
write a 1,300-1,800 word argument on a free-expression question using Mill and the American texts as evidence, and present it orally with claim, counterclaim and response in sequence.
Instruction
You have now read On Liberty complete. You have a principle (Mill’s), his own test cases (Chapters 4 and 5), a tradition of legal reasoning (Jefferson, Holmes, Brandeis), and a question of your own. This essay puts them to work.
Choose from the list or propose your own. Examples: Should a public school discipline students for off-campus online speech? Should a social media platform remove false health claims? Should a public university cancel a speaker whose views students find hateful? Should a city limit protests outside private homes? A question of your own qualifies if informed people disagree about it, you can find evidence on more than one side, and researching it does not require you to view or repeat content that targets real people.
Use the texts as interlocutors, not decorations. Mill and the justices are not there to agree with you. Use at least one text that supports your position and one that complicates it. Delineate the reasoning accurately (11-12.RI.2.D): what principle, what test, what assumption. Then evaluate whether it applies to your case. The corn-dealer example, Mill’s “definite risk of damage,” the fire in a theater and Brandeis’s “if there be time” are all tests you can apply to a modern case and find wanting or apt.
Formal style and objective tone (11-12.W.2.A). Argument about free expression can get heated. Keep the prose measured: represent opponents by their best reasons, avoid loaded labels, and use the vocabulary of the discipline accurately — concurrence, precedent, harm principle.
Conclude with consequence (11-12.W.3.A.a). A concluding section should follow from the argument and add something: what would change if your position were adopted, and what cost would have to be accepted.
Grammar and usage (11-12.W.3.A.c). Proofread for the errors that undermine credibility in formal argument: pronoun reference in long sentences, subject-verb agreement across interrupters, and the modern comma between subject and verb that Mill used and you must not.
The presentation (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C). Record a three-minute argument: a precise claim; a logical sequence of reasons; the strongest counterclaim, stated fairly; your response; and a close that tells the listener what to do or think. Use at least one rhetorical device deliberately — a balanced sentence, a conditional fork, an analogy — and be ready to say why you chose it. A live presentation is an equal-credit alternative.
Integrity. Your Stage 1 plan and Stage 2 draft are the evidence that the argument is yours. AI tools may not write any part of the essay; if you used one to find sources, say so in a note and verify every source yourself.
📖 Before this lesson, read: On Liberty, The whole essay (Chapters 1-5)
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Argument essay: the prompt, key passages, rubric and model
John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (London: John W. Parker and Son, 1859); Project Gutenberg eBook 34901; paragraph numbers count from the first paragraph of each chapter in that text, as in the reader on this page (chapter 1 has 16 paragraphs; chapter 2 has 44 paragraphs before its footnotes; chapters 3, 4 and 5 have 19, 21 and 23); retrieved 26 September 2026; Schenck (1919), Abrams (1919), Whitney (1927), Wikisource; retrieved 26 September 2026; sources fetched: Schenck v. United States (Cornell LII), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/249/47; Abrams v. United States (Cornell LII), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/250/616; Whitney v. California (Cornell LII), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/274/357 · SLS original prompt, rubric, model thesis and outline; quoted passages are public domain (Mill, 1859) or U.S. government works (U.S. Supreme Court opinions)
Cite Mill by chapter and paragraph as labeled and the opinions by case and year. Delineate the reasoning of a source before you use it.
The prompt
Write a 1,300-1,800 word argument on a free-expression question you choose from this list or propose yourself, provided informed people disagree about it, for example: whether a public school may discipline students for off-campus online speech; whether a social media platform should remove false health claims; whether a public university may cancel a speaker whose views students find hateful; whether a city may limit protests outside private homes. State a precise claim and its significance, distinguish it from at least two alternatives, and develop the strongest counterclaim with its own evidence before answering it. Use Mill’s On Liberty and at least two of the American texts, delineate the reasoning of at least one Supreme Court opinion accurately (the principle, the test, the assumption), and evaluate whether it supports or limits your position. Work through the three stages and record a three-minute argument presentation.
Key passages, located
Mill, chapter 1, paragraph 9 (the principle).
The object of this Essay is to assert one very simple principle, as entitled to govern absolutely the dealings of society with the individual in the way of compulsion and control, whether the means used be physical force in the form of legal penalties, or the moral coercion of public opinion. That principle is, that the sole end for which mankind are warranted, individually or collectively, in interfering with the liberty of action of any of their number, is self-protection. That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant.
Mill, chapter 2, paragraph 42 (why even a partly wrong opinion matters).
Secondly, though the silenced opinion be an error, it may, and very commonly does, contain a portion of truth; and since the general or prevailing opinion on any subject is rarely or never the whole truth, it is only by the collision of adverse opinions, that the remainder of the truth has any chance of being supplied.
Mill, chapter 3, paragraph 1 (the corn-dealer).
An opinion that corn-dealers are starvers of the poor, or that private property is robbery, ought to be unmolested when simply circulated through the press, but may justly incur punishment when delivered orally to an excited mob assembled before the house of a corn-dealer, or when handed about among the same mob in the form of a placard.
Mill, chapter 4, paragraph 10 (the test).
Whenever, in short, there is a definite damage, or a definite risk of damage, either to an individual or to the public, the case is taken out of the province of liberty, and placed in that of morality or law.
Holmes for the Court in Schenck, 1919 (the test).
The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent. It is a question of proximity and degree.
Holmes dissenting in Abrams, 1919 (the market).
But when men have realized that time has upset many fighting faiths, they may come to believe even more than they believe the very foundations of their own conduct that the ultimate good desired is better reached by free trade in ideas-that the best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market, and that truth is the only ground upon which their wishes safely can be carried out. That at any rate is the theory of our Constitution.
Brandeis concurring in Whitney, 1927 (the remedy).
If there be time to expose through discussion the falsehood and fallacies, to avert the evil by the processes of education, the remedy to be applied is more speech, not enforced silence. Only an emergency can justify repression.
Rubric, four levels (SLS original)
| Criterion | 4 Exemplary | 3 Proficient | 2 Developing | 1 Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Precise, significant, and placed between two stated alternatives | Precise and significant | General; significance unclear | A topic, not a claim |
| Counterclaim | Steelmanned with its own evidence and answered by refuting, limiting or outweighing | Fair and answered | Stated in one sentence | A straw man or absent |
| Use of sources | Mill and two American texts, each represented accurately with the principle, test and assumption; applied and evaluated | Accurate; some application | Quotation without reasoning | Misrepresents a source |
| Style and conclusion | Formal and measured; concludes with a consequence and its cost | Formal; conclusion follows | Loaded language; restates | Informal; no conclusion |
| Conventions | Exact quotation, MLA, standard usage | Few errors | Patterns of error | Errors obscure meaning |
| Presentation | Claim, counterclaim and response in clear sequence; a deliberate device | Clear sequence | Sequence unclear | Reads the essay |
A model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Question: Should a social media platform remove false health claims? Thesis: A platform should remove false health claims only when a specific, imminent harm can be shown, and should otherwise label and answer them, because Mill’s corn-dealer distinction and Brandeis’s remedy of more speech together set the line between an opinion that persuades and one that works as an act.
- The question and the alternatives: remove all false claims; remove none.
- Mill’s principle and his second case: a claim may be partly true, and removal loses the part that is (chapter 2, paragraph 42).
- The steelman: false claims spread faster than corrections and people act on them; a platform that amplifies them shares responsibility.
- The Court’s test: Brandeis’s “If there be time” turns on whether an answer can arrive before the harm. Delineate the test, then say what “time” means on a platform.
- The answer (concede and limit): where the claim tells people to skip a needed treatment today, there may be no time, and removal is justified; elsewhere, labeling.
- Consequence and cost: the rule will let some false claims stand, and that cost must be accepted.
Note that Holmes’s “free trade in ideas” points toward more speech. A draft that uses it to support removal misstates the source; use it as the counterclaim’s target instead.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
harm principle
Tap to revealLiberty may be restricted only to prevent harm to others (Mill, ch. 1).
clear and present danger
Tap to revealHolmes’s test in Schenck (1919).
free trade in ideas
Tap to revealHolmes’s metaphor in his Abrams dissent (1919).
more speech, not enforced silence
Tap to revealBrandeis’s remedy in Whitney (1927).
steelman
Tap to revealThe strongest fair version of the opposing view.
A draft quotes Holmes’s “free trade in ideas” to support removing false posts from a platform, without explaining it. What is the problem?
How confident are you that you can argue a precise position on free expression with fair counterclaims and accurate use of Mill and the Court?
Submit: Argument Essay on the Limits of Free Expression (1,300-1,800 words) + three-minute argument presentation
Task: Take a precise position on a free-expression question from the list or of your own and argue it using Mill’s On Liberty and at least two of the American texts, developing the strongest counterclaim with its own evidence.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Claim, alternatives, steelmanned counterclaim with evidence, response, audience (from Lesson 2.6), with the transition that opens each move.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner tests the steelman and the accuracy of your account of Mill and the Court; submit a revision note naming one change and the feedback behind it.
- Stage 3 — Final essay. 1,300-1,800 words, MLA, Works Cited including the court opinions.
- Stage 4 — Three-minute recorded argument presentation. Claim, reasons, counterclaim, response, close. A live presentation is an equal-credit alternative.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Claim (11-12.W.2.A) | Precise, significant, distinguished from alternatives. |
| Counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A) | Steelmanned with its own evidence; answered by refutation, limitation or outweighing. |
| Use of sources (11-12.RI.2.D) | Mill and at least two American texts represented accurately; legal reasoning delineated and evaluated. |
| Style and conclusion (11-12.W.2.A, 11-12.W.3.A.a) | Formal, objective; conclusion states consequences and costs. |
| Conventions (11-12.W.3.A.c) | Standard grammar and usage; exact quotation; MLA. |
| Presentation (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C) | Logical sequence of claim, counterclaim and response; a deliberate rhetorical device. |
On Liberty, The whole essay (Chapters 1-5)
On Liberty, The whole essay (Chapters 1-5) so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
On Liberty moves from principle to application. Chapter 1 names the danger of a democratic age, the tyranny of the majority and of opinion, and answers it with the harm principle, while excluding children and peoples Mill judged unready for liberty. Chapter 2 defends free thought and discussion on four grounds and insists that the other side be heard at its strongest. Chapter 3 extends liberty to ways of life, arguing that individuality is an element of well-being and that custom, enforced by opinion, stunts it. Chapter 4 separates self-regarding conduct from conduct that causes definite damage to others, and Chapter 5 tests both maxims on hard cases: the sale of poisons, the unsafe bridge, the slavery contract, compulsory education and the growth of government.