
carry out and document a lawful, non-partisan community action, present the whole project with a visual or digital display, and evaluate what happened against your plan and evidence.
Instruction
Phase 4 brings the semester together. You have described a community (Phase 1), researched its history (Phase 2) and weighed an issue from several perspectives (Phase 3). Now you act, present and reflect.
Carrying out the action. Follow your plan from Lesson 4.4, and keep a log: what you did, when, with whom, and what happened. Collect evidence, such as the meeting agenda and minutes, a copy of your comment, the resource you produced, attendance at your event or the archive’s receipt for oral histories, with permission for anything involving other people. If plans change, record why. Many actions do not produce immediate results; officials may listen without deciding. That is normal civic life, and your reflection is where you make sense of it.
The showcase. In six minutes, present the whole arc: the community and why you chose it; the history that matters; the issue and its stakeholders; the action you took; what happened; and what should happen next. Use a visual or digital display, such as slides, a poster, a short video or an interactive timeline (SL.9-10.5). Adapt your speech to your listeners (SL.9-10.6): define terms, avoid jargon, and thank partners by name only with their permission. A recorded presentation earns equal credit.
The reflection (WHST.9-10.1.e). This is an evaluative argument, not a diary. Claim: how successful was the action, measured against your theory of change? Evidence: your log and documents. Counterclaim: what would a skeptical stakeholder from Phase 3 say about your action? Conclusion: what you learned about the community, about how change happens, and what you would do next. Connect to at least one movement from Lesson 4.1: what did you learn from how the movement chose strategies and allies?
Worked example of an evaluative claim. Weak: “Our project was a success and we learned a lot.” Stronger: “Our public comment got the digitization request onto the board’s next agenda, which meets our first goal; but our theory of change assumed residents would attend to speak, and only two did, which suggests the barrier we studied also limited our own campaign.” The stronger claim measures the result against the plan and learns from the gap.
Scoring. You are scored on research, planning, communication and reflection, never on the cause you chose, the side you favored, or whether officials agreed with you.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Showcase partners and audience
Who hears your showcase (family, community partners from earlier units, librarians, local historians, elders) and where it happens are your choices.
Your project should reach someone outside your own household if you can, and you do not need anyone to arrange that for you. Choose one of the three audiences below; all three earn full credit. Whichever you choose, the showcase is non-partisan: you present research, reasoning and a proposal, not a campaign, and you represent fairly the people who would disagree with you.
Your route — choose one. All three earn full credit.
- Route A — A local body that can act on it — Missouri’s Sunshine Law (chapter 610, RSMo) requires a city council, county commission or school board to give notice of the time, date, place and tentative agenda of a meeting at least twenty-four hours ahead, not counting weekends and holidays when its facility is closed (section 610.020). The Missouri Attorney General’s guide says the law does not require that members of the public be permitted to speak, so find the agenda, then ask the body’s clerk how it takes comment, and either speak for the time allowed or send your brief in writing by the method the clerk gives. Afterward you may request the minutes under section 610.023. Submit a copy of what you sent, plus 200 words on what you cut to fit and why.
- Route B — The state officials who represent you — Find your state representative on the Missouri House member roster (house.mo.gov) and your state senator at senate.mo.gov/senators, and your member of Congress at house.gov and your senators at senate.gov. Send your brief with a one-page cover letter: who you are, the area you live in, the question you researched, your three findings with their sources, and one specific thing you are asking them to consider. Keep the cover letter under 400 words. Submit the letter, the brief and 200 words on how you decided what to put in the first paragraph.
- Route C — An audience you already have — Present to three to five people you already know (family, neighbors, teammates, co-workers, a club you belong to) in person or on a video call, or record the presentation and send it to them. Nobody is approached cold and anybody may decline. Give each listener the feedback questions from this lesson beforehand: what is the claim, which piece of evidence was strongest, what did you not believe, and what would you want to know next. Submit the recording or the slides, the written responses, and 200 words on what you would change after hearing them.
For the school — how this slot gets filled
Who holds this: Optional contributors: the community partners who contributed to the local knowledge sections across the semester, such as public library local-history staff, county historical societies, the Missouri Historical Society or the State Historical Society of Missouri. None is required.
- Credit every partner who contributed to a local knowledge section, as they agreed.
- If you present to officials, keep the presentation non-partisan: research, reasoning and a proposal, not a campaign.
- Offer a recorded or online option for family and partners who cannot attend.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which reflection claim is strongest?
If the public body you address does not adopt your request, your project cannot earn a high score.
How confident are you that you can carry out, present and evaluate a non-partisan community action?
Submit: Documented action + evaluative reflection (700-900 words) + 6-minute showcase
Task: Carry out the lawful, non-partisan action from your Phase 3 brief, document it, present the whole project with a visual or digital display, and write an evaluative reflection. If the action cannot safely or practically be carried out, a fully developed plan and a presentation to a family audience, or a recording, earn equal credit.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Final plan. Confirmed action, date, audience, theory of change, consent and safety checks, and your own written check that the action is non-partisan (a parent or guardian may read it with you).
- Stage 2 — Action log and self-reviewed reflection draft. Check that every claim in the reflection is backed by the log or a document, using the self-review sheet in the reading; submit a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Revised reflection. 700-900 words: evaluative claim, evidence, a skeptical stakeholder’s counterclaim, and a conclusion connecting to a movement from Lesson 4.1.
- Stage 4 — Showcase. Six-minute presentation with a visual or digital display, to listeners you choose or recorded; audience questions are optional (equal credit).
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Action and documentation (ES.OUT6) | The planned action carried out (or fully planned) and documented with evidence and consent. |
| Evaluative reflection (WHST.9-10.1, WHST.9-10.1.e) | A claim measured against the theory of change, supported by evidence, with a counterclaim and a conclusion that follows. |
| Movement connection (ES.GV6) | Accurately connects the project’s strategy to a studied movement. |
| Community focus and respect (ES.OUT7, ES.GV1) | Partners credited as agreed; community described in its own terms. |
| Presentation and display (SL.9-10.4, SL.9-10.5, SL.9-10.6) | Clear, organized, adapted to its listeners, with an effective display. |
| Use of digital tools (WHST.9-10.6) | Display or product produced and shared responsibly, with sources credited. |
Community Action Project, Phase 4: The Complete Brief, a Model Log and Reflection, and a Timed Showcase
SLS original brief, model action log, model evaluative reflection (invented situation), showcase outline, checklists and self-review sheet; rent strike facts from Lee and Randall, Belt Magazine (2019); section 610.023 RSMo · SLS original (models invented; one cited article paraphrased; one Missouri statute cited)
Why this reading. Phase 4 is the culmination of the Community Action Project: an action, a log, a 700–900 word evaluative reflection and a six-minute showcase. The lesson describes what each part contains, but not how a log entry looks, how a reflection that measures a result against a plan reads from start to finish, or how a showcase is timed. This reading gives you the full brief and rubric, a model log and a complete model reflection built on the invented example used in the Unit 4 workshop reading, a timed showcase outline, a display checklist and a self-review sheet, and it says what to do if your action cannot be carried out. What to look for: how every claim in the model reflection points back to a line in the log or a document, and how the movement connection uses a specific fact from Reading 4.1.
1. The brief
Task. Carry out the lawful, non-partisan action from your Phase 3 brief and Lesson 4.4 plan, document it, present the whole project with a visual or digital display, and write an evaluative reflection (700–900 words). If the action cannot safely or practically be carried out, a fully developed plan and a presentation to a family audience or a recorded presentation earn equal credit.
Stages. (1) Final plan: confirmed action, date, audience, theory of change, consent and safety checks, and your own written check, against the non-partisan rule in Lesson 4.4, that the action informs and does not campaign (a parent or guardian may read it with you). (2) Action log and self-reviewed reflection draft: you check that every claim in the reflection is backed by the log or a document, using the self-review sheet below, and write a revision note. (3) Revised reflection: evaluative claim, evidence, a skeptical stakeholder’s counterclaim, and a conclusion connecting to a movement from Lesson 4.1. (4) Showcase: six minutes with a visual or digital display, to family or other listeners you choose, or recorded; audience questions are optional (equal credit).
| Rubric row | Full credit means |
|---|---|
| Action and documentation | The planned action carried out (or fully planned) and documented with evidence and consent. |
| Evaluative reflection | A claim measured against the theory of change, supported by evidence, with a counterclaim and a conclusion that follows. |
| Movement connection | Accurately connects the project’s strategy to a studied movement. |
| Community focus and respect | Partners credited as agreed; community described in its own terms. |
| Presentation and display | Clear, organized, adapted to your listeners, with an effective display. |
| Use of digital tools | Display or product produced and shared responsibly, with sources credited. |
The rubric never scores the cause you chose, the side you favored or whether officials agreed with you.
2. What an action log looks like (SLS original; invented library-board example from the Unit 4 workshop reading)
| Date | What I did | With whom | What happened | Evidence kept |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wk 1, Mon | Emailed the library clerk for the meeting date and how to speak or send written comment | Library clerk | Reply: speakers sign up 30 minutes before the meeting; three-minute limit | Printed email; posted notice and agenda |
| Wk 2, Thu | Finished the script; timed it at 1 minute 58 seconds | Parent (timekeeper) | Cut one sentence to fit | Script with timing note |
| Wk 4, Tue | Gave the public comment | The board, about 12 attendees | The chair thanked me and asked staff to report at the next meeting | Agenda; minutes when posted; copy of the comment |
| Wk 4, Fri | Sent a follow-up letter asking when a reply would come | Library director | No reply within the week | Copy of letter |
| Wk 5, Tue | Requested the posted minutes (section 610.023) | Records custodian | Minutes record the request and “staff report at the next meeting” | Minutes, line 14 |
The rule for a log: what, when, with whom, what happened, what evidence. Nothing goes in it that you cannot point to, and anything involving another person is used only with permission.
3. A model evaluative reflection (SLS original; about 440 words; the situation is invented)
Claim. Our public comment met its first goal but not its second, and the gap taught us where the barrier we studied also limited us. Our theory of change said: if we presented documented evidence to the library board, then the board would be more likely to place a phased digitization plan on a future agenda, because its own annual report showed the neighborhood newspapers could be read only on one machine for 22 hours a week. Measured against that plan, the board asked staff to report on the request (Log, week 4; Minutes, line 14), which meets the first part. It did not schedule a plan, and no reply arrived to our follow-up letter (Log, week 4).
Evidence for the second point. Our plan assumed other residents would come to speak. Only two did, and both told us afterward that the meeting time overlapped with work. That is the same barrier our brief described: opening hours limit who can use the collection, and the meeting time limits who can speak about it. Our campaign faced it too.
A skeptical stakeholder’s counterclaim. In Phase 3 we described library staff who worry about cost and fragile pages. A skeptical staff member would say: “You asked for a phased plan, but you offered no estimate of what the first phase costs, so the board was right to wait.” This is a fair point. Our brief acknowledged the concern but did not cost the plan, and we would add a budget estimate from a real quotation next time.
Connection to a movement. The 1969 St. Louis rent strike, according to Belt Magazine, did not rest on one group or one act. Tenants of eight housing complexes each ran their own council and joined a Citywide Rent Strike Committee, and by October more than 2,400 tenants had withheld well over $600,000 in rent, which brought the Housing Authority to the verge of bankruptcy before it agreed to the tenants’ demands. Our action relied on one channel, a public comment, and no organized allies. The lesson we take is that we should have recruited allies whose schedules the meeting time did not exclude, such as a neighborhood association willing to gather written statements, and that we should have planned a second step in advance.
Conclusion. Change of this kind is slow and depends on who can take part in the process. We learned that a well-argued request can get onto an agenda and still lack the support to go further, and that measuring our result against our own plan showed us what to do next: build a wider group and cost the request.
Notice how every sentence that makes a claim about what happened is tied to the log, a document or a source (the rent strike facts are from Reading 4.1). Notice too that the reflection does not say whether the board was right or wrong; it evaluates the project.
4. A timed showcase (six minutes)
| Minutes | Section | Display |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00–0:45 | The community and why you chose it (Phase 1) | One slide or poster panel with a photo or map and the community’s own name for itself |
| 0:45–1:45 | The history that matters (Phase 2) | A timeline with three to five dated events |
| 1:45–2:45 | The issue and the three stakeholders (Phase 3) | Three short columns, each in the holders’ words |
| 2:45–3:45 | The action you took | A photo or copy of a document (with permission) |
| 3:45–5:00 | What happened, measured against the plan | Plan on the left, result on the right |
| 5:00–6:00 | What should happen next | One line and thank-yous, by name only with permission |
5. Display and digital-tool checklist
- Every image, quotation and data point has a source on the slide or a credits slide.
- Nothing shows a person’s face, name, address or story without their permission.
- Terms are defined for listeners who have not read your project; jargon is explained.
- Text is large enough to read from across a room; a recorded version has captions.
- Shared files contain no private information.
6. If the action cannot be carried out
If timing, safety or officials’ schedules prevent the action, complete: (1) the full plan from Lesson 4.4, (2) a written explanation of why the action was not carried out, (3) the presentation to a family audience, or a recording, with the same six sections, and (4) a reflection that evaluates the plan against the evidence and names a skeptical stakeholder’s counterclaim. The credit is the same.
7. Self-review sheet for the reflection draft
- Underline the evaluative claim. Is it measured against the theory of change?
- For each factual sentence, write the log line or document that supports it. Mark any without support.
- Is there a fair counterclaim from a stakeholder, stated as its holder would state it?
- Is the movement fact accurate, and does it explain something about the project? Check it against the source in Reading 4.1.
- Does the conclusion follow from the evidence?
- One cut, one addition. Read the draft aloud once; a parent or guardian may read it too and say what is unclear.
Sources. Brief, stages and rubric follow this course’s Phase 4 specification. The rent strike facts are from Caitlin Lee and Clark Randall, “Inside the St. Louis Rent Strike of 1969,” Belt Magazine, June 4, 2019 (paraphrased), retrieved 2026-11-15; section 610.023 RSMo (revisor.mo.gov). The log, reflection, timings and checklists are SLS original; the library, the board and all events in them are invented for illustration.
Sources: Belt Magazine: Inside the St. Louis Rent Strike of 1969 (2019) (beltmag.com); Section 610.023 RSMo, revisor.mo.gov (revisor.mo.gov)