
delineate the reasoning of the Dred Scott majority and dissent, use it to model fair counterclaims, and gather authoritative sources for my argument essay.
Instruction
In 1857 the Supreme Court decided the case of Dred Scott, an enslaved man who sued for freedom on the ground that he had lived for years in a free state and a free territory. Chief Justice Roger Taney’s opinion for the majority held that Scott could not sue in federal court at all, because Black Americans — free or enslaved — were not and could not be citizens of the United States. It also held that Congress had no power to prohibit slavery in the territories. Two justices dissented. The decision deepened the crisis that led to the Civil War, and the Fourteenth Amendment was written in part to overturn it.
Delineating Taney’s reasoning (11-12.RI.2.D). Stripped to its steps:
- The question is whether people of African descent are “citizens” in the sense the Constitution uses.
- The Constitution means what it was understood to mean when it was adopted.
- In 1787, Taney claims, such people were regarded as an inferior order with no rights the white man was bound to respect.
- Therefore they were not part of “the people” who made the Constitution, and are not citizens.
Notice that the passage above is often misquoted as Taney simply stating his own view. He presents it as a description of the founders’ era; but he adopts it as the premise of a binding legal ruling, so it became the law of the land.
Justice Curtis’s dissent. Justice Benjamin Curtis attacked step 3 with evidence. At the time the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution were adopted, he pointed out, free Black men were citizens of several states and in some of them voted on equal terms; if they were citizens of states that ratified the Constitution, they were among the people who ordained it. Curtis did not challenge Taney’s method (step 2). He challenged the historical premise — and if step 3 falls, the conclusion falls with it.
What this teaches about counterclaims (11-12.W.2.A). Curtis shows the most effective way to answer an argument: identify the premise it cannot do without, and bring the best evidence against that premise. In your essay, do the same in reverse. State the strongest opposing position — not a weak one — with the evidence its best advocate would use. Then point out its strengths honestly and its limits precisely. If you argue that excluded Americans successfully held the nation to its promise, your strongest counterclaim is Taney’s opinion itself: the highest court said the promise was never theirs. Give that counterclaim its full weight before you answer it.
Gathering authoritative sources (11-12.W.1.A.b). Your essay needs one source beyond the unit packet. Authoritative means produced by someone with the knowledge and accountability to be trusted on this question: the Court’s own text in United States Reports (free through the Library of Congress), the National Archives, a university press history, a peer-reviewed article. Use advanced searches: search a phrase in quotation marks, limit by site (site:loc.gov, site:archives.gov) and date. For each source, note its strengths and its limits for your purpose, and integrate its information selectively: quote only what you analyze, paraphrase the rest, and cite everything. Do not rely on any single source for your argument.
Cohesion (11-12.W.3.A.d). Plan the transitions between your claim, counterclaim and response: The strongest objection… This objection is right that… It fails, however, because…
Reading: Dred Scott: the majority and the dissent, a mentor paragraph, a student model, a revision and the organizer criteria
Dred Scott v. Sandford, 60 U.S. 393 (1857), opinions of Chief Justice Taney and Justice Curtis, in the printed Report of the Decision, Project Gutenberg #31425; retrieved 2026-09-26….. Identifiers: Project Gutenberg 31425 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (opinions of the Supreme Court of the United States, 1857)
Reprinted opinions of the Court are in the public domain; the printed report keeps 1850s spelling and capitalization.
Stage 1 asks you to delineate the majority’s reasoning, build a fair counterclaim and gather sources. Here are the passages the lesson works from, in the printed report, in its spelling and punctuation. Each paragraph in a box is a separate passage, in order; text between passages is left out. After them come a mentor paragraph, an SLS-original student model, a before-and-after revision, the criteria your organizer will be scored against, and a filled-in sample organizer. Everything outside the boxes is SLS original. The passages contain language about Black Americans that was the Court’s own; quote it only when your analysis requires it, and frame it as the Court’s.
Chief Justice Taney, for the majority (Dred Scott v. Sandford, 1857)
It becomes necessary, therefore, to determine who were citizens of the several States when the Constitution was adopted. And in order to do this, we must recur to the Governments and institutions of the thirteen colonies, when they separated from Great Britain and formed new sovereignties, and took their places in the family of independent nations. We must inquire who, at that time, were recognised as the people or citizens of a State, whose rights and liberties had been outraged by the English Government; and who declared their independence, and assumed the powers of Government to defend their rights by force of arms.
In the opinion of the court, the legislation and histories of the times, and the language used in the Declaration of Independence, show, that neither the class of persons who had been imported as slaves, nor their descendants, whether they had become free or not, were then acknowledged as a part of the people, nor intended to be included in the general words used in that memorable instrument.
They had for more than a century before been regarded as beings of an inferior order, and altogether unfit to associate with the white race, either in social or political relations; and so far inferior, that they had no rights which the white man was bound to respect; and that the negro might justly and lawfully be reduced to slavery for his benefit. He was bought and sold, and treated as an ordinary article of merchandise and traffic, whenever a profit could be made by it. This opinion was at that time fixed and universal in the civilized portion of the white race. It was regarded as an axiom in morals as well as in politics, which no one thought of disputing, or supposed to be open to dispute; and men in every grade and position in society daily and habitually acted upon it in their private pursuits, as well as in matters of public concern, without doubting for a moment the correctness of this opinion.
— Roger B. Taney, opinion of the Court, Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), from Report of the Decision of the Supreme Court of the United States, and the Opinions of the Judges Thereof, in the Case of Dred Scott versus John F. A. Sandford, Project Gutenberg #31425, retrieved 2026-09-26
Justice Curtis, dissenting
Citizens of the United States at the time of the adoption of the Constitution can have been no other than citizens of the United States under the Confederation. By the Articles of Confederation, a Government was organized, the style whereof was, “The United States of America.” This Government was in existence when the Constitution was framed and proposed for adoption, and was to be superseded by the new Government of the United States of America, organized under the Constitution.
To determine whether any free persons, descended from Africans held in slavery, were citizens of the United States under the Confederation, and consequently at the time of the adoption of the Constitution of the United States, it is only necessary to know whether any such persons were citizens of either of the States under the Confederation, at the time of the adoption of the Constitution.
Of this there can be no doubt. At the time of the ratification of the Articles of Confederation, all free native-born inhabitants of the States of New Hampshire, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, and North Carolina, though descended from African slaves, were not only citizens of those States, but such of them as had the other necessary qualifications possessed the franchise of electors, on equal terms with other citizens.
— Benjamin R. Curtis, dissenting opinion, Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), same printed report, Project Gutenberg #31425, retrieved 2026-09-26
Mentor paragraph: how the dissent answers a premise (the passages above)
Read Curtis’s three paragraphs as a model of a fair counterargument. He states Taney’s own test (“citizens of the United States at the time of the adoption of the Constitution”), so he is answering the opponent’s question and not a weaker one. He accepts the method and reduces the question to one checkable fact: were any free Black persons citizens of a State when the Articles were ratified? He then answers with named evidence: “New Hampshire, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, and North Carolina,” and the franchise “on equal terms with other citizens.” The phrase Of this there can be no doubt is confident; what makes it fair is that the evidence follows at once.
Delineating Taney’s reasoning, step by step (SLS original)
| Step | What the text says | Type |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | It is necessary “to determine who were citizens of the several States when the Constitution was adopted.” | The question, stated as a test of history. |
| 2 | The answer lies in “the legislation and histories of the times, and the language used in the Declaration of Independence.” | The method: read the founding-era record. |
| 3 | By public opinion then, Black persons “had no rights which the white man was bound to respect.” | The factual premise: what people believed in 1787. This is the step Curtis attacks. |
| 4 | So they were not “acknowledged as a part of the people.” | The conclusion. |
Test step 3 as a reader: Taney says this opinion was “fixed and universal.” Curtis’s evidence is that in five States free Black men were citizens and voters. One documented exception is enough to break a claim of universality.
SLS-original student model: a fair counterclaim paragraph
SLS original model; not a quotation from any student. Claim being argued: Excluded Americans could hold the nation to its promise, because the promise was written in universal words.
The strongest objection comes from the Supreme Court itself. In 1857 Chief Justice Taney held that Black Americans were not among “the people” who made the Constitution, on the ground that in 1787 they were regarded as having “no rights which the white man was bound to respect.” This objection deserves weight: it was the law of the land, and it rests on an argument about history, not merely on prejudice. It is right that the founders’ generation tolerated slavery and wrote it into the Constitution’s bargains. It fails, however, on its key premise. Justice Curtis showed from the laws of five States that free Black men were citizens, and in some of them voters, when the Constitution was adopted, so the founding record is not what Taney says it is. Where the record is contested, the universal words of the Declaration remain available to anyone who chooses to hold the nation to them.
Before and after: revising a weak counterclaim (SLS original)
Before. Some people might disagree because of the Dred Scott case, but they are wrong because slavery was unjust.
What is wrong with it. It names no opponent, gives the opposing view no evidence, and answers with a moral claim the opponent would not dispute. It also never touches the premise the opposing argument depends on.
After. The strongest objection is Chief Justice Taney’s holding that Black Americans were not part of “the people” who framed the Constitution. Taney reasons that in 1787 they were thought to have “no rights which the white man was bound to respect.” The objection is right that the founding generation tolerated slavery. It fails on its premise: Justice Curtis documents free Black citizens and voters in five States when the Articles were ratified.
Criteria your Stage 1 organizer is scored against (SLS original)
- The claim is arguable and names what the essay will prove.
- Each of three reasons is backed by a quotation from a different unit text, with the text named.
- The counterclaim is stated as its best advocate would state it, with that advocate’s own evidence.
- The response identifies the premise the counterclaim depends on and answers that premise.
- Transitions signal claim, counterclaim and response (“The strongest objection… This objection is right that… It fails, however, because…”).
- Three authoritative sources, one beyond the packet, each with a note on strengths and limits.
Sample source notes (SLS original)
| Source | Why authoritative | Strength for my purpose | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States Reports volume 60 (Dred Scott v. Sandford), Library of Congress | The Court’s official reporter. | The exact words of Taney and Curtis. | Says nothing about how the decision was received or overturned. |
| The Constitution as amended (National Archives) | The government’s own publication of the text. | Shows the Fourteenth Amendment’s citizenship sentence, written in response to the decision. | Does not itself say what the framers of the amendment intended. |
| A university-press history of the case (choose one) | Author expertise and editorial review. | Context and later evidence. | Read the author’s own argument critically. |
Search practice: try "Dred Scott" "United States Reports" site:loc.gov to reach the Court’s own text, and add a date range to leave out modern summaries.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which step of Taney’s reasoning did Justice Curtis attack with historical evidence?
The most effective counterclaim paragraph addresses the premise the opposing argument cannot do without.
Which is the most authoritative source for the text of Taney’s opinion?
Submit Stage 1: your claim; three reasons with evidence from at least three unit texts; the strongest counterclaim stated as its best advocate would state it, with evidence; your response; the transitions you will use; and three authoritative sources (one beyond the packet), each with a note on its strengths and limits.
How confident are you that you can delineate legal reasoning and develop a counterclaim fairly with authoritative sources?