
listen to two opposed arguments about Indian removal, evaluate each speaker’s stance, premises, evidence and word choice, and integrate a period map, noting discrepancies among sources.
Instruction
In 1830 Congress passed the Indian Removal Act, and President Andrew Jackson defended it in his annual message that December. That same year the Cherokee Nation sent Congress a memorial — a formal written petition — asking to remain on its land. Both texts were meant to be read aloud and heard: the message was read to Congress, and memorials were read into the record and reprinted in newspapers. In this lab you will listen to both, read aloud from a recording or by a classmate, before you see the text. 11-12.SL.1.B asks you to evaluate a speaker’s point of view, reasoning, and use of evidence and rhetoric: the stance, premises, links among ideas, word choice, points of emphasis and tone.
Jackson’s reasoning, in outline. Removal, he argues, benefits everyone: the United States gains land for settlement; the states are relieved of independent nations within their borders; and the Indians themselves will be protected from destruction by moving west, where they can pursue their own way of life under the government’s care. He asks whether any good man would prefer a country covered with forests and thinly peopled to a republic of cities and farms. His premises include that the nation’s growth is self-evidently good, that Native nations cannot survive near white settlement, and that relocation is voluntary and generous.
The Cherokee reasoning, in outline. The memorial (paraphrased here) argues that the Cherokee hold their land by the most ancient right, occupation from time immemorial; that the United States had guaranteed it by treaties the Cherokee had kept; that the Cherokee had done what the government’s own ‘civilization’ policy asked of them (by 1830 the nation had farms and schools, a written constitution adopted in 1827 and its own newspaper); and that the western lands offered were unknown, already occupied by other peoples, and could not replace a homeland. Its premise is legal and moral: a treaty is a promise, and a nation that breaks its promises dishonours itself.
Evaluating, not choosing sides by instinct. For each speaker, ask: What premises must I accept to accept the conclusion? Which claims are supported by evidence, and which are asserted? Where does word choice do work that evidence should do? Where does the tone change, and why? Jackson’s claim that removal is voluntary, for instance, can be checked against events: the Treaty of New Echota (1835) was signed by a small faction of Cherokee without the nation’s authorized leaders, and most Cherokee protested it; removal was completed by the army in 1838.
Integrating sources in different formats (11-12.SL.1.C). Your teacher will share a period map of Cherokee lands from the Library of Congress’s public map collections. Maps are arguments too: who drew it, for what purpose, and what does it show or leave out? Compare the map with each text’s claims about the land. Where do the sources disagree — about how the land was being used, how many people lived there, or who had title? Note each discrepancy and which source is more credible on that point, and why.
Legal reasoning (11-12.RI.2.D). In 1832 the Supreme Court ruled that Georgia’s laws had no force in Cherokee territory, but the ruling was not enforced. That gap between legal reasoning and power is itself evidence for your verdict.
Your verdict. Record 90 seconds judging whose reasoning is stronger, as reasoning, and whose rhetoric was more effective with its audience. They may not be the same.
Reading: Removal argued: passages from Jackson and the Cherokee memorials, a listening chart, and a worked verdict
Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message (1830), American Presidency Project; Memorial of the Cherokees (December 1829), National Archives, Wikisource transcription; all retrieved 2026-09-26… Identifiers: https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/second-annual-message-3; https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Memorial_of_the_Cherokees · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Jackson, 1830; Cherokee Nation, 1829)
The memorial transcription keeps the manuscript spellings (for example, degredation). The period map is a separate teacher-shared source and is not reproduced here.
This lab asks you to listen to two arguments and evaluate them, so here is what you will hear, in the printed texts, in the spelling and punctuation of the printings. Each paragraph in a box is a separate passage, in order; text between passages is left out. After the texts come a listening chart, a worked evaluation, a protocol, question stems and a model verdict. The period map is a separate source you open yourself from the Library of Congress; because it cannot be printed here, the discrepancy work below also sets the two texts against each other. Everything outside the boxes is SLS original.
Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message to Congress, 6 December 1830
Toward the aborigines of the country no one can indulge a more friendly feeling than myself, or would go further in attempting to reclaim them from their wandering habits and make them a happy, prosperous people. I have endeavored to impress upon them my own solemn convictions of the duties and powers of the General Government in relation to the State authorities. For the justice of the laws passed by the States within the scope of their reserved powers they are not responsible to this Government. As individuals we may entertain and express our opinions of their acts, but as a Government we have as little right to control them as we have to prescribe laws for other nations.
With a full understanding of the subject, the Choctaw and the Chickasaw tribes have with great unanimity determined to avail themselves of the liberal offers presented by the act of Congress, and have agreed to remove beyond the Mississippi River. Treaties have been made with them, which in due season will be submitted for consideration. In negotiating these treaties they were made to understand their true condition, and they have preferred maintaining their independence in the Western forests to submitting to the laws of the States in which they now reside. These treaties, being probably the last which will ever be made with them, are characterized by great liberality on the part of the Government. They give the Indians a liberal sum in consideration of their removal, and comfortable subsistence on their arrival at their new homes. If it be their real interest to maintain a separate existence, they will there be at liberty to do so without the inconveniences and vexations to which they would unavoidably have been subject in Alabama and Mississippi.
Philanthropy could not wish to see this continent restored to the condition in which it was found by our forefathers. What good man would prefer a country covered with forests and ranged by a few thousand savages to our extensive Republic, studded with cities, towns, and prosperous farms, embellished with all the improvements which art can devise or industry execute, occupied by more than 12,000,000 happy people, and filled with all the blessings of liberty, civilization, and religion?
The present policy of the Government is but a continuation of the same progressive change by a milder process. The tribes which occupied the countries now constituting the Eastern States were annihilated or have melted away to make room for the whites. The waves of population and civilization are rolling to the westward, and we now propose to acquire the countries occupied by the red men of the South and West by a fair exchange, and, at the expense of the United States, to send them to a land where their existence may be prolonged and perhaps made perpetual.
Doubtless it will be painful to leave the graves of their fathers; but what do they more than our ancestors did or than our children are now doing? To better their condition in an unknown land our forefathers left all that was dear in earthly objects. Our children by thousands yearly leave the land of their birth to seek new homes in distant regions. Does Humanity weep at these painful separations from every thing, animate and inanimate, with which the young heart has become entwined? Far from it. It is rather a source of joy that our country affords scope where our young population may range unconstrained in body or in mind, developing the power and faculties of man in their highest perfection.
Rightly considered, the policy of the General Government toward the red man is not only liberal, but generous. He is unwilling to submit to the laws of the States and mingle with their population. To save him from this alternative, or perhaps utter annihilation, the General Government kindly offers him a new home, and proposes to pay the whole expense of his removal and settlement.
— Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message (1830), text from the American Presidency Project, retrieved 2026-09-26
Memorial of the Cherokee Nation, December 1829 (printed January 1830)
By the will of our Father in heaven, the Governor of the whole world, the red man of America has become small, and the white man great and renowned. When the ancestors of the people of these United States first came to the shores of America, they found the red man strong—though he was ignorant and savage, yet he received them kindly, and gave them dry land to rest their weary feet. They met in peace, and shook hands in token of friendship. Whatever the white man wanted and asked of the Indian, the latter willingly gave. At the time the Indian was the lord, and the white man the suppliant. But now the scene has changed. The strength of the red man has become weakness. As his neighbors increased in numbers, his power became less and less, and now, of the many powerful tribes who once covered these United States, only a few are to be seen—a few whom a sweeping pestilence has left. The Northern tribes, who were once so numerous and powerful, are now nearly extinct. Thus it has happened to the red man of America. Shall we, who are remnants, share the same fate?
The land on which we stand we have received as an inheritance from our fathers, who possessed it from time immemorial, as a gift from our common father in heaven. We have already said, that when the white man came to the shores of America, our ancestors were found in peaceable possession of this very land. They bequeathed it to us as their children, and we have sacredly kept it as containing the remains of our beloved men. This right of inheritance we have never ceded, nor ever forfeited. Permit us to ask, what better right can a people have to a country, than the right of inheritance and immemorial peaceable possession? We know it is said of late by the State of Georgia, and by the Executive of the United States, that we have forfeited this right—but we think this is said gratuitously.
In addition to that first of all rights, the right of inheritance and peaceable possession, we have the faith and pledge of the United States, repeated over and over again, in treaties made at various times. By these treaties our rights as a separate people are distinctly acknowledged, and guarantees given that they shall be secured and protected. So we have always understood the treaties. The conduct of the Government towards us, from its organization until very lately, the talks given to our beloved men by the Presidents of the United States, and the speeches of the Agents and Commissioners, all concur to show that we are not mistaken in our interpretation.
We cannot consent to abandon it, for another far inferior, and which holds out to us, no inducements.
divest them of their liberty and country, and you sink them in degredation, and put a check, if not a final stop, to their present progress in the arts of civilized life, and in the knowledge of the christian religion. Your memorialists humbly conceive, that such an act would be in the highest degree oppressive.
You represent a virtuous, intelligent and christian nation. To you they willingly submit their cause for your righteous decision.
— Memorial of the Cherokees (December 1829), from the National Archives (Record Group 233, Tabled Petitions and Memorials, ARC 306680), Wikisource transcription, retrieved 2026-09-26
Listening chart (SLS original)
Fill one column per speaker while you listen the first time, then check it against the text.
| Question | Jackson | Cherokee Memorial |
|---|---|---|
| Stance (what the speaker wants done, and how the speaker addresses the audience) | Wants Congress to support removal; presents the policy as friendship: “no one can indulge a more friendly feeling than myself.” | Wants to remain; addresses Congress as “generous and just” (words from the memorial’s opening, which is not printed above; find them in the source). |
| Three premises the listener must grant | 1. The growth of the “extensive Republic” is plainly good. 2. Native nations “melt away” near settlement. 3. Removal is “liberal, but generous.” | 1. Long possession is the strongest title. 2. Treaties are promises binding on the United States. 3. The offered land is not equal to the homeland. |
| Strongest evidence | The Choctaw and Chickasaw treaties: two tribes have agreed. | The treaties themselves, and the intercourse law, which the memorial says forbids encroachment. |
| One loaded word choice | “wandering savage” set against “settled, civilized Christian.” | “gratuitously”: a legal word meaning without cause or proof, applied to the claim that the Cherokee forfeited their land. |
| A point of emphasis | Repetition of liberal, generous, kindly. | Repetition of inheritance and possession; the question “At what time have we made the forfeit?” |
| Where the tone changes | From regret (“melancholy reflections”) to confidence (“What good man would prefer…?”). | From lament (“Shall we, who are remnants, share the same fate?”) to legal argument to a courteous appeal. |
Worked evaluation of one premise (SLS original)
Claim tested: Jackson says the government “kindly offers” a new home, so removal is a choice. Evidence in the text: the same message says the Choctaw and Chickasaw “preferred maintaining their independence in the Western forests to submitting to the laws of the States,” and that the Indian “is unwilling to submit to the laws of the States.” Reasoning: the alternatives Jackson describes are removal, or submission to state law. The Cherokee Memorial says Georgia has set a date, “1st of June, 1830,” after which state law will be extended over them, and that the President “refused us protection.” A choice between leaving and losing your government is not the choice Jackson’s word kindly suggests. Verdict on the premise: that removal is voluntary is asserted, not shown; the memorial supplies a specific date and a specific refusal that Jackson’s message does not mention.
Two discrepancies between the texts (SLS original)
- What the land in the West is. Jackson: “a land where their existence may be prolonged and perhaps made perpetual.” The memorial: “another far inferior, and which holds out to us, no inducements.” Neither text describes the western land in detail. Ask which speaker could know what it was like, and what a period map shows about who already lived there.
- Whether the Cherokee have “civilized” habits. Jackson sets the “wandering savage” against the “settled, civilized Christian.” The memorial says removal would “put a check, if not a final stop, to their present progress in the arts of civilized life.” The two claims cannot both be right about the same people. A period map that shows towns, farms and roads is evidence on this point; say what it would need to show.
Map-reading questions (use with the map you opened from the Library of Congress): Who made it, when and for whom? What does it label, and what does it leave blank? Where do state lines and Cherokee boundaries fall, and who drew them? Which claim in Jackson or the memorial does it support, and which does it not touch?
Seminar protocol and question stems (SLS original)
- First hearing: listen with no text; write only the stance in one line for each speaker.
- Second hearing with the text: fill the chart. Two minutes of silent writing before any talk.
- Round one: each student states one premise from one speaker and says whether the text supports it. No one may reply yet.
- Round two: reply to the speaker before you, beginning with what you agree with.
- Record your 90-second verdict last.
Stems. “The premise this depends on is…” • “The evidence for that is…, but the text only asserts…” • “The word ___ does the work that evidence should do because…” • “I hear the tone change at…” • “The map and the speech disagree about…, and I trust ___ on this point because…” • “I saw it differently: I heard…”
Model 90-second verdict (SLS original)
SLS original model, not a quotation from any student or author.
As reasoning, the Cherokee Memorial is stronger, because its central premise, that a treaty is a promise, is one the United States had itself relied on, and it asks a question the message never answers: “At what time have we made the forfeit?” Jackson’s strongest evidence is that two tribes had agreed to move, but his own sentences show they were choosing between removal and state law. As rhetoric with its audience, though, Jackson may have been more effective: he speaks in the confident language of growth, and he ends with the picture of “cities, towns, and prosperous farms.” The memorial’s courtesy may have made it easy to set aside. I would answer a classmate who disagrees by asking which premise of Jackson’s the classmate accepts.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which premise must a listener accept for Jackson’s argument to succeed?
The Cherokee Memorial rests largely on the premise that treaties are binding promises between nations.
When a period map and a speech disagree about how land was being used, the best first step is to:
Complete the listening chart for both texts: stance, three premises, strongest evidence, one loaded word choice, one point of emphasis, tone shift. Add two discrepancies between the texts and the map. Then record a 90-second verdict on whose reasoning is stronger and whose rhetoric was more effective with its audience, and respond to one classmate who reached a different verdict.
How confident are you that you can evaluate a speaker’s premises, evidence and word choice when listening?