Why did the Articles of Confederation give way to the Constitution, and what did it take to persuade the states to accept a stronger national government?
describe the strengths and weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation, compare trade, money and taxation under the Articles and the Constitution, judge how well each carried out the ideals of the Declaration of Independence, explain the divisions between Federalists and Anti-Federalists, and explain how the promise of a bill of rights answered fears of a strong central government.

The United States’ first constitution was not the Constitution. From 1781 to 1789 the states were joined by the Articles of Confederation, agreed to by Congress on November 15, 1777 and in force after Maryland ratified on March 1, 1781. To see why Americans replaced it, and why the replacement nearly failed to win approval, read the documents themselves.
The Articles protected state sovereignty and kept taxes close to home but left Congress unable to tax, regulate trade or control money; the Constitution gave those powers to a government based on the people, and the promise of a Bill of Rights answered the fears that nearly defeated ratification.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
The first national constitution, in force 1781-1789; a league of sovereign states with a one-house Congress and no separate executive or courts.
Was the Anti-Federalists’ fear of a strong central government reasonable in 1787? Use one quotation to support your view.
Missouri standard: 9-12.GV.2.GS.C
Which feature of the Articles of Confederation most directly explains why Congress could not pay its debts?
What the Articles set up
Under Article XIII of the Articles, any change required the approval of every state legislature, so a single state could block an amendment.
Article II states the principle: “Each state retains its sovereignty, freedom, and independence, and every power, jurisdiction, and right, which is not by this Confederation expressly delegated to the United States, in Congress assembled.” Article III calls the Union “a firm league of friendship.” There was one branch, a Congress in which “each State shall have one vote.” There was no separate executive and no national court system for ordinary cases. Major decisions such as war, treaties, coining money and borrowing needed the assent of nine states, and Article XIII allowed no amendment unless it was “confirmed by the legislatures of every State.”
Final authority to govern; under Article II of the Articles, each state kept its sovereignty.
Missouri standard: 9-12.GV.3.EC.A
Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution gives Congress power to lay and collect and to regulate among the several States; Section 10 forbids any state to coin .
Strengths
The Articles were not a failure at everything. Under them the states won the war, Congress made the 1783 peace treaty, and in 1787 it passed the Northwest Ordinance, which provided for new states to join “on an equal footing with the original States,” declared that “schools and the means of education shall forever be encouraged,” and banned slavery in the territory. The Articles also honored a central idea of the Revolution: the people would not be taxed by a distant government they could not control.
The 1787 law passed under the Articles that set how territories north of the Ohio River would become equal states and banned slavery there.
The Articles of Confederation achieved nothing.
Congress under the Articles won the war, made the peace treaty and passed the Northwest Ordinance; its failures were in taxation, trade, money and enforcement.
Missouri standard: 9-12.GV.3.GS.B
A historian argues that the Articles were truer to the Declaration’s complaint against ‘imposing taxes on us without our consent,’ while the Constitution was truer to its goal of securing rights. Which evidence best supports BOTH halves?
Weaknesses: money, trade and taxes
The same caution that protected the states left the Union unable to act. Article VIII says expenses “shall be defrayed out of a common treasury, which shall be supplied by the several States,” and the taxes to pay each state’s share “shall be laid and levied by the authority and direction of the legislatures of the several States.” Congress could ask; it could not collect. Hamilton wrote in Federalist No. 15 that Congress’s requisitions were in practice “mere recommendations which the States observe or disregard at their option.” On money, Congress could regulate “the alloy and value of coin struck by their own authority, or by that of the respective States,” so states could strike coin too, and the Constitution’s later ban on state “Bills of Credit” (paper money) shows that state currencies were another worry. On trade, Congress had no power to regulate commerce among the states, and a commercial treaty could not stop a state from imposing its own duties. Even troops came by request: Article IX let Congress set each state’s quota and ask for it. When Shays’ Rebellion, an armed uprising of indebted farmers, shook Massachusetts in 1786–87, Hamilton later wrote in Federalist No. 6 that “If Shays had not been a DESPERATE DEBTOR, it is much to be doubted whether Massachusetts would have been plunged into a civil war.”
Under the Articles, a request from Congress that each state pay its share of national expenses; Congress had no power to force payment.
Missouri standard: 9-12.GV.2.PC.A
‘Brutus’ warned the new government would ‘possess absolute and uncontroulable power.’ Hamilton answered in Federalist No. 84, ‘why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do?’ What is the core disagreement?
The Constitution’s answer
The 1787 Constitution moved these powers to the national government. Article I, Section 8 gives Congress power “To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises,” “To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes,” and “To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof.” Article I, Section 10 says no state shall “coin Money; emit Bills of Credit” or, without Congress’s consent, “lay any Imposts or Duties on Imports or Exports.” Section 9 adds that “No Tax or Duty shall be laid on Articles exported from any State,” a protection for exporting states.
Missouri standard: 9-12.GV.3.CC.B
How were fears of a strong central government addressed so that key states would ratify?
Measuring both against the Declaration
The Declaration says governments exist to secure rights, “deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,” and it accuses the king of “imposing taxes on us without our consent” and “cutting off our trade with all parts of the world.” The Articles kept taxation close to the people through state legislatures but could not reliably pay for the common defense that secures rights. The Constitution begins “We the People,” puts taxation in a House elected by the people, and protects free trade among the states. Neither document fully lived up to “all men are created equal”: the Constitution counted “three fifths of all other Persons” for representation, and both left slavery in place in the states.
Missouri standard: 9-12.GV.2.GS.C, 9-12.GV.3.EC.A, 9-12.GV.3.GS.B, 9-12.GV.2.PC.A, 9-12.GV.3.CC.B
Paste your comparison table (taxation, money, trade, structure, amendment; one quoted clause per cell). Then write a 250-word argument: which document, the Articles or the Constitution, better carried out the ideals of the Declaration of Independence? Use at least three quotations, address one Anti-Federalist objection fairly, and explain how the Bill of Rights changed the answer.
Ratification and its divisions
Article VII required nine state conventions. Federalists argued a stronger Union was needed; Anti-Federalists feared it. “Brutus” warned that the new government would “possess absolute and uncontroulable power, legislative, executive and judicial, with respect to every object to which it extends.” Historians often describe the divisions as following interests and places: merchants and port towns that wanted uniform trade rules tended to support the Constitution, while many inland farmers and debtors feared distant taxes and courts. Hamilton argued in Federalist No. 84 that a bill of rights was unnecessary: “For why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do?” But the compromise that won was a promise of amendments. Massachusetts ratified on February 6, 1788, while recommending amendments that “would remove the fears & quiet the apprehensions of many of the good people of this Commonwealth”; Virginia asked for “a Declaration or Bill of Rights.” The First Congress proposed twelve amendments in 1789; ten were ratified on December 15, 1791, ending with the Tenth: powers not delegated “are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”
Supporters of ratifying the Constitution and a stronger national government, such as Madison, Hamilton and Jay.
Opponents of ratification who feared a distant, consolidated government, such as the writer ‘Brutus’.
The first ten amendments, proposed in 1789 and ratified December 15, 1791, largely in response to Anti-Federalist fears.
Key terms
The 1786-87 uprising of indebted farmers in western Massachusetts that showed the national government could not respond.
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Under the Articles of Confederation, how many votes did each state have in Congress, how many states had to agree to coin money or borrow, and who had to approve an amendment?
Check your answer
Answer: One vote per state; nine states for major decisions such as coining money, borrowing and war; every state legislature for any amendment. - Name the three powers over money and trade that Article I, Section 8 gives Congress and that Congress lacked under the Articles.
Check your answer
Answer: To lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts and excises; to regulate commerce with foreign nations, among the states and with the Indian tribes; and (as an exclusive national power) to coin money and regulate its value, with Section 10 barring states from coining money.Under Article IX of the Articles, Congress could regulate coin but states could strike coin too. - Define Federalist and Anti-Federalist and name one writer for each side.
Check your answer
Answer: Federalists supported ratifying the Constitution and a stronger national government (Madison, Hamilton or Jay, writing as Publius). Anti-Federalists opposed ratification as written, fearing a consolidated government (Brutus).
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Hamilton wrote that Congress’s requisitions were ‘mere recommendations which the States observe or disregard at their option.’ Which article of the Articles explains why, and how did the Constitution change it?
Check your answer
Answer: Article VIII: the common treasury was supplied by the states, and the taxes to pay each state’s share were ‘laid and levied by the authority and direction of the legislatures of the several States.’ The Constitution let Congress itself ‘lay and collect Taxes,’ acting directly on individuals rather than through state governments. - Compare trade under the two documents: one clause from each, and one effect on a merchant shipping goods from one state to another.
Check your answer
Answer: Articles, Article IX: a commercial treaty could not stop states ‘from imposing such imposts and duties on foreigners, as their own people are subjected to,’ and Congress had no power over commerce among the states. Constitution, Article I: Congress may ‘regulate Commerce … among the several States,’ and no state may lay duties on imports or exports without Congress’s consent. Effect: under the Constitution the merchant faces one set of national rules instead of separate state duties.Section 9’s ban on taxing exports from any state also protected exporting states. - Argue whether the Articles or the Constitution better carried out the Declaration’s ideal that governments secure rights by ‘the consent of the governed.’ Give evidence for both sides before concluding.
Check your answer
Answer: Model: For the Articles, taxes were levied only by state legislatures close to the people, answering the Declaration’s complaint of ‘taxes on us without our consent.’ For the Constitution, ‘We the People’ created a government strong enough to secure rights, with taxes voted by an elected House, and the Bill of Rights added explicit protections. Either conclusion is acceptable if it weighs both and notes that neither document secured equal rights for enslaved people.A strong answer defines the ideal, uses at least one quotation from each document and addresses the counterargument (WHST.11-12.1). - How were Anti-Federalist fears addressed so that ratification succeeded? Use two documents.
Check your answer
Answer: Massachusetts ratified while recommending amendments that ‘would remove the fears & quiet the apprehensions’ of its people, starting with a declaration that undelegated powers are reserved to the states; Virginia asked for ‘a Declaration or Bill of Rights.’ The First Congress proposed twelve amendments in 1789, and ten were ratified on December 15, 1791, including the Tenth Amendment.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Unit 1 review: Federalist No. 51 says government must first ‘control the governed’ and then ‘control itself.’ Which of those two problems did the Articles fail to solve, and which did the Bill of Rights address?
Check your answer
Answer: The Articles failed the first: the national government could not enforce its decisions or collect taxes. The Bill of Rights addressed the second, adding written limits so that the stronger new government would ‘control itself.’
The Articles could be changed only with every state legislature’s approval. Missouri’s Constitution takes the opposite approach for measures the people propose: under Article III, Section 51, “any measure proposed shall take effect when approved by a majority of the votes cast thereon.”
Which change from the Articles to the Constitution do you think mattered most for ordinary people, and why?
How confident are you that you can compare the Articles and the Constitution on taxes, money and trade, and explain how the ratification debate was resolved?
The Shift
- The Articles left taxes, trade and money largely to the states, and Congress could only request funds.
- The Constitution gave Congress power to tax, regulate commerce and coin money, and limited the states.
- Ratification was won by a promise of amendments that became the Bill of Rights.
From the Articles of Confederation to Ratification: The Clauses and the Debate
Articles of Confederation, Northwest Ordinance, Declaration of Independence, Federalist Nos. 6, 15 and 84 and the Delaware, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Virginia and Rhode Island ratifications via the Avalon Project (Yale Law School); Brutus No. 1 via The Founders’ Constitution (University of Chicago Press, public-domain text); the Constitution and Bill of Rights transcriptions via the National Archives; retrieved 2026-11-16 · Public domain
Why this reading. The lesson’s comparison table needs a quoted clause in every cell. Here are the clauses, set side by side, followed by the voices of the ratification debate and the documents that settled it. Spelling is as published. What to look for: for each topic, who holds the power under each document, and whether that power can be enforced on individuals.
1. The Articles of Confederation (agreed 1777, in force 1781)
Article II: Each state retains its sovereignty, freedom, and independence, and every power, jurisdiction, and right, which is not by this Confederation expressly delegated to the United States, in Congress assembled.
Article V: In determining questions in the United States in Congress assembled, each State shall have one vote.
Article VIII (taxation): All charges of war, and all other expenses that shall be incurred for the common defense or general welfare, and allowed by the United States in Congress assembled, shall be defrayed out of a common treasury, which shall be supplied by the several States in proportion to the value of all land within each State … The taxes for paying that proportion shall be laid and levied by the authority and direction of the legislatures of the several States within the time agreed upon by the United States in Congress assembled.
Article IX (trade): provided that no treaty of commerce shall be made whereby the legislative power of the respective States shall be restrained from imposing such imposts and duties on foreigners, as their own people are subjected to, or from prohibiting the exportation or importation of any species of goods or commodities whatsoever
Article IX (money): The United States in Congress assembled shall also have the sole and exclusive right and power of regulating the alloy and value of coin struck by their own authority, or by that of the respective States
Article IX (nine states): The United States in Congress assembled shall never engage in a war, … nor coin money, nor regulate the value thereof, … nor emit bills, nor borrow money on the credit of the United States, nor appropriate money, … unless nine States assent to the same
Article XIII (amendment): nor shall any alteration at any time hereafter be made in any of them; unless such alteration be agreed to in a Congress of the United States, and be afterwards confirmed by the legislatures of every State.
Northwest Ordinance (1787), Articles 3 and 6: Religion, morality, and knowledge, being necessary to good government and the happiness of mankind, schools and the means of education shall forever be encouraged. … There shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude in the said territory, otherwise than in the punishment of crimes whereof the party shall have been duly convicted
2. The Constitution (1787)
Preamble: We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Article I, Section 8: The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States; To borrow Money on the credit of the United States; To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes; … To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin
Article I, Section 9: No Tax or Duty shall be laid on Articles exported from any State.
Article I, Section 10: No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance, or Confederation; grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts … No State shall, without the Consent of the Congress, lay any Imposts or Duties on Imports or Exports, except what may be absolutely necessary for executing it’s inspection Laws
Article VII: The Ratification of the Conventions of nine States, shall be sufficient for the Establishment of this Constitution between the States so ratifying the Same.
3. The Declaration’s ideals (1776)
Declaration of Independence, as transcribed on the Avalon Project: that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; that, to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed … For cutting off our trade with all parts of the world: For imposing taxes on us without our consent
4. The debate
Alexander Hamilton, Federalist No. 15: The great and radical vice in the construction of the existing Confederation is in the principle of LEGISLATION for STATES or GOVERNMENTS, in their CORPORATE or COLLECTIVE CAPACITIES, and as contradistinguished from the INDIVIDUALS of which they consist. … in practice they are mere recommendations which the States observe or disregard at their option.
Alexander Hamilton, Federalist No. 6: If Shays had not been a DESPERATE DEBTOR, it is much to be doubted whether Massachusetts would have been plunged into a civil war.
“Brutus,” No. 1 (October 18, 1787): This government is to possess absolute and uncontroulable power, legislative, executive and judicial, with respect to every object to which it extends, for by the last clause of section 8th, article 1st, it is declared “that the Congress shall have power to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the foregoing powers…”
Alexander Hamilton, Federalist No. 84: I go further, and affirm that bills of rights, in the sense and to the extent in which they are contended for, are not only unnecessary in the proposed Constitution, but would even be dangerous. … For why declare that things shall not be done which there is no power to do?
5. How ratification was won
Delaware’s convention ratified first, on December 7, 1787; New Hampshire ratified on June 21, 1788, and Virginia on June 26, 1788; Rhode Island was last, on May 29, 1790.
Massachusetts ratification (February 6, 1788): And as it is the opinion of this Convention that certain amendments & alterations in the said Constitution would remove the fears & quiet the apprehensions of many of the good people of this Commonwealth & more effectually guard against an undue administration of the Federal Government, The Convention do therefore recommend that the following alterations & provisions be introduced into the said Constitution. First, That it be explicitly declared that all Powers not expressly delegated by the aforesaid Constitution are reserved to the several States to be by them exercised.
Virginia ratification (June 26, 1788): That there be a Declaration or Bill of Rights asserting and securing from encroachment the essential and unalienable Rights of the People
Preamble to the Bill of Rights (1789): THE Conventions of a number of the States, having at the time of their adopting the Constitution, expressed a desire, in order to prevent misconstruction or abuse of its powers, that further declaratory and restrictive clauses should be added
Tenth Amendment (ratified December 15, 1791): The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
The National Archives notes that the First Congress proposed 12 amendments on September 25, 1789, and that ten were ratified by three-fourths of the state legislatures on December 15, 1791.
Sources: Articles of Confederation, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Northwest Ordinance, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Declaration of Independence, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); The Federalist Papers: No. 6, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); The Federalist Papers: No. 15, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); The Federalist Papers: No. 84, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Brutus, no. 1, The Founders’ Constitution (press-pubs.uchicago.edu); Ratification by Massachusetts, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Ratification by Virginia, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Ratification by Delaware, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Ratification by New Hampshire, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); Ratification by Rhode Island, Avalon Project (avalon.law.yale.edu); The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription, National Archives (archives.gov); The Bill of Rights: A Transcription, National Archives (archives.gov)