change one thing about our better bumper, test it again and tell if it works better now.
Phase 4: Build
Fix the tower. The teacher builds a wobbly block tower. What one thing could we change so it stands still? Show me with your hands.
We change three things at once and it works. Do we know which change helped?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers make things better. Your best bumper did a good job. Can it do a great job?
Find the clue. Look at your misses. Did the ball go too far? Did it come back? Did the bumper wiggle? The miss tells you what to change.
Change one thing. You might change the slant. You might make the bumper longer. You might add more tape. Pick just one.
Worked example 1: Nia’s slant. Nia’s ball hit the slanted bumper and rolled past the goal. Too much turn? Not enough? Nia saw it did not turn enough. She tipped the bumper a bit more. Three new tries: goal, goal, goal! The new slant pointed the ball right at the goal. Sample results.
Worked example 2: Theo’s tape. Theo’s bumper slid when the ball hit it. He added two more strips of tape. Now it stays still. Before: 1 goal. After: 2 goals. Theo says, “When it stays still, it pushes the ball the same way every time.”
| Our bumper | Try 1 | Try 2 | Try 3 | Goals in all |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before the change | ||||
| After the change |
Teams pick one change, then test three times. Check in with these questions.
Before and after pictures.
Draw your bumper before the change and after the change. Circle the part you changed.
Tell your teacher: did the change make our bumper better? How do you know?
You went around the loop like real engineers. Next time we meet grown-up engineers who build bumpers for roads!
Finish out loud: “We changed ___, and the ball ___.”
Pacing: warm-up 4, read-aloud 6, mini lecture 7, change and test 15, drawing 5, closure 3.
Materials: each team’s better bumper from 1.19 (or the photo to rebuild), extra tape, blocks, cardboard, before/after chart.
Likely misconceptions: rebuilding everything from scratch; changing the push instead of the bumper (the push stays gentle by rule).
Supports / stretch: offer three change cards (more slant, longer, more tape). Stretch: predict the result before testing.
Answer guide: children name the changed part and say whether goals went up, stayed the same or went down, pointing to the chart. Any honest result is acceptable; “it did not help” is useful evidence.
NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, Engineering Design Process Flow Chart · NASA/JPL-Caltech; linked and retold in our own words
Here is a secret about NASA engineers. Their first try does not always work. That is okay! It happens to everyone.
The NASA chart of engineering steps has a loop, like a circle. After you test, you ask: did we solve the problem? If yes, you share it. If not yet, you go back.
Going back means you build again. You test again. You look again. You keep going around until it works. Some engineers call this making the design better, one step at a time.
Each trip around the loop teaches you something. A miss is not a mistake. It is a clue! It tells you what to change.
Today we go around the loop. Look at your best bumper. What clue did your chart give you? Change one thing. Test again. Did it get better?
Source: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, Engineering Design Process Flow Chart (jpl.nasa.gov)