THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP English 11A — Founding Arguments and the American Self

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 27 Lessons
  • Lifetime
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: The Argument for a Nation — Paine, the Founders and Those They Left Out
    8
    • 1.1
      Common Sense — Reading the Argument That Made a Nation
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      The Case Against Kings: Monarchy and Hereditary Succession
      45 mins
    • 1.3
      Language Lab — Usage Is a Convention: Reading Adams and Wheatley
      45 mins
    • 1.4
      The Present State of American Affairs: Paine’s Call to Independence
      45 mins
    • 1.5
      Seminar — Faction and the Large Republic: Federalist 10 and 51
      50 mins
    • 1.6
      Writing Workshop — Delineating Reasoning: Claims, Premises and Counterclaims
      50 mins
    • 1.7
      The Appendix: Paine Answers the King’s Speech
      45 mins
    • 1.8
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis of a Founding Argument
      200 mins
  • Unit 2: Sin, Law and Community — The Scarlet Letter
    9
    • 2.1
      The First Scaffold Scene — How The Scarlet Letter Is Built
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Hester at Her Needle: The Letter, the Child and the Governor’s Hall
      45 mins
    • 2.3
      Language Lab — Hawthorne’s Sentences: Syntax, Hedging and Nuance
      45 mins
    • 2.4
      The Leech and the Second Scaffold: The Minister’s Vigil
      45 mins
    • 2.5
      Seminar — Hawthorne’s Puritans and the Puritans’ Own Words
      50 mins
    • 2.6
      The Forest: Hester Throws Away the Letter
      45 mins
    • 2.7
      Writing Workshop — Two Themes, One Argument
      50 mins
    • 2.8
      The Third Scaffold: The Revelation of the Scarlet Letter
      45 mins
    • 2.9
      Key Assignment — Literary Analysis of The Scarlet Letter
      200 mins
  • Unit 3: Whose Declaration? Rights, Removal and the Nation’s Promise
    5
    • 3.1
      Using the Audience’s Values — Red Jacket and Douglass
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Language Lab — Irony, Hyperbole, Paradox and Euphemism
      45 mins
    • 3.3
      Listening Lab — Removal Argued: Jackson and the Cherokee Memorial
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Writing Workshop — Legal Reasoning and Fair Counterclaims: Dred Scott
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Key Assignment — Argument Essay: The Promise and Its Critics
      200 mins
  • Unit 4: The Self and Its Critics — Emerson, Thoreau, Fuller, Whitman and ‘Bartleby’
    5
    • 4.1
      Where I Lived — Emerson’s Scholar and Thoreau’s Experiment
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Language Lab — Whitman’s Catalogs and Fuller’s Claims: Hyphens, Dashes and Syntax
      45 mins
    • 4.3
      Seminar — ‘I Would Prefer Not To’: Bartleby and the Limits of the Self
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Writing Workshop — Reflective Narrative: Scene, Pacing and Reflection
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Key Assignment — Reflective Essay in the American Tradition
      200 mins

Key Assignment — Argument Essay: The Promise and Its Critics

Unit 3  ·  Culminating Unit Assessment  ·  Lesson 22 of 27

Key Assignment — Argument Essay: The Promise and Its Critics

11-12.W.2.ARLP-ENG11A
Blank legal document balanced against an iron shackle on courthouse scales, with hands reaching toward it.
By the end of this lesson I can…

write a 1,500-1,800 word argument about the reach of the nation’s founding promise, using legal and excluded voices, and present my findings orally.

Instruction

This essay is the semester’s longest argument so far, and it asks you to take a position on a question serious historians and citizens still dispute.

The question. Was the founding promise of equal rights a standard excluded Americans could successfully hold the nation to, or a promise that its authors and courts never intended to extend to them? You may argue a qualified position — for example, that the promise was not intended to include them, but that their use of it gave it a meaning its authors had not intended. A qualified claim is often the most defensible.

Required evidence. At least three unit texts, including one legal or governmental text (the Dred Scott opinions or Jackson’s message) and one by an excluded speaker (Douglass, Walker, Stewart, Red Jacket or the Cherokee Memorial). At least one additional authoritative source. For at least one text, delineate the reasoning: state its premises and evaluate one.

Precise claims (11-12.W.2.A). Your introduction must establish why the question matters and distinguish your claim from the alternatives. “Some argue… others argue… I argue…” is a start; better is a sentence that shows exactly where you disagree.

Formal style and objective tone (11-12.W.2.A). The subject includes slavery and the destruction of nations. Write about it with precision and gravity. Name what happened accurately; do not soften it with euphemism, and do not substitute emotional language for evidence. Quote hateful language only when your analysis requires it, and frame it as the speaker’s.

Writing for the task (11-12.W.2.A). Your audience is an informed reader who has not read the unit texts. Give just enough context for each source before analyzing it.

Conclusion (11-12.W.3.A.a). End with a section that follows from your argument. What does your answer imply about how later Americans — in the Reconstruction amendments you will study in English 11B — could use or change the promise?

The presentation (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C). Record four minutes presenting your findings so that a listener can follow your line of reasoning without the essay: claim, the key evidence, the counterclaim and your answer. Organization, substance and style should suit a formal audience. A live presentation is an equal-credit alternative.

Integrity and sources. Cite every source in MLA. Summaries of these documents are common online; your staged work and your own delineation of reasoning are what will be graded.

Reading: The Promise and Its Critics: prompt, key passages by location, a four-level rubric, and a model thesis and outline

Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), Project Gutenberg #31425; Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message (1830), American Presidency Project; Frederick Douglass (1852), University of Texas at Austin; David Walker, Appeal (1829), Project Gutenberg #16516; Red Jacket via Stone (1841), Internet Archive; Memorial of the Cherokees (1829), National Archives via Wikisource; all retrieved 2026-09-26… Identifiers: Project Gutenberg 31425; https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/second-annual-message-3; https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=What_to_the_Slave_Is_the_Fourth_of_July%3F; Project Gutenberg 16516; https://docsouth.unc.edu/nc/walker/walker.html; https://archive.org/stream/lifetimesofsagoy00stonuoft/lifetimesofsagoy00stonuoft_djvu.txt; https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Memorial_of_the_Cherokees · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (opinions of the Supreme Court, 1857; Jackson, 1830; Douglass, 1852; Walker, 1829; Red Jacket via Stone, 1841; Cherokee Nation, 1829)

Red Jacket’s speech is an English version made through an interpreter and printed later; wording differs among printings. Maria Stewart is named in the lesson but her text is not reproduced.

This page gives you what the essay needs in one place: the full prompt, the key passages by speaker and location, a four-level rubric, and a model thesis and outline. The passages are in the printed texts, in their spelling and punctuation. Each paragraph in a box is a separate passage, in order; text between passages is left out. The lesson names Maria Stewart among the excluded speakers you may use; her text is not reproduced here, so this page supplies four other excluded voices, and you need only one. Everything outside the boxes is SLS original.

The full prompt

Was the founding promise of equal rights a standard that excluded Americans could successfully hold the nation to, or a promise that its authors and courts never intended to extend to them? Write a 1,500-1,800 word argument that takes a position, which may be qualified. Use at least three unit texts, including one legal or governmental text (the Dred Scott opinions or Jackson’s message) and one by an excluded speaker (Douglass, Walker or Red Jacket, or the Cherokee Memorial). Add at least one authoritative source from outside the packet. For at least one text, delineate the reasoning: state its premises and evaluate one. Give the strongest opposing view its own evidence, and answer it. Cite in MLA. Then present your findings in four minutes.

Key passages, by location

Legal and governmental texts

They had for more than a century before been regarded as beings of an inferior order, and altogether unfit to associate with the white race, either in social or political relations; and so far inferior, that they had no rights which the white man was bound to respect; and that the negro might justly and lawfully be reduced to slavery for his benefit.

— Roger B. Taney, opinion of the Court, Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), Project Gutenberg #31425, retrieved 2026-09-26

Of this there can be no doubt. At the time of the ratification of the Articles of Confederation, all free native-born inhabitants of the States of New Hampshire, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, and North Carolina, though descended from African slaves, were not only citizens of those States, but such of them as had the other necessary qualifications possessed the franchise of electors, on equal terms with other citizens.

— Benjamin R. Curtis, dissenting opinion, Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), same report, retrieved 2026-09-26

Rightly considered, the policy of the General Government toward the red man is not only liberal, but generous. He is unwilling to submit to the laws of the States and mingle with their population. To save him from this alternative, or perhaps utter annihilation, the General Government kindly offers him a new home, and proposes to pay the whole expense of his removal and settlement.

— Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message to Congress (6 December 1830), American Presidency Project, retrieved 2026-09-26

Excluded speakers

I am not included within the pale of this glorious anniversary! Your high independence only reveals the immeasurable distance between us. The blessings in which you, this day, rejoice, are not enjoyed in common. — The rich inheritance of justice, liberty, prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me.

The sunlight that brought life and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me.

— Frederick Douglass, “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?” (Rochester, 5 July 1852), text posted by the University of Texas at Austin (Core Texts), retrieved 2026-09-26

See your declaration, Americans!! Do you understand your own language? Hear your language, proclaimed to the world, July 4, 1776–

— David Walker, Appeal (Boston, 1829), Project Gutenberg #16516, retrieved 2026-09-26

We do not wish to destroy your religion, or take it from you. We only want to enjoy our own.

— Red Jacket, reply to the missionary Cram (1805), in William L. Stone, The Life and Times of Red Jacket (1841; 1866 edition), Internet Archive, retrieved 2026-09-26

The land on which we stand we have received as an inheritance from our fathers, who possessed it from time immemorial, as a gift from our common father in heaven. We have already said, that when the white man came to the shores of America, our ancestors were found in peaceable possession of this very land. They bequeathed it to us as their children, and we have sacredly kept it as containing the remains of our beloved men. This right of inheritance we have never ceded, nor ever forfeited. Permit us to ask, what better right can a people have to a country, than the right of inheritance and immemorial peaceable possession? We know it is said of late by the State of Georgia, and by the Executive of the United States, that we have forfeited this right—but we think this is said gratuitously.

You represent a virtuous, intelligent and christian nation. To you they willingly submit their cause for your righteous decision.

— Memorial of the Cherokees (December 1829), from the National Archives (Record Group 233, Tabled Petitions and Memorials, ARC 306680), Wikisource transcription, retrieved 2026-09-26

Rubric at four levels (SLS original)

Criterion4 Exceeds3 Meets2 Approaches1 Beginning
Claim (11-12.W.2.A, .1.a)Precise, significant, qualified where evidence requires; sets itself against named alternatives.Precise and arguable; distinguishes at least one alternative.Stated but broad; alternatives implied.Missing, or a topic instead of a claim.
Reasoning delineated (11-12.RI.2.D, .9)Premises of a text stated and one evaluated with evidence; two texts compared for purpose and rhetoric.Premises stated and one evaluated.Reasoning summarized, premises not separated out.Text only paraphrased.
Counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A)Strongest opposing view stated as its best advocate would, with its evidence; strengths conceded; the premise it needs is answered.Fair opposing view with some evidence; answered.Opposing view weak or partial.Absent or a straw man.
Sources (11-12.W.1.A.b)Three or more unit texts and an authoritative outside source, quoted selectively and cited in MLA.Three unit texts and one outside source, cited.Fewer than three unit texts or an uncited source.Sources not used or unreliable.
Style and conclusion (11-12.W.2.A, .1.e, 11-12.W.2.A)Formal, precise and grave; no euphemism; conclusion follows and looks ahead to the Reconstruction amendments.Formal; conclusion follows.Uneven tone; conclusion repeats.Informal or emotional in place of evidence.
Presentation (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C)Line of reasoning clear without the essay; counterclaim and answer included.Claim, key evidence and a counterclaim in order.Reads the essay aloud.Not presented.

Model thesis and outline (SLS original)

SLS original; not a quotation from any student or author.

Model thesis. Although the Dred Scott Court denied that the founders’ promise included Black Americans, Douglass and Walker made that promise a standard the nation could be measured by, which is how it later came to be enlarged.

  1. Introduction. The question matters because the same words, “all men,” were used to claim and to deny rights. Name the alternatives: never intended, fully binding, or a standard that acquired meaning through use. State the thesis.
  2. Context and the promise denied. Delineate Taney’s steps: question, method, premise (1787 opinion), conclusion. Evaluate the premise.
  3. The promise held against the nation. Douglass: the audience’s own holiday turned against it (“shared by you, not by me”). Walker: “Do you understand your own language?” Explain each speaker’s use of the audience’s values.
  4. Strongest counterclaim. The Court’s holding was the law, and Jackson’s message shows government policy treating some peoples as outside the promise while calling that generosity. Concede what is true in this.
  5. Response. Answer Taney’s premise with Curtis’s evidence; show that the Cherokee Memorial also holds the United States to its own promises (treaties) and that Congress’s later action on citizenship answers Taney.
  6. Conclusion. What the argument implies for how the Reconstruction amendments, studied in English 11B, could use or change the promise. Do not end on a moral; end on the implication.

Presentation plan (SLS original)

Four minutes: 30 seconds on the question; 60 on the claim and the key text; 60 on the strongest counterclaim; 60 on your answer; 30 on what it implies. Mark your transitions in the margin so a listener can follow the line of reasoning.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

Flashcard

memorial

Tap to reveal
Answer

A formal written petition to a legislature.

Flashcard

dissent

Tap to reveal
Answer

A justice’s opinion disagreeing with the majority.

Flashcard

euphemism

Tap to reveal
Answer

A mild word for a harsh reality.

Flashcard

consistency argument

Tap to reveal
Answer

Holding an audience to its own professed principles.

Flashcard

qualified claim

Tap to reveal
Answer

A claim limited to what the evidence supports.

+50 XP

Which is the strongest claim for this essay?

It is qualified, precise and arguable, and it names its evidence.
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can write a sustained argument on a contested question using legal and excluded voices?

Not yetVery confident

Submit: Argument Essay (1,500-1,800 words) + 4-minute presentation of findings

Task: Argue whether the founding promise of equal rights was a standard excluded Americans could hold the nation to, or a promise never meant for them — or a qualified position — using legal, governmental and excluded voices.

Submission workflow

  1. Stage 1 — Organizer. Claim, reasons, counterclaim with evidence, response, transitions, three authoritative sources (from Lesson 3.4).
  2. Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner identifies the premise your own argument depends on and tests it; submit a revision note.
  3. Stage 3 — Final essay. 1,500-1,800 words, at least three unit texts and one outside source, MLA Works Cited.
  4. Stage 4 — Presentation. Four minutes, recorded or live, with a listener question answered.

How it is scored

CriterionWhat proficient looks like
Claim (11-12.W.2.A)Precise and significant; distinguished from alternative positions; qualified where the evidence requires.
Reasoning delineated (11-12.RI.2.D, 11-12.RI.3.B, 11-12.RI.3.C)Premises of at least one text stated and evaluated; texts analyzed for purpose and rhetoric.
Counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A)Strongest opposing view developed with its own evidence; strengths acknowledged; limits shown.
Sources (11-12.W.1.A.b)One authoritative outside source integrated selectively and cited.
Style and conclusion (11-12.W.2.A, 11-12.W.3.A.a)Formal, precise, grave; conclusion follows and points forward.
Presentation (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C)Line of reasoning easy to follow; organization and style suit a formal audience.

Missouri Learning Standards addressed in this lesson: 11-12.W.2.A, 11-12.W.3.A.a, 11-12.RI.3.B, 11-12.RI.3.C, 11-12.SL.2.A, 11-12.SL.2.B, 11-12.SL.2.C

Instructional focus: Argumentative writing from seminal U.S. documents, with oral presentation

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Writing Workshop — Legal Reasoning and Fair Counterclaims: Dred Scott
Prev
Where I Lived — Emerson’s Scholar and Thoreau’s Experiment
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content