present our build plan to the garden committee, explain how we know the numbers are right, and answer questions with math.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The committee may ask what color to paint the shed roof. Read about cool roofs again, then rehearse a one-sentence answer.
A committee member asks whether a light roof really matters for a small shed. Which kind of answer will convince her most?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today the committee hears our plan. Each team presents its page in about 2 minutes: what we built, the key equation, the answer with units, and how we checked it.
A strong math talk has three parts. Claim: what we recommend. Evidence: the numbers and where they came from. Reasoning: why the numbers support the claim and how we know they are right.
Worked example 1: Chloe answers a roof question. A member asks how much roof coating to buy. Chloe says: “Our shed roof is about 8 feet by 6 feet, so 48 square feet. Two coats need 96 square feet. The sample label covers 50 square feet per gallon, so 96 ÷ 50 = 1.92, and we buy 2 gallons.”
Worked example 2: Marcus answers a money question. A member asks how much of the grant is left. Marcus says: “The plan costs $245.75. 250 − 245.75 = $4.25 left. We use 245.75 ÷ 250 = 98.3% of the grant. We checked by adding every page’s cost twice.”
Listening is math, too. When another team presents, write one question that asks for a check, not just a fact. For example: “How do you know 22 bags is enough?”
Rehearse answers to questions the committee might ask.
Presentations. Listen like an inspector.
For two other teams, write one thing their page did well and one question that asks for a check.
After your talk, write the hardest question you were asked and the math you used to answer it. Would you answer it differently now?
A plan is only useful if the people who build it understand it.
Exit ticket: which number in our whole plan would you want the committee to double-check, and why?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 6 minutes, mini lecture 5, rehearsal 8, presentations 18 (seven teams about 2 minutes each plus questions), closure 3.
Audience: invite real community-garden volunteers, a parent who builds, or school staff to play the committee. If no guests are available, one team acts as the committee for each talk.
Likely misconceptions: reading answers without units; reporting the leftover percent as the used percent; saying light roofs are better without evidence.
Supports: claim-evidence-reasoning cards; a timer; one rehearsal with a partner. The roof size and coverage are sample values; the 50°F comparison is from the ENERGY STAR page.
Answer guide: warm-up: a sourced number; about 50°F; 2 gallons; 98.3%; true; 4.25; no, two boards cost $9.50.
ENERGY STAR (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency), Cool Roofs · U.S. government work, public domain
When people plan a building, they choose what covers its outside surfaces. ENERGY STAR’s page on cool roofs explains one of those choices.
A cool roof is made with materials or a coating that lower the temperature of the roof surface. A cooler roof sends less heat into the building below. Two properties matter: solar reflectance, how much sunlight the roof bounces away, and thermal emittance, how well it gives off heat. Lighter colors usually perform best.
The page shares a comparison from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. On a typical summer afternoon, a roof that reflects 80% of sunlight stays about 50°F cooler than a grey roof that reflects 20%.
The page also explains where cool roofs help most: hot, sunny climates and buildings with little roof insulation. It adds that savings in northern climates are predicted to grow as the climate warms.
Roofs are sorted by slope. A low-sloped roof has a pitch of 2:12 or less, about 9.5° from horizontal; steeper roofs are called sloped. Knowing the roof’s slope and surface area helps a builder pick the right product and buy the right amount.
Source: ENERGY STAR (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency), Cool Roofs (energystar.gov)