
write a four-sentence rhetorical précis and turn it into an analytical thesis that names a writer’s strategies and purpose.
Instruction
A rhetorical analysis does not ask whether the writer is right. It asks how the writer tries to move an audience, and how well. The most reliable way to start is a rhetorical précis, a four-sentence summary developed by the composition teacher Margaret Woodworth, which forces you to name each element of the rhetorical situation.
The four sentences.
1. The writer, the genre, the title and date, a rhetorically accurate verb (argues, suggests, implies, satirizes, exposes) and the central claim. Jonathan Swift, in his satirical essay A Modest Proposal (1729), exposes the cruelty of English and landlord policy toward the Irish poor by having a calm economist propose that their children be sold as food.
2. How the writer develops the claim. Swift develops his indictment through a persona whose statistical reasoning and market diction treat human beings as livestock.
3. The purpose, with “in order to”. He does this in order to shock complacent readers into recognizing that the existing treatment of the poor is already a kind of devouring.
4. The audience and the relationship the writer builds with it. Swift writes for educated Irish and English readers who have tolerated reform pamphlets without acting on them, adopting a deadpan tone that leaves them to supply the outrage the speaker lacks.
From précis to thesis. A précis summarizes; a thesis argues. Convert it by naming two or three strategies and making a claim about how they work together: Swift’s persona does the work of the argument: because the proposer never stops being reasonable, readers must supply the moral judgment he lacks, and in doing so they convict themselves of having accepted the same reasoning in milder forms. A thesis is arguable if a careful reader could reach a different conclusion from the same text.
Topic sentences that analyze (11-12.W.2.A). Organize by strategy or by the essay’s movement, not by paragraph order in Swift. Each topic sentence names a strategy and its effect. Weak: “In paragraph 10, Swift talks about prices.” Strong: “The proposer’s price list turns the reader into a customer, and the reader’s discomfort at being addressed as one is Swift’s argument.”
Evidence and explanation (11-12.W.2.A). For each strategy choose the most significant quotations, then explain the gap between the persona’s meaning and Swift’s. A useful pattern is quote — what the proposer means — what Swift means — effect on the reader. Two sentences of analysis for every sentence of quotation is a sound ratio.
Applying reading standards to literary nonfiction (11-12.RI.1.A). Your evidence must come from careful reading: accurate quotations, cited by paragraph number, since the essay has no line numbers.
Revision (11-12.W.3.A). The most common Stage 2 problem is an essay that proves the essay is ironic and stops. Everyone agrees it is ironic. Your peer reviewer will ask the harder question: so what? What does the irony make the audience do?
Reading: A mentor sentence, a model précis and a revision
Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed. (1911), “Swift, Jonathan”, via Wikisource; Benjamin Franklin, An Edict by the King of Prussia (Public Advertiser, 1773), via Wikisource; retrieved 26 September 2026; sources fetched: Britannica 1911 “Swift, Jonathan” (Wikisource), https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/1911_Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica/Swift,_Jonathan; Franklin, Edict (Wikisource), https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/An_Edict_by_the_King_of_Prussia · SLS original précis, thesis and revision; quoted passages are public domain (Encyclopaedia Britannica 1911; Franklin, 1773)
Use the model précis as a template only; write yours on Swift or Franklin’s Rules, and take your quotations from the passages hosted in Lessons 1.1 and 1.3.
A mentor from a public-domain critic
The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica entry on Swift has a sentence that does what the first sentence of a rhetorical précis does: it names the writer, the title, the date, a precise verb and the claim. Then it explains how the effect is made. Read it for the shape, not for its verdict.
Swift’s grave humour and power of enforcing momentous truth by ludicrous exaggeration were next displayed in his Modest Proposal for Preventing the’ Children of Poor People from being a Burden to their Parents or the Country, by fattening and eating them (1729), a parallel to the Argument against Abolishing Christianity, and as great a masterpiece of tragic as the latter is of comic irony. The Directions to Servants (first published in 1745) in like manner derive their overpowering comic force from the imperturbable solemnity with which all the misdemeanours that domestics can commit are enjoined upon them as duties.
Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed. (1911), “Swift, Jonathan”; Wikisource transcription, retrieved 26 September 2026. The transcription is reproduced as printed, including its typographical slips. Note the parts: a strong claim (enforcing momentous truth by ludicrous exaggeration), the text and date (A Modest Proposal, 1729), a second work as a comparison, and the mechanism (imperturbable solemnity).
A student model précis (SLS original)
This is a model, written for this course, not a quotation from anyone. It treats a text other than Swift’s so that you can see the pattern on new material.
- Benjamin Franklin, in his satirical decree An Edict by the King of Prussia (1773), exposes the injustice of British colonial trade regulation by presenting it as Prussian law imposed on Britain itself.
- Franklin develops the joke by having a confident foreign king announce that Britain was settled from German lands and therefore owes him revenue, and then apply to Britain the very trade restrictions Parliament had applied to America.
- He does this in order to make British readers feel, as subjects of an outside power, the arbitrary character of measures they had accepted when they fell on others.
- Franklin writes for London readers of a daily newspaper who supported colonial policy without thinking about it, adopting the flat, official voice of a royal decree so that the readers reach the comparison themselves.
Turned into a thesis: Franklin’s decree persuades by reversal: because the King of Prussia legislates for Britain in exactly the words Parliament used for America, readers who find the Edict outrageous must admit that outrage was owed to the colonists first. It names a strategy (reversal through an official persona), an effect (the reader’s own recognition) and a purpose (to move opinion about colonial policy), and a careful reader could argue against it.
Before and after: revising a body paragraph (SLS original)
Before (summary, no analysis): In the Edict, Franklin has the King say that Britain was settled by Germans. He also says that British hat-making should be limited. Then he says that criminals will be sent to Britain. These are things Britain did to America.
After (strategy, quotation, gap, effect): The Edict’s authority comes from its official form. The King announces, in the manner of a state paper, that hat-making in Britain “ought to be as much as possible restrained,” and the calm legal wording gives no sign that the joke is a reversal. What the King means and what Franklin means are different. The King means to serve the interest of Prussian manufacture. Franklin means to remind readers that Parliament had limited colonial hatters for the same reason. The effect is recognition: readers who would read the identical rule without comment in a bill about America find it insolent when the target is themselves.
The words “ought to be as much as possible restrained” are Franklin’s: they appear in the Edict’s paragraph on hats, “the making of Hats by our remote Subjects ought to be as much as possible restrained.”
The four-sentence pattern and the criteria for Stage 1
- Précis: four sentences, each doing its job: (1) writer, genre, title, date, exact verb, claim; (2) how it is developed; (3) purpose, with in order to; (4) audience and relationship.
- Thesis: names two or three strategies, an effect on the audience and a purpose, and is arguable.
- Topic sentences: each names a strategy and what it does to the reader. “Paragraph 10 is about prices” fails; “The price list makes the reader a customer” passes.
- Quotations: six, exact, with original spelling and a paragraph number; two sentences of analysis for each sentence quoted.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is the strongest analytical thesis?
A rhetorical analysis should mainly argue whether the writer’s position is correct.
Submit Stage 1: a four-sentence rhetorical précis of your chosen text; a thesis naming two or three strategies and the purpose; three topic sentences that each name a strategy and its effect; and six embedded quotations cited by paragraph number.
How confident are you that you can write a rhetorical précis and turn it into an analytical thesis?