THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP Ethnic Studies — Identity, History and Community Action in Missouri and the Nation

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 20 Lessons
  • 10 Weeks
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: Identity, Community and Key Concepts
    5
    • 1.1
      Who Am I, and Who Decides? Identity, Ethnicity and Race
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Race in the Law — Who Counted as a Citizen? From Dred Scott to Thind
      50 mins
    • 1.3
      Written Dialogue — Systemic Racism and Intersectionality in St. Louis
      50 mins
    • 1.4
      Writing Workshop — Community Cultural Wealth and Asset Framing
      50 mins
    • 1.5
      Community Action Project, Phase 1 — Community Asset Portrait
      150 mins
  • Unit 2: Land, Citizenship and Equal Protection in Missouri
    5
    • 2.1
      Native Missouri — The Osage, Missouria and Illinois Nations
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Treaty Promises — The Osage Treaties and the Indian Removal Act
      50 mins
    • 2.3
      Dialogue Lab — How Should Missouri Name and Remember the Removal of Native Nations?
      50 mins
    • 2.4
      Writing Workshop — Black Missourians and the Courts
      50 mins
    • 2.5
      Community Action Project, Phase 2 — Documented History Brief
      150 mins
  • Unit 3: Exclusion, Incarceration and Belonging
    5
    • 3.1
      Exclusion and Belonging — Chinese St. Louis, Hop Alley and the Law
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Executive Order 9066 and Korematsu — Reading the Order and the Court
      50 mins
    • 3.3
      Dialogue Lab — Many Communities, Distinct Histories, Shared Questions
      50 mins
    • 3.4
      Writing Workshop — Empire, Expansion and the Philippine Reservation at St. Louis in 1904
      50 mins
    • 3.5
      Community Action Project, Phase 3 — Multiple-Perspectives Issue Brief
      150 mins
  • Unit 4: Movements, Civic Participation and Community Action
    5
    • 4.1
      How Movements Work — Sharecroppers, Jefferson Bank, the Arch and the Rent Strike
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Apology and Redress — Reading the Civil Liberties Act of 1988 and Missouri’s Own Record
      50 mins
    • 4.3
      Dialogue Lab — Race-Conscious Policy, From Missouri v. Jenkins to the 2023 Admissions Decision
      50 mins
    • 4.4
      Workshop — The Tools of Civic Participation and the Action Plan
      50 mins
    • 4.5
      Community Action Project, Phase 4 — Action, Showcase and Reflection
      200 mins

Dialogue Lab — Race-Conscious Policy, From Missouri v. Jenkins to the 2023 Admissions Decision

Unit 4  ·  Dialogue & Multiple Perspectives Lab  ·  Lesson 18 of 20

Dialogue Lab — Race-Conscious Policy, From Missouri v. Jenkins to the 2023 Admissions Decision

ES.OUT8RLP-ETHNIC
A balanced scale and court opinions with a campus quad in the window.
By the end of this lesson I can…

explain the Supreme Court’s decisions in Missouri v. Jenkins (1995) and the 2023 admissions case, evaluate how far Supreme Court cases expanded or limited equal rights, represent the strongest arguments for and against race-conscious policy in their holders’ terms, and practice a written dialogue that distinguishes valid from fallacious arguments.

Instruction

Few questions divide Americans more evenly, or more across group lines, than whether government may take race into account to remedy inequality or promote diversity. This lab asks you to understand the strongest arguments on each side, in the words of the people who make them. You will not be asked which side you are on, and your work is judged only on how fairly and precisely you reason.

A Missouri case, 1995. Missouri v. Jenkins grew out of a suit filed in 1977 alleging that the State and others had caused and perpetuated segregation in the Kansas City area’s schools. By 1995 the case had cost hundreds of millions of dollars, and the Supreme Court, by a vote of 5 to 4, held that the trial court’s orders exceeded its remedial authority because they aimed to attract students from outside the Kansas City schools to a problem found inside them. Justice Thomas wrote separately that courts should not assume that a predominantly Black school is inferior. Justice Ginsburg, dissenting, traced Missouri’s own laws: an 1847 law barring schools for Black children, an 1865 constitution that permitted and an 1875 constitution that required separate schools, and the repeal of the statutes in 1957 and the rescinding of the constitutional provision in 1976. She concluded that ending desegregation efforts then was “too swift and too soon.”

A national case, 2023. In Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard and a companion case against the University of North Carolina, decided June 29, 2023, the Court held that the universities’ race-conscious admissions programs violated the Equal Protection Clause. Chief Justice Roberts wrote: “Eliminating racial discrimination means eliminating all of it.” Justice Sotomayor, dissenting, wrote that the Court “rolls back decades of precedent and momentous progress,” and Justice Jackson wrote that there is no requirement that institutions remedying their legacies of exclusion operate “with a blindfold.”

Position A, as its holders state it. The Equal Protection Clause protects individuals, not groups. Race-based decisions need measurable objectives and an end point, may not use race in a negative way and may not rely on stereotypes; a remedy has to fit the violation actually found; and courts should not assume that a predominantly Black school is inferior. Supporters include the Court’s majority in both cases.

Position B, as its holders state it. State-enforced segregation, including Missouri’s, has effects that continue; race-conscious steps have advanced the promise of equality and of Brown v. Board of Education; and institutions repairing their own histories of exclusion should not have to act blindfolded. Supporters include the dissenting justices.

How far did the Supreme Court expand equal rights? Evaluate each decision in your table: what the opinion itself says and the extent to which it expanded or limited equal rights. The two sides will answer differently, and the table asks for your reading of the words, with no required conclusion.

Valid and fallacious arguments (9-12.AH.1.CC.B / 9-12.AH.1.CC.D). Watch for fallacies on every side: ad hominem (“Only people who want to keep inequality support that opinion”; “Only people who want an advantage oppose it”), straw man (misstating the other view to refute it easily), and hasty generalization (“Everyone in group X thinks Y”). A valid argument states a premise you can check and a conclusion that follows.

Norms. Restate before responding. Tie claims to evidence. Question ideas, never people or groups. You may argue a position you do not hold, or explain why you are undecided. People of every background hold both views; no one speaks for a group. Your work is for you and, if you choose, a parent or guardian; nobody has to agree with it.

📖 Read for this lesson

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.

  • Two Supreme Court Opinions on Race-Conscious Policy: Missouri v. Jenkins (1995) and SFFA v. Harvard (2023)Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (1995); Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. 181 (2023), slip opinion; table, examples and model exchange SLS original · about 9 min

    Passages from Missouri v. Jenkins (Kansas City schools, 1995) and the 2023 admissions decision in the justices’ own words, the two positions as their holders state them, a table for judging how far each case expanded equal rights, fallacy examples and a model written restate-then-respond exchange.

Reading: Three passages on race-conscious policy

Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (1995) (opinion of the Court and opinion of Justice Ginsburg, dissenting); Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College (2023), opinion of Chief Justice Roberts · Public domain

All three passages are short. Before responding, restate each in your own words.

Missouri v. Jenkins (1995), opinion of the Court: The Court wrote that the trial court’s plan was aimed at an “inter district goal” that “is beyond the scope of the intra district violation identified by the District Court.”

Justice Ginsburg, dissenting: Given the deep, inglorious history of segregation in Missouri, to curtail desegregation at this time and in this manner is an action at once too swift and too soon.

SFFA (Roberts, 2023): Eliminating racial discrimination means eliminating all of it.

Vocabulary in context

  • race-conscious policy — A policy that takes race into account, for example in admissions, school assignment, hiring or contracting.
  • race-neutral alternative — A policy aimed at similar goals without using race, such as income-based outreach.
  • steel-man — Stating an opposing argument in its strongest form, the opposite of a straw man.
  • ad hominem — A fallacy that attacks a person or group instead of their argument.
  • straw man — A fallacy that misrepresents an opposing view so it is easier to refute.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

Which statement is an ad hominem fallacy?

It attacks the motives of the people who hold a view instead of engaging their argument.

Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.5.GS.C

Myth or Fact?

In Missouri v. Jenkins (1995), the Supreme Court found that no segregation had ever existed in the Kansas City schools.

The Court’s opinion describes the trial court’s finding that the State had operated a segregated system before 1954; the dispute was over how far the remedy could go.

Missouri standard: 9-12.AH.5.GS.C

+50 XP

Which is a fair statement of Position B?

A steel-man states the argument as its holders would.

Write (or record to yourself) a 90-second contribution on the question: Should public institutions be allowed to consider race to remedy past discrimination or promote diversity? You may argue either side, or explain why you are undecided, using one piece of evidence from the reading. Then write two replies to positions in the reading: restate the position in words its holder would accept, then identify one strong premise in it and one question you would ask about its evidence.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can state both sides of the race-conscious policy debate fairly and spot fallacies?

Not yetVery confident

Missouri Learning Standards — Social Studies addressed: 9-12.AH.1.CC.D, 9-12.AH.1.PC.A, 9-12.AH.1.CC.B, SL.9-10.1, SL.9-10.3, RH.9-10.6, 9-12.AH.5.GS.C

Instructional focus: Structured dialogue on a contested constitutional and policy question

Reading

Two Supreme Court Opinions on Race-Conscious Policy: Missouri v. Jenkins (1995) and SFFA v. Harvard (2023)

Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (1995); Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. 181 (2023), slip opinion; table, examples and model exchange SLS original · Public domain (Supreme Court opinions); table, examples and model exchange SLS original

Why this reading. The dialogue lab asks you to restate each side of a contested question in its holders’ terms, and to judge arguments as valid or fallacious. The lesson summarizes two Supreme Court decisions in a few paragraphs, so you have little of the Court’s own language to work from. This reading prints passages from both opinions in the justices’ own words: a Missouri case about school desegregation in Kansas City (Missouri v. Jenkins, 1995) and the 2023 admissions decision (Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard), with the facts each opinion gives, a table for judging how far each case expanded or limited equal rights, a list of fallacy examples, and a model written exchange. What to look for: the strongest sentence in each opinion for each side, the facts each opinion relies on, and the point at which two opinions disagree about what the facts mean. Content note: the opinions use the terms of their time, including “black” and “minority.”

1. Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (argued January 11, 1995; decided June 12, 1995)

What the case was about. Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote the opinion of the Court, joined by Justices O’Connor, Scalia, Kennedy and Thomas, and the vote was 5–4. The opinion says the case had been before the same federal judge since 1977, when the Kansas City, Missouri, school system, its board and the children of two board members sued the State of Missouri and others, alleging that they had caused and perpetuated racial segregation in the schools of the Kansas City area. The opinion gives these facts about the case as it then stood: the trial court had found the State operated a segregated system before 1954; it identified “25 racially identifiable schools with a population of over 90% black students” and a system-wide drop in student achievement; enrollment was 68.3 percent Black; the cost of the quality-education programs had “exceeded $220 million”; and total desegregation costs were “approaching an annual cost of $200 million.” The State asked the Supreme Court to rule on two orders: salary increases for virtually all staff, and continued funding of quality-education programs.

The majority’s reasoning (Position A, here). The Court held that the trial court’s orders were beyond its remedial authority. The Court wrote that the trial court’s plan was not “designed solely to redistribute the students within” the Kansas City schools, and continued: “Instead, its purpose is to attract nonminority students from outside the KCMSD schools. But this inter district goal is beyond the scope of the intra district violation identified by the District Court.” It also wrote: “The ultimate inquiry is ‘whether the [constitutional violator] ha[s] complied in good faith with the desegregation decree since it was entered, and whether the vestiges of past discrimination ha[ve] been eliminated to the extent practicable.’” (The bracketed letters are the Court’s own editing of a quotation from an earlier case.)

Justice Thomas, concurring. “It never ceases to amaze me that the courts are so willing to assume that anything that is predominantly black must be inferior. Instead of focusing on remedying the harm done to those black schoolchildren injured by segregation, the District Court here sought to convert the Kansas City, Missouri, School District (KCMSD) into a ‘magnet district’ that would reverse the ‘white flight’ caused by desegregation.”

Justice Souter, dissenting, joined by Justices Stevens, Ginsburg and Breyer. Souter’s first objection is about process: “The Court’s process of orderly adjudication has broken down in this case.” He argues the Court decided a foundational issue the parties were not warned would be decided.

Justice Ginsburg, dissenting (Position B, here). Ginsburg writes about Missouri’s own history. She states that Missouri entered the Union in 1821 as a slave state, and that “Before the Civil War, Missouri law prohibited the creation or maintenance of schools for educating blacks” (quoting an 1847 Missouri law). She writes that Missouri laws beginning in 1865 required separate public schools for Black children and that the Missouri constitutions of 1865 and 1875 first permitted and then required separate schools. After Brown v. Board of Education (1954), she writes, Missouri’s Attorney General declared the segregation provisions unenforceable, the statutes were repealed in 1957 and the constitutional provision was rescinded in 1976. She then concludes: “Given the deep, inglorious history of segregation in Missouri, to curtail desegregation at this time and in this manner is an action at once too swift and too soon.”

2. Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. 181 (argued October 31, 2022; decided June 29, 2023)

The case and the vote. Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion of the Court, joined by Justices Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Barrett. The Court decided two cases together, one against Harvard and one against the University of North Carolina; Justice Jackson took no part in the Harvard case, so that vote was 6–2, and the North Carolina vote was 6–3. The Court held that the admissions programs could not be reconciled with the Equal Protection Clause.

The majority (Position A). “Eliminating racial discrimination means eliminating all of it.” And in conclusion: “Both programs lack sufficiently focused and measurable objectives warranting the use of race, unavoidably employ race in a negative manner, involve racial stereotyping, and lack meaningful end points.” The majority also wrote that “as all parties agree, nothing in this opinion should be construed as prohibiting universities from considering an applicant’s discussion of how race affected his or her life, be it through discrimination, inspiration, or otherwise.”

The dissents (Position B). Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Kagan (and by Justice Jackson in the North Carolina case): “Today, this Court stands in the way and rolls back decades of precedent and momentous progress.” Justice Jackson, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Kagan, in the North Carolina case: “In a society where race continues to matter, there is no constitutional requirement that institutions attempting to remedy their legacies of racial exclusion must operate with a blindfold.”

3. How far did Supreme Court cases expand equal rights? A table to complete

CaseWhat the Court decided (from the opinion)Expanded or limited equal rights? Cite one sentence.
Brown v. Board of Education (1954)As described in Jenkins and the SFFA majority and dissents: the Court’s decision against segregated public schools, followed by Missouri’s Attorney General declaring its school segregation provisions unenforceable (Ginsburg)Your judgment, with one sentence from this reading
Missouri v. Jenkins (1995)The trial court’s plan to attract students from outside Kansas City exceeded its authority; the remedy must address the violation foundYour judgment, with one sentence from this reading
SFFA v. Harvard (2023)Harvard’s and North Carolina’s race-conscious admissions programs violated the Equal Protection ClauseYour judgment, with one sentence from this reading

The two sides read the same cases differently. Position A says the cases protect the individual from being treated differently by race; Position B says they carry out the promise of Brown. Your table should record what each opinion says, then your own evaluation of the extent to which each decision expanded or limited equal rights, supported by the opinion’s words, with no required conclusion.

4. The two positions in their holders’ terms (use these words, not a paraphrase of someone else)

Position A (SFFA majority; Justice Thomas in Jenkins). The Equal Protection Clause protects individuals; race-based decisions require a measurable purpose and an end point and may not use race in a negative way or stereotype; a remedy must fit the violation actually found; and courts should not assume that a school that is predominantly Black is inferior.

Position B (SFFA dissents; Justice Ginsburg in Jenkins). The history of state-enforced segregation, including Missouri’s own, has effects that continue; race-conscious steps have advanced the promise of equality and of Brown; and requiring institutions to ignore race when they are trying to remedy their own histories of exclusion is not constitutionally required.

5. Valid and fallacious arguments: examples (SLS original)

  • Ad hominem: “Only people who want to keep schools unequal support the Court’s opinion.” / “Only people who want an advantage support race-conscious policy.” Each attacks motives instead of premises.
  • Straw man: “The dissenters say merit does not matter.” The dissents quoted here do not say that; the example restates a position in a form nobody holds.
  • Hasty generalization: “Every Missouri family in the Kansas City area supports the plan.” Nothing in the opinions supports a claim about every person in a group.
  • A valid argument: “The trial court sought to attract students from outside the Kansas City schools; the violation it found was inside the Kansas City schools; a remedy must be tied to the violation; therefore the plan exceeded the violation.” (That is the majority’s argument as stated in the opinion; whether the premises are all true is what the dissenters dispute.)

6. A model written exchange (SLS original; restate, then respond)

Question: Should public institutions be allowed to consider race to remedy past discrimination? My restatement of Position B, in words I think its holders would accept: “Justice Ginsburg argues that because Missouri law required and then enforced separate schools until 1957 and 1976, ending desegregation efforts in Kansas City was ‘too swift and too soon.’ Justice Sotomayor argues that race-conscious admissions policies had advanced the Constitution’s guarantee of equality.” One strong premise in it: the premise that Missouri’s own laws created the segregation is supported by the dates Justice Ginsburg gives, which come from Missouri laws and constitutions. One question about the evidence: the majority in Jenkins says the remedy must be tied to the violation found, so what evidence shows that the programs the trial court ordered, such as higher salaries for all staff, were tied to that violation? My restatement of Position A: “Chief Justice Roberts argues that the Equal Protection Clause applies to every individual, so a program that uses race in a negative way and has no end point cannot stand; Justice Thomas adds that courts should not assume a predominantly Black school is inferior.” One strong premise: that a remedy must match the harm found. One question: if the harm found was decades of state-required segregation, what does the Court’s opinion say counts as a remedy that matches it?

Sources. Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (1995), Cornell Legal Information Institute; Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. 181 (2023), slip opinion, supremecourt.gov (the dissent passages are quoted from the slip opinion, whose pages differ from the bound volume); retrieved 2026-11-15. Court opinions are public documents. The table, the fallacy examples and the model exchange are SLS original.

Sources: Missouri v. Jenkins, 515 U.S. 70 (1995), Cornell Legal Information Institute (law.cornell.edu); Students for Fair Admissions v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, Nos. 20-1199 and 21-707 (2023), slip opinion, supremecourt.gov (supremecourt.gov)

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Apology and Redress — Reading the Civil Liberties Act of 1988 and Missouri’s Own Record
Prev
Workshop — The Tools of Civic Participation and the Action Plan
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content