
choose a current, actionable issue affecting the community I have studied, explain its history and present data, represent at least three stakeholder perspectives fairly, and recommend a lawful, non-partisan action.
Instruction
Phase 3 is where your project turns toward action. You will choose a current issue affecting the community you have studied, investigate it as a researcher, and write the kind of brief that a library board member or city staff member would find useful: accurate, sourced and fair to everyone affected.
Choosing an issue. A good issue is current, local and actionable by someone you can reach: a school, a city or county, a library, a community organization. Examples: English classes and translated notices for newcomers; preserving or marking a historic site, such as the place where a neighborhood stood; a public memorial or place name; mental health resources for refugee students; a community garden; recording and archiving elders’ oral histories. Avoid issues that can only be settled by a national election. Your project must never campaign for or against a candidate or ballot measure; Missouri law, in Section 115.646 of the Revised Statutes, bars public officers and employees from using public funds for that purpose, and your project should keep the same line.
Stakeholders. A stakeholder is anyone affected by or able to affect the issue: residents, students, families, business owners, officials, community organizations, taxpayers. Represent at least three perspectives. For each, give the position, the reasons and evidence its holders give, and what they fear or hope. Apply the test from every dialogue lab: would a holder of this view sign your summary of it?
Worked example. The reading’s model brief invents a Missouri city, Rivermoor, and asks whether its library should offer evening English classes and translated notices. It anchors the issue in two real statutes: Section 1.028, which recognizes English as “the common language used in Missouri” and says fluency “is necessary for full integration,” and Section 660.025, which provides grants, subject to appropriation, for programs that arrange “day care, transportation or other services” so that refugees and immigrants can reach English language services. The model states three perspectives (families learning English, city staff watching cost, residents who emphasize fluency) and then recommends a time-limited pilot with a count. The recommendation can be your own view or not; it is scored on reasoning, not on the cause.
Data. Use present data from public sources (Census Bureau and American Community Survey tables, Missouri state education reports, city reports) and state the year. If a number is illustrative, say so.
Scoring. The rubric scores accuracy, fairness to stakeholders, the logic of the recommendation and your presentation. It never scores which issue you picked or which side you favor, and you never have to share personal or family information.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which issue fits the project’s rules best?
You may recommend an action you do not personally favor, and your brief is scored the same way.
How confident are you that you can write a fair, sourced issue brief with a non-partisan recommendation?
Submit: Multiple-Perspectives Issue Brief (900-1,200 words) + 5-minute stakeholder presentation
Task: Choose a current, actionable issue affecting your community. Explain its history and present data, represent at least three stakeholder perspectives fairly, and recommend a lawful, non-partisan action you will take in Phase 4. Your own position is never graded, and you never have to write about your own family.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Issue proposal. The issue, who can act on it, three stakeholders, a source list with at least one data source, and a note confirming the project is non-partisan.
- Stage 2 — Self-checked draft. Check each stakeholder section against the self-check sheet in the reading (a parent or guardian may also read it and say whether each stakeholder sounds fair), and write a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. 900-1,200 words with citations, dated data and the recommendation.
- Stage 4 — Stakeholder presentation. Present for two minutes, then answer one written question for each perspective, aloud to your family or on a recording (equal credit).
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Issue and history (9-12.AH.1.G.B) | A current, actionable issue connected accurately to its history. |
| Stakeholder perspectives (WHST.9-10.1.b, ES.OUT4) | At least three perspectives, each stated in terms its holders would accept, with evidence. |
| Sources and data (WHST.9-10.8) | Credible, cited sources and dated data; illustrative numbers labeled. |
| Recommendation (WHST.9-10.1) | A lawful, non-partisan action that follows logically from the evidence. |
| Civic purpose (ES.OUT6) | Names who can act and how the community can take part. |
| Presentation defense (SL.9-10.4) | Answers the written question for each perspective with evidence and respect. |
Phase 3 Kit: The Issue Brief, the Fairness Test and a Model Brief Anchored in Two Missouri Statutes
Revised Statutes of Missouri, Sections 1.028, 660.025 and 115.646 (revisor.mo.gov), retrieved 2026-11-15; brief, stages, rubric, model brief, fairness test and self-check sheet SLS original · SLS original (the Missouri statutes quoted are public law)
Why this reading. Phase 3 is a 900-1,200 word issue brief with three fairly stated stakeholder perspectives, dated data and a lawful non-partisan recommendation, presented to family or recorded. The lesson describes the task and gives a short example, but no complete brief, no way to check that a stakeholder would accept your summary, no rule for labeling numbers and no self-check sheet. This reading has all of them: the brief and rubric, a full model brief on an invented Missouri city anchored in two real Missouri statutes, the fairness test, the data rules and a self-check sheet. What to look for: how each stakeholder is stated in terms its holders would sign, how numbers are labeled, and how the recommendation follows from the evidence rather than from the writer’s preference.
1. The brief
Task. Choose a current, actionable issue affecting your community. Explain its history and present data, represent at least three stakeholder perspectives fairly, and recommend a lawful, non-partisan action you will take in Phase 4. Your own position is never graded.
Stages. (1) Issue proposal: the issue, who can act on it, three stakeholders, a source list with at least one data source, and a note confirming the project is non-partisan. (2) Self-checked draft: write each stakeholder section, then check it against the self-check sheet in Part 6; a parent or guardian may also read it and tell you whether each stakeholder sounds fair, and you write a revision note. (3) Revised final: 900-1,200 words with citations, dated data and the recommendation. (4) Stakeholder presentation: two minutes presenting, then answers to one written question for each perspective, given to your family or recorded (equal credit).
| Rubric row | Full credit means |
|---|---|
| Issue and history | A current, actionable issue connected accurately to its history. |
| Stakeholder perspectives | At least three perspectives, each stated in terms its holders would accept, with evidence. |
| Sources and data | Credible, cited sources and dated data; illustrative numbers labeled. |
| Recommendation | A lawful, non-partisan action that follows logically from the evidence. |
| Civic purpose | Names who can act and how the community can take part. |
| Presentation defense | Answers the written question for each perspective with evidence and respect. |
2. Rules your issue must meet
- Actionable by someone you can reach (a school, city, county, library or community organization), not only by a national election.
- Non-partisan. Missouri Revised Statutes Section 115.646 provides:
This course’s projects use no public funds and take no side in elections, but the statute shows the line a public body must keep, and your brief should keep it too: it may inform and present options; it may not campaign.No contribution or expenditure of public funds shall be made directly by any officer, employee, or agent of any political subdivision, special district, or … to advocate, support, or oppose the passage or defeat of any ballot measure or the nomination or election of any candidate for public office
- No invented facts. Numbers must be sourced, or labeled “illustrative.”
- Personal information is optional. You never have to write about your own family. Stakeholder voices come from public records, published statements, or an interview with consent, if you choose to do one.
3. The fairness test for a stakeholder section
Write each position in the third person, as its holders would. Then ask: Would a member of this group sign this summary? A section passes if it (a) states the position and the reasons its holders give, (b) names the evidence they rely on, (c) says what they fear or hope, and (d) avoids words that only opponents would use. Do not include a perspective only to knock it down.
4. A model brief (SLS original; the city, the numbers and the speakers are invented)
This model is SLS original writing about “Rivermoor,” a made-up Missouri city that does not exist. All Rivermoor figures are illustrative and are labeled as such. The two laws cited are real, quoted from the Revised Statutes of Missouri on revisor.mo.gov, retrieved 2026-11-15.
Issue. Should Rivermoor’s public library, with the city’s support, offer evening English classes and translated notices for families who are new to English? Who can act: the library board and the city council, by vote at a public meeting.
History and law. Missouri Revised Statutes Section 1.028, “English is the common language of Missouri,” says in full:
The general assembly recognizes that English is the common language used in Missouri and recognizes that fluency in English is necessary for full integration into our common American culture for reading readiness.
Section 660.025 provides that, “Subject to appropriation from general revenue,” the director of social services
shall offer grants, on a competitive basis, to programs which are engaged in the resettling of refugees and legal immigrants for the purpose of arranging for day care, transportation or other services that will facilitate a refugee’s or immigrant’s accessing of English language services.
Section 1.028 recognizes a fact and a goal; it does not forbid or require translated notices. Section 660.025 supports services around English classes (day care, transportation) through grants to resettlement programs, subject to appropriation; it does not itself create classes or require a city to provide them. Other laws may apply, and a real brief would check. The question here is whether Rivermoor should.
Data (illustrative; not a real city). An illustrative 14 percent of Rivermoor residents were born outside the United States (illustrative Census-style survey, 2025). The library’s English class has an illustrative 40 adults on its waiting list and meets only on weekday mornings. An illustrative 9 of the last 10 city council meetings had no public comment from a resident who said English was a second language.
Perspective 1: families learning English (invented summary). Classes only on weekday mornings exclude people who work days or lack child care; evening classes with child care and a bus route would let them learn faster. They point to the state’s own recognition, in Section 660.025, that day care and transportation are what stand between people and English classes. Translated notices let them follow school and city information while they learn. What they hope: to learn English and take part. What they fear: a program that exists on paper but is held when they cannot attend.
Perspective 2: city staff and council members focused on cost (invented summary). They support the goal and point out that the state grants in Section 660.025 go to resettlement programs and are subject to appropriation, so the city cannot count on them. They favor partnering with an existing nonprofit rather than building a city program, and translating only essential notices first. What they fear: a commitment the budget cannot sustain. What they hope: a measured start with a report on cost and use.
Perspective 3: residents who emphasize English fluency (invented summary). They point to Section 1.028 and its statement that fluency “is necessary for full integration.” They support English classes as the main path and ask that translated notices be a bridge tied to enrollment, not a permanent substitute. What they hope: that newcomers can take part fully in community life. What they fear: services that never lead to fluency.
Recommendation (lawful, non-partisan). Present all three options at the library board’s next public meeting with a public-comment plan, and ask the board to invite a local resettlement or adult-education program to propose an evening class with child care for one semester, with a count of enrollment and cost afterward; ask city staff to translate only essential notices into the top two languages during that semester. Who can take part: any resident, by public comment. Why this follows: the evidence shows a need (a waiting list, no evening class), the statutes neither require nor forbid either option, and the three concerns are each addressed by a time-limited pilot with a count. Notice that the model never says which perspective is right, never claims the invented numbers are real, and ends with an action that is lawful, local and non-partisan.
5. Data rules
Give the source, the table or page, and the year for every number (for example, a Census Bureau American Community Survey table, a Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education report, a city report). If you compute or invent a number, say so: “illustrative.” If two sources disagree, report both.
6. Self-check sheet (Stage 2): check each stakeholder section yourself
| Question | Your answer |
|---|---|
| State the position in one sentence. Would its holders sign it? | |
| Is the evidence they rely on named? | |
| What do they fear or hope? Is it there? | |
| Is any word one only opponents would use? Quote it. | |
| One thing to add. |
If a parent or guardian reads your draft, ask them the same questions. Then write a revision note: what changed because of each check.
7. Presentation: how to prepare
Two minutes: the issue, the three perspectives in one sentence each, the recommendation. Then write one question that someone holding each view would ask you, and answer each one aloud for your family or on a recording. Practice the answer to the hardest question for your recommendation; concede what the evidence does not show. You are scored on evidence and respect, not on winning.
Sources. Revised Statutes of Missouri, Sections 1.028, 660.025 and 115.646, revisor.mo.gov (retrieved 2026-11-15). Brief, stages and rubric follow this course’s Phase 3 specification; the model brief, data, fairness test and self-check sheet are SLS original.
Sources: RSMo Section 1.028, English is the common language of Missouri, Revisor of Missouri (revisor.mo.gov); RSMo Section 660.025, Grants from department of social services, Revisor of Missouri (revisor.mo.gov); RSMo Section 115.646, Public funds expenditure by political subdivision officer or employee, prohibited, Revisor of Missouri (revisor.mo.gov)