
plan a literary analysis that argues how two themes interact across The Scarlet Letter, organized so each section builds on the last and linked by transitions that name those relationships, with evidence from the beginning, the middle and the forest chapters.
Instruction
11-12.RL.1.D raises the bar from Grade 10: you now analyze two or more themes, and how they interact and build on one another to produce a complex account. That changes how you plan an essay. A list of themes (“The novel is about sin. It is also about identity.”) is not an argument. An argument explains the relation.
Step 1 — Name two themes as claims, not topics. A theme is a claim the novel makes about life, not a single word. “Sin” is a topic. “Public punishment cannot produce the repentance it demands” is a theme. “Suffering shared can become the ground of sympathy” is another.
Step 2 — Find the choice that connects them. Ask what authorial decision makes the two themes meet. Example: Hawthorne makes the letter that was meant to isolate Hester the very thing that teaches her to recognize hidden sin in others, so the novel’s case against public punishment and its case for sympathy turn out to be one argument. The connecting choice here is the changing meaning of the letter.
Step 3 — Organize so each section builds (11-12.W.2.A). Order your sections by the logic of the argument, not by chapter. A strong plan: (1) the letter as the community intends it — punishment and isolation (Chapters 2-5); (2) what the letter actually does to Hester’s perception (Chapter 5, where she feels a “sympathetic knowledge” of hidden sin in others, and Chapter 13); (3) the contrast with Dimmesdale, whose hidden guilt gives his sermons a power of sympathy but brings him no release, only self-torment and a truth turned into falsehood (Chapters 11-12); (4) the forest, where Hester throws the letter away and Pearl will not come to her until she puts it back on (Chapters 18-19). Each section depends on the one before it. Leave room for a fifth section: you have not yet read the last four chapters, and Lessons 2.8 and 2.9 will give you the evidence to finish the argument.
Step 4 — Choose evidence across the novel so far (11-12.W.2.A). For Stage 1, gather at least six quotations from what you have read: some from the beginning, the middle and the forest chapters, including one from a scaffold scene and one from “The Custom-House.” Reserve a slot for at least one quotation from the ending (Chapters 21-24), which you will add after Lessons 2.8 and 2.9; the final essay needs seven or more. Select the most significant evidence, not the first you find. A quotation earns its place if your analysis of it says something the quotation cannot say alone.
Step 5 — Plan for ambiguity. Your essay must handle one place where Hawthorne offers several explanations: the rose-bush in Chapter 1, Mistress Hibbins’s invitation in Chapter 8 (“if we suppose this interview betwixt Mistress Hibbins and Hester Prynne to be authentic, and not a parable”), the meteor in Chapter 12, or the meaning of the letter to different townspeople (“Able,” as some come to say in Chapter 13). The final chapters will offer one more passage of this kind. Don’t pick one explanation and pretend the others don’t exist. Argue what the uncertainty contributes to your themes.
Step 6 — Transitions that show how the sections build (11-12.W.3.A.d). 11-12.W.3.A.d asks you to use appropriate and varied transitions and syntax to link the major sections of your essay, create cohesion, and clarify the relationships among complex ideas. In a two-themes essay the transitions carry the argument, because the reader must feel each section depend on the one before. Name the relationship first, then choose the words. An unintended effect: “Yet the isolation the magistrates intend produces something they did not foresee.” Contrast across characters: “Dimmesdale’s case proves the same point from the other side.” Concession: “Granting that the town softens toward Hester by Chapter 13, the letter still…” Escalation: “The forest puts both themes to their hardest test.” Avoid transitions that only add (“Also,” “Another theme is”), because they hide the relationship you are supposed to show. Vary the syntax as well as the words: a transition can be a whole sentence, a subordinate clause (“Because the letter has taught her to see hidden sin in others, …”), or a short sentence after a long paragraph. Write a transition into your plan now, between each pair of sections, and underline it.
Applying the reading standards in writing (11-12.RL.1.A). Your essay should show knowledge of the novel as a foundational American work: written in 1850 about 1640s Boston, by a descendant of the Puritans. Use that double time frame where it strengthens your argument.
Revision as a habit (11-12.W.3.A). Expect Step 2 to change after you gather evidence. Record what changed and why; that is your revision note.
📖 Before this lesson, read: The Scarlet Letter, The Custom-House through Chapter 20
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Evidence bank, worked plan and criteria for the two-themes organizer
Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter (Boston: Ticknor, Reed and Fields, 1850), Project Gutenberg #33, retrieved 2026-09-26….. Identifiers: Project Gutenberg ebook 33 (The Scarlet Letter) · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Nathaniel Hawthorne, 1850)
The model paragraph and revision are SLS original and are not attributed to any student or school.
Stage 1 asks you to plan a literary analysis in which two themes build on each other. This reading gives you an evidence bank from “The Custom-House” and from the beginning, the middle and the forest chapters of the novel (everything you have read so far), a worked plan with transitions, a model paragraph and a revision, and the criteria the organizer is scored against. Boxed text is Hawthorne’s own, in his British spelling. Everything else is SLS original.
Evidence bank: the novel and its frame
At all events, I, the present writer, as their representative, hereby take shame upon myself for their sakes, and pray that any curse incurred by them—as I have heard, and as the dreary and unprosperous condition of the race, for many a long year back, would argue to exist—may be now and henceforth removed.
— “The Custom-House” (Hawthorne on his ancestors)
Meagre, indeed, and cold, was the sympathy that a transgressor might look for, from such bystanders, at the scaffold.
— Chapter II (the crowd; beginning)
She shuddered to believe, yet could not help believing, that it gave her a sympathetic knowledge of the hidden sin in other hearts.
— Chapter V (the letter gives Hester a “sympathetic knowledge”; early-middle)
Poor, miserable man! what right had infirmity like his to burden itself with crime? Crime is for the iron-nerved, who have their choice either to endure it, or, if it press too hard, to exert their fierce and savage strength for a good purpose, and fling it off at once! This feeble and most sensitive of spirits could do neither, yet continually did one thing or another, which intertwined, in the same inextricable knot, the agony of heaven-defying guilt and vain repentance.
— Chapter XII (Dimmesdale on the scaffold at night; middle)
Such helpfulness was found in her—so much power to do, and power to sympathise—that many people refused to interpret the scarlet A by its original signification. They said that it meant Able, so strong was Hester Prynne, with a woman’s strength.
— Chapter XIII (the letter read as “Able”; middle)
So speaking, she undid the clasp that fastened the scarlet letter, and, taking it from her bosom, threw it to a distance among the withered leaves.
— Chapter XVIII (Hester in the forest; late middle)
“Yes; now I will!” answered the child, bounding across the brook, and clasping Hester in her arms “Now thou art my mother indeed! and I am thy little Pearl!”
— Chapter XIX (Pearl, after Hester puts the letter back on; late middle)
Worked plan (SLS original)
Two themes as claims. (1) Public punishment cannot produce the repentance it demands. (2) Suffering, shared or recognized, becomes the ground of sympathy.
The connecting choice. Hawthorne changes the meaning of the letter: meant to isolate Hester, it teaches her to recognize hidden sin in others and finally makes her a counselor. The novel’s case against public punishment and its case for sympathy turn out to be one argument.
| Section | Job in the argument | Evidence from the bank | Depends on the last section because… |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. The letter as the community means it | Shows punishment as isolation. | Chapter II, “Meagre, indeed, and cold, was the sympathy” (beginning) | (starts the argument) |
| 2. What the letter does to Hester | Shows isolation producing perception. | Chapter V, “a sympathetic knowledge of the hidden sin in other hearts”; Chapter XIII, “Able” | Only after the community’s intention is clear can its result surprise. |
| 3. The contrast with Dimmesdale | Shows that hidden guilt can move others but brings no release. | Chapter XII, “the agony of heaven-defying guilt and vain repentance” | The contrast proves the point from the other side: his sympathy stays in the pulpit, and with no letter to wear, his guilt has nowhere to go but inward. |
| 4. The forest | Tests whether the letter can be thrown away. | Chapter XVIII, “threw it to a distance among the withered leaves”; Chapter XIX, “Now thou art my mother indeed!” | Only after the letter has become part of Hester (sections 1-3) can its removal fail. |
| 5. The ending | (to be planned after Lessons 2.8 and 2.9) | (at least one quotation from Chapters XXI–XXIV) | (you will write this) |
The seven boxes above give you passages from “The Custom-House,” the beginning (Chapter II), the middle (Chapters V, XII and XIII) and the forest (Chapters XVIII and XIX). Choose the six quotations you will actually use now, and leave one slot for the ending. They must include one from a scaffold scene: take it from the scaffold passages in Lesson 2.1 (for example Hester’s “Never” in Chapter III).
The ambiguous passage to address. In Chapter XII the narrator blames the A in the sky on “the disease in his own eye and heart” and adds that “another’s guilt might have seen another symbol in it,” while the next morning the sexton reads the same light as “Angel.” A plan can say: this uncertainty supports Theme 1, because if the townspeople read one sign in opposite ways, their power to judge in public is exactly what the novel questions. The final chapters offer one more passage of this kind, and you may switch to it after Lesson 2.9.
Transitions between sections (SLS original)
| Between sections | Relationship | Model transition |
|---|---|---|
| 1 → 2 | An unintended effect | Yet the isolation the magistrates intend produces something they did not foresee. |
| 2 → 3 | Contrast across characters | Dimmesdale’s case proves the same point from the other side: he wears no letter, and his hidden guilt brings him only self-torment. |
| 3 → 4 | Escalation | The forest puts both themes to their hardest test, because there, for one hour, the letter is gone. |
| 4 → 5 | (to write after Lessons 2.8 and 2.9) | (you will write this) |
How the key works. Each model names a relationship before it states a fact. A reader who sees only the transitions should be able to reconstruct the logic of the essay. Notice that none of them begins with “Also” or “Another theme,” which add without relating.
Model paragraph (SLS original)
Hawthorne first shows a punishment that isolates. The crowd offers a transgressor only “meagre” and “cold” sympathy, and the letter takes Hester “out of the ordinary relations with humanity.” Yet the isolation has a result the magistrates did not intend. Once she is set apart, Hester begins to see what the town conceals: the letter gives her “a sympathetic knowledge of the hidden sin in other hearts.” The first theme, that public punishment cannot produce repentance, therefore sets up the second, that suffering can become sympathy, because the same mark that fails to reform Hester makes her able to recognize others.
Transitions to notice in the model: Yet turns from the intended punishment to its unintended result; Once she is set apart is a clause that marks cause; therefore announces how the first theme sets up the second.
Before and after: from topic to theme claim (SLS original)
| Before (a list of topics) | After (an argument) | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| The novel is about sin. It is also about identity. | Hawthorne makes the letter that was meant to isolate Hester the thing that teaches her to recognize hidden sin in others, so the novel’s case against public punishment and its case for sympathy are one argument. | Two topics became two claims; a named authorial choice (the changing meaning of the letter) connects them; Hawthorne is the grammatical subject. |
Criteria for the Stage 1 organizer (SLS original)
| Part | Meets the standard when |
|---|---|
| Two themes | Each is a sentence the novel argues, not a one-word topic. |
| Connecting choice | One sentence names an authorial decision that makes the themes meet. |
| Four-section plan | Each section depends on the one before; the order follows the argument, not the chapters; a fifth section on the ending is left open. |
| Six quotations, one slot for the ending | From the beginning, middle and forest chapters; one from a scaffold scene; one from “The Custom-House.” Copied exactly. One slot reserved for Chapters XXI–XXIV. |
| Transitions (11-12.W.3.A.d) | A transition written between each pair of sections, naming the relationship (cause, contrast, concession or escalation); no transition that only adds. |
| Ambiguous passage | Named, with a note on what the uncertainty contributes. |
| Revision note | Records what changed in the plan and why. |
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is a theme stated as a claim?
Organizing an essay in chapter order is always the clearest way to show how themes build.
Which transition best links a section on the town’s punishment of Hester to a section on what that punishment teaches her?
Submit Stage 1: two themes stated as claims; one sentence naming the choice that connects them; a four-section plan in which each section depends on the last, with a slot for a fifth section on the ending; a transition sentence written between each pair of sections, underlined, that names the relationship (cause, contrast, concession or escalation); six quotations (beginning, middle, forest chapters, one scaffold scene, one from ‘The Custom-House’); and the ambiguous passage you will address.
How confident are you that you can plan an essay on how two themes interact across a novel?
The Scarlet Letter, The Custom-House through Chapter 20
The Scarlet Letter, The Custom-House through Chapter 20 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Hawthorne frames the novel with “The Custom-House,” where he claims to have found the faded letter and the record of Hester Prynne’s story. In Puritan Boston, Hester stands on the scaffold with her infant, refuses to name the father, and recognizes her husband in the crowd; he takes the name Roger Chillingworth and swears her to secrecy (The Custom-House and Chapters 1-4). She lives apart by her needle, raises the brilliant, unruly Pearl, and keeps her daughter only because the young minister Arthur Dimmesdale pleads for her before the Governor (Chapters 5-8). Chillingworth becomes Dimmesdale’s physician and housemate, sees something on the sleeping minister’s breast that fills him with a wild joy, and torments him from within, until one midnight Dimmesdale stands on the scaffold with Hester and Pearl while a meteor lights the sky (Chapters 9-12). Seven years on, many townspeople read Hester’s letter as “Able”; Hester confronts Chillingworth and resolves to tell Dimmesdale who he is (Chapters 13-15). In the forest she does so, the two resolve to flee to Europe, and Hester throws away the letter until Pearl makes her put it back on; Dimmesdale returns to town shaken by wild temptations and writes his Election Sermon (Chapters 16-20).