
explain the evidence and reasoning behind four attributed positions on how to name and remember the removal of Native nations, and write a contribution that represents each view fairly.
Instruction
Lessons 2.1 and 2.2 established the documents: the Osage treaties of 1808 and 1825, the Indian Removal Act of 1830, and what the nations themselves say about removal. What people debate is how to name what happened and how to remember it in public. These are real questions of interpretation, and this lab asks you to understand them before you judge them. You will never be graded on the position you take, and you are never asked to share anything about your own family.
Question 1: what word names it? The documents themselves use different words. The 1830 statute is titled an act “to provide for an exchange of lands” and for “removal.” President Jackson’s 1830 message calls the policy “benevolent” and a “fair exchange.” Principal Chief John Ross, writing for the Cherokee Nation in 1836, says a supposed treaty was not “the act of our Nation” and that the Cherokee were “denationalized.” The National Park Service says Cherokee people were “forcibly evicted,” Missouri State Parks says they were “forcibly relocated,” and the Peoria Tribe says its nation “was removed from their homelands.” Each word carries a claim about who agreed and who held power.
Question 2: how should Missouri remember it? Missouri remembers removal in places and names. The Otoe-Missouria Tribe’s page says the state and its river are named after the Missouria. Missouri State Parks interprets Trail of Tears State Park, where nine of the 13 Cherokee detachments crossed the Mississippi in 1838 and 1839. The Otoe-Missouria Tribe describes its own youth retracing the 1881 removal route, and the Osage Nation’s Historic Preservation Office has published its claim under federal repatriation law for ancestors’ remains from a Pike County, Missouri, mound site. Remembering is done by agencies and by the nations themselves, and who decides the wording on a sign or a park page is itself part of the question.
Four positions to map. (1) President Jackson, 1830: removal is a benevolent exchange, and the states were promised jurisdiction. (2) The Cherokee Nation, 1836: the instrument was not made by the nation’s authorized government, so exchange hides a taking. (3) Public agencies today: the National Park Service and Missouri State Parks name the force used and preserve places. (4) The nations’ own present-day practice: remembering through their own words, journeys and legal claims.
How to prepare. For each position, write the claim, its strongest evidence, its key premise and what evidence would challenge it (9-12.AH.1.CC.D). Then ask whose voices each account centers (RH.9-10.6). Content note: the 1830 message contains language that is offensive today, quoted only as a historical document.
Norms for a solo lab. Restate before responding, in a sentence the holder of the view would accept. Tie claims to evidence. Question ideas, not people, groups or faiths. You are never required to say anything about your own identity or family, and you may pass on any question. Being undecided, with reasons, is a valid position. You write your replies (or record them to yourself), and a parent or guardian may read them if you wish.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What does John Ross’s 1836 letter argue about the 1835 New Echota ‘treaty’?
Both the Indian Removal Act and President Jackson’s 1830 message use the word ‘exchange’ for removal.
A reader of your draft says, ‘Anyone who uses the word removal is excusing it.’ Which reply best follows the norms?
Write (or record to yourself) a 250-word contribution on one question: which word best names what happened, or how Missouri should remember it in public places. Cite one attributed position. Then write two replies in which you restate a position in a sentence its holder would accept and add, qualify or question it. Being undecided, with reasons, is a valid position.
How confident are you that you can represent the naming and remembering positions fairly, with attributed evidence?
Naming and Remembering Removal: Four Documented Positions from Jackson’s Message to Missouri’s State Parks
Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message to Congress (Dec. 6, 1830); John Ross, letter to the Senate and House of Representatives (Red Clay, Sept. 28, 1836), NPS; NPS Trail of Tears National Historic Trail, History & Culture; Missouri State Parks, Trail of Tears State Park; Peoria Tribe history page; Otoe-Missouria Tribe news item; Osage Nation Historic Preservation Office, Osage cultural history page; Missouri Encyclopedia, ‘Osage’ (paraphrased); model exchange SLS original and invented · Public domain (1830 message, 1836 letter, statute); short attributed quotations from agency and tribal websites; scholarship paraphrased; map and model SLS original
Why this reading. The lab asks you to fill a perspective map of four attributed positions, cite one of them, and write a restate-then-respond reply that a person who holds the view would accept as fair. A description of a position is not the position, so this reading gives you each one in the words of the people or institutions that hold it, dated and attributed, with a blank map that has two rows filled in and a model exchange. What to look for: what each speaker is claiming, what evidence they rest it on, and whether they are answering the question “what should we call it” or the question “how should Missouri remember it.”
Content note: the 1830 presidential message quoted below uses language about Native peoples that is offensive today, such as “savage.” It appears only inside a quotation so that you can read the argument it makes as a historical document, not as a statement of this course.
What is settled, and what is being debated
Lessons 2.1 and 2.2 establish the facts you need: the Osage treaties of 1808 and 1825, the Indian Removal Act of 1830, and the nations’ own accounts of removal. Nobody in this lab disputes those documents. Two questions are open: Question 1: what word or words best name what happened to Native nations in and through Missouri in the 1800s? Question 2: how should Missouri remember it in public places such as parks, markers, trails and the state’s own place names? You will not be graded on the position you take, and you are never asked to share anything about your own family.
Position 1: President Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message to Congress, December 6, 1830
Jackson called the federal policy of removal “the benevolent policy of the government, steadily pursued for nearly 30 years, in relation to the removal of the Indians beyond the white settlements.” He described the plan as an exchange: “we now propose to acquire the countries occupied by the red men of the South and West by a fair exchange, and, at the expense of the United States, to send them to a land where their existence may be prolonged and perhaps made perpetual.” He also made an argument about states, naming Missouri among them:
Why, in authorizing Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Missouri, Mississippi, and Alabama to form constitutions and become separate states, did Congress include within their limits extensive tracts of Indian lands, and, in some instances, powerful Indian tribes? Was it not understood by both parties that the power of the states was to be coextensive with their limits, and that with all convenient dispatch the general government should extinguish the Indian title and remove every obstruction to the complete jurisdiction of the state governments over the soil?
A fair restatement: removal is generous and humane, and it also completes a promise Congress made to the new states. The statute he refers to (Lesson 2.2) is titled with the same word: an Act “to provide for an exchange of lands with the Indians.”
Position 2: the Cherokee Nation, letter of Principal Chief John Ross, September 28, 1836
The Cherokee were removed over roads that crossed Missouri, which is why this position belongs in a Missouri lab. In a letter “To the Senate and House of Representatives” from the Red Clay Council Ground (text as published by the National Park Service), Ross wrote that the 1835 New Echota agreement was made without the nation’s authority:
The instrument in question is not the act of our Nation; we are not parties to its covenants; it has not received the sanction of our people.
and described its effect: “We are denationalized; we are disfranchised.” and “We have neither land nor home, nor resting place that can be called our own.” A fair restatement: what Congress calls a treaty was not made by the nation’s own government, so the word “exchange” hides a taking. Notice the evidence Ross relies on: who was authorized to sign, not how the land was used.
Position 3: public agencies today, in the words they put on their own pages
The National Park Service’s page for the Trail of Tears National Historic Trail says that in May 1838 “U.S. Army troops, along with various state militia, moved into the tribe’s homelands and forcibly evicted more than 16,000 Cherokee Indian people.” Missouri State Parks’ page for Trail of Tears State Park says that nine of the 13 Cherokee detachments “forcibly relocated” to Oklahoma crossed the Mississippi River at the location of the park in the winter of 1838 and 1839. Both name the event with the word forcibly, which the 1830 statute and Jackson’s message do not use. Report a disagreement you can see: the National Park Service says Ross “orchestrated the migration of fourteen detachments,” while Missouri State Parks counts 13. The sources do not explain the difference. A fair restatement of the position: the state and federal governments now remember removal through places (a trail, a state park) and through words that name the force used.
Position 4: the nations’ own present-day practice
Three nations with Missouri homelands describe removal and its memory on their own sites. The Peoria Tribe of Indians of Oklahoma says its nation “was removed from their homelands throughout the 1800’s” and that it “is a sovereign nation with treaties with the United States government.” The Otoe-Missouria Tribe reports that a group of 26 of its youth set out to “retrace the same removal route their great grandparents traveled” in 1881, visiting ancestral sites as well. The Osage Nation’s Historic Preservation Office publishes the report of its claim under federal repatriation law (NAGPRA) for human remains removed from the Clarksville Mound Group in Pike County, Missouri, in which it presents oral tradition, archaeology and linguistics together as evidence of a shared Osage ancestry. A fair restatement: for these nations, remembering is done by the nation itself, through its own words and practices, and the nations speak of removal as something done to them. (The pages quoted here do not propose a single “correct” word for all of Missouri to use, so do not put one in the nations’ mouths.)
A secondary summary to read against the four
The Missouri Encyclopedia entry on the Osage (State Historical Society of Missouri) reports, in a paraphrase you may cite, that after statehood Missourians pressed the federal government to remove all Native peoples from the state, and that in the 1837 “Osage War” Missouri militia attacked Osage, Shawnee and Delaware hunting parties and drove them from Missouri. Notice that the encyclopedia uses “removal” and “driving out” in different sentences.
Perspective map (rows 1 and 2 filled in; fill rows 3 and 4)
| Position | Claim | Strongest evidence | Key premise | What would challenge it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Jackson, 1830 | Removal is a benevolent exchange. | Payment of expenses; a new territory; an earlier promise to the states. | Nations cannot be sovereign inside a state’s limits. | Treaties that guaranteed the land; Ross’s report that the removal treaty was unauthorized. |
| 2. Cherokee Nation, 1836 | The “treaty” was not the nation’s act. | Who signed and who did not. | Only the nation’s own government can bind it. | Evidence that the signers were authorized. |
| 3. Public agencies today | (you fill in) | (you fill in) | (you fill in) | (you fill in) |
| 4. The nations’ own practice | (you fill in) | (you fill in) | (you fill in) | (you fill in) |
A model restate-then-respond exchange (a made-up example, not a real person)
Restate: “You hold that Jackson’s word ‘exchange’ fits because the statute used it and the government offered land and expenses in return.” Respond: “I would add a question about evidence. Ross’s letter says the nation did not sign the 1835 instrument, and the National Park Service says ‘forcibly evicted.’ Is an exchange still an exchange when one side did not agree to it?” Notice that the reply names the other view in a way its holder would accept, and then adds, qualifies or questions it without calling anyone names.
Your written reply, step by step
(1) Choose Question 1 or Question 2. (2) Pick one position. (3) Write a restatement in one sentence that its holder would accept. (4) Write one reply that adds, qualifies or questions it, using one piece of evidence from this reading. (5) Read your pair aloud to yourself or to a parent or guardian if you wish, and ask whether the restatement is fair. (6) You may end by saying you are undecided, and why.
Sources: Andrew Jackson, Second Annual Message to Congress (December 6, 1830), Miller Center (millercenter.org); Chief John Ross Protests the Treaty of New Echota, National Park Service (nps.gov); Trail of Tears National Historic Trail: History & Culture, National Park Service (nps.gov); Trail of Tears State Park, Missouri State Parks (mostateparks.com); Peoria Tribe of Indians of Oklahoma: History (peoriatribe.com); Otoe-Missouria Tribe: Youth retrace removal path, visit ancestral sites (omtribe.org); Osage Nation Historic Preservation Office: Osage cultural history (osagenation-nsn.gov); Osage, Missouri Encyclopedia, State Historical Society of Missouri (missouriencyclopedia.org); Indian Removal Act, May 28, 1830, 4 Stat. 411, govinfo.gov (govinfo.gov)