revise our bumper to meet the criteria, or design a bumper for a goal in a new spot, and compare the results.
Phase 5: Prove It
Uh-oh, the goal moved! The teacher slides the goal to the other side of the lane. Will our old bumper still work? Show thumbs up or down.
The goal moved to the other side. What must change?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Challenge day, engineers! You pick one of two jobs.
Job 1: Fix it. If your bumper did not meet both criteria on Goal Day, make it better. Find the clue in your misses. Change one thing. Test three times.
Job 2: Move the goal. If your bumper met both criteria, the goal moves to the other side. Draw a new plan. Build it. Test three times. Same rules: blocks, cardboard and tape; one gentle push; no hands; bumper stays still.
Worked example 1: Mia fixes it. Mia’s ball kept bumping her bumper’s corner and going the wrong way. She made the bumper longer, so the ball always hits the slanted face. Before: 1 goal. After: 3 goals. Sample results.
Worked example 2: Eli moves the goal. The goal moved to the left. Eli turned his slant around so it points left. He drew it first, with an arrow to the new goal. First try: in! Eli says, “The shape is the same. Only the way it points changed.”
| Our challenge | Try 1 | Try 2 | Try 3 | Goals in all |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Old bumper | ||||
| New bumper |
Fix-it teams and move-the-goal teams work side by side. Check in with these questions.
Show your challenge.
Draw your old bumper and your new bumper side by side. Circle the one that worked better.
Tell one good thing and one not-so-good thing about each bumper.
Unit 1 is done, engineers! You know that pushes change how things move, and you built bumpers that prove it. Next unit, we find out about sunlight and warmth.
Show with your hands how a bumper turns a ball. Tell a partner your favorite part of the unit.
Pacing: warm-up 3, read-aloud 6, mini lecture 6, challenge build and test 17, drawing 5, closure 3.
Grouping: teams that met both criteria on Goal Day take Job 2; others take Job 1. Any team can switch after success.
Materials: each team’s bumper, blocks, cardboard, tape, a second goal position marked with tape on the other side of the lane.
Likely misconceptions: pushing harder instead of fixing the bumper; building a wall that blocks the goal. Remind: same gentle push, bumper in the ball’s path.
Answer guide: drawings show both bumpers with paths; the circled one has more goals on the chart. Good/not-so-good examples: “points at the goal” / “wiggles,” “longer face catches the ball” / “takes more blocks.”
Federal Highway Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation, Guardrail 101 · U.S. government work, public domain
Let’s learn more about guardrails, the big bumpers on roads.
A guardrail is not just one metal rail. It has many parts that work together. There are posts. There is the dirt the posts stand in. There is the part that joins the rail to the posts. All the parts help the rail do its job.
Every part matters. So the rail must be held tight and strong.
The road page also says size and speed matter. How big a car is, and how fast it goes, can change how well a rail works. Engineers plan for that.
Engineers also choose where each guardrail goes. They put rails where they are needed most.
We can think like road engineers today. Is every part of our bumper held tight? Is our push gentle? If the goal moves, where should our bumper go now?
Source: Federal Highway Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation, Guardrail 101 (fhwa.dot.gov)