make a class plan card that tells what our bumper must do and must not do, and how we will test it.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Look and listen. Your teacher shows a plan card with two sides. One side has a green check. One side has a red X. What could go on each side?
Which goes on the green check side?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A plan card. Engineers write down what their design must do. We will make one plan card for our class.
Must do (green check). Turn the ball into the goal. Stay still when the ball bumps it. Be tall enough to bump.
Must not (red X). Must not fall down. Must not have sharp parts. Must not block the start line.
Worked example 1: Nia sorts an idea. Nia said, “It must be made of blocks or cardboard.” The class said that tells what it is like. It goes on the green side.
Worked example 2: Jayden plans the test. Jayden said, “We roll the ball from the start line with the same gentle push. We see if it goes in the goal.” That is a fair test plan.
Ready to create. Next we will draw ideas, build and test bumpers. Our plan card will guide us.
Help fill our plan card. Point to your answer.
Make your own plan picture.
Draw the start line, the goal and your bumper idea. Draw an arrow to show the ball bumping and turning into the goal. Put a green check by one must-do.
Our plan card is ready. Next we will imagine, build and test our Ball-Steering Bumper!
Exit ticket: tell me one must-do and one must-not for our bumper.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 5, read-aloud 6, mini lecture 7, class plan card 6, guided practice 8, plan picture 6, exit ticket 2.
Materials: large two-sided plan card (green check / red X) with picture icons, sticky notes, plan picture paper, the class goal set-up.
Keep: post the plan card by the goal for all of part 2; it is the criteria list for 1.15-1.27.
Misconceptions: children may list wishes (“it must be pink”). Ask, “Does that help the ball go in the goal?”
Supports: picture icons for each criterion. Stretch: add a must-do about materials we have.
Answer guide: must-do: turns the ball into the goal, stays still, is tall enough. Must-not: falls down, sharp parts, blocks the start line. Test: same start line, same gentle push, check if it goes in.
NASA Next Gen STEM, Engineering Design Process educator notes · NASA content; NASA material is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
Let’s look at the NASA engineer steps again. Do you remember them?
Ask. Imagine. Plan. Create. Test. Make it better. Share.
We already did the ask step. We asked about our goal problem. We tested pushes and pulls. We learned what a bumper must do.
NASA tells older students to think about some questions. Why does a thing need to be made? Does it meet a need? Are there many ways to solve the problem? What materials will it need? How can it be tested?
NASA also says engineers make things better again and again. A pencil got better. A window shade got better. The first try is not the last try.
Today we plan. Our plan card tells what our bumper must do. It tells what it must not do. It tells how we will test it. Then we will be ready to create!
Source: NASA Next Gen STEM, Engineering Design Process educator notes (nasa.gov)