improve our shelter by fixing one weakness or testing a light-colored top, and tell which version works best.
Phase 5: Prove It
Make it even better! Engineers never really stop. Look at your shelter. What would you change?
A dark paper top and a white paper top sit in the sun. Which top will feel warmer to touch?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Shade Engineers, pick your path. Path 1: fix one weakness. Path 2: try a light-colored top.
Our shelter list. We said our shelter blocks sunlight, has a light color on top, is big enough for the spot and stands up. Now we make rules we can test.
Our shelter rules. Here is what our shelter must do. These are our criteria.
A light color on top is a good idea too. Light colors stay cooler.
Here are our limits. These are our constraints.
Path 1: fix a weakness. Did your shelter tip? Did the shade miss part of the play spot? Change one thing. Then test again.
Worked example 1: Hana fixes a weakness. Hana’s shade slid off the toy friend when the sun moved. Hana adds a side wall of cardboard. Now the toy friend stays in the shade longer.
Path 2: try a light top. Make two tops the same shape. One is dark paper. One is white paper. Put both in the sun. Feel the tops. Feel the sand under each.
Worked example 2: Owen tests two tops. Owen feels the tops. The dark top feels warmer. The white top feels cooler. The sand under both feels cooler than sunny sand. Owen says, “Both make shade. The white top stays cooler itself.” (Sample data.)
Choose your path, then check your thinking.
Do your path.
Make your change. Test it in the sun. Mark a thumbs chart for the old version and the new version.
Draw your best version. Tell a grown-up why it is the best, using one thing you saw or felt.
Wow, Shade Engineers! You designed, tested and improved a shade shelter. You are real engineers.
Exit ticket: show me your best version and say one reason it is best.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 3 and set any two-top trays in the sun, read-aloud 6, mini lesson 6, guided 7, revise and test 14, drawing and exit 4.
Use this flex lesson for revision with teams whose 2.24 test missed a rule (path 1), and as an extension for teams that met every rule (path 2).
Misconceptions: “a white top makes no shade” (both colors block light if thick enough; the white top itself warms less); “change everything at once.”
Supports: pre-cut matching dark and white tops. Stretch: test foil as a top and compare all three.
Answer guide: strong reasons use evidence: “the white top felt cooler,” “it did not tip,” “the friend stayed in the shade.”
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands · U.S. government work, public domain
Some builders want buildings to stay cooler in the sun. So they try a cool roof.
The most important thing about a cool roof is this: it bounces sunlight away. Then less sunlight turns into heat on the roof.
How do people make a cool roof? Some use light colors. Some paint on a special coating. Some use roof tiles made of baked clay.
Cool roofs can help a lot. In homes with no air conditioning, a cool roof can help the rooms stay cooler on hot days.
In very cold places, a cool roof can make the house need a bit more heat in winter. So people think about where they live before they choose.
Today you may try a light-colored top on your shelter. Will it stay cooler than a dark top?
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands (epa.gov)