THE VR SCHOOL
  • Schools & Districts
    • License the academy
    • Free program for your students
    • Request a demo
  • Catalog
    • AI & Data
    • Cybersecurity & Web
    • Programming
    • Health Science
    • All Guilds
    • All courses
  • Families
  • Accreditation
  • Log In
  • Request a demo
  • Home
  • Courses

RLP AI Design B — Case Studies, Prototypes, Patents and Capstone

Curriculum

  • 4 Sections
  • 20 Lessons
  • Lifetime
Expand all sectionsCollapse all sections
  • Unit 1: AI in the Clinic: Case Studies from Past to Present
    5
    • 1.1
      Posters, Press Releases and Proof: How Health Technology Is Sold
      50 mins
    • 1.2
      Storyboarding a Talk: Sticky Notes, Props and the Stage
      100 mins
    • 1.3
      Talking to Machines: A Structured Written Debate on Mental Health Chatbots
      100 mins
    • 1.4
      Radiology, Prediction and Telemedicine: Writing the Talk
      150 mins
    • 1.5
      Portfolio Task — Case Talk: Success, Challenge or Failure
      200 mins
  • Unit 2: Building Small Models: Testing AI as Designers
    5
    • 2.1
      Artists and Machines: From AARON to Trained Collaborators
      50 mins
    • 2.2
      Train, Test, Tally: A Controlled Experiment on a Classifier
      100 mins
    • 2.3
      Ninety Percent Accurate? Base Rates and Honest Accuracy Graphics
      50 mins
    • 2.4
      Sequences and Anomalies: Coding a Heart-Rate Flag
      150 mins
    • 2.5
      Portfolio Task — Tested Prototype Exhibit
      200 mins
  • Unit 3: Engineering Design and the Patent Drawing
    5
    • 3.1
      The Art of the Patent Drawing and the Inventor’s Process
      50 mins
    • 3.2
      Drawing to Patent Standard: Views, Numerals and Line
      100 mins
    • 3.3
      Reading a Real Patent: Claims, Drawings and What Can Be Owned
      100 mins
    • 3.4
      From Sketch to Prototype: Engineering a Biomedical Design
      150 mins
    • 3.5
      Portfolio Task — Engineering Design Portfolio and Hypothetical Patent
      200 mins
  • Unit 4: Capstone: A Biomedical AI Innovation from Concept to Exhibition
    5
    • 4.1
      Showing the Future: Exhibitions, Pitches and the Capstone Launch
      50 mins
    • 4.2
      Paper Prototypes and Think-Aloud Testing
      100 mins
    • 4.3
      Money, Rules and Ethics: A Review Panel on the Record
      100 mins
    • 4.4
      Resume, Portfolio and Recorded Mock Interview
      150 mins
    • 4.5
      Portfolio Task — Capstone Exhibition: A Biomedical AI Innovation
      250 mins

Reading a Real Patent: Claims, Drawings and What Can Be Owned

Unit 3  ·  Critique & Discourse Lab  ·  Lesson 13 of 20

Reading a Real Patent: Claims, Drawings and What Can Be Owned

MA:Re9A.IIRLP-AIDB
Hands compare a biomedical finger clip, its components, and abstract patent claim boundaries.
By the end of this lesson I can…

annotate a real biomedical patent to identify its parts, claims and drawing conventions, and argue a position on what should be patentable in medicine and AI.

Instruction

Patents are public documents written to be read closely. In this lab you will find a real U.S. patent for a biomedical technology, annotate it and compare it with two other patents from the readings (the Missouri glass-microsphere patent from Lesson 3.1 is one option) to find common patterns. Then you will argue, in writing, both sides of what should and should not be ownable.

Finding a patent. Use the USPTO’s free Patent Public Search. Search by keywords for your technology (for example, “pulse oximeter finger clip” or “myoelectric prosthetic hand”), and filter to granted patents. Choose one with clear drawings. Record its patent number exactly as it appears; never guess or retype a number from memory.

The parts of a utility patent. The front page gives the title, inventors, assignee (often the company that owns it), filing and issue dates, an abstract and a representative drawing. The drawings follow. The specification contains the background (the problem and earlier solutions), a summary, a brief description of each figure, and a detailed description that walks through the invention using the reference numerals. Last come the claims.

Claims are the boundary. The claims, not the drawings or the title, define what the patent owner can stop others from making, using or selling. An independent claim stands alone and is usually the broadest (“A device comprising: a housing; a light source; a sensor; and a processor configured to…”). A dependent claim refers back to another and adds a detail (“The device of claim 1, wherein the housing is spring-loaded”). Each element listed in a claim narrows it: a competitor who leaves out one element may not infringe. Read claim 1 of your patent and underline each element.

What can be patented. Under U.S. law, an invention must be a process, machine, manufacture or composition of matter; it must be useful, novel (new) and non-obvious to a person skilled in the field; and it must be described well enough for others to make and use it. The Supreme Court has held that laws of nature, natural phenomena and abstract ideas are not patentable in themselves. In Mayo v. Prometheus (2012) it held that a method based on the relationship between a drug’s metabolite levels and dosage was not patentable. In Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics (2013) it held that naturally occurring DNA sequences cannot be patented just because they have been isolated, although synthetic DNA can be. In Alice v. CLS Bank (2014) it held that implementing an abstract idea on a generic computer is not enough. These decisions matter for AI diagnostics, which often apply software to biological relationships.

AI and inventorship. In Thaler v. Vidal (2022) the Federal Circuit held that an inventor must be a natural person, so an AI system cannot be named as an inventor. The USPTO has issued guidance on inventions made with AI assistance, focused on whether a human made a significant contribution; check its website for the current version.

The debate. Patents give inventors a limited period of exclusive rights (for utility patents, generally 20 years from filing) in exchange for public disclosure. Supporters say this funds costly medical research and development. Critics argue patents on medical technologies can raise prices and limit access. Write a structured debate with both sides argued by you: should AI-assisted medical inventions be patentable, and on what conditions? Write the strongest case for one side, then the strongest case for the other, restating the view you are answering before you answer it, and end with your own judgment. A family member may read the opposing side aloud if you want to hear it.

📖 Read for this lesson

The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.

  • Reading a Real Patent: US 4,744,360 in Full Claims, the Law and the Debate FileUS 4,744,360 (Google Patents, retrieved 2026-09-26); 35 U.S.C. 100, 101, 103 (Cornell LII); Thaler v. Vidal, No. 2021-2347 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 5, 2022); 90 FR 54636 (Nov. 28, 2025); comparison table and debate table are SLS original · about 7 min

    A real patent in the parts the task turns on, with all seven claims, a table to compare three patents for trends, the statute and court statements on AI inventors, and the arguments for each side of the debate.

  • Three Real Patents: Numbers, Drawings in Words, the Drawing Rules and a Pacemaker Design LoopUS 4,744,360 (Bath), US 3,482,037 (Brown), US 3,057,356 (Greatbatch), retrieved from Google Patents 2026-09-26; 37 CFR 1.84 from eCFR 2026-09-26; Lemelson Center, Innovative Lives: Making Hearts Beat: Wilson Greatbatch (Internet Archive copy, retrieved 2026-09-26) · about 8 min

    The drawings of this patent and two others described in words, with the drawing rules, so you can judge which conventions each one uses well.

Vocabulary in context

  • claim — A numbered sentence at the end of a patent that defines the legal boundary of the invention.
  • independent and dependent claims — An independent claim stands alone; a dependent claim refers to another claim and adds a limitation.
  • specification — The written description of a patent: background, summary, description of the drawings and detailed description.
  • non-obvious — Not an obvious step to a person skilled in the field, one requirement for a patent.

Formative check

Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.

+50 XP

Which part of a patent defines what the owner can stop others from making, using or selling?

The claims are the legal boundary.
+50 XP

Claim 3 reads: ‘The device of claim 1, wherein the sensor is an infrared photodiode.’ What kind of claim is it?

It refers back to claim 1 and adds a detail.
Myth or Fact?

Under Thaler v. Vidal (2022), an AI system can be named as the inventor on a U.S. patent.

The Federal Circuit held that an inventor must be a natural person.

Give your patent’s number exactly as shown, its title and claim 1 with each element underlined or listed. Name one drawing convention it uses well and one it could improve. Then note one trend you see across three patents: yours and two from the readings.

0 words
Quick self-check

How confident are you that you can annotate a real patent’s parts and claims and argue about what should be patentable?

Not yetVery confident

Practice

Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.

Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)

Fluency

Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.

  1. List the parts of a utility patent in the order they appear, as the lesson describes.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Front page (title, inventors, assignee, filing and issue dates, abstract, representative drawing); the drawings; the specification (background, summary, brief description of each figure, detailed description); the claims, last.
    The claims, not the drawings or the title, define the legal boundary.
  2. Define independent claim, dependent claim and non-obvious.
    Check your answer
    Answer: An independent claim stands alone and is usually the broadest. A dependent claim refers back to another claim and adds a detail. Non-obvious means not an obvious step to a person skilled in the field, one requirement for a patent.
    Each element listed in a claim narrows it.
  3. Match each case to its holding: Mayo v. Prometheus (2012); AMP v. Myriad Genetics (2013); Alice v. CLS Bank (2014); Thaler v. Vidal (2022).
    Check your answer
    Answer: Mayo: a method based on the relationship between a drug’s metabolite levels and dosage was not patentable. Myriad: naturally occurring DNA sequences cannot be patented just because they are isolated, though synthetic DNA can. Alice: implementing an abstract idea on a generic computer is not enough. Thaler: an inventor must be a natural person, so an AI cannot be named.
    The first three are Supreme Court decisions; Thaler is a Federal Circuit decision.

Application

Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.

  1. An invented claim 1 reads: ‘A device comprising: a housing; a light source; a sensor; and a processor configured to estimate oxygen level.’ List its elements. A competitor’s device has a housing, light source and sensor but no processor. Based on the lesson, might it infringe claim 1?
    Check your answer
    Answer: Elements: housing; light source; sensor; processor configured to estimate oxygen level. It may not infringe, because a competitor who leaves out one element may not infringe.
    Each element narrows the claim; all elements must be present.
  2. Write a dependent claim that adds one detail to the invented claim 1 above.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Model: ‘The device of claim 1, wherein the housing is spring-loaded.’ (Any claim that refers back to claim 1 and adds one limitation is correct.)
    A dependent claim refers to another claim and adds a limitation.
  3. A utility patent is generally granted exclusive rights for 20 years from filing. An invented patent was filed in 2009 and issued in 2012. In about what year do its rights end, and what does the public receive in exchange?
    Check your answer
    Answer: About 2029. In exchange, the inventor discloses the invention publicly.
    2009 + 20 = 2029. The term counts from filing, not issue.
  4. Apply the four requirements (category, useful, novel, non-obvious) and the court decisions to decide which of these is more likely patentable, with a reason: (a) the natural relationship between a blood marker and a disease; (b) a new finger clip with a spring-loaded housing and a sensor.
    Check your answer
    Answer: (b) is more likely patentable: it is a machine or manufacture that could be useful, novel and non-obvious. (a) is a natural phenomenon or law of nature, which is not patentable in itself (Mayo).
    AI diagnostics often apply software to biological relationships, which is why these decisions matter; Alice adds that running an abstract idea on a generic computer is not enough.
  5. Write the strongest case, in 2-3 sentences, for allowing patents on AI-assisted medical inventions, then restate the opposing view in one sentence its holders would accept.
    Check your answer
    Answer: Model case: ‘Medical research and development is costly, and patents give a limited period of exclusive rights that funds it, in exchange for public disclosure. If an AI-assisted invention could not be protected when a human made a significant contribution, companies would have less reason to invest in it.’ Restatement of the opposing view: ‘Patents on medical technologies can raise prices and limit access, so extending them to AI-assisted inventions could keep useful tools from the patients who need them.’
    The debate asks you to argue both sides and restate before answering. USPTO guidance focuses on whether a human made a significant contribution.

Review

Keep earlier skills sharp.

  1. Review (Semester A, Unit 2): The Copyright Office requires human authorship; Thaler v. Vidal requires a human inventor. State the parallel in one sentence.
    Check your answer
    Answer: In both U.S. copyright and U.S. patents, the creator recognized by law must be a human, so AI-generated output alone does not qualify, while human contributions can.
    Semester A: purely AI-generated material is not copyrightable; human selection, arrangement and modification can be.

Missouri Learning Standards — Media Arts addressed: MA:Re9A.II, MA:Cn11A.III, RST.11-12.4, RST.11-12.5, SL.11-12.1

Instructional focus: Close reading and critique of technical-legal documents and debate on intellectual property

Reading

Reading a Real Patent: US 4,744,360 in Full Claims, the Law and the Debate File

US 4,744,360 (Google Patents, retrieved 2026-09-26); 35 U.S.C. 100, 101, 103 (Cornell LII); Thaler v. Vidal, No. 2021-2347 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 5, 2022); 90 FR 54636 (Nov. 28, 2025); comparison table and debate table are SLS original · Public domain (U.S. patent, U.S. Code, federal court opinion, Federal Register); SLS original (tables and debate arguments)

Why this reading. The lab asks you to annotate a real patent, underline the elements of claim 1, name a drawing convention it uses well, compare patents for trends, and argue about what should be patentable. Here is a real patent reproduced in the parts the task turns on (front-page data, abstract, description of the drawings, all seven claims), the law it sits under, the court and agency statements on AI inventors, and both sides of the debate. Patent numbers here are copied from the patent, not from memory.

The patent: US 4,744,360

Front-page fieldValue
Number4,744,360
TitleApparatus for ablating and removing cataract lenses
InventorPatricia E. Bath
FiledDec. 18, 1986, application 06/943,098
IssuedMay 17, 1988
Claims7
Owner listedIndividual (no company)
Also cited in the backgroundU.S. Pat. No. 3,971,382 (Krasnov), laser focused on the lens capsule

Abstract. A method and apparatus for removing cataracts in which a flexible line preferably 1 mm or less in diameter is inserted through an incision into the anterior chamber until its end is adjacent the cataract. Coherent radiation, preferably at a frequency between 193 and 351 nm, is coupled to the cataract by an optical fiber in the line. An irrigation sleeve provided about the fiber and an aspiration sleeve extending partially around the irrigation sleeve conduct irrigating liquid to and remove ablated material from the anterior chamber and form with the optical fiber the flexible line.

Brief description of the drawings. FIG. 1 shows a schematic view of the present invention for ablating a cataract lens. FIG. 2 shows a cross-section of the flexible line of FIG. 1 along the lines 2–2.

Claims (as printed).

  1. An apparatus for removing cataracts from an eye comprising: a flexible line including an optical fiber for conducting coherent radiation to the cataract and an aspiration sleeve extending at least partially about and along said fiber, the diameter of said line being 1 mm or less; a laser means coupled to said fiber for supplying said coherent radiation thereto at a wavelength such that crystalline lens material will be disintegrated into particles less than 0.1 mm in diameter; and means for applying suction to said aspiration sleeve for removing ablated cataract material.
  2. An apparatus as in claim 1 wherein said laser produces radiation in the wavelength between 193 and 351 nm.
  3. An apparatus as in claim 1 further comprising an irrigation sleeve extending wholly around said fiber and wherein said aspiration sleeve extends partially around said irrigation sleeve.
  4. An apparatus as in claim 1 wherein the width of said aspiration sleeve is 0.2 mm or less.
  5. An apparatus for removing cataracts from an eye comprising: a flexible line including an optical fiber for conducting coherent radiation to the cataract, an irrigation sleeve extending at least partially about and along said fiber and an aspiration sleeve extending at least partially about and along said fiber, the width of said aspiration sleeve being 0.3 mm or less and the diameter of said line being 1 mm or less; a laser coupled to said fiber for supplying said coherent radiation thereto at a wavelength such that crystalline lens material will be disintegrated into particles less than 0.1 mm in diameter; means for supplying an irrigation liquid to said irrigation sleeve; and means for applying suction to said aspiration sleeve for removing ablated cataract material.
  6. An apparatus as in claim 5 wherein said laser produces radiation in the wavelength between 193 and 351 nm.
  7. An apparatus as in claim 5 wherein said irrigation sleeve extends wholly around said fiber and said aspiration sleeve extends partially around said irrigation sleeve.

Reading the claims

ClaimTypeRefers to
1Independent
2Dependentclaim 1
3Dependentclaim 1
4Dependentclaim 1
5Independent
6Dependentclaim 5
7Dependentclaim 5

Claim 1, element by element. (a) a flexible line including an optical fiber for conducting coherent radiation to the cataract and an aspiration sleeve extending at least partially about and along the fiber, the line being 1 mm or less in diameter; (b) a laser means coupled to the fiber, at a wavelength such that lens material will be disintegrated into particles less than 0.1 mm across; (c) means for applying suction to the aspiration sleeve to remove ablated material. A device missing any one element does not fit claim 1. Now compare claim 5: it adds an irrigation sleeve and a means for supplying irrigation liquid, and narrows the aspiration sleeve to 0.3 mm or less in width. Claim 1 is broader; a device with no irrigation could fall under claim 1 but not claim 5. Dependent claim 4 narrows claim 1 further, to an aspiration sleeve width of 0.2 mm or less.

One drawing convention used well, one that could improve (a model answer)

Well: FIG. 2 is a cross-section taken at the plane marked 2-2 on FIG. 1, so the two figures tie together, and every numbered part has a lead line. Could improve: the sleeves in FIG. 2 are named both with printed words (IRRIGATION SLEEVE, ASPIRATOR SLEEVE) and with numerals, and the text calls part 32 the aspiration sleeve while the numeral 32 in the drawing sits at the seam between the sleeves; a reader has to work out which is meant. Check any patent you annotate for such mismatches between drawing and text.

Three patents side by side, for the trends chart

FeatureUS 4,744,360 (1988)US 3,482,037 (1969)US 3,057,356 (1962)
Claims714
Independent claims2 (claims 1, 5)13 (claims 1, 3, 4)
Figures2113
Filing to issueabout 1.4 yearsabout 3.3 yearsabout 2.2 years

Observations to test: the shortest and longest times to issue differ by about 1.9 years; the number of figures does not track the number of claims. With only three patents these are observations, not trends; say what more you would need to call one a trend.

What the law says (public domain)

  • 35 U.S.C. 101. “Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.”
  • 35 U.S.C. 103. A patent may not be obtained if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art “are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious” to a person having ordinary skill in the art (this is the non-obviousness requirement).
  • 35 U.S.C. 100(f). “The term ‘inventor’ means the individual or, if a joint invention, the individuals collectively who invented or discovered the subject matter of the invention.”
  • Thaler v. Vidal, No. 2021-2347 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 5, 2022). Stephen Thaler named an AI system, DABUS, as the inventor on patent applications. The Federal Circuit affirmed the refusal, writing that the Patent Act “requires an ‘inventor’ to be a natural person.”
  • USPTO, Revised Inventorship Guidance for AI-Assisted Inventions, 90 Fed. Reg. 54636 (Nov. 28, 2025). The USPTO rescinded its February 2024 guidance and replaced it. It states that AI systems “cannot be named as inventors or joint inventors,” and that AI systems are “instruments used by human inventors,” analogous to laboratory equipment or software, so the question is whether a natural person conceived the invention.

The lesson also cites two Supreme Court cases on laws of nature and natural DNA. This reading does not host them; use only what the statute and the two statements above support unless you can name a source.

The debate: what should be patentable in medicine and AI? Arguments for each side (SLS original)

PositionArguments a speaker may useWhere the evidence above helps
Patents should reach AI-assisted medical inventions broadlyDevelopment is costly and risky; a patent lets an inventor recover cost; Bath’s patent shows a documented 1-mm incision problem solved by a new combination of parts35 U.S.C. 101 covers any new and useful machine or process; the 2025 guidance says AI-assisted work is judged by human conception
Patents should be narrowA patent excludes others for years; broad claims can block cheaper care; Bath’s claim 1 shows how one missing element avoids infringement, so narrow claims still protect35 U.S.C. 103 requires non-obviousness; the claims, not the title, mark the boundary
An AI may not be an inventorThe statute says “individual”; the court held natural personThaler v. Vidal; 100(f); 2025 guidance

Sources: US 4,744,360, Bath (patents.google.com); Thaler v. Vidal, No. 2021-2347 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 5, 2022) (cafc.uscourts.gov); USPTO, Revised Inventorship Guidance for AI-Assisted Inventions, 90 FR 54636 (federalregister.gov); 35 U.S.C. 101 (law.cornell.edu)

Reading

Three Real Patents: Numbers, Drawings in Words, the Drawing Rules and a Pacemaker Design Loop

US 4,744,360 (Bath), US 3,482,037 (Brown), US 3,057,356 (Greatbatch), retrieved from Google Patents 2026-09-26; 37 CFR 1.84 from eCFR 2026-09-26; Lemelson Center, Innovative Lives: Making Hearts Beat: Wilson Greatbatch (Internet Archive copy, retrieved 2026-09-26) · Public domain (U.S. patents; 37 CFR); short quotation and paraphrase from the Smithsonian Lemelson Center, cited; SLS original (drawing descriptions and tables)

Why this reading. The lesson asks you to annotate two patent drawings, name their conventions and map a biomedical invention onto the engineering design process, citing the source that shows a loop back. Here are three real U.S. patents (public domain) with their numbers, dates and drawings described in words, the drawing rules you annotate against, and a verified account of one invention’s design loop. Nothing needs a search or a link.

Three real patents

US 4,744,360US 3,482,037US 3,057,356
TitleApparatus for ablating and removing cataract lensesHome security system utilizing television surveillanceMedical cardiac pacemaker
Inventor(s)Patricia E. BathMarie Van Brittan Brown and Albert L. BrownWilson Greatbatch
FiledDec. 18, 1986 (Ser. No. 06/943,098)Aug. 1, 1966 (Ser. No. 569,319)July 22, 1960 (Ser. No. 44,796)
IssuedMay 17, 1988Dec. 2, 1969Oct. 9, 1962
Claims714
Figures2 (one drawing sheet)11 (three drawing sheets)3 (one drawing sheet)
Filing to issue516 days (about 1.4 years)1219 days (about 3.3 years)809 days (about 2.2 years)

Source and rights. U.S. patent full text and drawings, retrieved from Google Patents on September 26, 2026 (the USPTO’s own full text carries the same numbers). U.S. patents are government documents in the public domain. The lesson’s flashcards give these inventors and years; the numbers above are checked against the patents.

The drawing rules to annotate against (37 CFR 1.84, retrieved from eCFR Sept. 26, 2026)

  • Numbers, letters and reference characters must measure at least .32 cm (1/8 inch) in height, must be plain and legible, must not be enclosed in outlines such as circles, and should not cross lines or sit on shaded surfaces.
  • Lead lines run between a reference character and the detail it names. They should be as short as possible, must not cross each other, and are required for each reference character except one placed on a surface it labels (which is underlined).
  • Views must not be connected by projection lines and must not contain center lines. Exploded views, with the separated parts embraced by a bracket, are permitted.
  • Every line, number and letter must be durable, clean, black, sufficiently dense and uniformly thick. Lines of different thickness may be used where the thickness has a meaning.
  • Shading is encouraged if it aids understanding; light should come from the upper left corner at an angle of 45 degrees; solid black shading areas are not permitted except for bar graphs or color.
  • Scale must be large enough to show the mechanism without crowding when the drawing is reduced to two-thirds. Notes such as “actual size” are not permitted.
  • Margins: top at least 2.5 cm, left at least 2.5 cm, right at least 1.5 cm, bottom at least 1.0 cm.

Drawing 1: US 4,744,360, Bath (described)

One sheet, headed “U.S. Patent, May 17, 1988, 4,744,360.” FIG. 1 is a schematic side view. At left, an outline of an eye in section with the lens drawn as a small lens-shaped form, labeled 22. A thin curved line enters the eye and joins a straight tapered handpiece. From the handpiece’s right end, three lines with arrowheads lead to three labeled boxes stacked at right: IRRIGATOR (31) above, LASER (20) in the middle, ASPIRATOR (34) below. A numeral 24 with a short arrow stands above the eye. FIG. 2 is a cross-section, marked by a pair of arrows and the number 2 on FIG. 1, of the flexible line (26): a large circle filled with slanted solid and dashed hatching for the optical fiber (28), wrapped by a thin ring (30, the irrigation sleeve), with an aspirator sleeve (32) running around the lower half only, like a shallow cup. A dimension mark labeled d shows the width of a sleeve. Words on the drawing are hand-lettered in italics. The patent’s text says the flexible line can be no greater than 1 mm in diameter, the optical fiber no more than 600 microns, and the aspiration sleeve no more than 0.1 mm thick.

Drawing 2: US 3,057,356, Greatbatch (described)

One sheet headed “Oct. 9, 1962, W. Greatbatch, 3,057,356, Medical cardiac pacemaker, Filed July 22, 1960.” FIG. 1 is a circuit diagram (numeral 10): a transformer (19) with two coils (18, 20), a resistor (22), a capacitor (21), a transistor (14, with collector 15, base 16, emitter 17), a battery (23), and two leads (24, 25) running right to electrodes (13) drawn as a small two-pronged plug on a cable (12). FIG. 2 repeats the circuit with a second transistor (26), two more resistors (30, 31) and a capacitor (32) for higher power; primed numerals (14′, 19′) mark parts repeated from FIG. 1. FIG. 3 is a perspective view: a flat, thick disc (11) shaded with stipple dots, with its cable (12) leaving the edge, drawn broken by a dashed section, ending at the electrodes (13). The patent text says the pulse is about 10 volts and about one millisecond, one pulse per second in the described circuit, and that the disc is cast in a hard epoxy compound covered with a thin coating of silicone rubber. Dimensions printed in the OCR text of this patent are garbled, so read them from the original sheet, not from this description.

Drawing 3: US 3,482,037, Brown (figure list)

Eleven figures on three sheets: FIG. 1, a perspective view, partly broken away, of the system installed at an entrance door and in a bedroom; FIG. 2, a fragmentary perspective of the front of the door; FIG. 3, an enlarged sectional view taken on line 3-3 of FIG. 2; FIG. 4, a rear elevation of part of the door; FIG. 5, an enlarged rear view of the apparatus at the door; FIG. 6, a front view of the video-audio receiver and control unit; FIG. 7, a diagram of the system; FIGS. 8 to 11, a perspective, side, top and sectional view of a second scanning device. The text numbers the parts: cabinet 20, door 22, video scanner 26, lens barrel 28, microphone 55, loudspeaker 56, television antenna 58, solenoid-operated bolt lock 60. Claim 1 of this patent describes windows in the door covered by pivoting protective plates, a cabinet containing a video scanning device that a motor drives up and down past the windows, a video transmitter, and a radio receiver and transmitter to control the motor from inside the home.

Evidence of a design loop: the pacemaker

The problem, in the patent’s own words. The patent’s background says existing artificial pacemakers “have required considerable power” and could not run from a battery without frequent replacement, and that their size and power needs required external mounting with wires through the skin, which caused discomfort and the possibility of infection. Its stated objects include low power consumption, battery operation for long periods, and materials compatible with the body so that permanent implantation is practical. Those are criteria and constraints.

The loop. The Smithsonian’s Lemelson Center account of Greatbatch’s work reports that about 1956, while building a circuit to record heart sounds, he grabbed the wrong resistor and the circuit pulsed for 1.8 milliseconds, stopped for a second and repeated, a rhythm he recognized as heartlike. On May 7, 1958 a prototype took control of a dog’s heartbeat. He recalled: “We were pretty naive about early pacemaker designs. We thought that wrapping the module in electric tape would seal it.” Body fluid got through, and the first implant lasted only four hours. They switched to casting the unit in a block of epoxy, and within a year devices could last four months. The patent, filed in 1960, describes exactly that solution: the circuit cast into hard epoxy and coated with silicone rubber. Claim 1 of the patent requires a circuit “cast in a potting compound” and claim 2 adds silicone rubber, so the fix that followed the failure ended up in the legal boundary of the invention. That is a documented iteration: prototype, test, failure, redesign, retest.

The other inventor’s process. Bath’s background describes three earlier approaches to cataract removal: cutting and aspirating with a sharp instrument; an ultrasonic probe through an incision of typically 3 mm; and earlier laser methods. Her invention aims for an incision of 1 mm or less. Her patent’s example reports laser ablation tests on bovine lenses and human lenses from cadaver eyes at a 308 nm wavelength, with a threshold near 10 mJ/mm2 for bovine nucleus and rates of 13 and 23 microns per pulse at two energy levels; the patent calls 308 nm “the most effective experimental wavelength.”

A model process map (Greatbatch)

StageEvidenceSource
Define the problemPacemakers need too much power and wires through the skinUS 3,057,356 background
Criteria and constraintsLow power; battery; body-compatible materials; implantableUS 3,057,356 objects
IdeasA blocking-oscillator pulse circuit, from an accidental resistor swapLemelson Center
Prototype and testMay 7, 1958 dog testLemelson Center
Loop backTape seal failed in 4 hours; changed to epoxy block; 4 monthsLemelson Center
CommunicatePatent filed July 22, 1960; issued Oct. 9, 1962US 3,057,356

Not hosted. The lesson also says the U.S. Patent Office generally required models until 1880. That statement could not be checked against a primary source for this reading; treat it as the lesson’s claim.

Sources: US 4,744,360, Bath, Apparatus for ablating and removing cataract lenses (patents.google.com); US 3,482,037, Brown and Brown, Home security system utilizing television surveillance (patents.google.com); US 3,057,356, Greatbatch, Medical cardiac pacemaker (patents.google.com); 37 CFR 1.84, Standards for drawings (ecfr.gov); Smithsonian Lemelson Center, Innovative Lives: Making Hearts Beat: Wilson Greatbatch (invention.si.edu)

Up NextComplete & Continue →

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Drawing to Patent Standard: Views, Numerals and Line
Prev
From Sketch to Prototype: Engineering a Biomedical Design
Next

© 2026 The VR School | Career content by Wiley | Powered by Sejal Learning Systems.

Join free · Accreditation · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service

Modal title

Main Content