
explain Tara Yosso’s six forms of community cultural wealth, distinguish asset framing from deficit framing, and write an explanatory paragraph that applies the framework to documented evidence about a community.
Instruction
How we describe a community shapes what we see in it. A deficit frame starts from what a community lacks — money, credentials, “the right” language — and treats those gaps as the explanation for its struggles. An asset frame starts from what a community has and does, without ignoring real hardship. This workshop teaches one influential asset framework and how to write with it carefully.
The framework. In a 2005 article in the journal Race Ethnicity and Education, the education scholar Tara J. Yosso argued that schools and other institutions often recognize only the knowledge and habits of the dominant group as valuable “capital,” and overlook the resources that communities of color bring. She named six forms of community cultural wealth:
- Aspirational — keeping hopes and goals alive despite real barriers.
- Linguistic — skills gained from speaking more than one language or style, such as translating for family or storytelling.
- Familial — knowledge and care carried through extended family and kin, including chosen family.
- Social — networks of people and community organizations.
- Navigational — skill at moving through institutions not built with the community in mind.
- Resistant — knowledge and skills gained by challenging inequality.
Worked example. Deficit sentence (an invented illustration, not a real neighborhood): “Many students in the neighborhood come from immigrant homes where English is not spoken, which holds them back.” Asset revision: “Many students in the neighborhood grow up translating between two languages for relatives at clinics and banks — what Yosso (2005) calls linguistic and navigational capital. Schools rarely give credit for these skills, although they involve the same careful attention to audience and meaning that academic writing requires.” The revision does not deny that schools may be hard to navigate. It changes what counts as evidence and names the framework and its author.
Two documented Missouri communities. The reading for this lesson gives you numbered evidence from two public National Park Service documents. One is about The Ville in north St. Louis, where local leaders campaigned to bring Sumner High School into the neighborhood in 1910 and where restrictive covenants from 1911 helped make it a Black enclave with a dense set of churches, schools, a hospital and a college for training educators. The other is about 18th & Vine in Kansas City, where in 1920 Black baseball owners met at the Paseo YMCA to create the Negro National League and where Black musicians formed an association in 1929 that later became the Mutual Musicians Foundation. Both sets include hardship as well as achievement, which is what a careful asset frame requires.
Use the framework honestly. An asset frame is not cheerleading. Your writing must still rest on evidence: public records, local histories, interviews carried out with consent, or published sources. Frameworks also have limits. Some scholars caution that asset lists can romanticize hardship or overlook differences inside a community. A strong paragraph uses the framework and names one thing it cannot explain.
Structure of an explanatory paragraph (WHST.9-10.2). (1) A topic sentence naming the community and the form of wealth. (2) Evidence, cited. (3) Explanation connecting the evidence to Yosso’s definition, using the precise term. (4) A limit or complication. (5) A concluding sentence that states why the point matters for how the community is understood.
Choosing your community. You may write about your own community, but you never have to. Equal alternatives: a documented Missouri community whose history is in public sources, such as The Ville or 18th & Vine, or a public figure’s community as described in published interviews or histories.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A student helps her grandmother complete Social Security paperwork and explains the rules to her. Which two forms of community cultural wealth does this best show?
Describing a community mainly by what it lacks is called framing.
An asset-framed paragraph does not need evidence because its purpose is to celebrate the community.
Draft a 350-450 word explanatory paragraph set on one community you choose (your own is optional; the reading gives evidence for The Ville and for 18th & Vine). Name two of Yosso’s forms of wealth, support each with cited evidence, and end with one limit of the framework.
How confident are you that you can apply community cultural wealth to evidence and write with an asset frame?
Writing With Community Cultural Wealth: Framework, Two Missouri Evidence Sets and a Model Paragraph
Yosso, Race Ethnicity and Education 8(1), 2005 (paraphrase); NPS, Historic and Architectural Resources of The Ville, St. Louis (1999); NPS National Historic Landmark nomination, Mutual Musician’s Foundation Building, Kansas City (1978); NPS, Places of Black Baseball; model paragraph and scoring sheet SLS original · Public domain (federal government documents); framework paraphrased with citation; models SLS original
Why this reading. The workshop asks you to write 350-450 words that name two of Yosso’s forms of wealth, support each with cited evidence, and end with a limit. The lesson gives you the six definitions in a sentence each but no evidence to cite, no model of a whole paragraph and no scoring criteria. This kit gives you all three: the framework as Yosso states it (paraphrased), two documented Black Missouri communities with numbered evidence you can cite (The Ville in St. Louis and the 18th & Vine district in Kansas City), a complete model paragraph, and a scoring sheet. What to look for: how a claim about “wealth” is tied to a specific, checkable fact, and how the paragraph says what the framework cannot explain.
The framework, in brief (paraphrase)
Tara J. Yosso, “Whose Culture Has Capital? A Critical Race Theory Discussion of Community Cultural Wealth,” Race Ethnicity and Education 8(1), 2005, pp. 69-91, argues that schools and other institutions often treat only the habits and resources of the dominant group as valuable “capital,” and that Communities of Color hold other forms that are overlooked. She names six (the article is copyrighted, so this is a paraphrase, with only a few short phrases quoted): aspirational (keeping hopes for the future alive “even in the face of real and perceived barriers”); linguistic (skills from communication in more than one language or style, including storytelling); familial (knowledge nurtured among kin that carries a sense of community history); social (“networks of people and community resources”; Yosso gives mutual aid societies as an example); navigational (“skills of maneuvering through social institutions” not made with the community in mind); and resistant (knowledge and skills built through opposing inequality). She also quotes the scholar Jerome Morris, who wrote of Black people developing their social capital “for survival and success in a segregated world.” A useful test for each form: what did someone actually do, and who could check it?
Evidence set A: The Ville, St. Louis, 1873-1979
These facts are paraphrased from the National Park Service’s National Register of Historic Places multiple property documentation form Historic and Architectural Resources of The Ville, St. Louis (prepared by the Landmarks Association of St. Louis and the Missouri Department of Natural Resources, approved 1999), a public federal document. Cite as (NPS, Ville) with the item number. Where the nomination quotes a resident or a scholar, the quote is theirs, not the NPS’s.
- A1. The Ville is described as a forty-two-square-block neighborhood in north St. Louis. In 1873 there were enough Black residents to establish an elementary school for them there, and within five years enrollment at Colored School #8 had nearly tripled. Antioch Baptist Church began in 1878 in the home of William and Laura Coker, and St. James African Methodist Episcopal Church was founded in 1885.
- A2. In 1906 local African American leaders began a campaign to move Sumner High School, then the city’s only high school for Black students, to a tract in the heart of the neighborhood. Residents “successfully swayed the Board of Education” away from sites in other, more densely Black parts of the city. The move was accomplished in 1910, four years after the campaign began, and the nomination calls it a major factor in the neighborhood’s later popularity and image.
- A3. Race restrictive covenants starting in 1911, and increasingly institutionalized segregation, combined to turn the neighborhood into an African American enclave “with boundaries imposed by regulation.” By 1930 the Black population of the Ville had nearly reached 90 percent, and its total population was 9,102.
- A4. Institutions the nomination lists: Poro College of Beauty Culture, the business of Annie Malone (map key date 1918); the St. Louis Colored Orphans Home (1922; renamed the Annie Malone Children’s Home in 1946); the Charles H. Turner Open-Air School for Crippled Children; Homer G. Phillips Hospital; Tandy Community Center (1938, after a 1936 bond issue paid for three recreation centers in Black neighborhoods); and Stowe Teachers College. A resident remembered in an oral history in the 1970s: “she brought all this prestige with her.”
- A5. The hospital followed a public campaign by a local Black lawyer, Homer G. Phillips, who was murdered in 1931 before it was built. The nomination’s text says it was completed in 1938; its own map key says 1937 (a small inconsistency that is worth noting in a footnote). The nomination reports, citing the hospital’s own 25th-anniversary publication, that it had trained more Black doctors and nurses than any other hospital in the world.
- A6. The Lincoln University School of Law opened in the Poro College building in 1939. The nomination says it was created after Lloyd Gaines, a Black graduate of Lincoln University, was denied admission to the University of Missouri School of Law, and the Supreme Court ruled that the state must provide legal education for Black students within Missouri. (Unit 2 reads that case.)
- A7. Hardship is part of the record too: “Excluded from most skilled trade unions, 43% of blacks in St. Louis were unemployed by 1930,” the nomination reports, citing other historians. It quotes the sociologist Sandra Schoenberg that the Ville shows “a richness in social life enforced by limited opportunity.”
- A8. Decline: the nomination reports a marked exodus of professionals from the Ville in the 1950s, coinciding with the citywide move west, and says urban renewal displaced thousands of older downtown Black residents, and that the 1979 closing of Homer G. Phillips Hospital accelerated the slide. It adds that all the Ville’s public schools, Tandy Community Center, the Annie Malone Center and all its historic churches remained open.
Evidence set B: 18th & Vine, Kansas City, 1920-1991
These facts are paraphrased from two National Park Service sources: the National Historic Landmark nomination for the Mutual Musician’s Foundation Building at 1823 Highland Avenue (a Landmarks Commission of Kansas City nomination dated 1978) and the NPS article “Places of Black Baseball.” Cite as (NPS, Foundation) or (NPS, Baseball).
- B1. The Paseo YMCA in Kansas City was established in 1914. In 1920, several African American baseball club owners met there, led by Rube Foster, and decided to create their own league, the Negro National League. The NPS calls it the “first all-Black league to survive more than one season.” It disbanded in 1931 because of “economic pressure caused by the Great Depression” (NPS, Baseball).
- B2. The Negro Leagues Baseball Museum was founded in 1990 by a group of former baseball players. The 18th and Vine Historic District, described by the NPS as a “historically Black neighborhood in Kansas City,” was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 1991 (NPS, Baseball).
- B3. The Foundation nomination says Kansas City’s Black population increased with rapid migration to urban areas in the first decades of the twentieth century, and that a “separate world of black entertainment and show business evolved,” with jazz as its greatest product. It dates the genesis of Kansas City jazz to about 1917, after the organization of Musicians’ Union Local #627.
- B4. The Negro Musicians Association was formed and chartered in 1929 by Black professional musicians “in need of rehersal facilities” (the nomination’s spelling). In 1958 it took its present name, Mutual Musicians Foundation, Inc., and the building at 1823 Highland Avenue, built in 1904 as an apartment house, was bought, the nomination says, with the proceeds of band tournaments staged by Local #627 since the early 1920s.
- B5. The nomination claims that the Foundation was “a second home, a training ground and a source of jobs” for approximately 90 percent of the musicians who created the Kansas City sound of the 1930s and 1940s, and names Count Basie, Bennie Moten, Jay McShann, Lester Young and Charlie “Bird” Parker among members. (This is the nomination authors’ claim, not a counted statistic you can check.) The song “627 Stomp,” by the pianist Pete Johnson and the singer Joe Turner, is named in honor of Local #627.
- B6. In the late 1950s and early 1960s the Foundation held weekend and after-hours events; the proceeds went to musical scholarships and other charitable projects.
- B7. A limit in the record: the nomination says the “general prosperity” of Kansas City’s entertainment economy ended suddenly in 1939 with the indictment of the political boss Thomas Pendergast for income tax evasion, after which most clubs closed.
- B8. Today the Black Archives of Mid-America in Kansas City describes its permanent exhibit, With My Eyes No Longer Blind, as tracing the story of African Americans in Kansas City “from the days of the Lewis and Clark expedition to the mayor-ship of Emanuel Cleaver II.” (The Archives’ own website, blackarchives.org.)
A complete model paragraph (SLS original, built from set A)
Do not copy this one. If you use set A, choose different forms of wealth from the two used here, or use set B.
The Ville in St. Louis shows what Yosso (2005) calls navigational and social capital. In 1906 African American leaders began a campaign to move Sumner High School, then the city’s only high school for Black students, into the neighborhood, and by 1910 they had “successfully swayed the Board of Education” away from other sites (NPS, Ville, A2). Persuading a school board that had not been designed with the community in mind is navigational capital in Yosso’s sense: skill at maneuvering through institutions. The move did more than place a school. In the thirty years after 1910, the nomination lists Poro College, the Colored Orphans Home, an open-air school, Tandy Community Center and Homer G. Phillips Hospital, and by 1930 the neighborhood was nearly 90 percent Black (NPS, Ville, A3 and A4). A dense set of institutions that residents built or fought for is social capital, which Yosso defines as networks of people and community resources. The framework has limits here. The nomination itself says that segregation, through restrictive covenants from 1911, drew the boundaries and concentrated the community (A3), and it quotes a sociologist that the Ville was “a richness in social life enforced by limited opportunity” (A7), so reading the institutions only as wealth would hide how far they answered exclusion. And the nomination is a summary by historians, with only a few residents’ own words, so it shows what institutions existed far better than what people felt about them. Even so, the evidence changes how the community is understood: the Ville appears not as a place that segregation merely happened to, but as one whose residents campaigned and organized to shape it (A1, A2).
From deficit to asset (SLS original)
Deficit: “Kansas City’s Black musicians only had a cramped old apartment house to practice in.” Asset revision, with the complication kept: “Kansas City’s Black professional musicians formed the Negro Musicians Association in 1929 because they needed rehearsal space, and the nomination says the proceeds of band tournaments staged by their union later bought the 1904 building on Highland Avenue (NPS, Foundation, B4), an example of what Yosso calls social capital; the same nomination says the city’s entertainment economy ended in 1939 with the Pendergast indictment (B7), which limits how much the concept explains.” The revision changes what counts as evidence and does not delete the hard facts.
Scoring sheet for your paragraph (350-450 words)
- Topic sentence: names the community and two of Yosso’s forms by their exact terms.
- Evidence: at least two specific facts, each tagged to its source (for example A2 or B4), quoted accurately or paraphrased.
- Explanation: for each fact, a sentence linking it to Yosso’s definition, using the term precisely.
- Limit: one thing the framework or the record cannot show.
- Closing sentence: why the point changes how the community is understood.
- Word count within range and citation format consistent.
Common errors: naming a form of wealth without a fact; treating a fact as proof of a form it does not show; using an asset frame to skip the hard facts; using the six terms as synonyms. Self-check: read your finished paragraph aloud to yourself, or to a parent or guardian if you like, and check each number against the evidence list.
Sources. National Park Service, Historic and Architectural Resources of The Ville, St. Louis (National Register multiple property documentation form, 1999); National Park Service, Mutual Musician’s Foundation Building, National Historic Landmark nomination (Landmarks Commission of Kansas City, Missouri, 1978); National Park Service, “Places of Black Baseball”; Black Archives of Mid-America, blackarchives.org; Yosso (2005), paraphrased and cited, with short phrases quoted. All retrieved 2026-11-15. The model paragraph and the revision are SLS original.
Sources: National Park Service, Historic and Architectural Resources of The Ville, St. Louis (National Register multiple property documentation form, 1999) (npgallery.nps.gov); National Park Service, Mutual Musician’s Foundation Building, National Historic Landmark nomination (Kansas City, Missouri) (npgallery.nps.gov); National Park Service, Places of Black Baseball (nps.gov); Black Archives of Mid-America, Kansas City (blackarchives.org); Tara J. Yosso (2005), Whose Culture Has Capital? Race Ethnicity and Education 8(1), 69-91 (paraphrased) (doi.org)