Warre, where every man is Enemy to every man; the same is consequent to the time, wherein men live without other security, than what their own strength, and their own invention shall furnish them withall. In such condition, there is no place for Industry; because the fruit thereof is uncertain; and consequently no Culture of the Earth; no Navigation, nor use of the commodities that may be imported by Sea; no commodious Building; no Instruments of moving, and removing such things as require much force; no Knowledge of the face of the Earth; no account of Time; no Arts; no Letters; no Society; and which is worst of all, continuall feare, and danger of violent death; And the life of man, solitary, poore, nasty, brutish, and short.
Note the spelling: Hobbes wrote poore. Modern editions and the lesson print poor. Quote whichever you like, but do not attribute modern spelling to a 1651 book without saying you modernized it.
Then the conclusion. This is what a social contract looks like when it is unlimited — Hobbes’s answer to the same question Locke answers differently:
…to appoint one man, or Assembly of men, to beare their Person; and every one to owne, and acknowledge himselfe to be Author of whatsoever he that so beareth their Person, shall Act… This is more than Consent, or Concord; it is a reall Unitie of them all, in one and the same Person, made by Covenant of every man with every man, in such manner, as if every man should say to every man, “I Authorise and give up my Right of Governing my selfe, to this Man, or to this Assembly of men, on this condition, that thou give up thy Right to him, and Authorise all his Actions in like manner.” This done, the Multitude so united in one Person, is called a COMMON-WEALTH… This is the Generation of that great LEVIATHAN, or rather (to speake more reverently) of that Mortall God, to which wee owe under the Immortall God, our peace and defence.
Two things to notice for the seminar. First, Hobbes’s sovereign is authorized by the people, which is why Hobbes is not simply a defender of divine right — James II would have found Hobbes’s premises alarming. Second, once the covenant is made there is no lawful way back, which is exactly what 1688 did.
3. John Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1689) — the chain of the argument
Locke’s argument is a sequence, and the lesson gives you links 2 and 7. Here is the whole chain, in his sections:
§4. To understand political power right, and derive it from its original, we must consider, what state all men are naturally in, and that is, a state of perfect freedom to order their actions, and dispose of their possessions and persons, as they think fit, within the bounds of the law of nature, without asking leave, or depending upon the will of any other man. A state also of equality, wherein all the power and jurisdiction is reciprocal, no one having more than another…
§6. But though this be a state of liberty, yet it is not a state of licence… The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one: and reason, which is that law, teaches all mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions.
§87. Man being born… with a title to perfect freedom… hath by nature a power, not only to preserve his property, that is, his life, liberty and estate, against the injuries and attempts of other men; but to judge of, and punish the breaches of that law in others…
§95. MEN being, as has been said, by nature, all free, equal, and independent, no one can be put out of this estate, and subjected to the political power of another, without his own consent.
§123. IF man in the state of nature be so free, as has been said… why will he part with his freedom?… though in the state of nature he hath such a right, yet the enjoyment of it is very uncertain, and constantly exposed to the invasion of others…
§199. AS usurpation is the exercise of power, which another hath a right to; so tyranny is the exercise of power beyond right, which no body can have a right to. And this is making use of the power any one has in his hands, not for the good of those who are under it, but for his own private separate advantage. When the governor, however intitled, makes not the law, but his will, the rule…
§202. Where-ever law ends, tyranny begins, if the law be transgressed to another’s harm; and whosoever in authority exceeds the power given him by the law… ceases in that to be a magistrate; and, acting without authority, may be opposed, as any other man, who by force invades the right of another.
§222. The reason why men enter into society, is the preservation of their property; and the end why they chuse and authorize a legislative, is, that there may be laws made… whenever the legislators endeavour to take away, and destroy the property of the people…
§240. Here, it is like, the common question will be made, Who shall be judge, whether the prince or legislative act contrary to their trust?… To this I reply, The people shall be judge; for who shall be judge whether his trustee or deputy acts well, and according to the trust reposed in him, but he who deputes him…
The sentence that does the most work is §240, and the lesson never quotes it. Everything before it can be accepted by someone who still thinks rebellion is unlawful. §240 answers the question the Stuart kings thought unanswerable — who decides? — and the answer is: the people. That is the difference between Hobbes and Locke, in one sentence, and it is also the sentence Jefferson is using in 1776.
Then apply Locke’s own test. The lesson suggests the “extend” move: was James II a tyrant under Locke’s own definition? You now have the definition (§199 and §202) and you have the charges against James in the document below. Do the comparison clause by clause; that is a strong contribution.
4. The English Bill of Rights, 1689 — all thirteen declarations
From Cheyney, Readings in English History, extract 332. The lesson gives you five of these. Read the whole list; the ones it omits are as revealing as the ones it keeps.
1. That the pretended power of suspending laws, or the execution of laws, by regal authority, without consent of parliament, is illegal.
2. That the pretended power of dispensing with laws, or the execution of laws, by regal authority, as it hath been assumed and exercised of late, is illegal.
3. That the commission for erecting the late court of commissioners for ecclesiastical causes, and all other commissions and courts of like nature, are illegal and pernicious.
4. That levying money for or to the use of the crown by pretense of prerogative, without grant of parliament, for longer time or in other manner than the same is or shall be granted, is illegal.
5. That it is the right of the subjects to petition the king, and all commitments and prosecutions for such petitioning are illegal.
6. That the raising or keeping a standing army within the kingdom in time of peace, unless it be with consent of parliament, is against law.
7. That the subjects which are Protestants may have arms for their defense suitable to their conditions, and as allowed by law.
8. That election of members of parliament ought to be free.
9. That the freedom of speech, and debates or proceedings in parliament, ought not to be impeached or questioned in any court or place out of parliament.
10. That excessive bail ought not to be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.
11. That jurors ought to be duly impaneled and returned, and jurors which pass upon men in trials for high treason ought to be freeholders.
12. That all grants and promises of fines and forfeitures of particular persons before conviction are illegal and void.
13. And that for redress of all grievances, and for the amending, strengthening, and preserving of the laws, parliament ought to be held frequently.
Now the clauses that decide the “for whom” question. Clause 7 grants arms to “subjects which are Protestants”, and only as “suitable to their conditions” — that is, according to rank. Clause 11 requires that jurors in treason trials be freeholders, which means property decides who judges. And clause 8 says elections “ought to be free” without touching who may vote in them.
The document then disposes of the crown itself:
…do resolve that William and Mary, prince and princess of Orange, be, and be declared king and queen of England, France, and Ireland… and that the sole and full exercise of the regal power be only in, and executed by, the said prince of Orange… and after their deceases, the said crown and royal dignity… to the heirs of the body of the said princess; and for default of such issue to the princess Anne of Denmark, and the heirs of her body…
Read that as evidence of two things at once. A crown is being handed over by a parliamentary assembly, on conditions — which no theory of divine right can survive. And the assembly doing it was summoned by letters from the prince who was about to receive the crown, and its members represented counties, boroughs and universities on a franchise limited by property. Both facts are in the document. The Bill of Rights also barred Catholics, and anyone married to a Catholic, from the throne.
5. What toleration meant in 1689
Bishop Gilbert Burnet sat in the House of Lords and wrote the best-known contemporary account, History of My Own Time (published 1724–34), printed here from Cheyney, extract 333:
The bill of toleration passed easily. It excused Dissenters from all penalties for their not coming to church, and for going to their separate meetings. There was an exception of Socinians; but a provision was put in in favor of Quakers; and though the rest were required to take the oaths to the government, they were excused, upon making in lieu thereof a solemn declaration. They were to take out warrants for the houses they met in, and the justices of peace were required to grant them… It was thought very unreasonable that while we were complaining of the cruelty of the church of Rome, we should fall into such practices among ourselves.
Burnet, who approved of the act, names its limit in one clause: an exception of Socinians — Protestants who denied the Trinity. The act protected Protestant Dissenters from penalties for worship. It did not extend to Roman Catholics, it did not repeal the laws barring Dissenters and Catholics from public office, and it excused nobody from paying tithes to the established church. “Toleration” in 1689 means relief from punishment for some, not equal citizenship for all.
Using this in the seminar
| Move | A contribution the documents support |
|---|---|
| Connect | “Bill of Rights clause 1 is Aristotle’s rule of law in statute: the king may not suspend the law, because law and not a person governs.” |
| Question | “Magna Carta clause 12 forbids taxation without the common council. Clause 14 lists who the council is. Does clause 12 protect anyone who is not named in clause 14?” |
| Extend | “Locke says in §199 that tyranny is power used for the ruler’s private advantage, and in §240 that the people judge. James II suspended laws (Bill of Rights, clause 1). By Locke’s test, was the 1688 settlement lawful resistance — and who counted as ‘the people’ who judged?” |
| Counter | “Even if the settlement was made by a propertied minority, clauses 1, 4, 6 and 13 bound the Crown permanently, and later movements used them. A limit written for a few can be claimed by many — which is exactly what happened to Magna Carta clause 39.” |
Sources: E. P. Cheyney, Readings in English History Drawn from the Original Sources (1908) (archive.org); Hobbes, Leviathan, Project Gutenberg ebook 3207 (gutenberg.org); Locke, Second Treatise of Government, Project Gutenberg ebook 7370 (gutenberg.org)