
explain the main ways games make money, calculate the expected cost of a randomized purchase, and argue a position on loot boxes that fairly represents the other side.
Instruction
Games cost money to make, and designers are increasingly responsible not only for fun but for how a game earns its keep. Some business models respect players; some exploit them. Knowing the difference, and the arguments on each side, is part of professional ethics.
Business models. Premium: pay once, own the game. Downloadable content (DLC) and expansions: pay for more content later. Subscription: pay monthly for access to one game or a library. Free-to-play with in-game purchases: the game is free; revenue comes from optional purchases such as cosmetic items, time-savers or seasonal battle passes. Advertising: common in mobile games. Each shapes design: a premium game wants to be satisfying to finish; a free-to-play game wants players to return daily.
Loot boxes are purchases with random contents: you pay, then learn what you got. Some contain only cosmetic items; some contain items that affect play.
Do the math. Suppose a box costs $2 and has a 1% chance of the item a player wants. On average it takes 1 ÷ 0.01 = 100 boxes, or $200, to get it. But the average hides the spread. The chance of getting it at least once in 100 boxes is 1 − 0.99100 ≈ 0.634, so about 37% of players who spend $200 still do not have it. To reach even a 50% chance takes 69 boxes ($138); a 95% chance takes 299 boxes ($598). Virtual currencies, which players buy in bundles and spend in the game, make these costs harder to see.
The case for. Defenders argue that loot boxes are optional, especially when cosmetic; that they fund games given away free to millions of players; that many players enjoy the surprise, as with trading cards or capsule toys; and that disclosure of odds lets players choose knowingly.
The case against. Critics argue that paying real money for a random reward resembles gambling; that variable rewards are especially compelling and can drive some players to spend far more than they intended; that children are exposed to them; and that game designs sometimes use pressure tactics (limited-time offers, confusing currencies) to push purchases.
What regulators and industry have done. Responses vary by country. In 2018 Belgium’s gaming regulator concluded that some paid loot boxes violated its gambling law. In 2020 the ESRB, which rates games in North America, added the notice “In-Game Purchases (Includes Random Items)”. Apple’s App Store rules require apps that sell randomized items to disclose the odds before purchase. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission in 2022 reached settlements with Epic Games, maker of Fortnite, totaling $520 million: a $275 million penalty for violating the children’s privacy law (COPPA) and $245 million in refunds to consumers over what the FTC called “dark patterns” that led players into unwanted purchases. Rules continue to change; check the current position before you rely on it or design around it.
Games, behavior and the economy. Monetization is one part of a wider debate about games’ effects. Researchers disagree about how much games affect behavior: studies have linked some kinds of play to measurable changes in attention, spatial skill and mood, while the effects of violent games on real-world aggression remain contested, with serious researchers on both sides. When you read claims, look at who did the study, what was measured and whether it has been replicated. Games are also a large industry that employs artists, programmers and many others, and it supports related businesses from hardware to streaming.
Fair design principles many designers adopt: show real prices and odds, never target children with random purchases, keep paid items from deciding competitive outcomes, and never punish players who do not pay.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A $3 box has a 2% chance of a rare skin. On average it takes boxes, costing $, to get it.
What does the ESRB notice “In-Game Purchases (Includes Random Items)” tell a parent?
The FTC’s 2022 settlements with Epic Games included refunds to consumers over purchase designs the FTC described as dark patterns.
Structured academic controversy, on your own: write the strongest case for loot boxes, then the strongest case against, each time in terms the other side would accept (optionally, read both aloud to a family member and ask which sounded stronger). Then drop the roles and write a 300-word position on whether your own game should sell randomized items, with at least one calculation and one regulator or rating-board action as evidence, answering the strongest opposing point.
How confident are you that you can calculate the expected cost of a randomized purchase and argue a fair position on loot boxes?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Name the business model: (a) pay once, own the game; (b) pay monthly for a library; (c) the game is free and sells cosmetic items and a battle pass; (d) pay later for an expansion; (e) a mobile game shows ads between levels.
Check your answer
Answer: (a) premium; (b) subscription; (c) free-to-play with in-game purchases; (d) DLC / expansion; (e) advertising.Each shapes design: a premium game wants to be satisfying to finish; a free-to-play game wants players to return daily. - Define loot box and dark pattern.
Check your answer
Answer: Loot box: a purchasable item with random contents revealed after payment. Dark pattern: a design that tricks or pressures users into choices they did not intend, such as unwanted purchases.Virtual currencies bought in bundles make loot-box costs harder to see. - Match each action to its year: Belgium’s regulator finds some paid loot boxes violate gambling law; the ESRB adds “In-Game Purchases (Includes Random Items)”; the FTC’s settlements with Epic Games.
Check your answer
Answer: Belgium 2018; ESRB 2020; FTC and Epic 2022.Rules continue to change; check the current position before relying on it.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A box costs $1.50 and has a 4% chance of the item a player wants. Find the expected number of boxes and expected cost. Then find the chance of having the item after buying 25 boxes (use a calculator).
Check your answer
Answer: 25 boxes, $37.50 on average. Chance after 25 boxes ≈ 64%, so about 36% of players spending $37.50 still do not have it.1 ÷ 0.04 = 25; 25 × $1.50 = $37.50. 1 − 0.9625 ≈ 1 − 0.360 = 0.640. - Using the lesson’s example (a $2 box with a 1% chance), how much more does a 95% chance cost than a 50% chance?
Check your answer
Answer: $460 more ($598 − $138).50% takes 69 boxes = $138; 95% takes 299 boxes = $598. 598 − 138 = 460. - The FTC’s 2022 settlements with Epic Games totaled $520 million. Give the two parts, what each was for, and check they add up.
Check your answer
Answer: $275 million penalty for violating the children’s privacy law (COPPA) and $245 million in consumer refunds over what the FTC called dark patterns. 275 + 245 = 520.The two parts address different problems: children’s privacy and unwanted purchases. - Write the strongest one-sentence case for loot boxes and the strongest one-sentence case against, each in terms the other side would accept.
Check your answer
Answer: For: when optional and cosmetic, with odds disclosed, they let players who enjoy surprise pay to fund games given away free to millions. Against: paying real money for a random reward resembles gambling, and variable rewards can drive some players, including children, to spend far more than they intended.A fair case uses the other side’s best argument, not a weak version of it. - A headline says “Study proves games change behavior.” Name three questions the lesson says to ask before believing it.
Check your answer
Answer: Who did the study? What was measured? Has it been replicated?Researchers disagree; the effects of violent games on real-world aggression remain contested.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 3.2): a pity rule caps unlucky streaks for free drops. Would adding a pity rule make a paid loot box fair? Use one fair design principle in your answer.
Check your answer
Answer: Not by itself: it limits the worst case, but fair design also requires showing real prices and odds, never targeting children with random purchases and keeping paid items from deciding competitive outcomes.Strong answers name at least one principle beyond capping streaks.
Loot-Box Math, Primary Statements from the FTC and Ratings Boards, and Evidence Cards
SLS original math; FTC press release 2022-12-19 and FTC staff perspective paper 2020-08; ESRB and PEGI pages paraphrased, all retrieved 2026-09-26 · SLS original, with public-domain U.S. FTC material
Why this reading. The lab asks you to calculate loot-box costs, cite at least one regulator or rating-board action, and argue both sides. This reading supplies the calculation table, the primary statements you may cite (the FTC’s own words, the ratings boards’ own categories) and evidence cards for each side, so the debate rests on printed evidence. Tables are SLS original; the FTC items are public domain (U.S. federal work); rating descriptions are paraphrased.
What a random purchase really costs (computed)
Average boxes = 1 / chance. Boxes for a given probability n = ln(1 minus probability) / ln(1 minus chance), rounded up. Check: 1% chance, 100 boxes give 1 minus 0.99 to the power 100 = 0.634, so 36.6% of buyers (about 37%) still lack the item.
| Chance per box | Price | Average boxes | Average cost | Still without it after the average | Boxes for 50% ($) | Boxes for 95% ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1% | $2 | 100 | $200 | 37% | 69 ($138) | 299 ($598) |
| 2% | $3 | 50 | $150 | 36% | 35 ($105) | 149 ($447) |
| 5% | $2 | 20 | $40 | 36% | 14 ($28) | 59 ($118) |
The lesson’s $3 box at 2% averages 50 boxes = $150.
Primary statements you can cite
- FTC press release, December 19, 2022: Epic Games will pay a $275 million penalty for violating the COPPA Rule and $245 million to refund consumers over what the FTC calls dark patterns and billing practices. Total $520 million (275 + 245).
- FTC staff perspective paper, August 2020, on the August 2019 loot box workshop: participants raised concerns that loot box marketing may encourage overspending or hide real costs, and about children; the paper notes that Apple and Google require odds disclosure for apps with loot boxes.
- ESRB (current ratings page, retrieved 2026-09-26): the interactive element In-Game Purchases (Includes Random Items) tells parents that digital items are bought with real money without knowing which items will be received.
- PEGI (retrieved 2026-09-26): its Paid Random Items descriptor marks loot boxes or card packs and is tied to PEGI 16 in its current descriptor guide.
Evidence cards
| For loot boxes | Against loot boxes |
|---|---|
| A cosmetic-only box does not change who wins | 36.6% of buyers spend the average cost and still lack a 1% item |
| Revenue can fund a game that is free to millions of players | The FTC recorded concerns about overspending and about children |
| Odds disclosure is now required by major app stores (FTC paper) | Confusing currencies hide real cost; the FTC’s 2022 case involved dark patterns |
Model position paragraph (SLS original, about 110 words)
My game will not sell random items. At a 2% chance and $3 a box, the average player pays $150 for one skin, and after 50 boxes 36% still have nothing. The strongest opposing point is that cosmetic boxes fund free play. I accept that, so I will sell each skin directly at a fixed price of $4, which funds the game without hiding the cost. Even honest odds do not answer the FTC’s concern about overspending, and a fixed price does.