describe the problem our bumper must solve and what the bumper should be like.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Look and listen. Your teacher rolls the ball from our start line. It goes straight. It misses the goal again! Let’s fix this.
Where should our bumper go?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Tell the problem. The ball rolls straight from the start line. It misses the goal. We want it to go in.
What must the bumper do? It must be in the ball’s path. It must push the ball toward the goal. It must stay still when the ball hits it.
What should it be like? It should be strong, so it does not fall over. It should be tall enough that the ball cannot roll over it. It should be turned the right way.
Worked example 1: Sofia’s idea. Sofia said, “Use one paper. It is light.” Ravi tried it. The ball pushed the paper away. A paper bumper is too weak.
Worked example 2: Ben’s idea. Ben said, “Use a heavy block. It stays still.” The ball bumped it. The block did not move. The ball went a new way. A strong bumper works better.
Use what we know. We know a wall’s push changes direction. We know a turned wall sends the ball to the side. We will use that!
Think like an engineer. Point to your answer.
Choose good materials.
Look at the material cards: block, paper, cardboard, tissue, book, cotton ball. Circle the ones that would make a strong bumper. Tell your teacher why.
We know our problem and what our bumper must do. Next time we make our bumper plan card.
Exit ticket: tell me one thing our bumper must do.
Pacing (40 min): demo 5, read-aloud 7, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, material sort 8, exit ticket 2.
Materials: class goal and start line, a sheet of paper and a heavy block for the worked-example demo, material picture cards.
Boundary: today we describe the problem and the bumper’s features only; building and comparing designs comes in part 2.
Misconceptions: “Softer is always better.” A soft bumper may absorb the bump instead of turning the ball. Let children try one cotton-ball wall if time allows.
Supports: real objects for the sort. Stretch: name two jobs the bumper has.
Answer guide: strong choices: block, cardboard, book. Reasons: it stays still, it is tall, the ball cannot push it away.
Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum, Airbags, Lander, Mars Pathfinder · Smithsonian Institution content; used under the Smithsonian Terms of Use for educational, non-commercial use
A big museum keeps a special object. It is a test airbag for the Mars Pathfinder lander. Engineers made it to try out their idea.
The engineers had a problem. The lander had to come down on Mars without breaking. So they made a plan.
First, a parachute slowed the lander. Then small rockets slowed it more. Last, the lander bounced on airbags. The museum calls this an unusual new way to land softly.
The engineers thought hard about what the airbags should be like. They had to be very strong. So the engineers used a super strong fabric. Inside was a layer that held the air in.
Engineers ask: what is the problem? What must our thing do? What should it be made of?
Now it is our turn. Our problem: the ball misses the goal. What must our bumper do? What should it be made of?
Source: Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum, Airbags, Lander, Mars Pathfinder (airandspace.si.edu)