
distinguish identities people claim for themselves from categories others assign to them, explain the difference between race and ethnicity as scholars use the terms, and show from census history that official categories change over time.
Instruction
Everyone carries more than one identity: a name, a language or several, a neighborhood, a faith or none, a family story, a school, a team. Some of these we choose and some we inherit. Ethnic studies begins with a simple but powerful distinction between the identities people claim for themselves and the categories assigned to them by others — neighbors, employers, courts and governments. The two often do not match, and the gap between them is where much of the history in this course happens.
Ethnicity and race. Scholars usually use ethnicity for a shared sense of belonging built on things like ancestry, language, customs, religion or homeland — something a group recognizes in itself. They use race for categories that sort people mainly by perceived physical appearance and ancestry, categories that have usually been created and enforced by those with the power to make rules. The federal government’s own current standard says its categories “are understood to be socio-political constructs” and “are not an attempt to define race and ethnicity biologically or genetically.” That is why scholars describe race as a social and historical idea: it is real in its effects, because laws and customs were built on it, but its categories were made by people and have changed over time.
Worked example: the census. The national census is the best evidence that official categories change. In 1930 printed instructions told the census taker which code to write in a “color or race” column, and the list included “Mex” for Mexican beside “Neg” for Negro and “Ch” for Chinese. Another rule told enumerators to return a person of mixed white and Black ancestry as Negro “no matter how small the percentage of Negro blood.” Those instructions were the same in Missouri as everywhere else. By 1940 the Mexican category was gone: “Mexicans are to be regarded as white unless definitely of Indian or other nonwhite race.” The 2020 census asked two questions, one about Hispanic origin and one about race, and printed a note on the form: “Hispanic origins are not races.” In 2024 the federal Office of Management and Budget (OMB) combined the two questions into one and added a Middle Eastern or North African (MENA) category. Commenters said that classifying people from that region as White did not reflect the reality of many of them; a few said some of them do consider themselves white. None of these changes happened because human beings changed. They happened because people argued about how they should be counted, and governments decided.
Why the categories matter. Categories decide who is counted, how voting districts are drawn, which communities qualify for programs, and how discrimination is measured. In 1900 St. Louis counted 35,665 African American residents among 575,235 people, 6.2 percent (35,665 ÷ 575,235), according to the National Park Service’s history of the Ville neighborhood; a count is only as good as the category behind it. A category that erases a community can make its needs invisible; a category imposed on people can also misdescribe them. Ask of any category: who made it, for what purpose, and who was left out?
Your own identity is yours. In this course you are never required to share personal or family information. When a task invites you to use your own story, you may instead study a public figure’s or a documented community’s history, and both routes earn the same credit.
Terms change too. People describe themselves differently: Black or African American; Mexican American or Chicano; Hispanic or Latino; American Indian, Native American, Indigenous, or the name of a specific nation. The 2020 form asked for the “name of enrolled or principal tribe(s),” and the 2024 standard asks agencies to offer write-in fields so respondents can “self-identify.” The best practice is to use the name a person or community uses for itself, and to recognize that members of the same group may disagree.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
The communities that built this place
Every Missouri place has its own layered history: the Native nation or nations whose homeland it is, and the communities who arrived, worked, organized and stayed. That history is held by the people who lived it, not by a course vendor.
The census example above is one lens on your area, not the whole story. Build the rest yourself: take one of the three routes below. Each one runs from any address in Missouri, from home, and needs nobody’s permission. If a community later contributes its own account of this place, hold that account above anything you assembled from records — the people who lived a history are its best source.
Your route — choose one. All three earn full credit.
- Route A — Who lives here now, and who lived here before (U.S. Census Bureau) — Open data.census.gov and search your city, town or ZIP code. Pull table DP05, ACS Demographic and Housing Estimates, from the most recent 5-year American Community Survey, and record the population and the share of residents in each race and ethnicity category. Pull table S1601, Language Spoken at Home, for the same place. Then pull the same place from a decennial census table for an earlier year that the site offers, and compare. Write 150 words on what changed, what held steady, and which of this lesson’s concepts — migration, exclusion, displacement, community cultural wealth — the numbers can show and which they cannot.
- Route B — The local press, decade by decade (Missouri Digital Newspapers) — Search Missouri Digital Newspapers (shsmo.org/collections/newspapers/mdnp), the State Historical Society of Missouri’s collection of historic Missouri newspapers; its images are freely available to the public and keyword searchable. Search your town’s name together with the name of a community, a congregation, a lodge, a mutual aid society, a union hall or a business district, and limit the search to one decade. Log five articles with date, paper and headline. For each, note who is speaking and who is being spoken about — nineteenth- and early twentieth-century papers often describe a community in language that community would never have used for itself, and that gap is evidence too.
- Route C — What was built, and what the record marks (Missouri Digital Heritage and the National Register) — Browse Missouri Digital Heritage (sos.mo.gov/mdh), the Missouri Secretary of State’s portal to the Missouri State Archives, the Missouri State Library and other institutions; its collections include photograph archives, county histories, county plat books and city directories. Collect five photographs, maps, directories or documents about your area. Then open NPGallery (npgallery.nps.gov/NRHP), search the National Register of Historic Places by state (Missouri) and county or city, and open one nomination form: these are federal public documents, often many pages of researched local history, and they name who built a place and who used it. Write 150 words on what the buildings and images show about who made this place, and on which communities left buildings and which did not.
For the school — how this slot gets filled
Who holds this: Optional local contributors: the Historic Preservation Office of the Osage Nation (osageculture.com), the Missouri Historical Society, the State Historical Society of Missouri, the local public library’s local-history room, and community organizations and elders who choose to take part.
- A contributor takes part only by choice, and no student is sent to a community partner; what a contributor shares for study is a different permission from what may be published online, so ask which applies.
- Use documented sources the contributors provide or approve: local archives, newspapers, city records, oral histories recorded with consent.
- Agree attribution in writing: the person, the organization, and who may revise the material later.
- If a contributor says some knowledge is not for a course, respect that answer and teach the slot as it stands.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which example shows an ascribed category rather than self-identification?
Official U.S. race and ethnicity categories have stayed the same since the first census.
Scholars call race a idea because its categories were made by people and have changed over time, even though their effects are real.
Choose one official category system (the census, a school form or a job application you have seen). Who made it, for what purpose, and who might not see themselves in it? You may answer about yourself or about a public figure; do not share anything you would rather keep private.
How confident are you that you can distinguish claimed identities from assigned categories and explain why official categories change?
Three Ways the Government Has Counted Race and Ethnicity
Fifteenth Census (1930) and Sixteenth Census (1940) Instructions to Enumerators; U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 Census informational questionnaire, Form DI-Q1 (2019); OMB Statistical Policy Directive No. 15, 89 Fed. Reg. 22182 (2024); worked model SLS original · Public domain (government documents); worked model SLS original
Why this reading. Your chart compares self-identification with three official category systems, and the lesson names the census and the 2024 federal revision without printing any of the official wording. This reading supplies the wording of three systems, so you can compare them line by line. What to look for: in each system, who does the classifying, what choices the form allows, and what happens to a person whose own account does not fit the boxes.
Content note. The 1930 and 1940 instructions use the labels of their time, including “Negro,” “Mexican” and “Hindu.” They appear here only inside quotations, because the way officials worded the rules is the evidence.
System A: the 1930 census, race written by the enumerator
In 1930 there was no box for a person to check. The census taker wrote a code in the “color or race” column, following printed instructions that were the same in every state, Missouri included. These are paragraphs 150, 151 and 154 of the instructions to enumerators for the Fifteenth Census (1930), as reproduced by the IPUMS project at the University of Minnesota:
150. Column 12. Color or race.—Write “W” for white; “Neg” for Negro; “Mex” for Mexican; “In” for Indian; “Ch” for Chinese; “Jp” for Japanese; “Fil” for Filipino; “Hin” for Hindu; and “Kor” for Korean. For a person of any other race, write the race in full.
151. Negroes.—A person of mixed white and Negro blood should be returned as a Negro, no matter how small the percentage of Negro blood. Both black and mulatto persons are to be returned as Negroes, without distinction.
154. Mexicans.—Practically all Mexican laborers are of a racial mixture difficult to classify, though usually well recognized in the localities where they are found. In order to obtain separate figures for this racial group, it has been decided that all person born in Mexico, or having parents born in Mexico, who are not definitely white, Negro, Indian, Chinese, or Japanese, should be returned as Mexican (“Mex”).
Notice four things. The person counted is never asked. “Mexican” sits in the same list as “Chinese” and “Negro,” although it names a country of origin. The rule for Black ancestry ignores the person’s own account and ignores how much of the person’s ancestry was Black: a single rule decides. And the Mexican rule is written by officials who admit the group is “difficult to classify” and then classify it anyway, “to obtain separate figures.” (“Hindu” was the census’s label for people from South Asia whatever their religion, a label from outside and not one the people claimed.)
System A, revised: the 1940 census
Ten years later the instructions changed. The Sixteenth Census (1940) enumerator instructions, also reproduced by IPUMS, say in paragraph 454:
Mexicans.—Mexicans are to be regarded as white unless definitely of Indian or other nonwhite race.
and in paragraph 455 the rule for Black ancestry is repeated almost word for word: “A person of mixed white and Negro blood should be returned as Negro, no matter how small a percentage of Negro blood.” The “Mexican” people had not changed between 1930 and 1940. The rule had. The “Negro” rule did not change, which shows that an official category can stay fixed while another one moves. Any statistic that compares the two censuses has to account for that.
A Missouri count to hold the system against. The Ville nomination to the National Register of Historic Places reports that in 1900 St. Louis had 575,235 residents, of whom 35,665 were African American, which is 6.2 percent (35,665 ÷ 575,235 = 0.0620). Behind that count are enumerators applying printed rules to each household. A count is only as good as the category behind it.
System B: two questions, 2020
The 2020 census form asks Hispanic origin and race in two separate questions, and says so in a note printed on the form: “Please answer BOTH Question 8 about Hispanic origin and Question 9 about race. For this census, Hispanic origins are not races.” The questions, as printed on the Census Bureau’s 2020 informational questionnaire (Form DI-Q1):
8. Is Person 1 of Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin?
No, not of Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin
Yes, Mexican, Mexican Am., Chicano
Yes, Puerto Rican
Yes, Cuban
Yes, another Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin — Print, for example, Salvadoran, Dominican, Colombian, Guatemalan, Spaniard, Ecuadorian, etc.9. What is Person 1’s race? Mark one or more boxes AND print origins.
White — Print, for example, German, Irish, English, Italian, Lebanese, Egyptian, etc.
Black or African Am. — Print, for example, African American, Jamaican, Haitian, Nigerian, Ethiopian, Somali, etc.
American Indian or Alaska Native — Print name of enrolled or principal tribe(s) …
Chinese, Vietnamese, Filipino, Korean, Asian Indian, Japanese, Other Asian (print, for example, Pakistani, Cambodian, Hmong, etc.)
Native Hawaiian, Samoan, Chamorro, Other Pacific Islander
Some other race — Print race or origin.
The Census Bureau explains the design on its website: “Persons who report themselves as Hispanic can be of any race.” The person now answers for themselves (or the household does), so the enumerator’s code is gone. But the form still limits the answer to the boxes it offers plus write-in lines. A person of Mexican descent who does not think of “Mexican” as a race must still choose among the race boxes or write something in.
System C: one combined question, 2024
On March 29, 2024, the Office of Management and Budget published revised Statistical Policy Directive No. 15 in the Federal Register (89 FR 22182-22196). It replaced the 1997 standard (the directive was first issued in 1977). It requires a single combined race and ethnicity question that lets respondents “select one category or multiple categories,” and it sets seven minimum categories: American Indian or Alaska Native; Asian; Black or African American; Hispanic or Latino; Middle Eastern or North African; Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander; and White. The directive defines the new category as “individuals with origins in any of the original peoples of the Middle East or North Africa, including, for example, Lebanese, Iranian, Egyptian, Syrian, Iraqi, and Israeli.” Its detailed categories name “Somali” under Black or African American, its examples for Asian write-ins include “Hmong,” and its White list names “Italian.” It asks that write-in fields let respondents “self-identify.” The effective date is March 28, 2024, and agencies must bring their data collections into compliance no later than March 28, 2029.
The public comments OMB summarized show disagreement, which is part of the evidence. Nearly all comments on the new category supported it, and commenters said the existing practice of classifying people from the region as White “does not reflect the reality of many who are MENA.” A few comments opposed it, saying some people from the region do consider themselves White, or that the government should not collect race and ethnicity data at all.
A worked model you can use directly (SLS original, invented people)
The three people below are made up for this course and describe no real person. Use them as your subject if you would rather not write about yourself or your family. Each row runs a made-up person through the three systems as they are printed above; the 1930 column is a thought experiment about what the rule would have written.
| Invented person | How they say it | 1930 system | 2020 system | 2024 system |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rosa, a Kansas Citian whose parents were born in Mexico | “Mexican American; I speak Spanish at home and my grandmother’s Zapotec with her.” | Written by the census taker as “Mex”: a race, chosen by an official. | Question 8: yes, Mexican. Question 9: her choice of the race boxes or a write-in. Her languages have no box. | One question; she may pick Hispanic or Latino and any other category that fits. Her Zapotec identity has no box of its own. |
| Sami, a St. Louisan whose grandparents came from Lebanon | “Lebanese American; my family is Maronite Christian.” | Written as “W.” Nothing in the record shows his ancestry. | White is the closest race box (the form lists Lebanese as a write-in example under White). | May select Middle Eastern or North African, so his community appears in the data as its own category. |
| Darius, whose family has lived in Missouri for generations, with white and Black ancestors on both sides | “I am Black and I know my white relatives too.” | Written as “Neg” under paragraph 151, however large or small the share of ancestry. | May mark more than one race box (“Mark one or more boxes”) and print origins. | May select more than one category in the single question. |
Each row shows the same thing from a different side: the person’s own account (column two) can stay the same across the decades, while the official category changes each time the rules are rewritten, and in 1930 it did not depend on the person’s own account at all. Neither category system is “false,” and neither is the person.
Four questions to ask of any category
- Who wrote it, and who fills it in: the person, a household member or an official?
- What choices does it allow, and what happens to a person the choices do not fit?
- What was it used for (representation, enforcement, funding, research)? The 2024 directive itself says its categories “are not to be used as determinants of eligibility for participation in any Federal program.”
- Who is missing, and how would anyone know?
Sources. Fifteenth Census of the United States: 1930, Instructions to Enumerators, paragraphs 150, 151 and 154; Sixteenth Census: 1940, Instructions to Enumerators, paragraphs 453-455 (both at usa.ipums.org/usa/voliii); U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 informational questionnaire, Form DI-Q1 (05-31-2019) and “About the Hispanic Population and its Origin” (census.gov); OMB, Revisions to OMB’s Statistical Policy Directive No. 15, 89 Fed. Reg. 22182 (Mar. 29, 2024); National Park Service, Historic and Architectural Resources of The Ville, St. Louis (multiple property form, 1999). All retrieved 2026-11-15. The worked model is SLS original.
Sources: IPUMS USA: 1930 Instructions to Enumerators (usa.ipums.org); IPUMS USA: 1940 Instructions to Enumerators (usa.ipums.org); U.S. Census Bureau: 2020 Census informational questionnaire (Form DI-Q1) (www2.census.gov); U.S. Census Bureau: About the Hispanic Population and its Origin (census.gov); Federal Register, 89 FR 22182 (March 29, 2024) (govinfo.gov); National Park Service, Historic and Architectural Resources of The Ville, St. Louis (1999), for the 1900 St. Louis count (npgallery.nps.gov)