
compare game engines and prototyping tools on license, cost, platforms and workflow, and explain why a license change can reshape an industry.
Instruction
A game engine is the software foundation a game is built on: it draws graphics, plays sound, simulates physics, reads input and packages the game for each platform. Choosing one is among the first and most expensive decisions a team makes, because switching later can mean rebuilding everything.
Prototyping tools. Not every idea needs an engine. Paper and cards test rules. Twine, a free open-source tool, builds branching interactive stories with no programming. Scratch, free from the MIT Media Lab, is quick for simple mechanics. Choose the fastest tool that can answer your design question.
Three professional engines.
- Godot is free and open source under the MIT license, which lets anyone use, change and sell games made with it with no fees or royalties. It was released as open source in 2014; version 4.0 arrived in 2023. It uses its own language, GDScript, and also supports C#. It is lighter than its competitors and runs on modest home computers.
- Unity is proprietary. It has long been popular for mobile, independent and cross-platform games and uses C#. It is free below revenue and funding thresholds set by Unity, with paid plans above them; those thresholds have changed over time, so check the current terms.
- Unreal Engine, from Epic Games, is proprietary and known for high-end 3D graphics. It uses C++ and a visual scripting system called Blueprints. Its standard license has been free to use, with a royalty on a game’s gross revenue above a set amount; check Epic’s current terms for the rate and threshold.
Case study: the Unity runtime fee. In September 2023 Unity announced a new “runtime fee” that would charge developers per game installation once a game passed certain revenue and install thresholds. Many developers objected that the fee was unpredictable, could be triggered by reinstalls or free-to-play success, and changed the terms on games already in development. Unity revised the policy within weeks and announced in 2024 that it was canceling the runtime fee. The episode taught a lesson that goes beyond one company: when you build on someone else’s platform, the license is part of your design constraints. Some developers moved to other engines, including Godot, and others stayed, judging Unity’s tools and experience worth the risk. Both are reasonable business decisions; the point is to make them knowingly.
Platforms and hardware. Engines export to platforms: Windows, macOS and Linux computers, the web, Android and iOS phones, game consoles and virtual-reality headsets. Each has different input (keyboard and mouse, gamepad, touch, motion controllers), different screen sizes and different store rules. Console export usually requires a developer agreement with the console maker. The platform shapes the design: a phone game is played in short sessions with a thumb; a console game is played on a large screen from a couch.
Tools that support the team. Beyond the engine, teams use art tools (Krita, GIMP and Inkscape for 2D; Blender for 3D, all free and open source), audio tools (Audacity), a task board and version control such as Git, which records every change so a mistake can be undone and studio teammates can work on the same project. Working alone, you still benefit: at minimum, keep dated backups.
Reading sources. Engine companies’ pages are marketing as well as documentation. Compare their claims with the license text itself and with independent developers’ experience, and note the date of anything you read.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A student sells a game made in Godot. Under Godot’s MIT license, what do they owe the Godot project?
The Unity runtime-fee case shows that an engine’s license terms can change after a team has already committed to it.
Sketch and describe a mock-up of a game platform ten years from now: its input device, its display, where it is played and one kind of game it makes possible. Base each feature on a real technology that exists today, and name it.
How confident are you that you can compare engines and tools on license, cost, platforms and workflow?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- For each engine give its license type and main programming language: Godot, Unity, Unreal Engine.
Check your answer
Answer: Godot: free and open source (MIT license), GDScript (also C#). Unity: proprietary, C#. Unreal Engine: proprietary, C++ plus Blueprints visual scripting.Unity is free below thresholds it sets; Unreal’s standard license charges a royalty on gross revenue above a set amount. Check current terms for both. - Match the free prototyping tool to its use: Twine, Scratch, paper and cards.
Check your answer
Answer: Paper and cards test rules; Twine builds branching interactive stories with no programming; Scratch (MIT Media Lab) is quick for simple mechanics.Choose the fastest tool that can answer your design question. - What is version control, and what is the minimum a solo developer should do instead if they do not use it?
Check your answer
Answer: A system, such as Git, that records every change so mistakes can be undone and teammates can work on the same project. At minimum, keep dated backups.Version control is one of the team-support tools alongside art tools, audio tools and a task board.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Choose the fastest tool for each design question and say why: (a) “Do players care which of three endings they get?” (b) “Is a dice-based combat rule fair?” (c) “Does a simple dodge mechanic feel fun on screen?”
Check your answer
Answer: (a) Twine: branching stories with no programming. (b) Paper and dice: test the rule directly. (c) Scratch (or a tiny Godot build): quick for simple on-screen mechanics.Not every idea needs an engine; the right tool answers the question fastest. - Summarize the Unity runtime-fee case in three sentences: what was announced, why developers objected and how it ended.
Check your answer
Answer: In September 2023 Unity announced a fee per game installation once a game passed revenue and install thresholds. Developers objected that it was unpredictable, could be triggered by reinstalls or free-to-play success, and changed terms on games already in development. Unity revised the policy within weeks and in 2024 announced it was canceling the fee.The broader lesson: when you build on someone else’s platform, the license is part of your design constraints. - A developer leaves Unity for Godot after the 2023 case; another stays. Explain why the lesson calls both reasonable.
Check your answer
Answer: The one who left reduced license risk by choosing an MIT-licensed engine with no fees; the one who stayed judged Unity’s tools and experience worth the risk. Both are business decisions made knowingly.The point is to make the decision with the license terms in view. - Explain how the platform shapes the design for (a) a phone game and (b) a console game, using input and play situation.
Check your answer
Answer: (a) Phone: touch input with no physical buttons, short sessions, played with a thumb on a small screen. (b) Console: gamepad, played on a large screen from a couch, often in longer sessions. Console export also usually needs a developer agreement.Each platform has different input, screen sizes and store rules. - You are comparing engines and find a page on an engine company’s own website claiming it is “the best engine for beginners.” How should you treat it?
Check your answer
Answer: As marketing as well as documentation. Compare the claim with the license text itself and with independent developers’ experience, and note the date of what you read.Company pages have a perspective; dated primary documents and several independent voices give a fairer picture.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 2.2): in the coin game, the coin emits its own collected signal instead of changing the score. What is the advantage?
Check your answer
Answer: The coin does not need to know anything about the score; any script can connect to the signal and react.Signals keep parts of a game separate: the main scene listens and adds 1 to score.
Engine Licenses on Sept. 26, 2026: Godot, Unity, Unreal and the Unity Runtime-Fee Timeline
SLS summary of vendor license pages read 2026-09-26: godotengine.org/license, unity.com/products/pricing-updates, unrealengine.com/license; Godot docs (CC BY 3.0) · SLS original summary; one sentence quoted from Epic’s public page
Why this reading. The comparison table and the analysis of the Unity runtime-fee case need the actual terms, and license terms change, so they cannot come from memory. This reading states the terms as I read them on each vendor’s own page on Sept. 26, 2026, in my own words except one quoted sentence, and gives a timeline of the fee case. Terms will have changed by the time you read this; the lesson’s habit is to note the date and check the page. The MIT text is Godot’s; the vendors’ terms are theirs and are summarized here, not hosted. Nothing here endorses any engine.
License terms, as read on Sept. 26, 2026
| Godot | Unity | Unreal Engine | |
|---|---|---|---|
| License | MIT license: free to use, change and sell games with, commercially, with no fees | Proprietary plans (Personal, Pro, Enterprise) | Proprietary; the Unreal Engine EULA |
| What you pay | Nothing | Personal: free for customers with up to $200,000 in revenue and funding. Pro, required above that: $2,310 per seat per year prepaid, or $210 per seat per month. Enterprise, required above $25 million in annual revenue: custom price | Under $1 million in revenue: free. Games above it: a royalty. Non-game commercial use above $1 million in the past 12 months: $1,850 per seat per year. Educators and schools: no revenue limits |
| Royalty | None | No runtime fee (canceled) | 5% of lifetime gross revenue above $1 million directly attributable to the product; sales through the Epic Games Store are royalty-free |
| What you must do | Keep the copyright and license notice with the engine | Follow the plan’s terms | Submit a release notification after shipping and report royalties each quarter |
| Scripting | GDScript, C#, C++ (docs list) | C# (the manual’s code and guides refer to C#) | C++ and Blueprints visual scripting (from the lesson; check Epic’s documentation) |
| Sources read | godotengine.org/license; Godot FAQ | unity.com/products/pricing-updates | unrealengine.com/license |
Epic’s page says it in one sentence: “All lifetime gross revenue above $1M that is directly attributable to the UE product, regardless of who collects it, will be subject to a 5% royalty.” Unity’s page also lists a 5 percent price increase for Pro and Enterprise starting Jan. 12, 2026.
Worked cost example (arithmetic, not a forecast)
A game earns $1,500,000 in lifetime gross revenue, none through the Epic Games Store. On Unreal the royalty is 5% of ($1,500,000 − $1,000,000) = 0.05 × $500,000 = $25,000. On Godot it is $0. On Unity there is no per-copy fee; the company above $200,000 would need Pro seats, for example two seats prepaid at $2,310 = $4,620 per year.
Timeline of the Unity runtime fee
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Unity announces a per-installation runtime fee (described in the lesson) | Lesson text |
| Sept. 12, 2024 | Unity cancels the fee, effective immediately, for every version including Unity 6 | Unity’s pricing-updates page |
| Oct. 10, 2024 | Editor Software Terms updated to remove the fee language | Same page |
| Oct. 17, 2024 | Personal plan threshold rises to $200,000 with the release of Unity 6 | Same page |
A model analysis paragraph
The runtime-fee case shows that a license is a design constraint that can move after you commit. Teams that had built on Unity in 2023 faced a cost model they could not predict, and Unity canceled the fee in September 2024, so the risk ended, but the episode remains a reason to date every license note, to keep the terms you agreed to, and to weigh Godot’s fixed MIT terms against Unity’s or Epic’s tools by fit and cost.
Input and display menu for the platform mock-up
Real technologies to build on: keyboard and mouse (digital keys plus a pointer); gamepad (digital buttons, analog sticks); touch screens; motion controllers and VR headsets that track hands and head; TV, monitor, phone and headset displays.
Sources: Godot Engine license (MIT) (godotengine.org); Unity pricing updates (unity.com); Unreal Engine licensing options (unrealengine.com); Godot FAQ (docs.godotengine.org)