
summarize and compare four nineteenth-century arguments about the purpose of education, and integrate them with current federal education data presented in tables and charts.
Instruction
A researched argument joins a conversation that began before you arrived. This unit gives you the opening of one: four nineteenth-century thinkers who disagreed about what education is for. You will not simply choose one. You will use them to sharpen a question of your own, and then bring in the evidence the present can supply.
Newman: knowledge as its own end. John Henry Newman gave a series of discourses in Dublin in 1852 as he helped found a new Catholic university. He argued that a university’s purpose is not to train for a profession but to form a mind: to teach a person to see things in relation to one another, to judge, to reason. Such an education, he claimed, is useful after all, because it raises the intellectual tone of a whole society. Newman’s school is a university of the liberal arts.
Huxley: education in the laws of nature. Thomas Henry Huxley, a biologist and a leading defender of Darwin, spoke to a college for working men in South London in 1868. He compared life to a game of chess against a hidden opponent: the board is the world, the pieces are the phenomena of nature, and the rules are the laws of nature. A liberal education, for Huxley, is learning those rules — science above all — and it belongs to working people as much as to gentlemen. Huxley’s school teaches science to everyone.
Cooper: who is education for? Anna Julia Cooper was born into slavery in North Carolina, earned degrees at Oberlin College in the 1880s, and became a teacher and principal in Washington. In “The Higher Education of Women”, from her book A Voice from the South (1892), she argues that women, and Black women in particular, must have the full college education that had been reserved for men, and that society is incomplete without the contribution of educated women. She challenges the fear that learning would unfit women for home life, and she presses her readers to support girls’ education in practice. (This is a summary; read the essay complete.) Cooper’s question is not what education is, but who is allowed it. She later earned a doctorate from the Sorbonne in 1925, in her sixties.
Dewey: education as life. John Dewey’s My Pedagogic Creed (1897) is a list of beliefs, each beginning “I believe”. He argues that school should be a form of community life, that learning should grow from the child’s own activity and interests, and that education is “the fundamental method of social progress and reform.” Dewey’s school is a working community, not a lecture hall.
Integrating data (11-12.RI.3.A / 11-12.RI.1.C). These authors argue from principle. Your essay must also argue from evidence. The National Center for Education Statistics publishes The Condition of Education and the Digest of Education Statistics, which report enrollment, completion, cost and outcomes; the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports earnings and unemployment by education level. These are public domain. Reading a table well means reading its title, units, source and date, and noticing what it does not measure. A chart of median earnings by degree cannot tell you whether the degree caused the earnings.
Central ideas that interact (11-12.RI.1.D). Build a synthesis grid: for each author, the purpose of education, who it is for, what it teaches, and how you would test the claim today.
Foundational documents (11-12.RI.3.B / 11-12.RI.3.C). Cooper and Dewey are American voices at the moment American public schooling was being defined. Ask what each assumes about democracy.
Reading: Four answers to one question: complete passages, a worked grid row and a practice table
John Henry Newman, The Idea of a University Defined and Illustrated (discourses delivered in Dublin, 1852; text of the later collected edition), Project Gutenberg eBook 24526; Thomas Henry Huxley, “A Liberal Education; and Where to Find It” (address at the South London Working Men’s College, 1868), in Lay Sermons, Addresses, and Reviews (London: Macmillan, 1870), Project Gutenberg eBook 16729; Anna Julia Cooper, “The Higher Education of Women” in A Voice from the South (Xenia, Ohio: Aldine Printing House, 1892), Project Gutenberg eBook 61741; John Dewey, “My Pedagogic Creed” (1897), Wikisource transcription, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/My_Pedagogic_Creed; retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original grid row, practice table and worked observations (the table’s numbers are invented and labeled as such); quoted passages are public domain (Newman, 1852; Huxley, 1868; Cooper, 1892; Dewey, 1897)
Read each passage for its purpose and its audience. Then complete the grid, using the worked Huxley row as your model.
Four writers, four answers to one question: what is education for? Each passage below is printed complete at its point. The spelling and punctuation are the authors’ own. Below the passages is a worked row of the synthesis grid and a practice data table, so that you can do every task in this lesson from this page.
Newman: knowledge as its own end
Newman was helping to found a Catholic university in Dublin. In Discourse V he argues that a mind is worth forming for its own sake. In Discourse VII, at the end of his argument about professional skill, he says what such training is for.
Knowledge is capable of being its own end. Such is the constitution of the human mind, that any kind of knowledge, if it be really such, is its own reward. And if this is true of all knowledge, it is true also of that special Philosophy, which I have made to consist in a comprehensive view of truth in all its branches, of the relations of science to science, of their mutual bearings, and their respective values. What the worth of such an acquirement is, compared with other objects which we seek,—wealth or power or honour or the conveniences and comforts of life, I do not profess here to discuss; but I would maintain, and mean to show, that it is an object, in its own nature so really and undeniably good, as to be the compensation of a great deal of thought in the compassing, and a great deal of trouble in the attaining. Now, when I say that Knowledge is, not merely a means to something beyond it, or the preliminary of certain arts into which it naturally resolves, but an end sufficient to rest in and to pursue for its own sake, surely I am uttering no paradox, for I am stating what is both intelligible in itself, and has ever been the common judgment of philosophers and the ordinary feeling of mankind.
— Newman, Discourse V (1852)
But a University training is the great ordinary means to a great but ordinary end; it aims at raising the intellectual tone of society, at cultivating the public mind, at purifying the national taste, at supplying true principles to popular enthusiasm and fixed aims to popular aspiration, at giving enlargement and sobriety to the ideas of the age, at facilitating the exercise of political power, and refining the intercourse of private life. It is the education which gives a man a clear conscious view of his own opinions and judgments, a truth in developing them, an eloquence in expressing them, and a force in urging them. It teaches him to see things as they are, to go right to the point, to disentangle a skein of thought, to detect what is sophistical, and to discard what is irrelevant. It prepares him to fill any post with credit, and to master any subject with facility. It shows him how to accommodate himself to others, how to throw himself into their state of mind, how to bring before them his own, how to influence them, how to come to an understanding with them, how to bear with them. He is at home in any society, he has common ground with every class; he knows when to speak and when to be silent; he is able to converse, he is able to listen; he can ask a question pertinently, and gain a lesson seasonably, when he has nothing to impart himself; he is ever ready, yet never in the way; he is a pleasant companion, and a comrade you can depend upon; he knows when to be serious and when to trifle, and he has a sure tact which enables him to trifle with gracefulness and to be serious with effect. He has the repose of a mind which lives in itself, while it lives in the world, and which has resources for its happiness at home when it cannot go abroad. He has a gift which serves him in public, and supports him in retirement, without which good fortune is but vulgar, and with which failure and disappointment have a charm. The art which tends to make a man all this, is in the object which it pursues as useful as the art of wealth or the art of health, though it is less susceptible of method, and less tangible, less certain, less complete in its result.
— Newman, Discourse VII, closing paragraph (1852)
Huxley: learning the rules of the game
Huxley, a biologist, spoke to working men in 1868. He defines education by a metaphor and then states the definition plainly.
Suppose it were perfectly certain that the life and fortune of every one of us would, one day or other, depend upon his winning or losing a game at chess. Don’t you think that we should all consider it to be a primary duty to learn at least the names and the moves of the pieces; to have a notion of a gambit, and a keen eye for all the means of giving and getting out of check? Do you not think that we should look with a disapprobation amounting to scorn, upon the father who allowed his son, or the state which allowed its members, to grow up without knowing a pawn from a knight? Yet it is a very plain and elementary truth, that the life, the fortune, and the happiness of every one of us, and, more or less, of those who are connected with us, do depend upon our knowing something of the rules of a game infinitely more difficult and complicated than chess. It is a game which has been played for untold ages, every man and woman of us being one of the two players in a game of his or her own. The chess-board is the world, the pieces are the phenomena of the universe, the rules of the game are what we call the laws of Nature. The player on the other side is hidden from us. We know that his play is always fair, just, and patient. But also we know, to our cost, that he never overlooks a mistake, or makes the smallest allowance for ignorance. To the man who plays well, the highest stakes are paid, with that sort of overflowing generosity with which the strong shows delight in strength. And one who plays ill is checkmated–without haste, but without remorse. My metaphor will remind some of you of the famous picture in which Retzsch has depicted Satan playing at chess with man for his soul. Substitute for the mocking fiend in that picture, a calm, strong angel who is playing for love, as we say, and would rather lose than win–and I should accept it as an image of human life. Well, what I mean by Education is learning the rules of this mighty game. In other words, education is the instruction of the intellect in the laws of Nature, under which name I include not merely things and their forces, but men and their ways; and the fashioning of the affections and of the will into an earnest and loving desire to move in harmony with those laws. For me, education means neither more nor less than this.
— Huxley, “A Liberal Education; and Where to Find It” (1868)
That man, I think, has had a liberal education, who has been so trained in youth that his body is the ready servant of his will, and does with ease and pleasure all the work that, as a mechanism, it is capable of; whose intellect is a clear, cold, logic engine, with all its parts of equal strength, and in smooth working order; ready, like a steam engine, to be turned to any kind of work, and spin the gossamers as well as forge the anchors of the mind; whose mind is stored with a knowledge of the great and fundamental truths of Nature and of the laws of her operations; one who, no stunted ascetic, is full of life and fire, but whose passions are trained to come to heel by a vigorous will, the servant of a tender conscience; who has learned to love all beauty, whether of Nature or of art, to hate all vileness, and to respect others as himself. Such an one and no other, I conceive, has had a liberal education; for he is, as completely as a man can be, in harmony with Nature. He will make the best of her, and she of him. They will get on together rarely; she as his ever beneficent mother; he as her mouth-piece, her conscious self, her minister and interpreter.
— Huxley (1868)
Cooper: who is education for?
Cooper was a Black woman born into slavery; she wrote these pages while a teacher in Washington. She argues from history, from a claim about what women add, and from figures she gathered herself.
In the very first year of our century, the year 1801, there appeared in Paris a book by Silvain Marechal, entitled “Shall Woman Learn the Alphabet.” The book proposes a law prohibiting the alphabet to women, and quotes authorities weighty and various, to prove that the woman who knows the alphabet has already lost part of her womanliness. The author declares that woman can use the alphabet only as Moliere predicted they would, in spelling out the verb amo; that they have no occasion to peruse Ovid’s Ars Amoris, since that is already the ground and limit of their intuitive furnishing; that Madame Guion would have been far more adorable had she remained a beautiful ignoramus as nature made her; that Ruth, Naomi, the Spartan woman, the Amazons, Penelope, Andromache, Lucretia, Joan of Arc, Petrarch’s Laura, the daughters of Charlemagne, could not spell their names; while Sappho, Aspasia, Madame de Maintenon, and Madame de Stael could read altogether too well for their good; finally, that if women were once permitted to read Sophocles and work with logarithms, or to nibble at any side of the apple of knowledge, there would be an end forever to their sewing on buttons and embroidering slippers. Please remember this book was published at the beginning of the Nineteenth Century. At the end of its first third, (in the year 1833) one solitary college in America decided to admit women within its sacred precincts, and organized what was called a “Ladies’ Course” as well as the regular B. A. or Gentlemen’s course.
— Cooper, “The Higher Education of Women” (1892)
All I claim is that there is a feminine as well as a masculine side to truth; that these are related not as inferior and superior, not as better and worse, not as weaker and stronger, but as complements—complements in one necessary and symmetric whole. That as the man is more noble in reason, so the woman is more quick in sympathy. That as he is indefatigable in pursuit of abstract truth, so is she in caring for the interests by the way—striving tenderly and lovingly that not one of the least of these ‘little ones’ should perish. That while we not unfrequently see women who reason, we say, with the coolness and precision of a man, and men as considerate of helplessness as a woman, still there is a general consensus of mankind that the one trait is essentially masculine and the other as peculiarly feminine. That both are needed to be worked into the training of children, in order that our boys may supplement their virility by tenderness and sensibility, and our girls may round out their gentleness by strength and self-reliance. That, as both are alike necessary in giving symmetry to the individual, so a nation or a race will degenerate into mere emotionalism on the one hand, or bullyism on the other, if dominated by either exclusively; lastly, and most emphatically, that the feminine factor can have its proper effect only through woman’s development and education so that she may fitly and intelligently stamp her force on the forces of her day, and add her modicum to the riches of the world’s thought.
— Cooper (1892)
I wrote a few days ago to the colleges which admit women and asked how many colored women had completed the B. A. course in each during its entire history. These are the figures returned: Fisk leads the way with twelve; Oberlin next with five; Wilberforce, four; Ann Arbor and Wellesley three each, Livingstone two, Atlanta one, Howard, as yet, none. I then asked the principal of the Washington High School how many out of a large number of female graduates from his school had chosen to go forward and take a collegiate course. He replied that but one had ever done so, and she was then in Cornell.
— Cooper (1892)
When a child I was put into a school near home that professed to be normal and collegiate, i. e. to prepare teachers for colored youth, furnish candidates for the ministry, and offer collegiate training for those who should be ready for it. Well, I found after a while that I had a good deal of time on my hands. I had devoured what was put before me, and, like Oliver Twist, was looking around to ask for more. I constantly felt (as I suppose many an ambitious girl has felt) a thumping from within unanswered by any beckoning from without. Class after class was organized for these ministerial candidates (many of them men who had been preaching before I was born). Into every one of these classes I was expected to go, with the sole intent, I thought at the time, of enabling the dear old principal, as he looked from the vacant countenances of his sleepy old class over to where I sat, to get off his solitary pun—his never-failing pleasantry, especially in hot weather—which was, as he called out “Any one!” to the effect that “any one” then meant “Annie one.” Finally a Greek class was to be formed. My inspiring preceptor informed me that Greek had never been taught in the school, but that he was going to form a class for the candidates for the ministry, and if I liked I might join it. I replied—humbly I hope, as became a female of the human species—that I would like very much to study Greek, and that I was thankful for the opportunity, and so it went on. A boy, however meager his equipment and shallow his pretentions, had only to declare a floating intention to study theology and he could get all the support, encouragement and stimulus he needed, be absolved from work and invested beforehand with all the dignity of his far away office. While a self-supporting girl had to struggle on by teaching in the summer and working after school hours to keep up with her board bills, and actually to fight her way against positive discouragements to the higher education; till one such girl one day flared out and told the principal “the only mission opening before a girl in his school was to marry one of those candidates.” He said he didn’t know but it was. And when at last that same girl announced her desire and intention to go to college it was received with about the same incredulity and dismay as if a brass button on one of those candidate’s coats had propounded a new method for squaring the circle or trisecting the arc. Now this is not fancy. It is a simple unvarnished photograph, and what I believe was not in those days exceptional in colored schools, and I ask the men and women who are teachers and co-workers for the highest interests of the race, that they give the girls a chance!
— Cooper (1892)
Dewey: education as life
Dewey wrote his creed as a list of beliefs, in five articles. These come from Article II (“What the School Is”) and Article V (“The School and Social Progress”).
I believe that the school is primarily a social institution. Education being a social process, the school is simply that form of community life in which all those agencies are concentrated that will be most effective in bringing the child to share in the inherited resources of the race, and to use his own powers for social ends. I believe that education, therefore, is a process of living and not a preparation for future living. I believe that the school must represent present life—life as real and vital to the child as that which he carries on in the home, in the neighborhood, or on the playground.
— Dewey, “My Pedagogic Creed,” Article II (1897)
I believe that education is the fundamental method of social progress and reform. I believe that all reforms which rest simply upon the enactment of law, or the threatening of certain penalties, or upon changes in mechanical or outward arrangements, are transitory and futile.
— Dewey, Article V (1897)
Worked row of the synthesis grid (SLS original)
For each author, fill four cells: purpose, who it is for, what it teaches, and how you would test the claim today. Here is Huxley done for you; the reasoning is in the last column.
| Author | Purpose | Who it is for | What it teaches | How to test it today | Reasoning note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Huxley | To learn the rules of the game of life, “the laws of Nature”, and to shape the will to live in harmony with them | Everyone. He addresses working men and warns against education that turns out “human tools” | The intellect in the laws of Nature (including “men and their ways”) and the training of will and affection | Compare how much school time goes to science with what students can do afterward; a claim about outcomes needs a measure, such as completion of laboratory science courses | His “laws of Nature” include the study of people, so science alone is not his whole answer. |
Your task is to complete the other three rows the same way. Cooper’s row shows that the question “who is it for?” can change the whole argument: her counts of Black women graduates are evidence, and her account of the school near her home is testimony.
Reading a table: a practice table (SLS original, invented numbers)
This table is made up for practice. It is not real data and must never be cited. It is shaped like the tables in the National Center for Education Statistics’ Digest of Education Statistics, which is where you will find real ones.
| Highest level completed (invented) | Median annual earnings, full-time workers (invented for practice) |
|---|---|
| No diploma | $24,000 |
| High school diploma | $31,000 |
| Associate’s degree | $38,000 |
| Bachelor’s degree | $52,000 |
The source line you would copy from a real table: agency, table number and title, year of data, units. Here: invented, practice only.
Worked observations. One thing it shows: in this invented table, median earnings rise with each level of schooling. One thing it cannot show: whether the schooling caused the higher earnings. People who finish a degree may differ in family income, health, location or luck, and the table does not control for any of that. It also says nothing about what Newman would care about, the quality of a mind, because earnings are not the same as learning. A careful sentence therefore reads: “In the table, workers with a bachelor’s degree have the highest median earnings; the table does not show that the degree caused the difference.” Say median, not average, and name the units and the year.
For your own two observations, open one real table on nces.ed.gov, copy the title, table number, year and units, and write one sentence that shows and one that limits.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which pairing of author and central claim is accurate?
A chart showing that people with bachelor’s degrees earn more than those without proves that the degree causes higher earnings.
Complete the synthesis grid for the four authors (purpose, who it is for, what it teaches, how to test the claim today). Then open one current table from NCES or BLS, record its title, source, date and units, and write two observations: one thing it shows and one thing it cannot show.
How confident are you that you can compare four arguments about education and integrate them with data in tables and charts?
Printable: Unit 4 Student Workbook
Every organizer for this unit in one booklet — the reading schedule, the vocabulary pages, all five lesson organizers, the peer review sheet and the scoring rubric. Print it before the unit starts and bring the page to each lesson.