find, explain and fix common errors in solving equations and inequalities, and use substitution to prove which answer is right.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Jada solved 3x + 12 = 57 like this: 57 ÷ 3 = 19, then 19 − 12 = 7. So x = 7.
Is Jada right?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Be an error detective. Mistakes are clues. Most equation errors fall into a few types. If you can name the type, you can fix it and avoid it next time. Your best tool is substitution: put the answer back into the original problem and see if it is true.
Error type 1: undoing in the wrong order. Jada divided first in 3x + 12 = 57 and got 7. The 12 is not shared among the 3 groups, so it must be removed first. Substitution shows 3 × 7 + 12 = 33 ≠ 57.
Error type 2 (worked example 1): the half-distributed group. Lily solves 4(x + 1.5) = 98 by writing 4x + 1.5 = 98. Then 4x = 96.5 and x = 24.125. Check: 4(24.125 + 1.5) = 4 × 25.625 = 102.5, not 98. The error: the 4 multiplies both terms, so 4(x + 1.5) = 4x + 6. Fix: 4x + 6 = 98, 4x = 92, x = 23. Check: 4(24.5) = 98.
Error type 3 (worked example 2): the forgotten flip. Sam solves 150 − 4d > 130. He gets −4d > −20, then writes d > 5. Test d = 6: 150 − 24 = 126, and 126 > 130 is false, so his answer is wrong. Dividing by −4 must reverse the sign: d < 5. Test d = 4: 134 > 130 is true.
Error type 4: doing a move to one side only. Writing 3x + 12 − 12 = 57 and then 3x = 57 forgets the right side. Every move happens to both sides.
Error type 5: the wrong model. If the story says each truck bundle weighs 1,250 pounds and the truck’s own weight on the tandem axle is 9,000 pounds (sample), the model is 1,250p + 9,000 < 34,000, not 1,250 + 9,000p < 34,000. Read which number repeats.
For each item, find the error, name its type and fix it. Prove your fix by substitution.
Make an error-detective card for our class wall.
Make a card for one error type. Show a wrong example, the substitution check that catches it, and the correct solution.
Which check proves that x = 23 solves 4(x + 1.5) = 98?
Solve 5(x − 2) < 30 correctly. Then write a likely wrong answer and explain the error that would cause it.
Substitution settles arguments. Next we decide when a story needs an equation and when it needs an inequality.
Exit ticket: Leo solved 6x − 4 = 20 and got x = 2.67. Find his error and fix it.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 6, mini lesson 12, guided practice 12, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the weigh station check, 20,000 / 34,000 / 80,000 pound limits, the 1975 bridge formula, the funding penalty and grandfathered limits are from the FHWA page. The 9,000-pound tandem share and 1,250-pound bundles are sample data.
Every wrong answer is re-derived: Jada 57 ÷ 3 − 12 = 7; Lily 4x + 1.5 = 98 gives 24.125; Ty 2x + 4 = 18 gives 7; Ana forgot the flip (−2x > 8 written as x > −4); Ravi 5 × 4 − 3 = 17; Leo (exit ticket) subtracted 4 instead of adding: 6x = 16, x = 2.67.
Answer guide: 1,250p < 25,000, p < 20, so at most 19 bundles. 5(x − 2) < 30: x − 2 < 6, x < 8; a likely wrong answer is x < 6.4 from 5x − 2 < 30 (multiplying only x). Exit ticket: add 4: 6x = 24, x = 4; check 24 − 4 = 20.
Federal Highway Administration, Freight Management and Operations: Commercial Vehicle Size and Weight Program · U.S. government work, public domain
The FHWA page explains that federal truck rules center on three things: weight, length and width. Trucks entering a weigh station are checked to make sure they follow the weight rules.
The weight rules work at two levels. Each axle has a limit: 20,000 pounds for a single axle and 34,000 pounds for a tandem axle on the Interstate. The whole vehicle has a limit too: a gross vehicle weight of 80,000 pounds.
The bridge formula, introduced in 1975, adds a third check. Heavy weight packed onto axles close together can harm bridges. So the formula may require a lower total weight unless the truck has more axles or a longer distance between them.
The rules are firm for states. If a state sets Interstate weight limits higher or lower than the federal standards, it can lose all of its National Highway System funding. States may keep some older “grandfathered” limits, but they cannot go above them. Getting the numbers right protects roads that everyone shares.
Source: Federal Highway Administration, Freight Management and Operations: Commercial Vehicle Size and Weight Program (ops.fhwa.dot.gov)