
explain how Black Missourians used courts and law to challenge slavery and segregation, from St. Louis freedom suits and the Scott case through Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada and Brown, and write a source-based explanatory essay section.
Instruction
Missouri entered the Union as a slave state, and its laws and courts shaped both slavery and the fight against it. This workshop traces how Black Missourians used the courts and the Constitution to widen freedom and equality, and teaches you to write an explanatory essay section that follows a line of change through primary sources.
Freedom suits. Missouri law let enslaved people sue for freedom. The National Park Service reports that St. Louis courts heard 287 freedom suits from 1810 to 1860 and that 110 of them, 38 percent, ended in freedom by court order. A woman named Winny, held for years in Illinois, filed in 1818; the Missouri Supreme Court heard her case in 1824 and declared her free, and “once free, always free” became the courts’ precedent. Other laws worked against Black Missourians: an 1825 law required free Black residents to hold a certificate to stay in the state, and an 1847 law banned all Black Missourians from learning to read and write. The Scott case shows a precedent reversed: Dred and Harriet Scott petitioned in St. Louis on April 6, 1846, won in January 1850, and lost in 1852 when the Missouri Supreme Court overturned the verdict, saying “times now are not as they once were.” The U.S. Supreme Court dismissed Scott’s suit on March 6, 1857; Lesson 1.2 reads its citizenship holding.
Emancipation. Missouri’s constitutional convention, meeting in St. Louis, passed an ordinance abolishing slavery on January 11, 1865, with only four delegates voting against. The Thirteenth Amendment, ratified by December 6, 1865, made abolition national (Section 1) and gave Congress the power to enforce it (Section 2).
The Great Migration and World War I. When World War I halted European immigration, the State Historical Society of Missouri reports, African Americans filled much of the void in the workforce, and the Great Migration greatly increased Missouri’s Black population. The Census Bureau’s table shows St. Louis’s Black population rising from 43,960 in 1910 to 93,580 in 1930 and its share of the city from 6.4 to 11.4 percent; Kansas City’s rose from 23,566 to 38,574, but its share stayed about 9.5 percent, because the whole city grew too. A number answers how many arrived; a share answers how much the city changed.
Gaines and Brown. In 1938 the Court decided Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada. Lloyd Gaines, a graduate of Lincoln University, was refused admission to the University of Missouri’s law school; the state offered to pay his tuition in another state. The Court held that Missouri had to provide him substantially equal legal education inside the state. Read the opinion whole: it also says separate laws are admissible when the privileges are equal, and Justice McReynolds dissented, writing that Missouri had long believed in separate schools. A National Park Service summary says the Court “ordered” the law school “to integrate,” which is broader than the opinion’s own words; when a summary and an opinion differ, quote the opinion. Gaines never attended; he disappeared in March 1939. In Brown (1954) the Court held that separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.
Limits and reversals. Law was also used the other way. St. Louis Public Radio reports that about 20,000 African American St. Louisans were displaced by the demolition of Mill Creek Valley, which began in 1959 after voters approved a bond issue, and quotes one scholar’s view that leaders used laws that made it easy to declare an area blighted.
Writing the section (WHST.9-10.2). Choose one line of change, for example Winny, the Scott case, Missouri’s 1865 ordinance, Gaines, Brown. For each step: (1) state what happened and when; (2) cite the source; (3) explain how it connects to the step before it (cause, precedent, or the same people and arguments); (4) note a limit, what the ruling did not change. Use transition words that show relationship: because, as a result, building on, however. End with a sentence explaining what the whole line shows about how legal change happens (9-12.AH.1.CC.E).
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Constitutional text and three opinions
Thirteenth Amendment, Sections 1 and 2 (1865); Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada, 305 U.S. 337 (1938); Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954) · Public domain
Gaines contains two passages that pull in different directions. Read both; a full account of a source includes the parts that complicate it.
Thirteenth Amendment, Section 1: Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Gaines (1938), the holding: The white resident is afforded legal education within the State; the negro resident having the same qualifications is refused it there and must go outside the State to obtain it. That is a denial of the equality of legal right to the enjoyment of the privilege which the State has set up, and the provision for the payment of tuition fees in another State does not remove the discrimination.
Later in the same opinion: The admissibility of laws separating the races in the enjoyment of privileges afforded by the State rests wholly upon the equality of the privileges which the laws give to the separated groups within the State.
Brown (1954): We conclude that, in the field of public education, the doctrine of “separate but equal” has no place. Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.
Black Missourians and the courts, near you
Many Missouri communities have their own record of freedom suits, segregated schools and neighborhoods, and of families who challenged them, in court, at public meetings or through their own schools and institutions. That record is local knowledge.
The record of freedom, segregation and desegregation near you sits in three places: what the press printed at the time, what the courts and archives wrote down, and what the numbers say. Take one route below; all three earn full credit. If the record for your area turns out to be thin, say so and show exactly what you searched: a documented absence is a finding, and a good Community Action Project question.
Your route — choose one. All three earn full credit.
- Route A — What the court records show — Open the Freedom Suits Memorial Foundation’s plaintiffs page (stlfreedomsuits.org/the-plaintiffs/), which links to the digitized case files of St. Louis freedom suits. Choose one plaintiff, read the documents the page links, and log the dates, the claim, who the lawyers or witnesses were and the outcome. Then say what the case file can show and what it cannot, such as how the plaintiff felt or what happened afterward.
- Route B — What the press printed at the time — Search the State Historical Society of Missouri’s Missouri Digital Newspapers (shsmo.org/mdnp) and Chronicling America (loc.gov/collections/chronicling-america) for your city or county between about 1890 and 1975. Use the terms the record itself used, including ones we would not use today, because that is how the articles are indexed: “colored school”, “separate school”, “school board”, “bond election”. Log five items with date, paper and headline, and for each say who is quoted, who is not, and what the paper treats as normal.
- Route C — What the numbers say — Open the Census Bureau’s Working Paper No. 76, Table 26 for Missouri (census.gov/library/working-papers/2005/demo/POP-twps0076.html, Missouri file), which covers Independence, Kansas City, St. Joseph, St. Louis and Springfield. Pick one city and compute the Black population’s number and share for 1910, 1930 and 1960. Write 200 words saying what the numbers can establish and what they cannot; a difference is not by itself a cause.
For the school — how this slot gets filled
Who holds this: The Freedom Suits Memorial Foundation, the Black Archives of Mid-America in Kansas City, the State Historical Society of Missouri, the Missouri State Archives, and your public library’s local-history room, as places to find documented history; community organizations and families who choose to share documented history, as optional contributors.
- Use the public archives and press listed above; you do not need to contact anyone.
- Cite every document; do not rely on unsourced recollection presented as fact.
- Family and community interviews are optional, need a parent or guardian’s knowledge and the speaker’s consent, and are never required; the archive routes earn full credit.
- Treat every person in a case file with respect; discriminatory language appears only inside quotations from the documents.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which connection between freedom suits and Gaines is supported by the evidence in the lesson?
In Gaines, the Supreme Court held that laws separating the races are never allowed in public education.
In Brown, the Court held that separate educational facilities are inherently .
Draft your 500-600 word explanatory section on one line of legal change. For each step, state what happened, cite the source, explain the connection and note a limit. End with what the whole line shows about how change happens.
How confident are you that you can trace a line of legal change through primary sources in explanatory writing?
Black Missourians and the Courts: Source Packet from Freedom Suits to Gaines and Brown, with Census Numbers on the Great Migration
NPS Gateway Arch National Park, ‘Slavery and the Law’ and Dred Scott Chronology; Missouri State Archives, African American history guide; Thirteenth Amendment (National Archives); Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada, 305 U.S. 337 (1938), LII; Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954), National Archives; Gibson and Jung, Census Bureau Working Paper No. 76 (2005), Table 26 (Missouri); Census Bureau, The Great Migration; State Historical Society of Missouri, Immigrant Experience Research Guide; St. Louis Public Radio (2018) on Mill Creek Valley; model step SLS original · Public domain (court opinions, amendment, federal data, NPS pages); journalism and encyclopedia paraphrased with short quoted phrases; model SLS original
Why this reading. Lesson 2.4 asks you to write an explanatory section that follows one line of legal change through primary sources, and each step needs a date, a source, a connection to the step before it and a limit. This reading gives you the sources for the line that runs through Missouri: St. Louis freedom suits, the Scott case’s path through three courts, Missouri’s 1865 emancipation and the Thirteenth Amendment, Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada (1938), and Brown v. Board of Education (1954), plus census numbers on the Great Migration to St. Louis and Kansas City and a short account of Mill Creek Valley. It ends with a model step written the way your section should read. What to look for: in each ruling, who gained something and what the ruling left in place.
Content note: the 1938 opinion and dissent use the period term “negro,” and the 1954 opinion quotes it too. These words appear only inside quotations from the court documents.
1. Freedom suits in St. Louis (National Park Service, “Slavery and the Law”)
The National Park Service’s Gateway Arch page reports that St. Louis courts heard 287 “freedom suits” from 1810 to 1860, and that 110 of them (38%) “successfully led to an enslaved person receiving their freedom by court order.” (110 of 287 is 38.3%.) It reports that a woman named Winny, who had been enslaved for several years in Illinois, filed a suit in St. Louis in 1818; the Missouri Supreme Court heard her case in 1824 and declared her free, and “once free, always free” became the legal precedent the courts embraced. Lucy Delaney, whose mother had won a freedom suit in the early 1840s, won her own suit; her 1891 book From Darkness Cometh the Light is, per the NPS, the only first-person account of a freedom suit known. The same NPS page reports laws that limited Black Missourians: an 1825 law requiring free Black residents to hold a certificate to stay, and an 1847 law banning all Black Missourians, free or enslaved, from learning to read and write. (Paraphrase of NPS; the quoted phrases are short.)
2. The Scott case through three courts (National Park Service chronology)
| Date | Court | What the NPS chronology says |
|---|---|---|
| April 6, 1846 | St. Louis Circuit Court | Dred and Harriet Scott file separate petitions for their freedom in the Old Courthouse. |
| 1847 | St. Louis | The Scotts lose on a technicality and are given permission for a second trial. |
| January 12, 1850 | Circuit Court of St. Louis County | The court awards Dred Scott and his family their freedom; Mrs. Irene Emerson appeals. |
| 1852 | Missouri Supreme Court | Overturns the decision; the court declares “times now are not as they once were.” |
| 1854 | Federal court | The Scotts sue John F. A. Sanford; the jury finds that they are still enslaved. |
| March 6, 1857 | U.S. Supreme Court | Chief Justice Taney reads the opinion; the Court dismisses Scott’s suit, holding that Black Americans were not citizens and that Congress could not limit slavery in the territories. |
Lesson 1.2 reads the citizenship holding in the opinion itself. Here the point is the path: a precedent (“once free, always free”) that Missouri courts had applied since 1824 was reversed by the Missouri Supreme Court in 1852, and then the question was answered for the whole nation in 1857.
3. Emancipation: Missouri’s ordinance and the Thirteenth Amendment
The Missouri State Archives reports that the state’s constitutional convention, which opened in St. Louis on January 6, 1865, passed an ordinance abolishing slavery on January 11, 1865, with only four delegates voting against. (Paraphrase; the Archives page links the ordinance itself as a PDF.) The Thirteenth Amendment, which the National Archives reports was ratified by December 6, 1865, reads:
Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Section 2. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.
4. Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada, 305 U.S. 337 (argued November 9, decided December 12, 1938)
The facts, from the opinion of Chief Justice Hughes: Lloyd Gaines “was graduated with the degree of Bachelor of Arts at the Lincoln University, an institution maintained by the State of Missouri for the higher education of negroes. That University has no law school.” He was refused admission to the School of Law of the State University of Missouri. A Missouri statute allowed the curators to arrange for the attendance of Black Missourians at the universities of adjacent states, with tuition paid. The Court reversed the Missouri Supreme Court.
The holding, in the Court’s words:
The white resident is afforded legal education within the State; the negro resident having the same qualifications is refused it there and must go outside the State to obtain it. That is a denial of the equality of legal right to the enjoyment of the privilege which the State has set up, and the provision for the payment of tuition fees in another State does not remove the discrimination.
…the State was bound to furnish him within its borders facilities for legal education substantially equal to those which the State there afforded for persons of the white race, whether or not other negroes sought the same opportunity.
The limit, in the same opinion: the Court did not strike down separate schools. It wrote that “The admissibility of laws separating the races in the enjoyment of privileges afforded by the State rests wholly upon the equality of the privileges which the laws give to the separated groups within the State.” Reading the opinion whole means reading both sentences. Compare a short summary: the National Park Service’s Brown v. Board site says the Court in Gaines “ordered the University of Missouri Law School to integrate.” The opinion’s own words are narrower, requiring “facilities for legal education substantially equal” within the state. When a summary and an opinion differ, quote the opinion.
The dissent. Justice McReynolds (Justice Butler joined) wrote: “For a long time Missouri has acted upon the view that the best interest of her people demands separation of whites and negroes in schools.” He argued that the State’s offer to pay tuition at a nearby school was “far from unmistakable disregard of his rights.” A dissent is a primary source for the argument the majority rejected.
What the opinion does not tell you. The National Park Service’s Brown v. Board site reports that Gaines never attended the University of Missouri School of Law because he disappeared in March 1939.
5. Brown v. Board of Education (decided May 17, 1954)
We conclude that, in the field of public education, the doctrine of “separate but equal” has no place. Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.
(National Archives text of the opinion. The opinion notes that the doctrine “did not make its appearance in this Court until 1896” in Plessy v. Ferguson.)
6. The Great Migration: St. Louis and Kansas City (Census Bureau, Working Paper No. 76, Table 26, Missouri)
The Census Bureau describes the Great Migration as “the massive internal migration of Blacks from the South to urban centers in other parts of the country” and says: “Between 1910 and 1970, an estimated 6 million Blacks left the South.” The State Historical Society of Missouri adds, in a paraphrase you may cite, that when European immigration was halted during World War I, African Americans filled much of the void in the workforce, and the Great Migration greatly increased the state’s Black population. Here are the city numbers from the Census Bureau’s table:
| Census year | St. Louis, Black population | Share of city | Kansas City, Black population | Share of city |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1910 | 43,960 | 6.4% | 23,566 | 9.5% |
| 1920 | 69,854 | 9.0% | 30,719 | 9.5% |
| 1930 | 93,580 | 11.4% | 38,574 | 9.6% |
| 1940 | 108,765 | 13.3% | 41,574 | 10.4% |
| 1950 | 153,766 | 17.9% | 55,682 | 12.2% |
| 1960 | 214,377 | 28.6% | 83,146 | 17.5% |
Reading the table. From 1910 to 1930, St. Louis’s Black population grew by 49,620 (43,960 to 93,580) and its share of the city rose from 6.4% to 11.4%. Kansas City’s Black population grew by 15,008 (23,566 to 38,574), but its share stayed almost unchanged, 9.5% to 9.6%, because the whole city grew too. A number and a percentage answer different questions; to say how many families arrived, use the number, and to say how much the city’s makeup changed, use the share. (Computed from the table; the Census Bureau’s counts for 1910 to 1930 are shown as published.)
7. Mill Creek Valley, St. Louis (St. Louis Public Radio)
A 2018 St. Louis Public Radio report on Mill Creek Valley, a historic St. Louis neighborhood, says that about 20,000 African American St. Louisans were displaced by a demolition that began in 1959 and that voters approved the bond issue connected to it. It quotes political scientist Terry Jones, who covered the story as a student editor, that the region’s leaders took advantage of laws that made it easy to declare an area blighted and clear it completely (the report’s summary of his view), and it quotes Gwen Moore, a curator who lived there as a child, saying Mill Creek “became sort of the poster child of how not to do urban renewal.” Treat this as one documented account of how law, not only prejudice, was used to remove a community; Lesson 1.3 covers the housing cases, and Unit 4 returns to what followed.
A model step, written the way your section should read (SLS original)
Step: the Gaines decision (1938). “In 1938 the U.S. Supreme Court held in Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada that Missouri had to give Lloyd Gaines, a graduate of the all-Black Lincoln University, a legal education inside the state, because paying his tuition in another state ‘does not remove the discrimination’ (305 U.S. 337). The ruling built on the long Missouri line of lawsuits by Black Missourians, from the freedom suits to the Scott case, in that the Court again treated a Missouri law as a question about a person’s rights, not only the state’s policy. But it had a limit: the Court said laws separating the races are admissible if the privileges are equal, so Missouri did not have to give up separate schools; it had to make them equal inside the state. The case opened the way for the Court’s later statement in Brown (1954) that ‘Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.’”
Notice the four parts: what happened and when; the source; the connection to the step before; the limit.
Sources: Slavery and the Law, Gateway Arch National Park, National Park Service (home.nps.gov); Dred Scott Chronology, Gateway Arch National Park, National Park Service (nps.gov); Missouri State Archives: African American history guide, ordinance abolishing slavery (sos.mo.gov); 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: Abolition of Slavery (1865), National Archives (archives.gov); State of Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada, 305 U.S. 337 (1938), Legal Information Institute (law.cornell.edu); Brown v. Board of Education (1954), National Archives (archives.gov); Breakthroughs, Brown v. Board of Education National Historical Park, National Park Service (home.nps.gov); Gibson and Jung, Historical Census Statistics on Population Totals By Race, 1790 to 1990, Working Paper No. 76 (2005), Missouri table (www2.census.gov); The Great Migration, U.S. Census Bureau (census.gov); Immigrant Experience Research Guide, State Historical Society of Missouri (shsmo.org); Remembering Mill Creek Valley, once home to 20,000 black St. Louisans, St. Louis Public Radio (stlpr.org)