
bring a research question and sources to a recorded research circle, test them against peers’ evidence, and synthesize the discussion into a revised question.
Instruction
Research is lonely only if you do it badly. Professional researchers test questions on colleagues before they commit months to them. This circle does the same, in groups of four, recorded.
Come prepared (11-12.SL.1.A). The standard asks you to arrive having read and researched the material, and to draw on that preparation explicitly. Bring a preparation sheet: your question; why it matters and to whom; the anchor author whose view is closest to yours and the one furthest; two sources you have found, with one sentence each on what they claim and how you know they are credible; and one thing you do not yet know.
What makes a research question good. It is arguable (informed people disagree), researchable (evidence exists and you can reach it), focused (answerable in 2,500 words) and significant (someone must decide something). “Is education important?” fails all four. “Should a state’s public universities admit students without regard to standardized test scores?” is arguable and significant, but you would need to check what the universities currently do and why — and the answer may have changed recently, so find the current policy from the source itself.
Testing sources together (11-12.W.1.A.b). In the circle, each student presents one source, and the group asks four questions. Who produced it, and what do they gain if you believe it? When — is it current enough for your question? What evidence does it offer — data, studies, experience, opinion? What are its limits — sample, date, scope, bias? A think tank’s report may be useful and still be advocacy; a government table may be reliable and still not measure what you need. Name strengths and limitations of each in terms of your task, purpose and audience.
Civil, democratic inquiry (11-12.SL.1.A). Set roles: a facilitator who keeps time and turns, a recorder, a skeptic who asks the four source questions, and a connector who links each student’s question to someone else’s evidence. Rotate roles if the circle runs twice. Agree a goal: every member leaves with a sharper question and at least one new lead.
Synthesis (11-12.SL.1.C). The last ten minutes are for synthesis. Each member states what they heard: where the group’s evidence agreed, where it conflicted, and what further information would resolve the conflict. Then each member revises their question on the spot.
A note on AI tools. AI chat tools can invent sources that look real, with plausible titles and authors. Never cite a source you have not opened and read. If a tool suggests a source, find it yourself in a library database, on the publisher’s site or through a government website, and verify it exists and says what you claim.
Reading: Research circle: five passages, a protocol, question stems and worked source tests
John Henry Newman, The Idea of a University Defined and Illustrated (discourses delivered in Dublin, 1852; text of the later collected edition), Project Gutenberg eBook 24526; Thomas Henry Huxley, “A Liberal Education; and Where to Find It” (address at the South London Working Men’s College, 1868), in Lay Sermons, Addresses, and Reviews (London: Macmillan, 1870), Project Gutenberg eBook 16729; Anna Julia Cooper, “The Higher Education of Women” in A Voice from the South (Xenia, Ohio: Aldine Printing House, 1892), Project Gutenberg eBook 61741; John Dewey, “My Pedagogic Creed” (1897), Wikisource transcription, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/My_Pedagogic_Creed; retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original protocol, stems, worked tests and model contribution (all invented examples); quoted passages are public domain (Newman, 1852; Huxley, 1868; Cooper, 1892; Dewey, 1897)
Use the protocol as written, and record your own contributions.
This page gives you positions the circle can test, a protocol, question stems, a source test, and a model preparation sheet and contribution. Spelling in quotations is the authors’ own.
Five passages to test your question against
Knowledge is capable of being its own end. Such is the constitution of the human mind, that any kind of knowledge, if it be really such, is its own reward.
— Newman, Discourse V (1852)
Once more, these people, whom there is no pleasing, venture to doubt whether the glory, which rests upon being able to undersell all the rest of the world, is a very safe kind of glory–whether we may not purchase it too dear; especially if we allow education, which ought to be directed to the making of men, to be diverted into a process of manufacturing human tools, wonderfully adroit in the exercise of some technical industry, but good for nothing else.
— Huxley, “A Liberal Education” (1868)
We might as well expect to grow trees from leaves as hope to build up a civilization or a manhood without taking into consideration our women and the home life made by them, which must be the root and ground of the whole matter.
— Cooper, “The Higher Education of Women” (1892)
I believe that education is the fundamental method of social progress and reform. I believe that all reforms which rest simply upon the enactment of law, or the threatening of certain penalties, or upon changes in mechanical or outward arrangements, are transitory and futile.
— Dewey, Article V (1897)
I believe that the school is primarily a social institution. Education being a social process, the school is simply that form of community life in which all those agencies are concentrated that will be most effective in bringing the child to share in the inherited resources of the race, and to use his own powers for social ends. I believe that education, therefore, is a process of living and not a preparation for future living. I believe that the school must represent present life—life as real and vital to the child as that which he carries on in the home, in the neighborhood, or on the playground.
— Dewey, Article II (1897)
These are openings, not answers. Your circle’s task is to say which of them your question is closest to, and which is furthest.
The protocol (SLS original): 50 minutes, groups of four
| Minutes | Step | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 0-5 | Roles | Facilitator, recorder, skeptic, connector |
| 5-25 | Each member, 5 minutes | Present question, one source, closest and furthest author; the group asks the four source questions |
| 25-40 | Cross-testing | The connector links two members’ evidence; the skeptic names one limit on each source |
| 40-50 | Synthesis | Each member states agreement, conflict and what would resolve it, then says the revised question aloud |
Question stems
- Who produced this, and what do they gain if I believe it?
- How current is it for this question, and has anything changed since?
- What kind of evidence is it: data, a study, testimony, opinion?
- What does it not measure?
- Which of the anchor authors would accept this evidence, and which would reject it?
- What would change your mind?
- Is that a reason or a source?
Testing a question: three versions (SLS original)
| Question | Test | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Is education important? | No informed person disagrees; nothing to research | Too broad and not arguable |
| What is the graduation rate in your state? | One number answers it | Factual, not arguable |
| Should high schools in your state require a course in personal finance for graduation? | Informed people disagree; evidence exists; answerable in 2,500 words; a decision depends on it | Passes all four tests |
A source test, worked (SLS original)
Take Cooper’s counts of Black women graduates (see Lesson 4.1) as if they were your source. Who: Cooper herself, who wrote to the colleges and reports what they returned; she has a stake in the cause. When: 1892, so it is history, not current evidence. What evidence: counts by college that she collected, plus one testimony about a school. Limits: a small letter survey, one writer, no denominators. It is strong evidence for what was true then and for how she argued, and useless as evidence of today. Do the same four questions for each of your two sources.
A model preparation sheet and contribution (SLS original, invented example)
Question: Should high schools in your state require a course in personal finance? Why it matters: students and families; legislators; districts. Closest author: Dewey, who wants school to be real life; furthest: Newman, who resists useful training as the aim. Two sources: (1) Cooper’s 1892 pages, which show that debates about what schools should teach were also debates about who is served; I cannot use them for current evidence. (2) A federal table on financial outcomes, which I will find and open myself. Unknown: what districts already require.
Model contribution: “My source is a federal table, and the skeptic asked what it does not measure. It gives the year and the units, but it does not tell me whether a course changes behavior. I agree with our connector that the year matters, and I disagree that one table settles it. I would revise my question to ask about a required course in the eleventh grade rather than any course.”
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
An AI chat tool gives you a source with a real-looking title, author and journal. What should you do?
A good research question is one that has a single factual answer you can look up.
Complete your preparation sheet: question; significance and stakeholders; closest and furthest anchor author; two sources with a credibility note each; one unknown. Upload it before the circle.
After the circle, write your synthesis: where the group’s evidence agreed, where it conflicted, what would resolve it, and your revised question with one sentence explaining the change.
How confident are you that you can test a research question and sources with peers and revise the question from what I heard?