use our test chart to compare two bumpers and tell what is good and not so good about each.
Phase 4: Build
Counting game. The teacher shows a chart with apples: 3 red apples and 1 green apple. Hold up fingers: how many red? How many green? Which has more?
Bumper A has 2 goals. Bumper B has 1 goal. Which has more?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Scientists read charts. A chart holds what we saw. Today we count and compare.
Step 1: count. Count the goal marks for Bumper A. Count them for Bumper B. More goals means it did our job more times.
Step 2: look at shape. What shape was each bumper? Flat, slanted or curved? Did it stay still or wiggle?
Step 3: good and not so good. Tell one good thing about each bumper. Tell one thing that was not so good.
Worked example 1: Rosa compares. Rosa’s chart: slanted Bumper A got 3 goals. Curved Bumper B got 1 goal. Rosa says, “The slant pointed the ball right at the goal. The curve sent it too far.” Sample results.
Worked example 2: Ben finds a pattern. Ben looks at every team’s chart on the wall. Most slanted bumpers that were taped down got lots of goals. Bumpers that wiggled got fewer goals. Ben says, “Stuck-down bumpers work better.” That is a pattern: something that happens again and again.
Mid-build check. Look at the class chart. Answer on your own by pointing. Then we talk.
Show what you know.
Circle the bumper on your sheet that worked better. Put a smiley next to its good part.
Tell your teacher why it worked better. Use the word “shape” or “still.”
Now we know which bumper is ahead. Next time we make it even better.
Thumbs up if you can find the better bumper on a chart. Tell a partner how you know.
Pacing: warm-up 4, read-aloud 6, mini lecture 7, check 12, circle-and-tell 8, closure 3.
Checkpoint use: the guided quizzes are a formative check. Note who points correctly to the bumper with more goals and who explains with shape or stillness. Group for 1.21 support.
Likely misconceptions: “Ours is better because we like it.” Redirect to the marks. Some children count X marks as goals.
Supports: use cubes stacked by bumper to make counts visible.
Answer guide: good part examples: “the slant pointed at the goal,” “it stayed still.” Not-so-good: “it wiggled,” “the ball went too far,” “it sent the ball back.”
NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, NGSS Engineering: Grades K-2 · NASA/JPL-Caltech; linked and retold in our own words
Let’s visit that NASA page for teachers again. It tells what young engineers can do. You can do these things!
Young engineers build two things for the same problem. Then they test both. They write down what happened. They might use marks on a chart.
Next, they look closely at the chart. They ask: Which one did the job more times? What was different about the two? Was one taller? Was one curved? Was one stuck down better?
The page says engineers compare how well each one works. Comparing means looking at two things side by side to see how they are the same and how they are different.
Sometimes one design is best. Sometimes each one has a good part. Engineers tell the good parts and the not-so-good parts of each.
Today we read our bumper chart. We count goals. We look at shapes. Then we say which bumper worked better, and why.
Source: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Education, NGSS Engineering: Grades K-2 (jpl.nasa.gov)