compare test results for two shelters on a chart and tell what is good and not so good about each one.
Phase 4: Build
Look and compare! Here are two shelters: a tent shelter and an umbrella shelter. How are they the same? How are they different?
What is the same about both shelters?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Shade Engineers, let’s compare! Two teams tested two different shelters. We put both results on one chart. Then we look for what is the same and what is different.
| Our shelter rule | Shelter A | Shelter B |
|---|---|---|
| Makes shade over the play spot? ☀️ | 👍 or 👎 | 👍 or 👎 |
| Sand feels cooler under it? ✋ | 👍 or 👎 | 👍 or 👎 |
| Stands up by itself? 🏗️ | 👍 or 👎 | 👍 or 👎 |
Worked example 1: the tent shelter. Jada’s tent shelter made shade. The sand under it felt cooler. It stood up. Three thumbs up! But it covered only a small spot. Only one toy friend fit. (Sample data.)
Worked example 2: the umbrella shelter. Eli’s umbrella shelter had a big round top. It made a big shade. The sand felt cooler. But it fell over once in a breeze. Two thumbs up, one thumbs down. (Sample data.)
What do we see? The wide top made the biggest shade. The tent shape stood up best. Each one has a good part and a not-so-good part.
Which is best? Both made the sand cooler. The tent followed every rule, so it is best for our rules today. The umbrella could be even better with stronger legs.
Read the chart with me. Point to the thumbs.
Compare your team’s shelter with a partner team’s shelter.
Fill in a thumbs chart for the two shelters with your partner team. Use thumbs up and thumbs down stickers.
Draw a star on the part of your shelter that works best. Draw a circle on the part to fix. Tell a grown-up about them.
Great comparing, Shade Engineers! Next time we meet people whose job is making shade.
Exit ticket: tell one strength and one weakness of your shelter.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 4, read-aloud 6, mini lesson 8, guided 9, pair-team charts 10, exit 3.
Setup: enlarge the thumbs chart; use the sample tent and umbrella models from 2.19 or two real team models with their 2.20 results. Pair teams with different shelter shapes.
Misconceptions: “the biggest one is always best”; “one thumbs down means it is bad.” Stress that both worked and each can improve.
Supports: limit the chart to two rows for some children. Stretch: count the thumbs up for each shelter.
Answer guide: strong comparisons name a feature and its result, such as “the big top made big shade but it tipped.” The tent met all three rules in the sample.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands · U.S. government work, public domain
A roof is like a hat for a building. It sits on top in the sun all day long.
Scientists at the EPA study roofs. They compare different kinds. Some roofs are dark. Some roofs are light-colored. Light roofs bounce more sunlight away. People call them cool roofs.
A cool roof stays cooler in the sun. The rooms under it can stay cooler too. Even the air around the building can be cooler.
But cool roofs are not perfect. Some cost more money. Some need to be cleaned so they keep bouncing sunlight away.
So every roof has good things and not-so-good things. People compare them. Then they choose the best roof for the job.
Today we compare two shelters, just like that.
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands (epa.gov)