
write a 1,800-2,500 word researched argument on my own question about education, entering the conversation of the anchor authors and using current evidence, and defend it orally.
Instruction
This is the semester’s capstone. You have practiced each of its parts: rhetorical reading in Unit 1, claim and counterclaim in Unit 2, audience and delivery in Unit 3, and research in this unit. Now you put them together.
Enter the conversation. Open by showing the reader the conversation you are joining: what two of the anchor authors argued, what has changed since, and where the disagreement now lies. Then state your claim precisely. A strong introduction answers three questions: what is at stake, who disagrees, and where do you stand?
Build the argument, not a report. Organize by reasons, not by sources. A paragraph that begins “According to the NCES…” is organized by source. A paragraph that begins “Free tuition alone may not raise completion if the costs that push students out are mostly costs other than tuition” is organized by reason; it then tests that reason against the sources, and must follow the evidence wherever it leads.
Evidence (11-12.RL.1.A / 11-12.RI.1.A). Draw evidence from the anchor texts and from your research. Quote the anchor authors where their exact words matter; use data where numbers carry the claim; state what each piece of evidence can and cannot show. Every number must be exactly as it appears in the source, with the year and the source named in your sentence.
The counterclaim. Develop the strongest objection with its own evidence, as you did in Unit 2, and answer it by refutation, limitation or outweighing.
Research integrity (11-12.W.1.A, 11-12.W.1.A.b). Cite every source in MLA format in the text and in Works Cited. Submit your research log with the final. AI tools may not write any part of the essay; if you used one to search, say how in a short note, and confirm you opened and read every source you cite.
Writing over time (11-12.W.2.A). This paper is written over several weeks. Keep to the stage deadlines; a paper written in two nights shows it.
The defense (11-12.SL.2.A, 11-12.SL.2.B, 11-12.SL.2.C). Five minutes: the question and why it matters, your answer and the two strongest reasons, the strongest objection and your response, and one thing you would research next. You may use one visual — a chart of data from your sources, properly labeled — if it helps listeners follow your reasoning. Then take two questions. A live or recorded defense are equal-credit options.
What the reader should feel at the end. That you know this conversation better than they do, that you have been fair to those you disagree with, and that your answer is the best one the evidence supports.
Reading: Researched argument: the prompt, key passages, rubric and models
John Henry Newman, The Idea of a University Defined and Illustrated (discourses delivered in Dublin, 1852; text of the later collected edition), Project Gutenberg eBook 24526; Thomas Henry Huxley, “A Liberal Education; and Where to Find It” (address at the South London Working Men’s College, 1868), in Lay Sermons, Addresses, and Reviews (London: Macmillan, 1870), Project Gutenberg eBook 16729; Anna Julia Cooper, “The Higher Education of Women” in A Voice from the South (Xenia, Ohio: Aldine Printing House, 1892), Project Gutenberg eBook 61741; John Dewey, “My Pedagogic Creed” (1897), Wikisource transcription, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/My_Pedagogic_Creed; retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original prompt, rubric, thesis, outline and exemplar; quoted passages are public domain (Newman, 1852; Huxley, 1868; Cooper, 1892; Dewey, 1897)
Use the rubric to plan your work, and check every quotation and number against its source.
The prompt. Pose your own arguable question about the purpose or practice of education and answer it in a researched argument of 1,800 to 2,500 words that enters the conversation begun by at least two of Newman, Huxley, Cooper and Dewey, uses at least six credible sources (at least two current, at least one quantitative from a federal or state source), and develops the strongest counterclaim with its own evidence. Submit an annotated bibliography of at least eight sources, and give a five-minute research defense.
Key passages, by location
Quote from these or from your own reading of the full works. Locations are by author and section.
Such is the constitution of the human mind, that any kind of knowledge, if it be really such, is its own reward.
— Newman, Discourse V (1852)
Well, what I mean by Education is learning the rules of this mighty game. In other words, education is the instruction of the intellect in the laws of Nature, under which name I include not merely things and their forces, but men and their ways; and the fashioning of the affections and of the will into an earnest and loving desire to move in harmony with those laws. For me, education means neither more nor less than this. Anything which professes to call itself education must be tried by this standard, and if it fails to stand the test, I will not call it education, whatever may be the force of authority, or of numbers, upon the other side.
— Huxley, “A Liberal Education” (1868)
We might as well expect to grow trees from leaves as hope to build up a civilization or a manhood without taking into consideration our women and the home life made by them, which must be the root and ground of the whole matter.
— Cooper, “The Higher Education of Women” (1892)
I believe that education is the fundamental method of social progress and reform. I believe that all reforms which rest simply upon the enactment of law, or the threatening of certain penalties, or upon changes in mechanical or outward arrangements, are transitory and futile.
— Dewey, “My Pedagogic Creed,” Article V (1897)
The rubric at four levels (SLS original)
| Row | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question and claim | Broad or factual question; claim vague | Arguable question; claim stated but general | Arguable, significant question; precise claim | Precise claim placed between two anchor authors’ positions, with a stipulated key term |
| Research | Fewer than four sources, or one dominates | Six sources but little current data | Six or more credible sources including current data; limits noted | Sources tested on who, when, evidence and limits; no overreliance |
| Evidence | Quotations unattributed or inexact | Numbers correct but unexplained | Evidence organized by reason; exact and attributed; limits stated | Evidence answers the objection as well as supports the claim |
| Counterclaim | Missing | Named but a straw man | Strongest objection with its own evidence and an answer | The objection sharpens the writer’s own position |
| Bibliography and integrity | Incomplete; no annotations | Eight entries, weak evaluation | Eight entries with summary, evaluation and use; MLA; log | Annotations show how the argument changed |
| Defense | Reads notes | Covers the parts | Clear reasoning; visual labeled; questions answered | Answers questions with evidence and concedes a real limit |
A model thesis and outline (SLS original, invented question)
Question: Should high schools in your state require a personal finance course? Thesis: The state should require it, but only if the course is taught as a practical form of what Dewey called a process of “living” and not as a list of terms; otherwise it will be the kind of school that Huxley warned would turn out “human tools”. Outline: (1) The conversation: Dewey and Huxley on useful learning. (2) Definition: personal finance, stipulated. (3) Reason one: choices students face at eighteen. (4) Reason two: evidence from a current federal or state source, with what it cannot show. (5) Counterclaim: crowded schedules and unproven effects; answer by limitation. (6) Conclusion: what a fair reader should now accept.
A short exemplar paragraph (SLS original)
Requiring a course is not enough; what matters is what the course asks students to do. Dewey holds that “education, therefore, is a process of living and not a preparation for future living”, and a course in which students compare loan offers is closer to that ideal than one that asks them to define interest. A table can tell us how many students completed such a course in a given year; it cannot tell us whether they chose better afterward. I will therefore argue for the course and for its evaluation.
Defense outline (SLS original)
Minute 1: the question and why it matters. Minutes 2 and 3: the answer and the two strongest reasons. Minute 4: the strongest objection and your response. Minute 5: one thing you would research next. One labeled chart is allowed.
Research log template
| Date | Search terms and site | What I found | Kept or dropped, and why | Did my question or plan change? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
research question
Tap to revealArguable, researchable, focused, significant.
annotation
Tap to revealSummary, evaluation, use.
organize by reason
Tap to revealTopic sentences state reasons; sources supply evidence.
correlation
Tap to revealA relationship that does not by itself show cause.
stipulated definition
Tap to revealAn explicit statement of how a term is used in the essay.
Which topic sentence is organized by reason rather than by source?
How confident are you that you can write and defend a researched argument that enters an ongoing conversation?
Submit: Researched Argument (1,800-2,500 words) + Annotated Bibliography + five-minute defense
Task: Pose your own arguable question about the purpose or practice of education and answer it with a researched argument that enters the conversation of at least two anchor authors and uses at least six credible sources, including current federal or state data.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Proposal and annotated bibliography. One-page proposal and at least eight annotated sources (from Lesson 4.4).
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner checks organization by reason, accuracy of every quotation and number, and the counterclaim; submit a revision note naming two changes and the feedback behind them.
- Stage 3 — Final argument. 1,800-2,500 words, MLA, Works Cited, research log.
- Stage 4 — Five-minute research defense with questions. Live or recorded; equal-credit options.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Question and claim (11-12.W.2.A) | Arguable, significant question; precise claim situated in the conversation of two anchor authors. |
| Research (11-12.W.1.A, 11-12.W.1.A.b) | Six or more credible sources including current data; strengths and limits acknowledged; no overreliance. |
| Use of evidence (11-12.RL.1.A / 11-12.RI.1.A) | Evidence organized by reason; every quotation and number exact and attributed; limits of data stated. |
| Counterclaim | Strongest objection developed with its own evidence and answered. |
| Annotated bibliography and integrity | At least eight entries with summary, evaluation and use; MLA; research log submitted. |
| Defense (11-12.SL.2.A, 11-12.SL.2.B, 11-12.SL.2.C) | Clear line of reasoning; any visual labeled and sourced; questions answered with evidence. |