
write and present an analytical portrait of a community I choose, explaining it through two of the unit’s key concepts, supported by a primary source and an attributed scholarly idea, and naming each concept’s limits.
Instruction
The Community Action Project runs through the whole semester. In Unit 4 you will choose an issue and act on it; that action will only be as good as your understanding of the community it serves. Phase 1 builds that understanding.
Choosing a community. A community can be a neighborhood, a school, a congregation, a language community, a group of workers, or an ethnic community in your city or region. You may choose your own, but you never have to. If you choose a community you do not belong to, rely on documented sources and describe the community as its members describe themselves.
What the portrait does. It is analytical, not a list of facts. It uses two key concepts from the unit — for example, race as a social construction and community cultural wealth, or intersectionality and systemic racism — to explain something about the community’s history or present. Every concept is attributed: who proposed it, and where.
Worked example of a thesis. Weak: “The Ville in St. Louis is important and has a rich history.” Stronger: “The Ville shows how exclusion and community cultural wealth worked together: restrictive covenants from 1911 helped make it a Black enclave, and within it residents built the churches, schools and institutions that later made it the center of the city’s Black culture.” The stronger thesis names the concepts, makes a claim that could be tested, and points to evidence a reader could check. (If you used it, you would have to confirm each part with sources; the reading for Lesson 1.4 gives you numbered evidence.)
The asset map. Show the community’s cultural wealth: organizations, languages, places, traditions, leaders and networks, each with its source. If you interview anyone, tell the person what the project is, ask permission to quote them, and let them decline.
Limits. Name one thing each concept cannot explain about your community. This is what distinguishes analysis from advocacy.
Scoring. The rubric scores your thesis, your evidence, your accurate use of concepts, your statement of limits, and your presentation. It never scores which community you chose or what you believe about it.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Community partners for the portraits
Portraits are stronger when someone who holds a community’s history speaks inside them. Which people and organizations are willing to be contacted is local knowledge.
A portrait is strongest when someone who holds a community’s history speaks inside it — but that is a person’s decision, never an assignment. So this lesson gives you three routes you can run from home. Never approach a stranger, an elder or an organization cold because a course asked you to. Two of the three routes need no interview at all, and all three earn exactly the same credit.
Your route — choose one. All three earn full credit.
- Route A — Oral histories that are already public — Search the StoryCorps Archive (archive.storycorps.org), an online collection of more than 425,000 recorded conversations that you can search by keyword, using your town, neighborhood or community name, and browse the oral histories among the digitized collections of the State Historical Society of Missouri (shsmo.org/collections/digital). Choose two interviews. For each, log the speaker, the date, the interviewer and three claims about this place, quote no more than a sentence, and cite it in full.
- Route B — The community’s own published record — Communities write their own histories: a mutual aid society’s anniversary book, a union local’s newsletter, a congregation’s centennial history, a cultural center’s exhibit catalog, a city’s own history. Look for three in the Missouri Historical Society‘s online collections (mohistory.org/collections), the Missouri Digital Heritage portal (sos.mo.gov/mdh), the digital gallery of the Black Archives of Mid-America in Kansas City (blackarchives.org), or your public library’s catalog; ask your library whether it can borrow what it does not own. Record each document’s author, date and publisher, and say in 150 words what the community chose to record about itself, and what a document written for a community’s own members shows that an outside account would not.
- Route C — An interview you arrange yourself, under this protocol — Optional, and only with someone already in your own life — a relative, a neighbor, an employer, a coach, someone at a place you already go — and with a parent or guardian knowing who it is. Before any question: say who you are, what the project is, where it will be shown and who will see it; say that they may decline any question, stop at any time, and ask you to remove anything afterward; say they may read any quotation before you submit it. Record their agreement in writing or at the top of the recording. Ask about places, work and events, not about trauma, immigration status or family conflict. You may decline this route for any reason, without explaining, and take Route A or B for identical credit — and if the person says no, that is the end of it, and you switch routes.
For the school — how this slot gets filled
Who holds this: Optional contributors: the Missouri Historical Society, the State Historical Society of Missouri, public libraries’ local-history rooms, the Black Archives of Mid-America in Kansas City, cultural centers and community organizations.
- Contributors take part only by choice; no portrait depends on any one person agreeing to be interviewed.
- Use the consent script in the reading before interviewing or quoting anyone, and let a parent or guardian know who you are speaking with.
- Keep any contact with community members through a parent or guardian.
- Agree attribution in writing, and honor any request to leave something out.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which thesis is strongest for the portrait?
To earn full credit, you must write about your own family.
How confident are you that you can write and present an analytical community portrait using two attributed concepts and their limits?
Submit: Community Asset Portrait (800-1,000 words) + asset map + 3-minute talk
Task: Write an analytical portrait of a community you choose, explaining its history or present through two of the unit’s key concepts. Use at least one primary source and one attributed scholarly concept, include an asset map, and state one limitation of each concept. Personal or family history is optional; a documented community or a public figure’s community earns the same credit.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Community chosen and why; two concepts with their authors; a working thesis; a source list with at least one primary source; your consent plan for any interview.
- Stage 2 — Self-reviewed draft. Check the draft against the self-review sheet in the reading, check that each concept is used accurately and attributed and that the thesis could be tested, and write a revision note. A parent or guardian may read it too.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. 800-1,000 words with citations, the asset map, and a limits paragraph.
- Stage 4 — Three-minute talk. Present the thesis and one piece of evidence, to family or recorded (equal credit).
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Thesis and analysis (WHST.9-10.2) | A testable claim that uses two key concepts to explain the community, developed through the essay. |
| Evidence (9-12.AH.1.CC.C / 9-12.AH.1.CC.D) | At least one primary source and one attributed scholarly concept, accurately cited. |
| Concepts and limits (ES.OUT3) | Concepts defined and attributed accurately; one limitation of each stated. |
| Community focus and respect (ES.OUT7, ES.GV1) | The community described in its own terms, with an asset map grounded in sources and, if you interviewed anyone, consent. |
| Revision (WHST.9-10.5) | The final shows substantive changes in response to your self-review. |
| Talk (SL.9-10.4) | Clear claim and evidence, organized for the audience, within time. |
Community Action Project, Phase 1: The Complete Brief, a Model Portrait of The Hill and the Self-Review Sheet
SLS original brief, model portrait, self-review sheet and consent script; model built from the City of St. Louis, The Hill Neighborhood Overview; U.S. Immigration Commission, Dictionary of Races or Peoples (Reports of the Immigration Commission, 1911); OMB Statistical Policy Directive No. 15, 89 Fed. Reg. 22182 (2024); Yosso (2005), paraphrased · SLS original (model built from public-domain government documents and a municipal web page)
Why this reading. Phase 1 is a four-stage project, and the lesson describes it but does not give you the brief in one place, a finished example, or a sheet for checking your own draft. This reading is the complete package: the brief and rubric, a planning template, a full model portrait with its asset map, the self-review sheet, a talk outline, an optional interview consent script and two ways to do the project without sharing anything personal. What to look for: how each rubric row is met in the model, so you can point to the same moves in your own work.
1. The brief
Task. Write an analytical portrait of a community you choose (800-1,000 words), explaining its history or present through two of the unit’s key concepts. Include at least one primary source and one attributed scholarly concept, an asset map, and one limitation of each concept. Present it in a three-minute talk to family or recorded (equal credit).
Stages. (1) Plan: the community and why, two concepts with their authors, a working thesis, a source list with at least one primary source, and your consent plan for any interview. (2) Self-reviewed draft: you check the draft against the self-review sheet below, optionally have a parent or guardian read it, and write a revision note. (3) Revised final: 800-1,000 words with citations, the asset map and a limits paragraph. (4) Talk: thesis plus one piece of evidence.
Key concepts to choose from (attributed). Race as an assigned, changing category (Lessons 1.1 and 1.2; the 2024 federal standard itself says its categories “are understood to be socio-political constructs”); systemic racism (inequality produced by laws and institutions, as in the housing record of Lesson 1.3); intersectionality (Crenshaw, 1989); community cultural wealth (Yosso, 2005).
| Rubric row | Full credit means |
|---|---|
| Thesis and analysis | A testable claim that uses two key concepts to explain the community, developed through the essay. |
| Evidence | At least one primary source and one attributed scholarly concept, accurately cited. |
| Concepts and limits | Concepts defined and attributed accurately; one limitation of each stated. |
| Community focus and respect | The community described in its own terms, with an asset map grounded in sources and, if you interviewed anyone, consent. |
| Revision | The final shows substantive changes in response to your self-review (and any reader’s comments). |
| Talk | Clear claim and evidence, organized for the audience, within time. |
The rubric scores none of these: which community you chose, whether it is yours, or what you believe about it.
2. Two ways to do the project without sharing anything personal
Route 1: use the model as your subject. The model below is a complete portrait of a documented community. You may not hand it in, but you may choose the same community and use the evidence in it, provided you choose your own thesis, at least one concept different from the model’s, and write your own sentences. (The Ville and 18th & Vine, from Lesson 1.4, are two more documented communities you can use the same way.)
Route 2: a community documented in public sources. A neighborhood, a school, a workplace, a language community or a movement described in a published history, a court record, a census table, a National Park Service document or a city’s own web page. You need no interview and no personal information.
3. A model portrait (SLS original; built from public documents)
This model is SLS original writing. It describes The Hill, the Italian American neighborhood of south St. Louis, using three public documents, and invents nothing about any living person. It does not say anything about what any family on the Hill experienced beyond what those documents say.
Thesis. The Hill shows two things about one community at once. The government’s own label for its Italian immigrants was a made category, one that split Italians into two “races” in 1911 and appears nowhere in today’s federal standard. The community’s own social and familial wealth, a neighborhood that became self-supporting and a club that members bought a building for, is documented in the city’s own record. That the label changed while the neighborhood’s institutions are named in public records points to which evidence is the steadier.
The community. The City of St. Louis says that before the Civil War immigrants of German and Irish origin came to the Hill to mine its clay, that African Americans joined the community, and that after the Evens and Howard Fire Brick Company and clay mines opened in 1854-55, more than a dozen brick and tile factories rose along the River Des Peres. Between the 1880s and 1924 Italian immigrants outnumbered the other groups there. In the days of the mining camp most of the Italians were men who lived in boarding houses; eventually they “arranged for their families to join them” and the neighborhood became “self-supporting,” with work, shopping, socializing, church and school all within it (City of St. Louis, The Hill Neighborhood Overview).
Concept 1: race as an assigned, changing category. In 1911 the Immigration Commission’s Dictionary of Races or Peoples listed the “races or peoples” in the classification the Bureau of Immigration and Naturalization used for statistics, and in that list “Italian, North” and “Italian, South” are separate entries (Immigration Commission, 1911). The 2024 federal standard reaches a different result: it lists “Italian” once, among examples under White (OMB, 2024), and says its categories “are understood to be socio-political constructs.” The same people were two categories in one system and one in the other, which is what an assigned category looks like.
Concept 2: community cultural wealth. Yosso (2005) names familial capital, knowledge and care carried by kin, and social capital, networks of people and community resources, for which she gives mutual aid societies as an example. The men who sent for their families and the neighborhood that became self-supporting fit familial and social capital as the City describes them. The “Big Club,” where members played cards and bocce and which grew into a neighborhood community center, bought a building at Shaw and Marconi in 1929 (City of St. Louis), is a documented example of a network that owned something together.
Limits. The 1911 list shows that the federal government classified Italians in two groups; it does not show what that classification meant for any family on the Hill, and I have not found a source that links the two, so I make no claim about its effect. Community cultural wealth explains how the neighborhood held together, but the City’s page is a short summary, mostly about institutions and events, and it contains almost none of residents’ own words. The same page also records a loss that the framework does not explain: in the early 1970s the building of Interstate 44 destroyed 98 of the Hill’s homes and isolated 450 residents from the heart of the neighborhood.
Why it matters. Read together, the two records show that an official category is something a government made and later changed, while a neighborhood’s institutions are what its members built, and a portrait should keep the two apart.
(The model above is compressed to show every move; your final draft is 800-1,000 words and develops each paragraph with more evidence.)
Asset map for the model (each asset with its source).
| Asset | Form of wealth | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Work in the clay mines and brick and tile factories | Economic | City of St. Louis, Hill overview |
| Men sending for their families | Familial | Same |
| A neighborhood with work, shopping, socializing, church and school all inside it | Social | Same |
| The Big Club, which bought a building in 1929 | Social | Same |
| Loss: 98 homes destroyed and 450 residents isolated by Interstate 44 (early 1970s) | Not a form of wealth; a limit the framework cannot explain | Same |
4. Planning template (Stage 1), filled for the model
- Community and why: The Hill, St. Louis, Italian American neighborhood; documented in a city record and a federal classification.
- Two concepts and authors: race as an assigned, changing category (the unit’s census lesson; OMB 2024 text); community cultural wealth (Yosso, 2005).
- Working thesis: as above.
- Sources: primary, the Immigration Commission’s Dictionary of Races or Peoples (1911) and the OMB directive; scholarly, Yosso; a second primary source would strengthen it (for example a census table, an oral history or a church history).
- Consent plan: none needed; no interviews.
5. Self-review sheet (Stage 2): answer each yourself, or have a parent or guardian answer them
- State the thesis in one sentence. Could two careful researchers disagree with it?
- Is each concept defined in your own words and attributed to its author and year?
- Point to the primary source. Is a quotation or fact from it cited exactly?
- Does the asset map name a source for every asset?
- Is there a limitation for each concept, and is it real, not a compliment?
- Is the community described in its own terms, without exaggeration?
- One thing to cut and one thing to add.
Then write a revision note: two changes made because of this review, and one suggestion you did not take, with the reason.
6. Talk outline (three minutes)
0:00-0:30 name the community and the thesis. 0:30-1:30 one piece of evidence, read aloud. 1:30-2:30 how the two concepts explain it. 2:30-3:00 one limit and one sentence on why it matters. Give the talk to family, or record it for yourself and watch it back.
7. If you interview someone (optional; with a parent or guardian’s knowledge)
An interview is never required, and a project with no interview earns the same credit. If you choose one, choose someone already in your life, and let a parent or guardian know who it is and what you are asking. Say: “I am doing a school project on the history of [community]. May I ask you some questions? I would like to quote you by first name only, or not at all, and you may see anything I write about what you said. You can stop at any time or decline any question.” Write down what they agree to. Do not include anything they ask you to leave out. Ask about places, work and events, not about trauma, immigration status or family conflict.
Sources. City of St. Louis, The Hill Neighborhood Overview (stlouis-mo.gov); U.S. Immigration Commission, Dictionary of Races or Peoples (Reports of the Immigration Commission, 1911; Internet Archive scan); Federal Register, 89 FR 22182 (Mar. 29, 2024); Yosso (2005), paraphrased and cited. All retrieved 2026-11-15. Brief, rubric and stages: this course’s Phase 1 specification; model, templates and scripts: SLS original.
Sources: City of St. Louis, The Hill Neighborhood Overview (stlouis-mo.gov); U.S. Immigration Commission, Dictionary of Races or Peoples (Reports of the Immigration Commission, 1911), Internet Archive scan (archive.org); Federal Register, 89 FR 22182 (March 29, 2024), OMB Statistical Policy Directive No. 15 (govinfo.gov); Tara J. Yosso (2005), Whose Culture Has Capital? Race Ethnicity and Education 8(1), 69-91 (paraphrased) (doi.org)