
research one documented episode in a community’s history, explain how law and people’s responses to it shaped the community, compare two attributed interpretations, and present my findings.
Instruction
Phase 2 turns the community you chose in Phase 1 into a research question. You will find one documented episode in its history, such as a law, a court case, a strike, a school fight, a neighborhood change or a migration, and explain how law and people’s responses to it shaped the community. If your Phase 1 community has little documented history, you may choose a community studied in this unit instead, such as the Osage Nation, Black Missourians or Kansas City’s Westside.
From topic to question. A topic is “Mexican families in Kansas City’s Westside.” A research question is “How did the Guadalupe Center, begun in 1919 by a Catholic women’s club, come to be led by the Westside community itself?” A good question names a place, a period and a relationship you can investigate. Test it: could two careful researchers reach different answers? If not, it is a fact to look up, not a question.
Sources. You need at least five credible sources, including two primary sources: a statute, treaty, court opinion, government record, census data, historical newspaper or photograph with its archive record. Good places to search, all free: Missouri Digital Heritage, the State Historical Society of Missouri (including its digital newspapers), the Missouri Historical Society, the Kansas City Public Library’s Missouri Valley Special Collections, the Library of Congress (Chronicling America), the National Archives and your public library. For every source, record who created it, when, for what purpose, and what it cannot tell you (WHST.9-10.8).
Checking dates and facts. Your timeline needs at least eight dated events. Check every date against a source, and cite it. If two sources disagree, report the disagreement rather than choosing silently. Never invent a quotation, a number or a date; if you are unsure of exact wording, paraphrase and say so.
Interpretations. Include one paragraph comparing two interpretations of your episode, with their authors named, for example a historian and an organization, or two historians. Explain what evidence each relies on.
Oral history is optional. If you interview someone, a parent or guardian should know, you ask consent first, you explain how you will use their words, you let them review quotations and you let them decline. Personal family history is always optional, and there is always an equal route using only archives and published sources.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Simulation & tools
Build a sourced timeline
Build your timeline of at least eight events in TimelineJS by following its instructions for a Google Sheets template (a parent or guardian can help set up the free account; you do not need an account at all if you use the paper route). For each event, enter the date, a one-sentence description and the source in the credit field. Then look at the finished timeline and answer: where are the longest gaps, and what might have happened in them that your sources do not show? Paper route (equal credit): draw the timeline on one page with the same three pieces of information for each event.
Open Knight Lab ↗ · Knight Lab, Northwestern University (TimelineJS, StoryMapJS) · MPL-2.0 open source
Which is the best research question for the brief?
If two sources give different dates for an event, you should pick the one that fits your argument.
How confident are you that you can research and present a documented episode in a community’s history with checked sources?
Submit: Documented History Brief (900-1,200 words) + sourced timeline + 4-minute talk
Task: Research one documented episode in your chosen community’s history (or a community studied in this unit) and explain how law and people’s responses shaped it. Use at least five credible sources, including two primary sources; include a timeline of at least eight sourced events and a paragraph comparing two attributed interpretations.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Research plan. Research question, working source list with at least two primary sources, and an annotated note on each source’s creator, purpose and limits.
- Stage 2 — Self-checked draft. Check every date and quotation against its source, mark any claim without a citation, and write a revision note; a parent or guardian may read it too if you wish.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. 900-1,200 words with citations, the timeline and the interpretations paragraph.
- Stage 4 — Four-minute talk. Present the question, the answer and the most important source, to family or recorded (equal credit).
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Research question and inquiry (WHST.9-10.7) | A focused, answerable question pursued through the sources. |
| Sources (WHST.9-10.8) | Five credible sources including two primary; each assessed for creator, purpose and limits. |
| Explanation (WHST.9-10.2) | Explains how law and responses shaped the community, with accurate dates and citations. |
| Interpretations (RH.9-10.9, 9-12.AH.1.CC.C / 9-12.AH.1.CC.D) | Two attributed interpretations compared on their evidence. |
| Inclusion and community focus (ES.OUT2, ES.OUT7) | Centers the community’s own voices and records where available; no invented stories. |
| Talk (SL.9-10.4) | Clear question, answer and evidence for the audience. |
Community Action Project, Phase 2: The Complete Brief and a Worked Model on Kansas City’s Guadalupe Center
SLS original brief, model, timeline, source-assessment table and self-check sheet; starter sources: Census Bureau Working Paper No. 76, Table 26 (Missouri); Guadalupe Centers, About Us; Rodriguez and Kniggendorf, KCUR (Feb. 29, 2020); ‘The Guadalupe Centers (Kansas City)’, stmupublichistory.org; Madrigal, KU ScholarWorks (2023); Rast, Gonzaga repository (2018) · SLS original (starter sources are a public-domain government table and short attributed quotations and paraphrases of published pages and abstracts)
Why this reading. Phase 2 is a research brief, and the lesson tells you to find five sources and eight dated events but shows you no finished example, no source note, no timeline and no interpretations paragraph. This reading is the whole package: the brief and rubric, a complete worked model built on one documented episode (the Guadalupe Center on Kansas City’s Westside), with a sourced timeline, a source-assessment table and an interpretations paragraph, plus a self-check sheet you can use on your own draft. If your own community has few documents, you may use the model’s starter sources as your research base. What to look for: how each claim is tied to a dated source, and how two readings of the same episode are compared on their evidence, not on whose side they take.
1. The brief
Task. Research one documented episode in your chosen community’s history (or a community studied in this unit) and explain how law and people’s responses shaped it. Use at least five credible sources, including two primary sources; include a timeline of at least eight sourced events and a paragraph comparing two attributed interpretations. Present in a four-minute talk, to family or recorded (equal credit).
Stages. (1) Research plan: question, working source list with at least two primary sources, and a note on each source’s creator, purpose and limits. (2) Self-checked draft: you check every date and quotation against its source, mark any claim without a citation, and write a revision note; a parent or guardian may read it too if you wish. (3) Revised final: 900-1,200 words with citations, the timeline and the interpretations paragraph. (4) Talk: question, answer and the most important source.
| Rubric row | Full credit means |
|---|---|
| Research question | A focused, answerable question pursued through the sources. |
| Sources | Five credible sources including two primary; each assessed for creator, purpose and limits. |
| Explanation | Explains how law and responses shaped the community, with accurate dates and citations. |
| Interpretations | Two attributed interpretations compared on their evidence. |
| Community focus | Centers the community’s own voices and records where available; no invented stories. |
| Talk | Clear question, answer and evidence for the audience. |
The rule for dates and quotations: check every one against its source; if two sources disagree, report both. Never invent a quotation, a number or a date. Interviews are optional. If you interview a family or community member, a parent or guardian is present or knows about it, you ask consent first, explain how you will use their words, let them review quotations and let them decline. There is always an equal route with no interview, using only archives and published sources.
2. From topic to question, with a model
Topic: Mexican families in Kansas City’s Westside. Question that can be answered: How did the Guadalupe Center, begun in 1919 by a Catholic women’s club, come to be led by the Westside community itself, and how did law and public policy shape that community in between? Test: could two careful researchers give different answers? Yes, and the two interpretations below do.
3. The starter sources
Primary 1: a government table. Gibson and Jung, Historical Census Statistics on Population Totals By Race, 1790 to 1990, Census Bureau Working Paper No. 76 (2005), Table 26 (Missouri). For Kansas City in 1930 it shows a total population of 399,746, of whom 357,741 are in the “White” column when “Mexican” is counted in “Other race,” 38,574 Black, 115 American Indian, 332 Asian and Pacific Islander and 2,984 in “Other race.” (Subtracting the other columns from the total gives 2,984.) The table does not say how many of those 2,984 were Mexican; it counts “Mexican” in “Other race” that year, so treat 2,984 as an upper bound for Mexicans, not a count of them. The fact that the 1930 census treated “Mexican” as a racial category at all is part of the story of how a government sorted people.
Primary 2: the organization’s own account. The Guadalupe Centers’ “About Us” page says that, in the early 1900s, “the hardships caused by the Mexican Revolution” led many Mexican nationals to leave their homeland, and that some settled on the Westside. It says that on arriving, they “faced yet another hardship. Discrimination,” that “Mexican children were not allowed into certain schools,” and that “a Catholic women’s club in 1919 decided to establish a volunteer school and clinic.” It also says that, according to the National Register of Historic Places, the Guadalupe Centers is the longest continuously operating agency serving Latinos in the United States. This is a primary source for what the organization says about itself; it is not independent proof of the school and shopping claims.
Secondary 1: journalism. Lisa Rodriguez and Anne Kniggendorf, “The Guadalupe Centers once tried to ‘Americanize’ Mexicans. Now it empowers Latinos in Kansas City,” KCUR, February 29, 2020 (with historian Valerie Mendoza and researcher Theresa Torres). Photographs are credited to the Missouri Valley Room of the Kansas City Public Library (the Library’s site now calls the department Missouri Valley Special Collections).
Secondary 2: a public-history entry. “The Guadalupe Centers (Kansas City),” Latino community development: Histories of economic and social justice (a public-history website, stmupublichistory.org, whose author and date are not given on the page): the Center “was established in 1919 as an extension of the Our Lady of Guadalupe Catholic Church” to assist Mexican immigrants.
Secondary 3 and 4: scholarship (abstracts). Anna Madrigal, Repatriation Beyond the Borderlands (University of Kansas honors thesis, April 19, 2023) and Raymond W. Rast, “Cultivating a Shared Sense of Place: Ethnic Mexicans and the Environment in Twentieth-Century Kansas City” (2018), both read here only through their published abstracts. Madrigal writes that authorities in Kansas City used large-scale Mexican repatriation during the Depression of 1921, and analyzes “the community-building that took place between 1921 and 1929.” Rast’s abstract lists the railroads, urban planning, the flood of 1951 and the freeways built after the 1950s among the forces on the Westside.
The archive to search next: the Kansas City Public Library’s Missouri Valley Special Collections (kchistory.org), whose site describes thousands of photographs, postcards, maps and documents on the Kansas City region.
4. Source-assessment table
| Source | Creator and date | Purpose | What it cannot tell you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Census Table 26 | Census Bureau (Gibson and Jung), 2005, from 1930 census | Population counts by race | How many were Mexican; why they came; what they did |
| Guadalupe Centers, About Us | The organization, current website | To describe its mission and history | Independent proof of its claims; the founders’ own words |
| KCUR article | Journalists, 2020 | To tell a century of the Center’s history to a general audience | Footnoted sources for each date |
| Public-history entry | Public-history website, undated | To summarize the Center’s role | Detail beyond the summary |
| Madrigal; Rast | Scholars, 2023 and 2018 | To argue claims about repatriation and place | Their evidence, if you read only the abstract |
5. A sourced timeline (every date checked against the source named)
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1919 | The Guadalupe Center is founded by a Catholic women’s club, the Agnes Ward Amberg Club. | Guadalupe Centers; KCUR; public-history entry (all say 1919) |
| 1921 | Kansas City authorities use large-scale repatriation during the Depression of 1921. | Madrigal (thesis abstract) |
| 1925 | Women and children wait to be seen at the Center’s Well Baby Clinic (photograph). | KCUR, photo caption (Missouri Valley Room) |
| 1926 | The Center holds its first Gran Fiesta. | KCUR |
| 1930 | The census counts Mexicans in “Other race”; Kansas City’s “Other race” column is 2,984. | Census Table 26 |
| 1935 | Dorothy Gallagher buys land and pays for the building still in use on the Westside. | KCUR |
| 1951 | A major flood affects the Kansas City area. | Rast (abstract) |
| 1950s-1960s | Freeways are built through the metropolitan area. | Rast (abstract) |
| 1978 | The Latino community hires one of its own, Tony Salazar, to run the Center. | KCUR |
| 1980 | Cris Medina becomes chief executive officer (“Since 1980”). | KCUR |
Where the sources disagree. The Guadalupe Centers’ page dates the arrival of Mexican families to the early 1900s and the Mexican Revolution; KCUR says Latinos “started moving to Kansas City in the mid-1800s.” Both are reported here, and a researcher would look for a primary document (a census page, a church record) that settles it. Dates on this timeline come from a single source except 1919, which three sources give.
6. The interpretations paragraph (model)
“Two accounts explain how the Guadalupe Center came to be run by the community it served. The Guadalupe Centers’ own history presents the 1919 founding as an answer to a need: families who ‘faced yet another hardship. Discrimination,’ and a women’s club that decided to start a volunteer school and clinic. KCUR, reporting with historian Valerie Mendoza and researcher Theresa Torres, tells it as a change over time: the club’s founders formed the center to teach newly arrived women and children what the founders saw as the culture of their adopted country, the women of the community did not want to be ‘taught’ skills they already had, and the Center changed after home visits by Dorothy Gallagher, the first Gran Fiesta in 1926, and the community’s hiring of Tony Salazar in 1978. The two do not flatly contradict each other: the first relies on the organization’s self-description of its purpose, the second on interviews and the Center’s activities over a century. What neither can show, from these sources alone, is what the founders wrote at the time; the Center’s scrapbooks and correspondence, if available in the Missouri Valley Special Collections, would be the next place to look.”
7. Self-check sheet (use on your own draft)
- Every date matches the source named beside it (tick each one).
- Every quotation is word for word, and under about fifteen words unless it comes from a public-domain document.
- Every claim has a citation; any claim without one is marked and either sourced or removed.
- At least five sources, at least two primary, each assessed for creator, purpose and limits.
- At least eight dated events, with disagreements between sources reported.
- Two interpretations, with their authors or organizations named and their evidence compared.
- No invented person, quotation, number or story; any interview was optional, with consent.
- Word count 900-1,200 for the final; talk about four minutes.
Sources: Gibson and Jung, Historical Census Statistics on Population Totals By Race, 1790 to 1990, Working Paper No. 76 (2005), Missouri table (www2.census.gov); Guadalupe Centers: About Us (guadalupecenters.org); The Guadalupe Centers once tried to ‘Americanize’ Mexicans. Now it empowers Latinos in Kansas City, KCUR (Feb. 29, 2020) (kcur.org); The Guadalupe Centers (Kansas City), Latino community development: Histories of economic and social justice (stmupublichistory.org); Madrigal, Repatriation Beyond the Borderlands (University of Kansas honors thesis, 2023), KU ScholarWorks (kuscholarworks.ku.edu); Rast, Cultivating a Shared Sense of Place (2018), Gonzaga University repository (repository.gonzaga.edu); Missouri Valley Special Collections, Kansas City Public Library (kchistory.org)