
explain imperialism from the perspective of the colonized, compare the varied immediate and long-term responses of peoples under colonial rule, and describe independence struggles including the roles of leaders, ideology and religion.
Instruction
Colonized people were never passive. Their responses ranged from armed resistance to negotiation, reform, religious revival, migration and, eventually, independence movements. This lab compares six cases. As you read, sort each response into one or more types: military resistance, religious or cultural revival, modernizing reform, or nationalist organizing.
1. Ethiopia: victory at Adwa (1896). Emperor Menelik II bought modern rifles and artillery, united rival regional rulers, and on 1 March 1896 defeated an Italian invasion army at Adwa. Ethiopia kept its independence, and Adwa became a symbol of African resistance across the continent and the diaspora.
2. German East and South West Africa. In 1905 peoples of southern German East Africa rose in the Maji Maji war, united partly by a spiritual belief that sacred water (maji) would protect them from bullets. The Germans crushed the rising with a scorched-earth policy that caused a famine; historians estimate that deaths ran into the tens of thousands, and some estimates are far higher. In South West Africa (Namibia), after the Herero and Nama rose against land seizures in 1904, the German commander ordered the Herero driven into the desert and killed. A large majority of the Herero and about half of the Nama died. In 2021 the German government acknowledged these events as genocide.
3. The Congo. Under Leopold II, the Congo Free State forced villagers to meet rubber quotas, enforced by hostage-taking, mutilation and killing. Population loss, from violence, famine and disease, ran into the millions, though no reliable census exists and estimates are debated. Among the first to expose it was George Washington Williams, a Black American historian, in an open letter to Leopold in 1890; the British consul Roger Casement’s 1904 report and an international campaign forced Belgium to take the colony from Leopold in 1908.
4. India: from rebellion to nationalism. The rebellion of 1857, begun by Indian soldiers (sepoys) in the East India Company’s army, spread across northern India before it was crushed; Britain then ruled India directly. Western-educated Indians founded the Indian National Congress in 1885 to seek a greater say in government. Economist Dadabhai Naoroji argued that British rule “drained” India’s wealth. Religion shaped nationalism in different ways: some leaders drew on Hindu revival, while the All-India Muslim League (1906) spoke for Muslims. In North America, Punjabi Sikh and other Indian immigrants founded the Ghadar Party in the United States in 1913 to work for armed revolution against British rule.
5. China: from the Opium Wars to Sun Yat-sen. After Britain defeated China in the Opium Wars (1839-1842 and 1856-1860), foreign powers forced “unequal treaties” that opened ports, gave foreigners legal immunity and carved spheres of influence. Responses included the Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864), led by a man who claimed to be Jesus’s younger brother; “self-strengthening” reforms; and the anti-foreign Boxer uprising (1899-1901), crushed by eight foreign powers including Japan and the United States. Sun Yat-sen, educated in Hawaii and Hong Kong, raised funds among overseas Chinese — including in the United States — for a revolution based on his Three Principles of the People: nationalism, democracy and people’s livelihood. The revolution of 1911 ended more than two thousand years of imperial rule, and the Republic of China was proclaimed on 1 January 1912.
6. The Philippines and Korea. The writer José Rizal, executed by Spain in 1896, and the Katipunan secret society inspired a revolution against Spain. When the United States took the islands in 1898, Filipino forces under Emilio Aguinaldo, who had declared independence, fought the Philippine-American War (1899-1902); estimates of Filipino civilian deaths, mostly from disease and hunger, run to 200,000 or more. Korea, annexed by Japan in 1910, answered with the peaceful March First Movement of 1919. Korean exiles organized in the United States too: the Korean National Association was founded there in 1909 to work for Korean independence.
Interpreting in context (HI.3). Judge each response by the choices open to people at the time. Adwa succeeded because Menelik could buy modern weapons; most African states could not. Long-term, many leaders concluded that military resistance alone could not defeat industrial armies, and turned to organization, education and nationalism — the path that led to independence after the world wars.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which factor best explains Ethiopia’s success at Adwa when most African states were conquered?
Sun Yat-sen’s Three Principles were nationalism, and people’s livelihood; the Republic of China was proclaimed in ; the Ghadar Party was founded in by Indian immigrants in the United States.
Religion played no role in resistance to colonial rule.
Complete the matrix for the six cases: who resisted, when, what type(s) of response, the role of a leader, the role of ideology or religion, and the immediate and long-term outcome. Then write a generalization that fits at least four cases, and name one case that is an exception, explaining why.
How confident are you that you can explain imperialism from the perspective of the colonized and compare their responses and independence struggles?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: (a) Battle of Adwa; (b) Indian Rebellion; (c) Boxer uprising begins; (d) Republic of China proclaimed; (e) Korea’s March First Movement.
Check your answer
Answer: (b) 1857 → (a) 1896 → (c) 1899 → (d) 1 January 1912 → (e) 1919.Resistance spans the whole period of the New Imperialism and continues after it. - Complete: Sun Yat-sen’s Three Principles of the People were nationalism, ____ and ____.
Check your answer
Answer: democracy; people’s livelihood.Sun raised funds among overseas Chinese, including in the United States, for the revolution of 1911.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Sourcing: much of what we know about the Congo Free State comes from outsiders — George Washington Williams’s open letter (1890) and Roger Casement’s British consular report (1904). What are the strengths and limits of such sources, and what is missing?
Check your answer
Answer: Strengths: eyewitness investigation and, in Casement’s case, an official report that led to action. Limits: outsiders’ views, written for European or American audiences. Missing: the Congolese people’s own accounts, which survive far less often in the written record.A strong answer names who wrote each source and for whom, and identifies whose voices are absent. - Compare Ethiopia’s response to Italy with the Maji Maji war against Germany. Why did one succeed militarily and the other fail?
Check your answer
Answer: Menelik II bought modern rifles and artillery and united regional rulers, so Ethiopia defeated Italy at Adwa in 1896. The Maji Maji fighters, united partly by a spiritual belief in protective water, lacked modern weapons and were crushed by a scorched-earth campaign.A strong answer compares access to weapons and political unity, and judges each response in the context of the choices available. - Cause or sequence? “The Boxer uprising was crushed in 1901, and the Qing dynasty fell in 1911, so the Boxers caused the revolution.” What mechanism, if any, links them?
Check your answer
Answer: A possible link: the defeat showed the Qing could not defend China from foreign powers, weakening its legitimacy and strengthening reformers and revolutionaries such as Sun Yat-sen. But many other causes mattered, and ten years lie between the events.A strong answer offers a mechanism cautiously and names at least one other cause.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Unit 2): which earlier revolution, led by formerly enslaved people, defeated a European army and won independence for a colony?
Check your answer
Answer: The Haitian Revolution (independence on 1 January 1804).Adwa (1896) later became a similar symbol for Africa and the diaspora.
Two Voices from Inside the Empire, and Four Cases Where the Archive Fails
Dadabhai Naoroji, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (London: Swan Sonnenschein, 1901), introduction, quoting Lord Salisbury’s minute of 26 April 1875 from parliamentary command paper C. 3086-I; Sun Yat-sen, Kidnapped in London: Being the Story of My Capture by, Detention at, and Release from the Chinese Legation, London (Bristol: J. W. Arrowsmith, 1897), written by Sun in English · Public domain
Why this reading. Lesson 4.1 tells you that “you will read the colonized side at length in Lesson 4.2”. This lesson has no reading. Its objective is to explain imperialism “from the perspective of the colonized”, and its matrix asks for the role of a leader and the role of ideology in six cases — from a mini-lecture that summarizes all six in the same voice. Kipling got seven stanzas in the last lesson. Here are two of the colonized speaking for themselves, at the length their arguments need, with a plain note about the four cases where we could not do the same. What to look for: neither of these men is writing to his own people. Both are arguing in the imperial language, to the imperial public, using the empire’s own stated principles against it. That is a strategy, and it belongs in your matrix under “type of response”.
1. India — Dadabhai Naoroji, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901)
Naoroji was a Bombay-born businessman and professor who became, in 1892, the first Indian elected to the British House of Commons. He spent fifty years assembling the case that British rule was making India poorer, using the British government’s own published statistics. The book is a compilation of his papers and speeches, published in London, addressed to a British readership.
The argument, which he called the drain:
…the evil of the “bleeding” and impoverishing drain by the foreign dominion nearly or above £30,000,000 a year in a variety of subtle ways and shapes; while about the beginning of the last century the drain was declared to be £3,000,000 a year — and with private remittances, was supposed to be near £5,000,000 — or one-sixth of what it is at present. If the profits of exports and freight and insurance, which are not accounted for in the official statistics, be considered, the present drain will be nearer forty than thirty millions…
The drain, in his account, is the wealth taken out of India and not returned: the salaries and pensions of British officials paid in London, the profits of British firms remitted home, the interest on debt raised in London and charged to India, the cost of the army. His claim is not that Indians were poor, which everybody granted, but that a specific mechanism of government was making them poorer, and that the mechanism could be measured.
Then the argument about who paid for the empire:
But the drain is not all. All the wars by which the British Indian Empire is built up have not only been fought mainly with Indian blood, but every farthing of expenditure (with insignificant exceptions) incurred in all wars and proceedings within and beyond the frontiers of India by which the Empire has been built up and maintained up to the present day has been exacted from the Indian people. Britain has spent nothing.
And the sentence that does the most damage, because it is not his. Naoroji quotes the British Secretary of State for India, Lord Salisbury, from an official minute of 26 April 1875 printed in a parliamentary command paper, which Naoroji cites by number:
“The injury is exaggerated in the case of India, where so much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent. As India must be bled the lancet should be directed to the parts where the blood is congested or at least sufficient, not to those” (the agricultural people) “which are already feeble from the want of it.”
Naoroji’s comment follows immediately: those who were considered as having sufficient blood “are also being brought lower and lower”, and famine and plague were then “fast bleeding the masses to death”.
How to use this in the matrix. Naoroji’s type of response is not military resistance, religious revival or modernizing reform. It is something the lesson’s four categories do not quite name: constitutional argument inside the imperial system, conducted in the imperial capital, using the imperial government’s own numbers and its own ministers’ own words. His role as a leader is to make a moral case measurable. Note the title: Un-British Rule. He is not saying the British are wicked; he is saying they are betraying their own stated standards, which is an argument designed to be unanswerable by people who believe in those standards. Whether that strategy worked is a question your generalization can take on.
2. China — Sun Yat-sen, Kidnapped in London (1897)
In October 1896 Sun Yat-sen, then an exile with a price on his head, was seized on a London street and held prisoner inside the Chinese legation, which intended to ship him back to China for execution. A friend raised the alarm, the Foreign Office intervened, and he was released after twelve days. He wrote this book in English, immediately, and it made him famous. These are his own words about why he had joined a reform movement in the first place:
…I first learned of the existence of a political movement which I might best describe as the formation of a “Young China” party. Its objects were so wise, so modest, and so hopeful, that my sympathies were at once enlisted in its behalf, and I believed I was doing my best to further the interests of my country by joining it. The idea was to bring about a peaceful reformation, and we hoped, by forwarding modest schemes of reform to the Throne, to initiate a form of government more consistent with modern requirements.
The people have no say whatever in the management of Imperial, National, or even Municipal affairs. The mandarins, or local magistrates, have full power of adjudication, from which there is no appeal. Their word is law, and they have full scope to practise their machinations with complete irresponsibility, and every officer may fatten himself with impunity. Extortion by officials is an institution; it is the condition on which they take office…
English readers are probably unaware of the smallness of the established salaries of provincial magnates… so that, in order to live and maintain himself in office, accumulating fabulous riches the while, he resorts to extortion and the selling of justice… Once obtained, as he cannot live on his salary, perhaps he even pays so much annually for his post, licence to squeeze is the result… With advancement comes increased licence and additional facility for self-enrichment, so that the cleverest “squeezer” ultimately can obtain money enough to purchase the highest positions…
…an imperium in imperio, an unjust autocracy, which thrives by its own rottenness. But this system of fattening on the public vitals — the selling of power — is the chief means by which the Manchu dynasty continues to exist.
Two things this document shows that no summary can. First, Sun begins as a constitutional reformer and says so — “peaceful reformation”, “modest schemes of reform to the Throne” — and turns to revolution only after that route closes. For your matrix, that is a case of a response changing type over time, which is worth more than a fixed label. Second, his target here is the Qing dynasty and its officials, not the foreign powers. The Chinese case is unlike the Indian one because there were two things to resist: a foreign-imposed treaty system and a domestic dynasty that could not stand up to it. Sun is addressing English readers in English and asking, in effect, for their sympathy against his own government.
And notice why he could write it. This book exists because a Chinese revolutionary was kidnapped in central London and the British press made it a scandal. His argument reached a British audience through his captors’ mistake. That is a fact about how colonized people got heard, and it belongs in the exception you are asked to name.
3. The four cases where we could not do this, and why it matters
This course does not print quotations it cannot verify against a scan or an official text. For four of the six cases in your matrix we could not reach a source that met that standard, and saying so is more useful to you than filling the space:
| Case | What exists | What you should do |
|---|---|---|
| Ethiopia, 1896 | Menelik II issued proclamations in Amharic; the English versions in circulation are modern and unattributed | Argue from the outcome and the conditions: modern rifles bought abroad, regional rulers united, a European army defeated in a pitched battle. Describe, do not quote |
| Maji Maji, 1905–07 | Oral testimony collected decades later by historians, and German military records | Say whose record you are using. German sources tell you what the army did and how it explained it; they are not evidence of what the fighters believed |
| The Congo | George Washington Williams’s open letter to Leopold II of 1890 and Roger Casement’s consular report of 1904 are both public domain, and Casement’s prints Congolese testimony — but taken down by a British consul, through interpreters, for a British government | Cite them by name and date, and state that chain of transmission when you use the testimony |
| Korea, 1919 | The Declaration of Independence of 1 March 1919 was translated into English at the time by Korean exiles and published in the United States | Name the document and its date and describe its argument — that Korea declares independence as a right belonging to a people, and pledges that the movement will not use violence |
This is itself a finding for your generalization. The two voices we can print at length are an Indian elected to the British Parliament and a Chinese doctor educated in Hawaii and Hong Kong — both of them men who had learned the colonizer’s language and could publish in the colonizer’s capital. The peoples whose resistance was armed and rural left far fewer documents of their own in the archives that survive, and what we have of them was mostly written down by the people who defeated them. When the lesson asks you to judge each response “by the choices open to people at the time”, add a second question: by the records that survived. A matrix that shows constitutional argument as the best-documented response is telling you something about libraries, not only about history.
Sources: Dadabhai Naoroji, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) (archive.org); Sun Yat-sen, Kidnapped in London (1897) (archive.org)