compare solving a word problem with arithmetic steps and with an equation, and explain why the two paths match.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now (sample design). The shed door needs a ramp for wheelbarrows and wheelchairs. It has one sloped run that goes 12 inches forward for every 1 inch up, plus a 60-inch level landing. The total length is 156 inches. How high is the door step?
Which first step makes sense?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two paths, one answer. Many students solve word problems by working backward with arithmetic. Others write an equation. Today we show the two paths are really the same steps, written in different ways.
Worked example 1: arithmetic path. Mei reads the Do Now. The total is 156 inches. Step 1: the landing is not sloped, so 156 − 60 = 96 inches of sloped run. Step 2: each inch of rise takes 12 inches of run, so 96 ÷ 12 = 8. Step 3: check forward: 8 × 12 = 96, and 96 + 60 = 156. The step is 8 inches high.
Worked example 2: algebra path. Andre writes 12r + 60 = 156, where r is the rise in inches. Step 1: subtract 60 from both sides: 12r = 96. Step 2: divide both sides by 12: r = 8. Each line of Andre’s work matches a line of Mei’s. For p(x + q) = r, the paths match too: 3(x + 2.5) = 22.5 by arithmetic is 22.5 ÷ 3 = 7.5, then 7.5 − 2.5 = 5; by algebra, divide both sides by 3, then subtract 2.5.
Why the order reverses. To build the total, we multiply the rise by 12 and then add 60. To find the rise, we undo those in reverse: subtract 60, then divide by 12. Equations record that thinking so others can follow it.
When algebra helps more. Arithmetic works well for small problems. Algebra shines when numbers are negative or fractions, when the story is long, or when we need an inequality. It also leaves a written record that a garden volunteer can check.
Does it make sense? An 8-inch rise is more than 6 inches, so the Access Board guide says this ramp needs handrails on both sides. It is less than 30 inches, so one run is enough. Interpreting the answer tells us what to build.
Solve each problem both ways. Write the two paths side by side.
Two paths for each problem, then one sentence that interprets the answer.
A sample shed ramp has one run of 12r inches and a 60-inch landing, 180 inches in all. Find r both ways. Does the ramp need handrails? Explain using the guide.
Which is 1:12 written as a percent, rounded to the hundredth?
Write a problem of your own that is easy by arithmetic, and one that is easier with an equation. Explain the difference.
Arithmetic and algebra are the same reasoning. Next we focus on checking whether answers make sense in the story.
Exit ticket: solve 4(x + 1.25) = 15 by arithmetic and by algebra.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 12, guided practice 11, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the ½-inch trigger, 1:12 maximum running slope (8.33%), 30-inch maximum rise per run, landings at the top and bottom of each run, 60 by 60 inch turning landings, 36-inch minimum width, handrails when the rise is greater than 6 inches and the drainage rule are from the Access Board guide. The shed ramp designs are sample data; a real ramp would follow the full standards and local code, and landing sizes vary by situation.
Likely misconceptions: dividing 156 by 12 first (13); reading 1:12 as 12%; thinking arithmetic and algebra give different answers.
Answer guide: 12r + 60 = 180: 12r = 120, r = 10 inches; 10 > 6, so handrails on both sides. Exit ticket: 15 ÷ 4 = 3.75, 3.75 − 1.25 = 2.5; or 4x + 5 = 15, 4x = 10, x = 2.5. Replies to Mei should name a case such as negative numbers or an inequality.
U.S. Access Board, Guide to the ADA Accessibility Standards, Chapter 4: Ramps and Curb Ramps · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Access Board writes guides to the ADA Standards, the rules that make buildings usable by people with disabilities. Its chapter on ramps explains what a ramp must do.
Ramps are needed on accessible routes where the ground level changes by more than ½ inch. Slope compares the vertical rise to the horizontal length. The steepest running slope allowed is 1:12, which means 1 inch up for every 12 inches forward, or about 8.33%. The guide says a gentler slope is easier for more people to use.
A single run, one sloped section, can rise at most 30 inches. A ramp may have as many runs as it needs, with a level landing at the top and bottom of each run. Where a ramp changes direction, the landing between runs must be at least 60 inches by 60 inches.
Ramp runs must be at least 36 inches wide. A ramp with a rise greater than 6 inches needs handrails on both sides. Landings must be designed so water does not collect on them.
Source: U.S. Access Board, Guide to the ADA Accessibility Standards, Chapter 4: Ramps and Curb Ramps (access-board.gov)