make side-by-side dot plots of two data sets and compare them using the mean and the median.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Old Faithful is a famous geyser in Yellowstone National Park. Park rangers predict its next eruption. Do you think the wait between eruptions is always the same? Write a guess and a reason.
Rangers time how long an eruption lasts. What do you think happens after a longer eruption?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two populations. The rangers’ table splits Old Faithful’s waits into two groups: waits after short eruptions and waits after long eruptions. Each group is a population of waits. The numbers 68 and 94 are typical values, or centers.
Measures of center. The mean is the sum of the values divided by how many there are. The median is the middle value when the data are in order; with an even number of values, it is the mean of the two middle values.
Side-by-side dot plots. To compare two groups, draw both dot plots on the same number line scale, one above the other. Then you can see where each group is centered and whether the groups overlap.
Worked example 1: waits after short eruptions. Sample data (made-up values that match the rangers’ rule): 62, 64, 66, 67, 68, 68, 70, 71, 72, 72 minutes. Step 1: sum = 680. Step 2: mean = 680 ÷ 10 = 68 minutes. Step 3: the two middle values are the 5th and 6th, 68 and 68, so the median is 68 minutes.
Worked example 2: waits after long eruptions. Sample data: 86, 89, 91, 93, 94, 94, 96, 97, 99, 101 minutes. Step 1: sum = 940. Step 2: mean = 940 ÷ 10 = 94 minutes. Step 3: the 5th and 6th values are 94 and 94, so the median is 94. Step 4: compare: 94 − 68 = 26, so waits after long eruptions are about 26 minutes longer. Step 5: the dot plots do not overlap at all; the longest short-group wait (72) is far below the shortest long-group wait (86).
Using the comparison. Sample situation: an eruption lasting 4 minutes starts at 1:15 p.m. It is longer than 3 minutes, so add 94 minutes: 1:15 + 1 hour 34 minutes = 2:49 p.m. That is the predicted next eruption.
Today’s hands-on. Teams build the two dot plots with sticky dots on a long number-line strip from 60 to 105 minutes.
Hands-on. Put the short-eruption waits on the top line and the long-eruption waits on the bottom line of your 60-105 minute strip, one sticky dot per value. Use the sample data from the worked examples.
Compare two groups from our school (sample data).
Sample data, minutes to get ready for school. Grade 7: 15, 20, 20, 25, 30, 30. Grade 8: 20, 25, 30, 30, 35, 40. Find each mean and median, and write one sentence comparing the groups.
A 3.5-minute eruption begins at 2:30 p.m. When is the next one predicted?
Why does the Park Service warn that a prediction may not be exactly right? Connect your answer to the spread of the dots.
Centers tell us where each group sits. Next time we measure how spread out each group is.
Exit ticket: name one question about two groups in our school that we could compare with means or medians.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 7, mini lesson 10, dot plot build and guided practice 14, independent practice and exit ticket 5.
Materials: per team, a paper number-line strip from 60 to 105 minutes and sticky dots in two colors.
Accuracy: the webcam timing steps, the half-minute rounding, the 68-minute and 94-minute intervals for eruptions under and over 3 minutes, and the warning that the geyser changes are from the NPS Predict Old Faithful page (last updated 2018; opened 2026-11-20). The ten-value data sets are SAMPLE data written to match those centers, not park records. Checked: sums 680 and 940, means 68 and 94, medians 68 and 94, difference 26; 1:15 + 94 min = 2:49; 10:40 + 68 min = 11:48; 2:30 + 94 min = 4:04; 70, 75, 80, 85, 140 has sum 450, mean 90, median 80.
Likely misconceptions: forgetting to order data before finding the median; drawing the two dot plots with different scales; adding 94 minutes as 94 on the clock.
Supports: minutes-to-hours strip (60 minutes = 1 hour). Stretch: an eruption lasts exactly 3 minutes; the table does not say. What would you do and why?
Answer guide: grade 7: sum 140, mean 23 1/3 (about 23.3), median 22.5; grade 8: sum 180, mean 30, median 30. Grade 8 students in this sample take about 7.5 minutes longer by the median (30 − 22.5 = 7.5). Predictions are not exact because the waits in each group spread out around the center.
National Park Service, Predict Old Faithful · U.S. government work, public domain
Most geysers cannot be predicted, but Old Faithful in Yellowstone National Park is famous for being regular. The National Park Service shares the rangers’ method so that students can make their own prediction.
First, you time an eruption on the park’s live webcam. The eruption starts when water begins splashing out of the cone without stopping. It ends when only steam is coming out. You record the length to the nearest half minute.
Next, you use a two-row table. If the eruption lasted less than 3 minutes, the interval until the next eruption is 68 minutes. If it lasted more than 3 minutes, the interval is 94 minutes. You add that interval to the start time of the eruption you watched. The answer is your prediction.
Then you compare your prediction with the rangers’ prediction and watch the next eruption. The page reminds students that Old Faithful is a natural feature that changes often, so no prediction will always be exactly right.
Source: National Park Service, Predict Old Faithful (nps.gov)