Why do some jobs pay vastly different wages than others, and how is technology changing what skills employers value?
explain wage differences among jobs using supply, demand and productivity, and describe the current economy’s goods, services, skills and the effects of technological change on work.

Why does a registered nurse earn more than a nursing assistant, a software developer more than a retail worker, and a professional athlete more than a teacher who arguably does more good? Economics offers an explanation that is powerful and incomplete.
Wage differences among jobs are primarily explained by productivity, the supply and demand for skills, and job characteristics, with technology constantly reshaping these factors.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Consider two jobs you know well. Based on the lesson’s introduction, what initial ideas do you have about why one might pay more than the other?
Why do night-shift oil-rig jobs often pay more than daytime office jobs requiring similar skills?
Productivity
Historically, economies have evolved from primarily agricultural to industrial, and most developed countries are now primarily service economies.
Employers are willing to pay up to the value a worker adds to output. Workers whose skills, training or tools let them produce more value tend to earn more. Education raises wages largely because it raises productivity — and because it signals abilities to employers. This is why earnings rise strongly with education on average: BLS data consistently show higher median earnings and lower unemployment for workers with more education.
Output per worker or per hour worked.
Most U.S. workers today are employed in manufacturing.
Supply and demand for skills
Wages are high where demand for a skill is high relative to the supply of people who have it. Skills that take years to acquire, that few people have, or that are needed in growing industries command high wages. Jobs many people can do, or want to do, pay less. Superstar athletes and entertainers earn enormous sums because their talent is rare and technology lets them reach millions of customers at once.
Jobs that are more important or require more effort should always pay more than less important or easier jobs.
Economics explains wage differences through productivity, the supply and demand for skills, and compensating differentials, which means some highly valued or difficult jobs may not pay as much as others with rarer skills or higher productivity.
Write your 500-600 word essay comparing two occupations’ wages, with a cited data table (median pay, education, projected growth), an explanation using productivity and supply and demand, and one factor the simple model misses.
Compensating differentials
Unpleasant, dangerous or irregular jobs often pay more than their skill requirements alone would suggest, to attract workers; pleasant or prestigious jobs can pay less. Wages also reflect unions, discrimination, geography and law — factors the simple model leaves out and research continues to measure.
The current economy
The U.S. economy today is overwhelmingly a service economy: health care, education, professional services, retail, hospitality, finance and technology employ far more people than manufacturing, although manufacturing output remains large because of productivity gains. Missouri’s economy, measured by jobs, is led by health care and social assistance (15.8 percent of jobs in 2025), followed by retail trade (10.5 percent), manufacturing (9.7 percent) and accommodation and food services (9.0 percent); farms, rivers and rail make agriculture and logistics important in particular regions. Employers report strong demand for workers who can combine technical skills with communication, problem-solving and the ability to keep learning.
Technological change
Technology changes which tasks people do. It has historically destroyed some jobs — switchboard operators, typists — while creating others and raising productivity and incomes overall. The adjustment can be painful for the workers whose tasks are automated. Economists describe skill-biased technological change, which raises demand for workers who can use new technology and lowers it for routine tasks that machines can do. Artificial intelligence is the current case: its effects on which occupations grow and shrink are being studied now, and forecasts vary widely. Treat confident predictions with the skepticism of Lesson 2.3.
The workshop
Write a 500-600 word explanatory essay (WHST.11-12.2) comparing two occupations’ wages. Use the Occupational Outlook Handbook for median pay, education, and projected growth, and explain the difference using productivity, supply and demand, and at least one factor the simple model leaves out. Present the data in a table (RH.11-12.7) and cite it.
Key terms
Skills and knowledge that raise a worker’s productivity.
Extra pay for undesirable job characteristics.
An economy in which most employment is in services rather than goods production.
Technology that raises demand for skilled workers relative to routine-task workers.
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- A warehouse crew ships 480 orders in a 40-hour week. What is its productivity per hour?
Check your answer
Answer: 12 orders an hour480 ÷ 40. - Why might an oil-rig night-shift job pay more than a day office job needing similar skills?
Check your answer
Answer: A compensating differential for danger and hardshipUnpleasant conditions require higher pay to attract workers. - Define human capital.
Check your answer
Answer: Skills and knowledge that raise a worker’s productivityEducation and training build it. - Do most U.S. workers today work in services or in manufacturing?
Check your answer
Answer: ServicesManufacturing output stays large because of productivity gains.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- An extra warehouse worker lets a firm ship 30 more orders an hour, each adding $1.10 of revenue after materials. What is the most the firm would pay per hour? Would it hire at $22?
Check your answer
Answer: Up to $33.00 an hour; yes, at $22 it gains $11.00 an hourEmployers pay up to the value a worker adds. - Median annual pay in Missouri (BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025): registered nurse $81,780; nursing assistant $37,680. Convert each to an hourly rate (2,080 hours a year) and explain the gap using the unit’s concepts.
Check your answer
Answer: $39.32 versus $18.12 an hour (2.2 times). Nursing needs years of training and a license, which limits supply, and adds more value per hour; demand is high and growing.Divide by 2,080. - Median weekly earnings in 2025 (BLS, full-time workers aged 25 and over): high-school diploma $966, bachelor’s degree $1,578. What is the annual gap, and the gap over a 40-year career in today’s dollars (ignoring raises and discounting)? Give two reasons education raises pay.
Check your answer
Answer: $31,824 a year; $1,272,960 over 40 years. It raises productivity (human capital) and signals ability to employers.(1,578 − 966) × 52; × 40. - A bank branch has 6 tellers handling 1,200 transactions a day. New technology lets 4 tellers handle 1,400. What happens to transactions per teller, and what does this show about technology and jobs?
Check your answer
Answer: From 200 to 350 a teller, a 75% rise; the branch needs 2 fewer tellers. Productivity and output rise, but the workers whose tasks were automated bear the adjustment.Output ÷ workers before and after.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Skill-biased technological change: new software raises demand for data analysts and lowers demand for routine data-entry clerks. Describe the shift in each labor market and the effect on wages and employment.
Check your answer
Answer: Analysts: demand shifts right, so wages and employment rise. Clerks: demand shifts left, so wages and employment fall. Over time, workers may retrain, shifting supply from the clerk market to the analyst market.Apply the Lesson 1.2 model to labor. - A tutor earns $40 an hour teaching 1 student at a time, 30 hours a week. An online course sells to 20,000 students at $15 each. Compare weekly tutoring revenue with the course’s total revenue, and explain the superstar effect.
Check your answer
Answer: Tutoring $1,200 a week; the course $300,000. Technology lets rare talent reach millions at once, so earnings concentrate among the best-known performers.40 × 30; 20,000 × 15.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Qd = 1,500 − 25P and Qs = −300 + 35P. Find equilibrium.
Check your answer
Answer: P = 30, Q = 7501,800 = 60P. - What is the opportunity cost of a two-year training program for someone who would otherwise earn $36,000 a year, if tuition totals $3,000?
Check your answer
Answer: $75,0002 × 36,000 + 3,000.
Missouri’s jobs are led by health care and social assistance (15.8 percent in 2025), followed by retail trade (10.5 percent) and manufacturing (9.7 percent), which shows where employers’ demand for particular skills is concentrated.
How might factors the simple model leaves out, such as unions or discrimination, influence the wage differences you found in your workshop essay?
How confident are you that you can explain wage differences with productivity and supply and demand, using real data?
The Shift
- Wages reflect a worker’s productivity and value to an employer.
- The supply and demand for specific skills drive wage levels.
- Technological change continuously shifts which skills are in demand and reshapes job tasks.
Why Jobs Pay What They Pay: Ten Occupations, With the Missouri and National Wage Data
SLS original, with data retrieved November 5, 2026 from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, Missouri, May 2025; Employment Projections 2025-35 tables; Education pays 2025; Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, Missouri, 2025) and the Missouri Economic Research and Information Center (long-term occupational projections 2024-2034) · SLS original
Why this reading. Your essay compares two occupations’ wages with a cited data table, explains the gap using productivity and supply and demand, and names one factor the simple model misses. This reading gives you ten occupations with national and Missouri median pay, Missouri employment, entry education and two ten-year projections — so you can pick any two and have a complete, citable table without leaving the page — plus the earnings-by-education figures and the sector data you need for the part of the essay about the current economy. What to look for: two rows where the wage gap is not explained by education. Those are the rows where the second half of your essay lives.
1. Productivity: the ceiling on what an employer will pay
An employer hires one more worker while that worker adds more to the value of output than the wage costs. What the worker adds is marginal product; what that output sells for converts it into dollars. So the most an employer will pay, in the long run and in a competitive market, is the value of what the worker produces. Two consequences follow, and they are the ones students most often get backward:
- Pay tracks the value of output, not the effort or the worth of the job. A nurse and a teacher may work equally hard and matter equally to society; what determines pay is what their labor adds to something someone will pay for, and how many people can do it.
- Tools and organization raise productivity as much as skill does. The same person is more productive with better equipment, better systems, more capital behind them. This is why wages in a country rise over a century even for jobs whose tasks have not changed much: the whole economy is more productive.
Human capital is the stock of skills, knowledge and health a worker carries. Education raises wages partly because it genuinely raises productivity and partly because it signals attributes an employer cannot observe directly — persistence, trainability. Economists argue about the relative size of the two channels; both predict the same correlation, which is why the correlation alone cannot settle it.
2. Education and earnings: the BLS table
Median usual weekly earnings of full-time wage and salary workers aged 25 and over, and unemployment rates, 2025 (national):
| Highest level of education | Median weekly earnings | Unemployment rate |
|---|---|---|
| Doctoral degree | $2,307 | 1.8% |
| Professional degree | $2,294 | 1.9% |
| Master’s degree | $1,876 | 2.6% |
| Bachelor’s degree | $1,578 | 2.8% |
| Associate’s degree | $1,135 | 3.0% |
| Some college, no degree | $1,062 | 3.8% |
| High school diploma | $966 | 4.3% |
| Less than a high school diploma | $770 | 6.1% |
| All workers | $1,268 | 3.4% |
The gradient runs both ways at once: more education is associated with higher pay and with a lower chance of being out of work. The weekly gap between a bachelor’s degree and a high school diploma is $1,578 − $966 = $612 a week, or $31,824 over 52 weeks. Two cautions for anyone citing this table. It is a median for a whole category, so it hides enormous variation — some people with a high school diploma out-earn some people with a master’s, and which field a degree is in matters as much as the level. And it is a correlation across people who differ in many ways besides schooling, so it is an upper bound on what an extra year of education would do for any particular person. (BLS notes that the 2025 annual estimates are eleven-month averages excluding October, because data for October 2025 were not collected during the federal government shutdown.)
3. Supply and demand for skills
Productivity sets a ceiling; supply and demand decide where within it the wage lands. A wage is high when the demand for a skill is large relative to the number of people who have it. That gives three questions for any occupation:
- How many people can do it? Long training, licensure, rare talent and unpleasant conditions all restrict supply.
- How badly is it wanted? Demand for a worker is derived from demand for what the work produces — an aging population raises demand for nurses; a housing slowdown lowers demand for electricians.
- How many people can one worker serve? This is the “superstar” effect. A performer or an athlete whose work is recorded and distributed can serve millions at once; a hairdresser serves one person at a time. Technology that widens reach concentrates earnings at the top of talent distributions.
Compensating differentials are the adjustment for everything else about a job. Danger, night shifts, isolation, dirt and instability push wages up for a given skill level; pleasant, safe, prestigious or flexible work can pay less than its skill requirements would suggest, because people accept part of their compensation in kind. This is why an oil-rig night shift can pay more than an office job requiring the same training, and it is a factor the simple model does account for — unlike the next paragraph.
What the simple model leaves out. Unions and collective bargaining; licensing rules that restrict who may practice; minimum wages and other legal floors; monopsony, where few employers face many workers; geography, since the same job pays differently in St. Louis and in a rural county and living costs differ too; discrimination; information, since workers cannot see what others earn; and norms about what a job “should” pay. Your essay must name at least one of these and show it operating in one of your two occupations.
4. The ten-occupation table
U.S. median wages, entry education and projected U.S. growth are from the BLS Employment Projections tables (base year 2025, projections to 2035). Missouri median wages and employment are from the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025. Missouri growth (2024–2034) and annual openings are from the Missouri Economic Research and Information Center (MERIC) long-term projections. Pick any two rows.
| Occupation | U.S. median annual wage | Missouri median annual wage | Missouri vs. U.S. | Missouri employment | Typical entry education | Projected U.S. growth, 2025–35 | Projected Missouri growth, 2024–34 | Missouri annual openings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software developers | $135,980 | $126,120 | -7% | 20,020 | Bachelor’s degree | +10.2% | 12.84% | 1,418 |
| Registered nurses | $97,550 | $81,780 | -16% | 76,310 | Bachelor’s degree | +5.6% | 6.43% | 4,699 |
| Dental hygienists | $98,100 | $92,750 | -5% | 3,810 | Associate’s degree | +8.0% | 4.24% | 243 |
| Elementary school teachers | $63,970 | $50,910 | -20% | 33,180 | Bachelor’s degree, plus state license | −0.4% | −% | 1,958 |
| Electricians | $63,190 | $65,410 | +4% | 12,780 | High school diploma, then an apprenticeship | +9.2% | 6.69% | 1,685 |
| Heavy and tractor-trailer truck drivers | $58,640 | $54,550 | -7% | 47,760 | Postsecondary nondegree award (commercial driver’s license) | +3.8% | 5.30% | 5,412 |
| Nursing assistants | $42,260 | $37,680 | -11% | 34,050 | Postsecondary nondegree award (state-approved program) | +2.6% | 3.33% | 4,883 |
| Fast food and counter workers | $31,200 | $30,390 | -3% | 29,360 | No formal educational credential | +5.8% | 6.87% | 5,685 |
| Retail salespersons | $35,410 | $33,460 | -6% | 67,140 | No formal educational credential | −0.3% | −% | 8,359 |
| Home health and personal care aides | $35,800 | $33,080 | -8% | 94,810 | High school diploma or equivalent | +18.1% | 6.73% | 11,344 |
Four things worth noticing before you choose.
- Missouri pays less than the nation in nine of the ten. The Missouri median is below the U.S. median in every row of the table except one — the exception is Electricians. The Missouri median runs from 3 to 20 percent below the U.S. median in those nine rows. Part of that is lower living costs and part is the mix of employers; the table cannot separate the two, and a good essay says so.
- The aide and fast-food rows are near the legal floor. Missouri’s median home health and personal care aide earned $33,080 a year — $33080 ÷ 2,080 hours = $15.90 an hour — against a state minimum of $13.75 in 2025, 16 percent above it. The median fast food and counter worker earned $30,390, or $14.61 an hour, 6.3 percent above the 2025 minimum. A median wage within a few percent of the legal floor is what a labor market looks like when pay is set largely by law rather than by competition for scarce skills. The statewide minimum rose to $15.00 on January 1, 2026 (Lesson 2.3).
- Education explains some gaps and not others. A dental hygienist (associate’s degree) earns $92,750 in Missouri against $50,910 for an elementary school teacher (bachelor’s degree plus a license); nationally the same pair is $98,100 against $63,970. Registered nurses, $81,780, earn 2.2 times what nursing assistants earn, $37,680, holding the workplace constant and varying the training.
- Growth and pay are not the same axis, and neither is the same as openings. MERIC projects Missouri software developers to grow 12.84% (the fastest in the table) and registered nurses 6.43%; retail salespersons are projected to shrink 2.34%, yet MERIC still projects 8,359 openings a year, because people leave and transfer. Home health and personal care aides are projected to grow only 482 jobs a year but to have 11,344 openings. Openings and growth are different numbers, and the first is usually much larger.
Ready-made comparisons. Electricians against retail salespersons isolates training and apprenticeship. Dental hygienists against elementary teachers is the sharpest pair in the table. Registered nurses against nursing assistants holds the workplace constant and varies the training. Fast food workers against truck drivers holds the credential nearly constant and varies the license and the working conditions.
5. The current economy: what Missourians actually do
Employment in Missouri by sector, 2025 annual average, all covered employment (2,898,452 jobs) (BLS Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages). The BLS withholds some sectors, including construction, to protect confidentiality, so the rows below do not add to 100 percent.
| Sector | Employment | Share of total |
|---|---|---|
| Health care and social assistance | 458,013 | 15.8% |
| Retail trade | 304,942 | 10.5% |
| Manufacturing | 281,886 | 9.7% |
| Accommodation and food services | 261,707 | 9.0% |
| Professional and technical services | 163,101 | 5.6% |
| Administrative and waste services | 143,425 | 4.9% |
| Finance and insurance | 131,474 | 4.5% |
| Wholesale trade | 125,704 | 4.3% |
| Transportation and warehousing | 107,151 | 3.7% |
| Government (federal, state and local) | 415,170 | 14.3% |
Manufacturing employs 281,886 Missourians, 9.7 percent — fewer than one worker in ten. This is the fact behind the true/false check, and the reason it is a myth rather than a simple error is that manufacturing output has not collapsed — productivity growth means fewer workers produce a great deal. Employment moved to services; production did not disappear. Health care and social assistance is the single largest sector, at 15.8 percent of jobs.
6. Technological change
Technology changes which tasks people do. It has historically destroyed some jobs — switchboard operators, typists — while creating others and raising productivity and incomes overall. The adjustment is painful for the workers whose tasks are automated. Economists describe skill-biased technological change, which raises demand for workers who can use new technology and lowers it for routine tasks that machines can do. Artificial intelligence is the current case: its effects on which occupations grow and shrink are being studied now, and forecasts vary widely. Treat confident predictions with the skepticism of Lesson 2.3.
7. Writing the essay
- Choose two rows and copy their figures into your own table, with the source for each column.
- State the gap in dollars and in percent, and say which wage you are comparing (U.S. or Missouri).
- Explain it with productivity (what each worker adds), with supply and demand (how many can do the job, how badly it is wanted), and with one thing the simple model leaves out.
- Label each claim positive or normative, and be specific about what the table cannot show.
Sources: BLS, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, Missouri, May 2025 (public data API, series OEUS29…) (bls.gov); BLS, Employment Projections: Occupational projections and worker characteristics (2025-35) (bls.gov); BLS, Education pays: earnings and unemployment rates by educational attainment, 2025 (bls.gov); BLS, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, Missouri, 2025 annual averages (data.bls.gov); MERIC, Occupational Projections, Long-Term Projections 2024-2034, Missouri (meric.mo.gov); Missouri Department of Labor and Industrial Relations, Minimum Wage (labor.mo.gov)