THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP English 12A — Rhetoric and Argument: The Public Conversation

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 23 Lessons
  • Lifetime
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Reading Rhetorically — Satire and the Rhetorical Situation
    5
    • 1.1
      The Rhetorical Situation — Reading A Modest Proposal
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Language Lab — Diction, Connotation and Tone in Swift
      45 mins
    • 1.3
      Listening Lab — Franklin’s Satires of 1773
      50 mins
    • 1.4
      Writing Workshop — The Rhetorical Précis and the Analytical Thesis
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Key Assignment — Rhetorical Analysis Essay
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Liberty of Thought and Discussion — Mill’s On Liberty and the American Free-Speech Tradition
    8
    • 2.1
      Mapping a Long Argument — On Liberty, Chapter 1 and the Harm Principle
      55 mins
    • 2.2
      Four Grounds for Free Discussion — On Liberty, Chapter 2
      50 mins
    • 2.3
      Language Lab — Syntax as Logic: Mill’s Sentences and Academic Hyphenation
      45 mins
    • 2.4
      Individuality as an Element of Well-Being — On Liberty, Chapter 3
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Seminar — Mill and the Court: Where Should Speech Stop?
      55 mins
    • 2.6
      Writing Workshop — Claims, Counterclaims and the Steelman
      50 mins
    • 2.7
      Mill Applies His Principle — On Liberty, Chapter 5
      50 mins
    • 2.8
      Key Assignment — Argument Essay on the Limits of Free Expression
      150 mins
  • Unit 3: The Speech as Public Argument — Burke, Bryan and Terrell
    5
    • 3.1
      Three Speeches in Crisis — Reading Burke, Bryan and Terrell
      55 mins
    • 3.2
      Language Lab — Figures of Speech and the Changing Language of Oratory
      45 mins
    • 3.3
      Listening Lab — Text, Delivery and Occasion
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Writing Workshop — Writing for the Ear
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Key Assignment — Persuasive Speech and Rhetorical Rationale
      150 mins
  • Unit 4: What Is Education For? — The Researched Argument
    5
    • 4.1
      Four Answers and the Data — Newman, Huxley, Cooper and Dewey
      55 mins
    • 4.2
      Language Lab — Defining Contested Terms and Using Academic Vocabulary
      45 mins
    • 4.3
      Research Circle — Testing Questions and Sources Together
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Writing Workshop — From Question to Annotated Bibliography
      100 mins
    • 4.5
      Key Assignment — Researched Argument: What Is Education For?
      200 mins

Writing Workshop — Claims, Counterclaims and the Steelman

Unit 2  ·  Recursive Writing Workshop  ·  Lesson 11 of 23

Writing Workshop — Claims, Counterclaims and the Steelman

11-12.W.2.ARLP-ENG12A
Students build a strong bridge between opposing arguments while setting aside a flimsy straw version.
By the end of this lesson I can…

state a precise claim, distinguish it from alternatives, develop the strongest counterclaim with its own evidence before answering it, and link those moves with transitions that make the relationships clear.

Instruction

Mill gives you the method for this essay: “He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that.” A senior argument earns trust by stating the other side better than its opponents expected. This workshop builds that habit before you draft.

Step 1 — A precise claim (11-12.W.2.A). “Free speech is important” is not a claim anyone disputes. A precise claim names a situation, a position and a reason: A public school should not discipline students for off-campus social media posts unless the posts target a specific student or staff member, because the harm principle distinguishes offense from injury. It establishes significance (schools make these decisions often) and could be argued against.

Step 2 — Distinguish it from alternatives. Name at least two positions yours is not. Some argue schools may discipline any post that disrupts school; others that schools have no authority off campus at all. Placing your claim between them shows the reader exactly where you stand and why the question is hard.

Step 3 — Steelman the counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A). A straw man is a weak version of the opposing view, easy to knock down. A steelman is the strongest version, the one its best defender would recognize. Write it as they would, with their best evidence. For the school example, the strongest counterclaim is not “students should be controlled” but that online harassment follows students into school and can destroy a student’s ability to learn, and that schools have a duty to every student, including the target.

Step 4 — Give the counterclaim its own evidence. This is the step most essays skip. A counterclaim stated in one sentence and answered in the next has not been developed. Supply the most relevant evidence for it — a passage from Mill’s own limits (the corn-dealer example in chapter 3, where the same opinion is protected in print but punishable when shouted to an angry mob outside the dealer’s house), a line from Holmes’s “clear and present danger”, or reliable data — and point out its strengths.

Step 5 — Answer it. There are three honest answers: refute (the evidence is wrong or does not apply), concede and limit (it is right in some cases, and your claim now excludes them), or outweigh (it is right, but a greater value is at stake). Concession is not weakness. A claim refined by a counterclaim is stronger than one that ignores it.

Step 6 — Link the moves with transitions (11-12.W.3.A.d). A claim, a counterclaim and a response are separate moves, and the reader needs to know when you change from one to the next. 11-12.W.3.A.d asks you to use words, phrases and clauses, as well as varied syntax, to link the major sections of the essay, create cohesion, and clarify the relationships between claim and reasons, between reasons and evidence, and between claims and counterclaims. Each relationship has its own family of transitions. Claim to reason: because, since, the reason is that. Reason to evidence: for example, Mill’s own case shows, in his concurrence Brandeis writes. Claim to counterclaim: defenders of the other view argue, the strongest objection is, it may be said. Counterclaim to response: I concede that, even so, this objection holds only when. Section to section: a whole clause that names what was just shown and what comes next: Having shown that the post is an opinion and not a threat, I turn to whether the school may punish it anyway.

Mill is a master of the clause-length transition. He turns from his first argument with “Let us now pass to the second division of the argument,” introduces an objection with “To abate the force of these considerations, an enemy of free discussion may be supposed to say,” and opens a reply flatly: “I answer that it is assuming very much more.” In Chapter 4 he concedes before he limits: “I fully admit that the mischief which a person does to himself, may seriously affect” others. Two cautions. A transition must name a relationship that is really there: therefore must follow from something, and however must actually turn. And a list of single-word transitions (first, also, additionally) links sentences but hides the logic; between major sections, prefer a clause that says what the last section proved.

Anticipate the audience. 11-12.W.2.A asks you to anticipate your audience’s knowledge, concerns, values and possible biases. Choose an audience — your school board, a newspaper’s readers, classmates — and ask what they already believe and what they fear.

Evidence from nonfiction (11-12.RI.1.A). When you use Mill or a court opinion, represent the reasoning accurately before you use it. Misrepresenting Holmes to make him agree with you is the fastest way to lose a careful reader.

Revision (11-12.W.3.A). At Stage 2, your partner’s first job is to test your steelman: would a defender of the other side recognize it?

📖 Before this lesson, read: On Liberty, Chapters 1-4

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.

  • On Liberty, Chapters 1-4Homer, The Odyssey, tr. Samuel Butler (1900); Robert Louis Stevenson, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1886)

Reading: Steelmanning and transitions: mentors, a model plan and a revision

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (London: John W. Parker and Son, 1859); Project Gutenberg eBook 34901; paragraph numbers count from the first paragraph of each chapter in that text, as in the reader on this page (chapter 1 has 16 paragraphs; chapter 2 has 44 paragraphs before its footnotes; chapter 4 has 21); retrieved 26 September 2026; Whitney v. California, 274 U.S. 357 (1927), Brandeis concurring, Wikisource; sources fetched: Whitney v. California (Cornell LII), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/274/357 · SLS original model plan, revision and criteria; quoted passages are public domain (Mill, 1859) or U.S. government works (U.S. Supreme Court opinion, 1927)

Use the model for the method. Your question, claim and evidence are your own.

Two mentors from public-domain texts

Mill, 1859: the duty to know the other side (chapter 2, paragraph 23). This is the standard your counterclaim is held to.

He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that. His reasons may be good, and no one may have been able to refute them. But if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side; if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no ground for preferring either opinion. The rational position for him would be suspension of judgment, and unless he contents himself with that, he is either led by authority, or adopts, like the generality of the world, the side to which he feels most inclination.

Brandeis, 1927: a claim that concedes its limit. Brandeis defends free speech and, in the same paragraph, says where it stops. Notice that the concession makes his claim more credible, not less.

But, although the rights of free speech and assembly are fundamental, they are not, in their nature, absolute. Their exercise is subject to restriction if the particular restriction proposed is required in order to protect the State from destruction or from serious injury, political, economic, or moral.

Brandeis then names the test that limits the concession: the danger must be a “clear and imminent danger of some substantive evil.” A limit stated as a condition can be applied by a reader.

Mill’s transitions: four mentors (chapters 2 and 4)

Section to section (chapter 2, paragraph 21).

Let us now pass to the second division of the argument, and dismissing the supposition that any of the received opinions may be false, let us assume them to be true, and examine into the worth of the manner in which they are likely to be held, when their truth is not freely and openly canvassed.

Claim to counterclaim (chapter 2, paragraph 24).

To abate the force of these considerations, an enemy of free discussion may be supposed to say, that there is no necessity for mankind in general to know and understand all that can be said against or for their opinions by philosophers and theologians.

Counterclaim to response (chapter 2, paragraph 6).

I answer that it is assuming very much more.

Concession, then limit (chapter 4, paragraph 10).

I fully admit that the mischief which a person does to himself, may seriously affect, both through their sympathies and their interests, those nearly connected with him, and in a minor degree, society at large. When, by conduct of this sort, a person is led to violate a distinct and assignable obligation to any other person or persons, the case is taken out of the self-regarding class, and becomes amenable to moral disapprobation in the proper sense of the term.

A transition bank by relationship (SLS original)

RelationshipWords and phrasesClause-length version
Claim to reasonbecause, since, forThe reason this line holds is that …
Reason to evidencefor example, in particularMill’s own corn-dealer case shows exactly this: …
Claim to counterclaimyet, on the other handThe strongest objection to this position comes from those who …
Counterclaim to responseeven so, still, butI concede that …; even so, the objection holds only when …
Section to sectionnext, finally (use sparingly)Having shown that …, I turn to …

A model plan (SLS original)

This model shows the parts of Stage 1 on a question you may choose: should a public school discipline students for posts they make off campus? It is a model for the method, not a text to imitate sentence by sentence.

  • Claim and why it matters: A public school should not discipline students for off-campus posts unless the post threatens a specific person, because Mill’s line between an opinion and an act still holds when the classroom is replaced by a screen. Schools decide this question every week, and the students on both sides are minors.
  • Alternative 1: Schools may discipline any post that disrupts school. Alternative 2: Schools have no authority off campus at all. My claim sits between them.
  • Steelmanned counterclaim: Harassment that begins online follows a student into school, and a school has a duty to every student, including the one who is targeted. A school that waits for physical harm has waited too long.
  • Evidence for the counterclaim (two pieces): Mill, chapter 3: an opinion “may justly incur punishment when delivered orally to an excited mob”, so context can turn speech into an act. Brandeis in Whitney: restriction is allowed when speech would produce “a clear and imminent danger of some substantive evil.”
  • Answer (concede and limit): I concede that a threat aimed at a specific student can be an act and not an opinion, and my claim excludes it. Where the post is rude, unkind or unwelcome but is not a threat, Brandeis’s demand for “reasonable ground” to fear serious harm is not met, and the remedy Mill and Brandeis both prefer is to answer it, not to punish it.
  • Audience: a school board. It believes it must protect students; it fears a lawsuit and a preventable tragedy.
  • Transitions planned: into the counterclaim, The strongest objection comes from those who must protect every student:; into the answer, I concede that a threat aimed at a specific student is an act, not an opinion; even so, …; into the close, Having drawn the line at threats, I turn to what the school should do with everything on the other side of it.

Before and after: from straw man to steelman

Before: Some people think schools should control everything students say online because they want to censor students. This is a straw man. Nobody holding that view would say it that way.

After: Defenders of school authority argue that online harassment enters the classroom the next morning, and that a school that ignores it fails the target, who has no other place to learn. On this view the question is not whether the post was written at home, but whether its effects arrive at school. A defender of the other side would recognize this.

Criteria for Stage 1 (SLS original)

  • The claim names a situation, a position and a reason, and could be argued against.
  • Two real alternatives are stated in a way their defenders would accept.
  • The counterclaim is stated at its strongest, with two pieces of evidence of its own.
  • The answer is named (refute, concede and limit, or outweigh) and does what it says.
  • Each move opens with a transition that names its relationship to the one before (11-12.W.3.A.d).
  • Any use of Mill or the Court says what the source actually reasons, with a quotation you can find on the page.

Vocabulary in context

  • counterclaim — A claim that opposes or complicates the writer’s own.
  • steelman — The strongest, fairest version of an opposing argument.
  • straw man — A weak or distorted version of an opposing argument, easy to defeat.
  • concession — Acknowledging that an opposing point is valid in some respect.
  • significance — Why a claim matters: who is affected and what depends on it.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

Which is a steelman of the view that platforms should remove false health claims?

A steelman states the opposing view as its best defender would, with its strongest reason.
Myth or Fact?

Conceding part of a counterclaim always weakens an argument.

False. Concession that limits your claim to the cases where it holds makes the argument more precise and more credible.
+50 XP

A writer has just stated the strongest counterclaim and its evidence. Which sentence best opens a response that concedes part of it and limits the claim?

A transition should name the relationship between the moves. “I concede …; even so” signals concession and then limit; “for example” and “additionally” signal relationships that are not there.

Submit Stage 1: your precise claim and why it matters; two alternative positions yours is not; a steelmanned counterclaim with two pieces of its own evidence; your answer (refute, concede and limit, or outweigh); and the audience you are writing for, with one belief and one fear they bring; and, for each move, the transition sentence that will open it, labeled with the relationship it signals (claim to counterclaim, counterclaim to response, section to section).

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can develop a counterclaim fairly with its own evidence before answering it?

Not yetVery confident

Missouri Learning Standards addressed in this lesson: 11-12.W.2.A, 11-12.W.3.A.d, 11-12.RI.1.A, 11-12.W.3.A

Instructional focus: Recursive writing process

Reading

On Liberty, Chapters 1-4

On Liberty, Chapters 1-4 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text

A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.

Chapter 1 states the harm principle: society may coerce an adult only to prevent harm to others, though Mill excludes children and peoples he judged unready for liberty. Chapter 2 defends free discussion on four grounds (a silenced opinion may be true, may hold part of the truth, and even if true becomes a prejudice and then a lifeless formula when it is never contested). Chapter 3 extends the argument from opinion to conduct: people should be free to make “experiments of living” at their own risk, because individuality is part of well-being, though even an opinion may be punished when, like the speech to the mob outside the corn-dealer’s house, it becomes an instigation to harm. Chapter 4 draws the line: conduct that concerns only oneself may meet advice and avoidance but not punishment, while a definite damage, or a definite risk of damage, to others brings conduct under morality or law.

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Seminar — Mill and the Court: Where Should Speech Stop?
Prev
Mill Applies His Principle — On Liberty, Chapter 5
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content