
write a precise, knowledgeable claim about how a founding argument persuades, distinguish it from opposing claims, plan how to develop the strongest counterclaim fairly, and link claim, reasons and counterclaim with transitions that name logical relations.
Instruction
A rhetorical analysis is an argument about an argument. It is not a summary of what Paine said, and it is not your opinion of independence. It is a claim about how a text works on its audience and how well. 11-12.W.2.A asks for a claim that is precise and knowledgeable, that establishes its own significance, and that is distinguished from opposing claims.
From topic to claim. Watch one claim sharpen:
- Topic: Paine uses rhetoric in Common Sense. (True of every writer.)
- Vague claim: Paine uses emotional and logical appeals to persuade colonists. (Still true of almost any argument.)
- Precise claim: Paine persuades readers who still thought of themselves as loyal Englishmen by securing agreement on abstract first principles before he names the king, so that independence arrives as a conclusion they have already accepted.
The third names a specific audience, a specific strategy (order of argument) and a specific effect.
Establish significance. Answer “so what?” in a sentence: This matters because it shows that Paine’s radicalism depended on appearing to be common sense — a strategy later American reformers would borrow.
Distinguish it from alternatives. Name the reading you are not making: Readers often credit Paine’s fiery final pages; I argue the quiet opening does more of the work. That sentence tells your reader where you stand in a conversation.
Delineate, then evaluate. For the reasoning you analyze, identify at least one premise the argument depends on (11-12.RI.1.A asks you to apply the reading standards for seminal U.S. texts in your writing). Paine’s island-and-continent analogy depends on the premise that the governed should not be larger than the governor. Is that premise true? Size does not obviously determine legitimacy. Yet the analogy persuades because it makes the connection with Britain look physically absurd. A strong essay can say both: the reasoning is weak, and the rhetoric is powerful. That distinction is what 11-12.RI.2.B means by analyzing how style and content contribute to the power of a text.
Counterclaims, fairly (11-12.W.2.A). The best counterclaim is the one a smart reader would actually raise. If you argue that Paine’s structure does the persuading, a reader might answer that events did — the burning of Norfolk, the king’s rejection of the Olive Branch Petition — and that the pamphlet only gave people words for what they already felt. Present that view at its strongest, with evidence, then show its limit: the pamphlet’s reprints and the arguments it provoked suggest it shaped, not just reflected, opinion. Say what the counterclaim gets right. Readers trust writers who concede real points.
Transitions carry the logic (11-12.W.3.A.d). A transition is not decoration between paragraphs; it is a small claim about how two ideas relate. 11-12.W.3.A.d asks you to use words, phrases and clauses, along with varied syntax, to link the major sections of your essay, create cohesion, and make clear the relationships between claim and reasons, between reasons and evidence, and between claim and counterclaims. Choose each transition by the relation you mean:
- Adding a reason: a second reason is that…; more important still…
- Reason to evidence: the clearest evidence comes in Section 3, where…; Paine’s own example shows…
- Conceding: granted…; it is true that…, and yet…
- Turning against a counterclaim: yet this view explains too little; even so…
- Consequence: because this premise fails…; as a result…
Paine signposts the same way. In Section 3 he asks what would follow if Britain and America were reconciled: “I answer, the ruin of the continent. And that for several reasons.” He then numbers the reasons (“First.” and “Secondly.”) and marks his strongest one as the climax: “But the most powerful of all arguments, is, that nothing but independance, i.e. a continental form of government, can keep the peace of the continent and preserve it inviolate from civil wars.” The reader always knows how many reasons are coming and which one matters most. Test your own plan the same way: write only the opening clause of each paragraph. If those clauses alone show how your reasons build toward your claim and where the counterclaim is answered, your transitions are doing their job. If a therefore stands before a point that does not follow, the transition is making a claim your argument has not earned; change the argument or the word.
Plan in stages (11-12.W.3.A). Stage 1 is a plan. Expect your claim to change as you reread. Record each change and why: that record becomes your revision note at Stage 2.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Common Sense, Introduction–Section 4
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Two founders’ mentor paragraphs, a student model, and the Stage 1 criteria
Thomas Paine, Common Sense (1776), Project Gutenberg #147; The Federalist No. 10 (1787), Project Gutenberg #1404; retrieved 2026-09-26….. Identifiers: Project Gutenberg 147; Project Gutenberg 1404 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Thomas Paine, 1776; James Madison, 1787)
The student model and revision are SLS original and are not attributed to any student or school.
Stage 1 asks for a precise claim, a premise you will test, and a counterclaim developed fairly. This reading gives you two mentor paragraphs from the founders, a student model and a revision written for this course, and the criteria Stage 1 is scored against. Boxed text is the founders’ own; everything else is SLS original.
Mentor paragraph 1: stating an opposing view, then answering it (Paine, 1776)
I have heard it asserted by some, that as America hath flourished under her former connexion with Great-Britain, that the same connexion is necessary towards her future happiness, and will always have the same effect. Nothing can be more fallacious than this kind of argument. We may as well assert that because a child has thrived upon milk, that it is never to have meat, or that the first twenty years of our lives is to become a precedent for the next twenty. But even this is admitting more than is true, for I answer roundly, that America would have flourished as much, and probably much more, had no European power had any thing to do with her. The commerce, by which she hath enriched herself are the necessaries of life, and will always have a market while eating is the custom of Europe.
— Thomas Paine, Common Sense (Philadelphia, 1776), Thoughts on the Present State of American Affairs. Text from Project Gutenberg #147, retrieved 2026-09-26
What to notice. Paine states the opposing view as its supporters would: America thrived under the connection, so the connection is necessary. That is fair. His answer is a counter-analogy (a child fed on milk), and then a factual reply. But he concedes nothing: “Nothing can be more fallacious.” Your assignment asks for more than he gives. Study the next mentor for the part he leaves out.
Mentor paragraph 2: conceding a real limit (Madison, 1787)
The effect of the first difference is, on the one hand, to refine and enlarge the public views, by passing them through the medium of a chosen body of citizens, whose wisdom may best discern the true interest of their country, and whose patriotism and love of justice will be least likely to sacrifice it to temporary or partial considerations. Under such a regulation, it may well happen that the public voice, pronounced by the representatives of the people, will be more consonant to the public good than if pronounced by the people themselves, convened for the purpose. On the other hand, the effect may be inverted. Men of factious tempers, of local prejudices, or of sinister designs, may, by intrigue, by corruption, or by other means, first obtain the suffrages, and then betray the interests, of the people. The question resulting is, whether small or extensive republics are more favorable to the election of proper guardians of the public weal;
— James Madison (Publius), The Federalist No. 10 (22 November 1787), Project Gutenberg #1404
What to notice. Madison argues that representatives will “refine and enlarge” public views. Then he writes “On the other hand, the effect may be inverted” and describes how the remedy could fail. He gives the counterclaim its due before returning to his case. That is the move 11-12.W.2.A describes: point out the strengths and the limits of the opposing view.
Student model (SLS original): claim, counterclaim, answer
Claim. Paine persuades readers who still thought of themselves as loyal Englishmen by winning their agreement on first principles before he names the king, so that independence arrives as a conclusion they have already accepted.
Counterclaim paragraph. A reader might reasonably answer that the pamphlet did not persuade anyone: events did. By the winter of 1775–76 the king had refused to receive the Olive Branch Petition and the war was already nine months old, so colonists had every reason to give up on reconciliation whether or not Paine wrote a word. This view is right about one thing: Paine could not have succeeded with readers who were not already angry. Yet it explains too little. Events made independence possible; they did not tell a colonist that giving up the king was consistent with the principles he already held. Paine supplies that link, and he supplies it in the order the claim describes, with government first and the king later. The pamphlet was reprinted, argued over and answered, which suggests it shaped opinion as well as reflecting it.
Why it works. The counterclaim is stated the way its best advocate would state it, it comes with evidence, it names what the counterclaim gets right (“Paine could not have succeeded with readers who were not already angry”), and only then shows its limit. Compare the transitions: A reader might reasonably answer… This view is right about one thing… Yet it explains too little.
Before and after: revising a weak counterclaim (SLS original)
| Before | After | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Some people say events changed minds, not Paine, but that is silly because everyone read Common Sense. | The strongest objection is that events, not the pamphlet, ended reconciliation: the king’s refusal of the Olive Branch Petition gave colonists reason enough. That is true as far as it goes, but it does not explain why colonists who wanted to remain English came to see independence as consistent with English principles. | The insult (“silly”) is gone. The objection is stated at full strength with one piece of evidence. A strength is acknowledged (“true as far as it goes”) and the limit is named precisely. The claim “everyone read it” was unsupported, so it was dropped. |
Mentor passage 3: signposting reasons (Paine, 1776)
But admitting that matters were now made up, what would be the event? I answer, the ruin of the continent. And that for several reasons.
But the most powerful of all arguments, is, that nothing but independance, i.e. a continental form of government, can keep the peace of the continent and preserve it inviolate from civil wars.
— Thomas Paine, Common Sense (Philadelphia, 1776), Thoughts on the Present State of American Affairs. Text from Project Gutenberg #147
What to notice. Between these two passages Paine gives his reasons under the headings “First.” and “Secondly.” The question announces the topic, “for several reasons” promises a sequence, and “the most powerful of all arguments” tells the reader that the climax has arrived. Each transition names a relation: sequence, then rank.
Transitions that name the relation (SLS original)
| Relation | Transitions | In a sentence about Paine |
|---|---|---|
| Claim to first reason | The first sign of this is…; this strategy begins… | The strategy begins before the king is even named. |
| Reason to evidence | The clearest evidence comes…; Paine’s own example shows… | The clearest evidence comes in Section 2, where scripture does the work of political theory. |
| Adding weight | A second reason is…; more important still… | More important still, Paine answers the strongest objection before readers can raise it. |
| Conceding | Granted…; it is true that…, and yet… | It is true that events were already turning colonists against the king, and yet… |
| Turning against a counterclaim | Yet this view explains too little…; even so… | Yet this view explains too little, because events cannot supply a reason. |
| Consequence | Because this premise fails…; as a result… | Because the island-and-continent premise fails, the analogy persuades by picture rather than proof. |
Criteria for the Stage 1 organizer (SLS original)
| Part of the organizer | Meets the standard when |
|---|---|
| Claim | Names an audience, a strategy and an effect, and can be disputed. |
| Significance | One sentence answers “so what?” and says what the claim shows about persuading Americans. |
| Reading you are not making | One sentence names an alternative reading a smart reader might hold. |
| Three reasons | Each has an exact quotation from your chosen text, spelled as the original. |
| Premise to evaluate | Stated in your own words as something the argument depends on, with a note on whether it holds. |
| Counterclaim plan | Stated as its best advocate would state it, with evidence, what it gets right, and where it fails. |
| Transitions | Each body paragraph and the answer to the counterclaim opens with a word, phrase or clause that names its relation to the claim (sequence, evidence, concession, contrast or consequence). |
Self-check questions. Could a reader disagree with my claim? Have I quoted, not paraphrased, where my reason depends on exact wording? Would the person who holds the counterclaim say I stated it fairly?
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is the most precise claim for a rhetorical analysis?
A strong counterclaim paragraph presents the opposing view in its weakest form so it is easy to refute.
Your counterclaim paragraph has just stated the strongest objection to your claim. Which opening for the next paragraph best signals how the two ideas relate?
Submit Stage 1: your precise claim; one sentence of significance; one sentence naming the reading you are not making; three reasons, each with a quotation; one premise you will evaluate; the strongest counterclaim with the evidence you will give it; and, for each body paragraph and for your answer to the counterclaim, the opening transition you plan to use and the logical relation it names.
How confident are you that you can write a precise claim about how an argument works, plan a fair counterclaim, and choose transitions that name logical relations?
Common Sense, Introduction–Section 4
Common Sense, Introduction–Section 4 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
After an Introduction that calls America’s cause “the cause of all mankind,” Paine builds from first principles: government is a necessary evil meant to secure freedom and security, and the complicated English constitution fails that test (Section 1). He attacks kingship as contrary to natural equality and to scripture, and hereditary succession as an imposition on later generations (Section 2). Section 3 answers the arguments for reconciliation one by one, denies that England is America’s “parent,” appeals to what the war has already cost, and sketches a continental government under a written constitution in which the law is king. Section 4 argues that the colonies can succeed now: their numbers and unity are enough, they can build a navy from their own materials, debt is no obstacle, and youth is the right time to form a union and a government.