The Ball-Steering Bumper
How can we build a bumper that makes a rolling ball change direction and roll into our class goal?
The mystery: A ball rolls across the floor, bumps into a wall, and rolls back the other way. What made it change direction?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
ask questions about our goal problem, sort them, and tell why we will test pushes and pulls.
Phase 1: Spark
Look and listen. Look at our Wonder Board. Your teacher will read some of our questions. Put your thumb up when you hear your own idea.
Which question can we answer by trying it in our room?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers ask first. Before we build, we ask. What is the problem? Why does it happen? What do we want?
Two kinds of questions. Some questions we can test. We try something and watch. Some questions need a book or a person to ask. We will sort our questions into two piles.
Worked example 1: a try-it question. Zara asked, “Does a big push make the ball go far?” We can try a big push and a little push. Then we watch. It goes in the try-it pile.
Worked example 2: an ask-someone question. Kenji asked, “Who made our goal box?” We cannot test that with a ball. We can ask our teacher. It goes in the ask-someone pile.
Why test pushes and pulls? Our bumper must change how the ball moves. So we need to learn how pushes and pulls change things. That is why we test.
Help sort our Wonder Board. Listen, think, then point.
Sort question cards with your table.
Your teacher gives you picture question cards. Put each card in the try-it basket or the ask-someone basket. Then circle the card you most want to try.
We sorted our questions. We know we will test pushes and pulls. Next time we find out: is it a push or a pull?
Exit ticket: show me with your hands. Is your favorite question a try-it question (hands moving) or an ask-someone question (hands by your mouth)?
Pacing (40 min): Wonder Board review 6, read-aloud 6, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, card sort 8, exit ticket 2.
Materials: Wonder Board, two baskets labeled with a hand icon (try it) and a mouth icon (ask someone), picture question cards made from the Wonder Board.
Misconceptions: children may think every question can be tested. Model one of each kind with a think-aloud.
Supports: pair a confident speaker with a quieter child. Accept pointing and gestures.
Answer guide: try-it questions involve doing something to the ball, wall or goal (push harder, turn the wall). Ask-someone questions are about names, history or opinions.
NASA Next Gen STEM, Engineering Design Process educator notes · NASA content; NASA material is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
What does an engineer look like? NASA says anyone can be an engineer. Engineers can be girls or boys. They can be any age. They can come from any family. That means you can be an engineer, too!
Engineers solve problems. They use science and math. They use tools. They also use good, clever ideas.
NASA tells about the steps engineers use. First they ask. What is the problem? What do people need? Next they imagine ideas. Then they plan, create and test. Last they make it better.
NASA says engineers made lots of things in your classroom. A pencil was engineered. A window shade was engineered. People kept making them better, again and again.
Today we are in the ask step. Our questions are like keys. They help us open up our goal problem.
Source: NASA Next Gen STEM, Engineering Design Process educator notes (nasa.gov)